Nickey Brennan: Crammed fixtures and focus on football rules have hurt hurling
Former GAA president Nickey Brennan argues the combination of a condensed inter-county championship period and football's new rules have taken away from the publicity of hurling.
A clash of broadcasted provincial hurling championship fixtures this Sunday means followers won't be able to take in the three top-tier hurling games in Leinster and Munster.
Brennan also stresses there is less written and said about hurling matches staged on Saturdays, but the Kilkenny man's bigger point is the scheduling difficulties are symptomatic of 'such a short window and you have to cram the matches in.'
He says: 'Let me be clear, I am not for one minute underestimating the challenges faced by the national CCC (competitions control committee) because it has to balance when counties are playing both codes, balance access to venues and TV companies who pay significant money to show the games and also have commitments to other codes.
'There are a lot of balls in the air they have to juggle but right now hurling is not coming out of this well at all. It's losing stakes and because it's crammed it's vying with itself for column inches.
'Because of the incredible work done by Jim Gavin too. He has done a brilliant job with the football rules and it's more entertaining and a much more watchable product, although I feel the real tests for them lie ahead. The rules and the analysis of them have taken up unnatural publicity and are eating up column inches hurling may have gotten as well.'
Brennan can't understand the 3pm scheduling of the Dublin-Kilkenny Leinster SHC game on GAA+ this Sunday, which clashes with the end of the Tipperary-Waterford and start of the Limerick-Cork fixtures in Munster, which will both be televised on RTÉ.
'I absolutely accept that the Munster championship right now is the main hurling product, but Leinster is getting shortchanged. It's getting poor coverage, poor publicity. The crowds aren't coming in great numbers yes but partly because there is so little said about them. Leinster has become a by the way.
'This Sunday, one of the key matches in the competition – Kilkenny v Dublin – is bang in the middle of two big Munster games. Who in the name of God is going to be bothered with that when they'll either be at it or watching the other games on television?
'Some of the scheduling has been horrendous. We seem to be paranoid about going up against football matches. Clare and Tipperary should have been played last Sunday, not the Saturday.'
The lack of promotion for the lower level hurling championships also disappoints Brennan. 'There was a right match on Clubber last Sunday – Carlow v Kildare – in the Joe McDonagh Cup. It was a cracker and we hardly heard a thing about it. The fixtures list that the GAA sends out highlights which games are shown on RTÉ, TG4 or GAA+ but Clubber is not mentioned.
'The Joe McDonagh is hotting up now with right big games. There will always be gaps between tier one and tier two but we should never forget the McDonagh is a fine competition.'
Although the Galway-Antrim game forms part of an anticipated sold-out double header with the footballers' meeting with Dublin on Saturday, Leinster SHC gate receipts are expected to be down this year, which will be offset by last Sunday's Louth-Meath football final.
'The GPA was the reason we lost the pre-season competitions and the provinces lost out on a small fortune,' Brennan highlights. 'The only saving grace for Leinster this year and what will keep it ticking over is the crowd at the football final.
'To be fair to (Leinster chairman) Derek Kent, he was ballsy enough to reduce prices for the first round and get the semi-finals out of Croke Park and the golden goose game came last Sunday. I'm delighted for him because he made some brave calls.'
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Examiner
an hour ago
- Irish Examiner
Kildare's Leinster SHC clash with Galway will be special for the Qualter family
Joe McDonagh Cup final hero David Qualter says facing Galway in next year's Leinster SHC will be a particularly special moment for him and his family. Free-taker Qualter blasted 13 points at Croke Park to help Kildare secure a breakthrough tier two title win, returning them to the MacCarthy Cup race for the first time since 2004. The Maynooth clubman is the grandson of Galway great PJ Qualter who, ironically, lined out in the 1975 National League and All-Ireland finals alongside Joe McDonagh, scoring a goal in both deciders. David's father, Paul Qualter, is a Turloughmore stalwart too while his uncle, Seamus Qualter, had spells in charge of the Westmeath and Roscommon senior teams, as well as Ireland's hurling/shinty side. "My Dad is Turloughmore and growing up I would always imagine myself playing for Galway nearly when I was out on the green playing hurling with the lads," said Qualter. "That's what we're trying to be now for the young Kildare hurlers, a team to look up to and aspire to. Hopefully young lads are looking out at Cian Boran, James Burke and lads like that. We just need to give them a platform to look up to, at what they can be when they grow up. "And look, now we're in the Leinster championship ourselves and we'll be facing them (Galway). It's unreal, I can't believe it." Read More Kildare roar to Liam MacCarthy status with convincing victory over Laois Kildare will have another opportunity to promote hurling in the county when they host Dublin in an All-Ireland preliminary quarter-final tie this weekend. "We'll get a big crowd into Newbridge," predicted Qualter. But it's a MacCarthy Cup fixture that few anticipated, particularly when Kildare started the McDonagh Cup campaign with a loss to Kerry. "We were in a dark place," acknowledged Qualter. "Especially after losing to Down in the league final before that, and then the loss to Kerry. I don't know if I've ever been in a worse room in my life, never mind a dressing-room, after that loss to Kerry. "But we had a chat about it and said a few realities there on the Tuesday night after that and we've just come such a long way since then." Sunday's 10-point defeat of Laois followed Kildare's 11-point win over the same opposition at the group stage last month. They beat Westmeath and Carlow along the way too. It has the appearance of an overnight success story though Qualter smiled at that misconception. "It's just absolutely savage work that's been done by people in the background and Jesus, it's something to be really proud of," he said. "That work didn't just appear after we beat Westmeath, Carlow and Laois, that work was already done even after we lost to Kerry." Qualter said that he personally felt a Joe McDonagh Cup triumph was a possibility from as far back as a couple of seasons ago. That's despite losing all of the games that they'd played in the competition in their two previous seasons in it, 2021 and 2023. "When we got relegated from it two years ago, we were in the pub the day after and we honestly said, 'We are good enough to win the Joe McDonagh'," said Qualter. "We knew we had the talent within the group but then after the loss to Kerry, look, there might have been a seed of doubt out there but between us in the dressing-room and in the panel, and the management, we knew we were going to come back."
Irish Examiner
3 hours ago
- Irish Examiner
Shane Kingston and Conor Lehane 'representing Cork the best way they know how'
'I suppose it's nothing I'm not used to at this stage,' offered Shane Kingston with a wry smile about trying to make an impact from the bench as he did on Saturday. Three points and a goal in the penalty shoot-out was fair clipping as was Conor Lehane's brace, the free he won that Darragh Fitzgibbon sent over in extra-time and of course one of the other two penalties converted by Cork. The pair continue to pack a punch as much as they have both had a quiet season up to the Munster final. A pulled hamstring impacted Kingston's starting chances last year. His galivanting solo earned Patrick Horgan the game-changing penalty goal against Limerick in Cork 13 months ago. He picked off two points from the bench in the All-Ireland final but had been brought on and replaced in the semi-final. This year, his ailment has been a groin issue whereas a dislocated shoulder in February's Division 1A draw with Limerick stopped Lehane in his tracks. Recalled to the panel in 2023, he might not be as acquainted with the cameo role as much as Kingston but is growing into it. 'Sure look, that's the nature of the game. You wouldn't be involved unless you didn't know that going into it. I have no issue. With the talent that's there, representing Cork the best way they know how. "They've done themselves justice numerous times. It's healthy competition.' Kingston's contribution had shades of his seven points coming off the bench against Kilkenny in the 2021 All-Ireland semi-final. "I was actually wearing the same number (23), so it's becoming a bit of a thing now. 'Any day you're not in the starting 15 is obviously disappointing. The management put out their best team on any given day, so you just have to stop feeling sorry for yourself and focus on getting the best out of yourself if you're fortunate to be called upon. 'It's just about coming on and running relentlessly, hoping you get on that ball. For the first five, 10 minutes I didn't touch anything and then I got a ball in from Robbie [O'Flynn] and I just said I'd take it on because the boys were after playing 65, 70 minutes so I knew they'd be tired." Cork 's Eoin Downey and Conor Lehane celebrate after the penalty shoot out against Limerick. Pic: Eddie O'Hare. Kingston's penalty hit wasn't the cleanest. But for it taking an unusual bounce in front of Nickie Quaid, it mightn't have passed the Limerick goalkeeper. 'It was a bad strike too but it went in, so I was lucky,' admitted the Douglas man. "I think Pat came up to me and said, 'Do you want to hit one?' and I said, 'Yeah, absolutely.' Obviously, the confidence was high so I just said I had nothing to lose so I just drove on. From then on, I was just thinking I was going to score and that was kind of it, really. 'I suppose if I wasn't playing well I probably would have been a bit more hesitant hitting it. But confidence was high at the time. As soon as I knew I was hitting one, I just focused on scoring it. I just got the pick and it went in then." Lehane sure felt the tension as he stood up to his strike. 'You'd rather not be in too many of those situations. But when it comes out the better end for you, it's the best feeling in the world. Hopefully it's the last I'll ever do as well. "It was nerve-wracking alright. Nearly got to zone in, hit it as hard as you can and hope for the best.' Both men are complimentary of the value the other gave to Cork at the weekend. 'Shane was unbelievable,' says 32-year-old Lehane of 27-year-old Kingston. 'He's lethal in general. Look, sometimes the ball will go for you and then other times the donkey work that someone might do that you mightn't see that has a huge impact on the game, can happen too.' Kingston remarked of his team-mate from Midleton: 'Lehane came on the last day (v Waterford) as well and got a lovely point. He was lifting there when he came on. He's been showing that in training as well. "Having trained well over the last couple of weeks, it's nice to get the recognition."
RTÉ News
3 hours ago
- RTÉ News
Barry Kelly: Kelly: Munster final required a tighter rein early on
Four-time All-Ireland hurling final referee Barry Kelly believes that Sunday's thrilling Munster final between victors Cork and Limerick required a firmer early touch to clamp down on some of the niggly scenes that accompanied the action at the Gaelic Grounds. In a game ultimately decided by penalties, and saw referee Thomas Walsh replaced by James Owens in extra-time, the first half was notable for plenty of physicality but just six frees with the two management teams clashing as they both tried to approach Walsh as he made his way off the pitch at the break. The third quarter saw a series of cards flashed by the match official, but Kelly felt that it was an approach that maybe should have been deployed earlier in the contest. "It's like riding a horse, you have to let the horse know who's in control and then you can loosen the reins a bit," he told the RTÉ GAA podcast. "There was probably too much of a loose rein early on and it's hard to pull it back then." "'Tyler' (Walsh) probably thought he could go out and blow everything and end up with 40 or 50 frees and no one wants that," Kelly also said. "It's about trying to get the balance and it's a learning curve for 'Tyler.' I had referred Cork and Tipp back in 2004 in Killarney, it was my biggest game, knockout as well and Cork went on to win the All-Ireland – whoever won that game was probably going to go on and win the All-Ireland. "I learned an awful lot that day in Killarney, the match was delayed and it was a hugely intense atmosphere, two teams in knockout hurling championship. "'Tyler' probably went out and said 'OK, I'm going to let this go' because the alternative is to blow everything. "Trying to get the balance right, even the throw-in was a bit chaotic at the start. Six frees like (in the first half). "At half time, and I don't know and I don't want to be dissing 'Tyler' at all because he's a fine referee and he's a great fella, maybe Liam (Gordon), maybe James said to him at half time - there were four five cards given out in the first six, seven minutes of the second half and seven or eight frees." It was a point also made by RTÉ GAA analyst Shane McGrath who pointed to how long it took for Limerick's Aaron Gillane to get a shot at goal from a free. "I know the players have great respect for Thomas Walsh, or 'Tyler' Walsh as everyone now knows his nickname after the weekend. "He is very good with the players, the way he speaks to them and nowadays we are saying to refs 'you have to let it flow' and it's that fine line between letting it flow and blowing for frees. "I think I'm right in this, Aaron Gillane didn't score a free until there was 52, 53 minutes gone in the game. And that wasn't Aaron Gillane missing frees, there just weren't frees given."
