Celebrate Pi Day with the best store-bought apple pie, according to a pro baker
When you have a math teacher for a mother, Pi Day is a holiday that never goes unobserved. Every year, without fail, I'll get a call from my mom on March 14, during which she'll recite far more pi digits than the average person should be able to memorize. I respect her impressive (if slightly dorky!) party trick, but as a former professional baker? I prefer to celebrate Pi Day by ... eating pie. Even on an ordinary day, a meal just isn't complete without a sweet finale, in my humble (pie) opinion — and I'm here to tell you that there's no shame in foregoing the homemade route for an easy-breezy store-bought apple pie.
But you don't want to opt for just any pre-made option. There are several widely available frozen apple pies on the market from brands like Sara Lee, Mrs. Smith's and Marie Callender's. They can't all be created equal, can they?
That's what I set out to determine. I've made (and enjoyed) many a pie in my day, but just to keep any pastry biases I might have in check, I enlisted the help of my sister, Chelsea, who manages a Philadelphia-based restaurant called Alice, and my husband, Dan, an enthusiastic pie eater. I set aside time to bake all three pies one morning so we could sample them side-by-side for a true comparison.
Now, you might be thinking, "Britt, I'm pretty sure there are four slices of pie on that plate, not three." And you'd be correct! In addition to the three frozen pies, I also picked up a pre-baked pie from Whole Foods as a control. It tastes pretty close to homemade, so I compared the frozen pies against it just to see if there were any big differences.
Alright, ready to see how these frozen treats fared? Keep scrolling to see which one(s) deserves a spot on your Pi Day table.
Just to have a non-frozen pie to compare the others to, I picked up a fresh apple pie from Whole Foods Market. We thought it was just slightly tastier than the Marie Callender's apple pie, and is a fab option if you want a ready-to-eat dessert.
In case you've never purchased a frozen pie before, you can rest assured that preparing one is easy as, well, you know. All you have to do is remove the pie from its box and plastic wrapping, place it on a sheet tray and bake it in a preheated oven according to the package's instructions. That's it! Some pies have an additional step of making slits in the top crust to allow steam to escape, but that's really the only "work" required on your part.
In terms of prep, the Sara Lee and Mrs. Smith's pies required scoring the crusts, while the Marie Callender's pie did not — and that's because it had a lattice crust, meaning there were already openings in it. Each set of instructions recommended covering the sheet tray with aluminum foil before placing the pie on it and baking; that way, should any filling bubble over, it would stick to the foil and not make a mess of the tray. I only had enough foil for one pie, so I used parchment paper for the others and it worked out just fine.
All of the pies included the optional suggestion of brushing the crust with an egg wash for a more golden color, but to keep things as simple as possible (which is what buying a frozen pie is all about!), I skipped this step. Also, if you haven't noticed, eggs are pretty pricey these days...
Directions varied slightly when it came to baking temperature, ranging from 400° F to 425° F; internal pie temperatures ranged from 160° F to 165° F. I served all of the pies at room temperature, not only for consistency purposes but because I feel it's easier to detect nuances in flavor when food isn't piping hot.
To assess these pies as fairly as possible, I numbered them rather than telling Chelsea and Dan which pie was from which brand. I also made score sheets so we could write down our notes on the appearance, flavor and texture of each pie, as well as give them an overall rating, from 1 to 10, with 10 being the best pie we've ever had in our lives. (Spoiler alert: None of these pies were quite at that level, but some scored pretty high!)
As for our testing pool, I selected brands that are widely available across the country, and went with the most traditional versions I could find. For instance, some brands make Dutch apple pies or apple crumb pies — for consistency's sake, I left those out because anything with a streusel topping has an unfair advantage in my book.
On a similar note, here's what I generally look for in an apple pie: a crust that's tender but not super soft, ample flakiness and a filling that marries sweetness and tartness, ideally with a bit of spice. I also prefer a medium-sized apple slice — too small, and the filling becomes mushy; too big, and the apples sometimes aren't cooked enough.
Store-bought apple pies are super low-maintenance, but there are a few tools you'll need for baking and slicing 'em up. Here's what I used:
And if you'd like to try your hand at a from-scratch pie...

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Newsweek
2 hours ago
- Newsweek
Puppy Ready To Meet Adopters but They Never Showed, Then Euthanasia Loomed
Based on facts, either observed and verified firsthand by the reporter, or reported and verified from knowledgeable sources. Newsweek AI is in beta. Translations may contain inaccuracies—please refer to the original content. Hearts have broken when a German Shepherd facing euthanasia was adopted, only for her new owners to never show up to collect her. Everyone was delighted when Flora, just 8 months old, was adopted. But after the shelter had arranged her spay appointment, the adoptive family never returned to collect her. "Her potential adopters completed the paperwork, and she stayed for her spay surgery. However, when it was time for pickup, they never came, and the shelter hasn't heard from them since. It's disheartening to see people change their minds when a dog's life hangs in the balance," Amanda Downes, from California-based Advocate 4 Paws who network dogs at high-risk shelters told Newsweek. Flora the German Shepherd who was left at the shelter after being adopted. Flora the German Shepherd who was left at the shelter after being adopted. @advocate4paws/Instagram Flora was found as a stray, and like many dogs in shelters across the U.S., was facing euthanasia. According to Shelter Animals Count, around 748,000 animals experienced non-live outcomes, including euthanasia, in 2024. While this represents a 1.6 per cent decrease compared to 2023 and a 20 per cent drop from 2019, the number remains high. Placed at Stanislaus Animal Services Agency, her future looked bleak. "Currently, dogs in the Stanislaus Shelter are given about a month before being placed on the euthanasia list. The shelter is severely over capacity, housing 330 dogs when it's only meant for 180, with more coming in daily," Downes explained. In 2024, approximately 7 million animals entered U.S. shelters and rescues, according to Shelter Animals Count—an increase of nearly 3 percent from 2023. By the end of the year, 103,000 more pets had entered shelters than had exited, contributing to an ongoing capacity crisis in U.S. shelters. There has been a positive update in Flora's story: a rescue has stepped to take over her care. There has been a positive update in Flora's story: a rescue has stepped to take over her care. @advocate4paws/Instagram "She is a typical happy-go-lucky puppy who is all tail wags and gets along well with other dogs," Downes said. "She's an affectionate 8-month-old German Shepherd mix who enjoys attention from shelter volunteers and she just loves people. She's such a great puppy, I can't believe her adopters didn't come back for her." Thankfully, there has been a positive update in Flora's story: a rescue has stepped to take over her care, and Downes hopes that she will soon have a home to call her own. "We want Flora to never see the inside of a shelter again and pray that her forever home is on the horizon, she deserves it," she said. Despite Flora's happy ending, there are still many dogs in need, and Downes hopes that sharing their stories will help them find a rescue too, and encourage more people to adopt or foster. "We hope that her story, along with others we share, will highlight the shelter crisis and encourage more people to open their homes to foster dogs to help lighten the load," she said. Flora isn't the only dog having a tough time being adopted. Earlier this month a dog called Dexter gained viral attention after his shelter revealed he has been returned by adopters five times. While Duke the terrier mix gained sympathy after he was returned just one day after being adopted.
Yahoo
3 hours ago
- Yahoo
Success for All Foundation Approved to Provide Evidence-Based Literacy Support for Hawaii Public Schools
$100,000 Scholarships Available for Eligible Schools to Implement Science of Reading-Based Model HONOLULU, June 10, 2025 /PRNewswire/ -- The Success for All Foundation (SFA), a nationally recognized nonprofit focused on whole-school literacy improvement, has been approved by the Hawaii Department of Education (HIDOE) as a qualified provider of Comprehensive Assistance, Training & Educational Resources (CATERS). This designation makes it easier for public schools across the state to partner with SFA to strengthen early literacy outcomes through an integrated, proven approach. Already working in 14 Hawaii schools, SFA provides a comprehensive schoolwide model grounded in the Science of Reading, pairing high-quality curriculum with embedded instructional coaching to help educators achieve immediate and lasting results. "Principals and teachers are working hard to do it all: raise reading scores, coach instruction, manage behavior, and find time to plan," said Julie Wible, CEO of Success for All. "With our Science of Reading-based curriculum, built-in coaching, and team-based structures we remove the guesswork and provide educators with an effective model to achieve immediate results. With SFA, schools move forward with clarity and confidence and every child achieves at the highest levels." Success for All partners with schools to align every layer of instruction, support, and leadership into a connected system. Teachers receive real-time coaching as they implement a high-quality, ready-to-teach curriculum. The use of schoolwide practices—such as cooperative learning, daily progress monitoring, and structured leadership teams—ensure that every student's academic and behavioral needs are consistently met. The result is a cohesive, energized instructional environment where educators and students work together toward a shared vision of success. "The transformation in our Hawaii schools has been incredible," said Kathy McLaughlin, Director of Implementation at Success for All. "In just a short time, we've seen classrooms go from silent and disengaged to joyful and alive with student voices. Students are working together, debating ideas, and supporting one another's learning. Schools have embraced cooperative learning, our proven cycle of effective instruction, and practices that help children express their thinking and collaborate respectfully. We're seeing significant academic growth and renewed engagement among teachers, students, and families." In addition to its CATERS approval, SFA is offering $100,000 scholarships to support Title I-eligible Hawaii K–5 schools that are committed to implementing a sustainable, systemwide approach to literacy. To learn more or apply for the scholarship, school leaders can contact:Kenly NovotnySuccess for All Foundationknovotny@ About Success for All FoundationSuccess for All is a nonprofit organization that has partnered with schools for more than 40 years to ensure every child, regardless of background, achieves at the highest levels. Grounded in the Science of Reading and earning the highest ESSA evidence rating, the SFA model offers schools a comprehensive, sustainable path to literacy and academic success. Media Contact Kenly NovotnySuccess for All Foundation396458@ 410.616.2394 View original content to download multimedia: SOURCE Success for All Foundation Error in retrieving data Sign in to access your portfolio Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data
Yahoo
12 hours ago
- Yahoo
Pregnant moose struck and killed on Summit County highway, nonprofit says
PARK CITY, Utah () — A pregnant moose has reportedly been struck and killed on SR-224, according to a local nonprofit. According to (SPSW), a Utah-based nonprofit, the cow (female) moose was found on the side of SR-224 — the highway that runs from I-80 at Kimball Junction to Park City, all the way down to the Summit County border near Midway. 'She was dragged out of sight of the road and discarded like trash,' . 'Let's work together to change our optics and improve safety for all road users by implementing evidence-based solutions to the wildlife vehicle collision problem on this roadway.' Bear sighting in Stansbury Park sparks humor and discussion on social media Save People Save Wildlife was started by residents who were 'alarmed by the number of wildlife-vehicle collisions taking place along the gateway to Park City,' their website says. Volunteers work to track how many animals are killed and push for a wildlife crossing over the roadway. According to numbers compiled by SPSW volunteers, 48 large wildlife were struck and killed on SR-224 in 2024. One coyote, three moose, four elk and 40 deer were counted. SPSW says that this estimate should be multiplied by eight, as experts say 'not all animals die in the location they are struck.' So far, in 2025, seven large wildlife have been killed by vehicles on the road: five deer and two moose. done for the Utah Department of Transportation and Division of Wildlife Resources (DWR) identified the road as the fifth-worst hotspot for animal-vehicle crashes in the state. ABC4 News has reached out to DWR and SPSW for more information about the cow moose. Reporter hit by rubber bullet during live report from Los Angeles immigration protests Logan Police ask for help locating missing 15-year-old Gov. Cox's pick to head new state records office gets OK from Senate panel despite criticism Pregnant moose struck and killed on Summit County highway, nonprofit says Best and worst cities for staycations in the U.S. — how does SLC measure up? Copyright 2025 Nexstar Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.