‘Alpha predator' sharks and humans clash on an Israeli beach

Straits Times

17-05-2025

Free-divers swim next to Sandbar sharks near the northern Israeli coastal city of Hadera. PHOTO: AFP
HADERA, Israel – With its golden sand and blue waters, the beach front in central Israel looks much like any other stretch of Mediterranean coast, but a closer look reveals something unusual peeking through the rippling surf: black shark fins.
The sharks are attracted to this patch of water in Hadera during the cold season because of the warmth generated by the turbines of a nearby power station.
This has provoked an adrenaline-filled coexistence between the increasingly bold ocean predators and the curious, sometimes even careless, humans who come to swim.
In April, a man who got a little too close was mauled to death as spectators on the beach screamed in terror.
All that was left were his bones, rescuers said.
Now, bathers, the authorities, and environmental and shark experts are asking how such an event, never seen before in Israeli waters, happened and what can be done to prevent it in the future.
'Sharks do not harm and never normally attack unless they feel either threatened or if somebody's getting into their territory,' Ms Irene Nurit Cohn, a member of rescue agency Zaka's scuba unit and a seasoned diver, said.
'I've been diving since 1982. I've seen many sharks in my life. It has been thrilling and beautiful to watch sharks, but they're not, and I repeat, they're not dangerous,' she said.
Ms Cohn, who was part of the team that searched for the remains of Mr Barak Tzach, a 45-year-old father of four, added that it was the people visiting the unique site who were 'not behaving as they should.'
'People were touching them and disturbing them,' she said, adding that recent media coverage had drawn even more people to the beach.
'It's dangerous'
Immediately after the deadly attack, the local authority erected metal fences with 'danger' signs and blocked an access road into the adjacent nature reserve with a cement barrier.
Two weeks later, those had been removed, and life at the beach was back to normal.
Friends Einav and Carmel, teenagers from a nearby town, appeared largely undeterred by the recent death. They came specifically to see the sharks.
'Sharks are my favourite animals, and so I really wanted to see them, but we said that we will not go inside (the water) because it's dangerous,' said Carmel.
A shark's fin is pictured as Israeli rescue services search for a man believed to have been attacked by sharks on April 22.
PHOTO: AFP
Mr Matan Ben David, a spear-fishing and diving instructor who said he has continued to enter the water, said swimmers should keep a distance and adhere to the rules of the sea.
'Sharks are part of nature, something we have to respect. We have to respect the ocean. We're just visitors here,' he said, describing how he has witnessed people crowding the sharks and taking photographs.
'Sharks are an incredible animal, very majestic but they're an alpha predator and, at the end of the day, a lot of people do not always follow best practices,' Mr Ben David noted.
Like all unsupervised beaches in Israel, the one where the fatal attack took place was off-limits to swimming, a ban that is widely flouted.
Human-wildlife conflict
Ms Leigh Livine, a shark researcher who has been monitoring this area for the past four years, said research initially showed 'the sharks were staying away from direct conflict with the humans entering the water'.
But 'you have a very, very small space that you see this human-wildlife conflict really coming out at certain times of the year.'
Ms Livine said the sharks were a combination of Dusky and Sandbar sharks, and that they were present in the area between November and May.
But with temperatures rising each year due to climate change, 'you have a lot more bodies in the water coming into conflict with the sharks'.
Ms Livine said she was shocked by the attack in April but, with interaction between the sharks and humans increasing, was surprised 'that something hasn't happened sooner'.
'It usually comes down to a conflict of space, either food resources, space resources, and we've been seeing humans harass the sharks, really provoking them,' she said. AFP
Find out more about climate change and how it could affect you on the ST microsite here.