Toyota supplier hit with criticism at shareholder meeting over $33 billion deal
TOKYO :Some investors in Toyota Industries voiced disapproval of a $33 billion buyout offer on Tuesday, adding to criticism that the bid from Japanese parent Toyota Motor was unfair to minority shareholders.
The 4.7 trillion yen ($33 billion) offer to take the forklift maker private has already come under fire from international shareholders including London-based Zennor Asset Management and Hong Kong-based Oasis Management. But on Tuesday, domestic shareholders at what is likely to be the company's last annual general meeting before it is taken private, also expressed their concerns about the plan.
The world's top-selling automaker plans to take Toyota Industries private in a complex, multi-part transaction that includes an offer price of 16,300 yen a share. The price, some shareholders have said, undervalues the supplier's intrinsic value and strengthens the founding Toyoda family's control over the broader group.
"I don't think I am the only one who feels the price is too low," said one shareholder at the meeting.
Another said the acquisition would lead to the "domination" of Toyota Industries, one of Toyota's key suppliers, by the automaker.
The meeting ran for almost 2 hours, its longest ever, the company said. Toyota Industries' executives also took some two dozen questions from shareholders, the most ever.
On Thursday Toyota chairman Akio Toyoda may face similar questions at the automaker's annual general meeting.
Toyota has said the acquisition would allow Toyota Industries to deepen collaboration with group companies, without concerns of short-term profit targets, as Toyota itself becomes a broader "mobility company".
Under the deal, a new holding company will be set up. Unlisted real estate company Toyota Fudosan will invest 180 billion yen while Toyoda, the founder's grandson, will invest 1 billion yen. Toyota Motor will invest 700 billion yen for non-voting preferred shares.
"This was not a decision that neglected minority shareholders, but rather one that was taken with all the factors in mind," Toyota Industries' President Koichi Ito told shareholders.
Oasis, which has shares in both Toyota Motor and Toyota Industries, said on Friday it would push for a higher price.
Zennor and some others have said the price undervalues the substantial real estate on Toyota Industries's books.
Toyota Industries had 1.5 trillion yen of property, plants and equipment on its balance sheet as of the end of March, a number that reflects the cost paid for the assets, minus depreciation, rather than their current market value.
Toyota Group companies hold at least 39 per cent of Toyota Industries, according to LSEG data and the deal is widely expected to go through. Shares finished at 16,300 yen on Tuesday.
Toyota Industries, formerly Toyoda Automatic Loom Works, was founded in 1926 to make automatic looms. An automotive division within the company was set up and later spun off as Toyota Motor.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CNA
2 hours ago
- CNA
FAQ: What Jetstar Asia customers need to know about the airline's upcoming closure
SINGAPORE: With Jetstar Asia set to cease operations on Jul 31, what happens if you have a booking, a voucher or a membership? The Singapore-based budget airline, which is owned by Australia's Qantas, operates 16 intra-Asia routes that will be affected by the closure. What do I do if I have a booking to fly after Jul 31? The airline will contact you directly with the option of a full cash refund. It will reach customers through the email address provided when the booking was made. Customers who booked through a travel agent or another airline should contact them instead of Jetstar Asia. Some customers may be offered seats on an alternative flight offered by Qantas-owned airlines, depending on what is available. The company said customers with connecting flights to or from Australia, and those traveling between Singapore and Bali, Manila and Osaka may be offered alternative flights. The closure of Jetstar Asia does not affect flights operated by Jetstar Airways or Jetstar Japan. Jetstar Airways has flights between Australia and Southeast Asia. Jetstar Asia currently operates flights between Singapore and destinations in Malaysia, Indonesia, Thailand, the Philippines, China, Sri Lanka, Japan and Australia. I have a Jetstar Asia flight before Jul 31. Will the flight still happen? That depends on whether the flight is affected by Jetstar Asia's "progressively reduced schedule" ahead of the closure. The airline will notify customers or their travel agents if the flight is affected by the closure. Those who have an active booking with Jetstar Asia can get the latest information through the airline's travel alert page. I don't want to take my Jetstar Asia flight anymore. Can I do that? The airline said it will offer "increased flexibility" for their customers before the closure. The latest schedule updates and travel advice will also be on Jetstar Asia's travel alert page. Can I get a refund for my Jetstar voucher? Yes, if you have a voucher related to Jetstar Asia travel. The airline will contact you in August to convert the voucher balance into a monetary refund. However, vouchers that expired before the closure announcement on Jun 11 are not eligible for refunds. If you used a voucher to make a booking within the last 18 months, the airline will automatically refund the amount to the card used for payment where possible. It will then inform you via email when the refund is completed. For all other bookings, the airline will contact customers with further instructions. "We will never ask you to provide us your credit card information," said Jetstar. If separate vouchers were issued for each passenger, the airline will email the person who made the booking to coordinate refunds for each voucher. Those who used vouchers for bookings through travel agents or third party sites will be contacted either by the airline or by the travel agent. I'm a Club Jetstar member. What happens to my membership? The membership will be cancelled, and the annual fee will be refunded for all Singapore-based Club Jetstar members. The refunds will be processed from August, and will be refunded to the card used to purchase the membership. If that is not possible, the airline will email you with further instructions. Memberships that expired before Jun 11 will not be refunded. I'm flying on a Jetstar Asia partner airline. Will the flight still happen? The partner airline will contact you about alternative arrangements if your flight will be affected, just as Jetstar will inform you if your Jetstar Asia flight is impacted. Partner airlines refer to airlines that Jetstar Asia works with. In such cases, customers book through Jetstar Asia but fly on a different airline. I booked my flight through a third-party website or travel agent. Who will contact me?
Business Times
3 hours ago
- Business Times
Qantas' Jetstar Asia to shut down on Jul 31; over 500 staff to lose jobs
[SINGAPORE] Australian flag carrier Qantas will wind down operations for its Singapore-based unit Jetstar Asia and shut it down on Jul 31, 2025, as the low-cost airline has been facing challenges that threaten the sustainability of its business, Jetstar Asia said in a Wednesday (Jun 11) statement. The Singapore-based airline will continue operating flights for the next seven weeks and progressively reduce its schedule across its short-haul international network outside of Singapore before its last day of operations, said Jetstar Asia. More than 500 employees will receive support through the closure, in the form of retrenchment packages, employment and employability support as well as opportunities within the Qantas Group, where possible, and other airlines and aviation partners in Singapore, it added. Customers whose bookings have been impacted by the closure will be contacted directly with the option of a full cash refund or an alternative flight, where possible, Jetstar Asia said. The closure will impact 16 intra-Asia routes and will not affect Jetstar Group's Australian and New Zealand unit, Jetstar Airways, or its Japan-based unit, Jetstar Japan. The two airlines will continue to operate their current schedule, including Jetstar Airways flights between Australia and Singapore. The move comes as Jetstar Asia has been saddled with escalating supplier costs, airport fees and aviation charges alongside growing regional capacity and competition. Latest media reports said the carrier was expected to post an underlying EBIT loss of A$35 million in the current financial year. 'These rising costs are projected to continue into the foreseeable future, putting unsustainable pressure on the airline's ability to offer low fares, which is fundamental to its business model,' said Jetstar Asia. BT in your inbox Start and end each day with the latest news stories and analyses delivered straight to your inbox. Sign Up Sign Up It will free up A$500 million (S$420 million) of capital for Qantas to reinvest in its fleet renewal plans. Once the airline's operations have ceased, its 13 Jetstar Asia Airbus A320 aircraft will be redeployed across the Qantas Group to support fleet renewal and growth in its Australia and New Zealand businesses, in line with underlying demand, Jetstar Asia said. The Qantas Group will provide support for Jetstar Asia to continue to meet its obligations as operations wind down towards closure. The Singapore Manual & Mercantile Workers' Union (SMMWU) said it was notified of the job cuts and had negotiated with Jetstar Asia to 'ensure that affected members and workers are treated with care and receive fair compensation'. 'The company has committed to providing a comprehensive retrenchment package in line with the Tripartite Advisory on Managing Excess Manpower and Responsible Retrenchment,' it added in a statement.
CNA
3 hours ago
- CNA
Japan wholesale inflation slows, taking pressure off BOJ
TOKYO :Japan's annual wholesale inflation slowed in May on falling import costs for raw materials, data showed on Wednesday, taking some pressure off the central bank to raise interest rates. But the rise in wholesale prices for food and beverages gathered pace in May in a sign global uncertainties and soft consumption are not discouraging firms to pass on higher costs. The corporate goods price index (CGPI), which measures the price companies charge each other for their goods and services, rose 3.2 per cent in May from a year earlier, data showed, falling short of a median market forecast for a 3.5 per cent gain. It followed a revised 4.1 per cent increase in April and marked the slowest year-on-year rise since a 3.1 per cent gain in September. "As wholesale inflation slows, consumer prices will also come under downward pressure with a lag," said Masato Koike, senior economist at Sompo Institute Plus. "The BOJ may have lost the opportunity to raise interest rates because inflation will have slowed significantly by the time the fog hanging over Japan's tariff talks (with the U.S.) clears," he said. Prices of steel goods fell 4.8 per cent and those of chemical products were down 3.1 per cent, while non-ferrous metals products saw prices slide 2.1 per cent, the data showed. The yen-based import price index fell 10.3 per cent in May from a year earlier after a 7.3 per cent drop in April, indicating the currency's rebound was pushing down raw material import costs. By contrast, prices of food and beverages rose 4.2 per cent in May, accelerating from a 4.0 per cent increase in April in a sign of simmering inflationary pressure, the data showed. Japan is struggling to reach a deal with Washington in tariff negotiations, clouding the outlook for its economy, which is heavily reliant on automobile shipments to the U.S. The uncertainty over U.S. trade policy forced the BOJ to cut its growth forecasts on May 1, suggesting the timing of its next rate hike may be delayed despite steadily rising inflation. Japan's core consumer inflation hit 3.5 per cent in April, marking the fastest annual pace in more than two years and exceeding the BOJ's 2 per cent target for more than three years, due largely to a surge in food costs. While the BOJ expects food inflation to moderate later this year, it has signaled its readiness to raise rates again once the economy resumes a recovery on solid wage gains. The BOJ ended a decade-long stimulus programme last year and in January raised interest rates to 0.5 per cent on the view Japan was on the cusp of durably hitting its 2 per cent inflation target. A Reuters poll, taken on May 7-13, showed most economists expect the BOJ to hold rates steady through September with a small majority forecasting a hike by year-end.
