The national gallery ‘masterpiece' that's 91% likely to be a fake
On the second floor of the National Gallery hangs a prized painting that, when it changed hands in 1980, was bought for a record sum. The original Samson and Delilah was painted by the 17th century Flemish master Peter Paul Rubens around 1609; it was a commission from his close friend and patron Nicolaas II Rockox, the mayor of Antwerp, to hang above his fireplace. It is now seemingly in pride of place in the gallery on Trafalgar Square in London. However, some art historians argue this is not a long-lost Rubens masterpiece at all – contending instead that it is an extraordinarily expensive fake.
The question of its authenticity is one of the great unsolved mysteries of the art world. Around 1641, the painting disappeared, before mysteriously resurfacing in Paris nearly three centuries later, in 1929. A German scholar named Ludwig Burchard – now discredited as he was found to have misattributed works for commercial gain – declared it was the real deal, the missing Rubens' masterpiece that had been lost to history. Then, in 1980, the National Gallery purchased the piece in an auction at Christie's for £2.5 million (a bargain by today's standards, but at that time, a record-breaking price).
It depicts the Biblical story of Samson and Delilah, in which Samson's hair is cut to reduce his superhuman strength. Some critics argue that just as Samson is betrayed by his Philistine lover as he lies sleeping in her lap, the National Gallery blindly handed over a record-breaking sum of public money for a facsimile.
This week, the debate over the painting's authenticity has been reignited ahead of the publication of a book on the subject with the no-nonsense title NG6461: The Fake Rubens. For its author, the Greek painter and art historian Euphrosyne Doxiadis, this is the culmination of a career's worth of research on the mystery of the Rubens' authenticity.
In 1992, when Doxiadis was a mature student at the Wimbledon School of Art, she visited the National Gallery and was immediately struck by the colour and craftsmanship of the painting, which she believes is inconsistent with Rubens' other work, such as The Raising of the Cross, which dates from 1610/11. Doxiadis, along with two fellow students, submitted a report to the Gallery setting out what they claimed was evidence that the prized painting is a copy. The arguments contained in it have persisted to this day. 'The execution seemed crude, the colour unsubtle and uncharacteristic of Rubens' palette,' the report said. 'The tonal values were incorrect in relation to the light sources. The handling of the paint was very crude, the draughtsmanship was poor and there was weakness in the depiction of textures.'
There were whispers from then on. Those who question the painting's authenticity have built on these arguments. The painting that hangs in the National Gallery differs from eyewitness reproductions from the period, they say. It is deeply unusual for the artist – although many scholars contest this – and too garishly coloured, they argue. There are five soldiers in the doorway, rather than three, as shown in contemporaneous reproductions such as a c.1613 engraving made by the Dutch printmaker Jacob Matham. One is even staring directly at the viewer. Could this even be a hint as to the identity of its creator? And what happened to Samson's left foot which, in the painting hung in the Gallery, has no toes? They appear in a Frans Francken the Younger's painting Supper at the House of Burgomaster Rockox, showing Ruben's work hanging in the spot its owner intended.
In a 1997 article for the Sunday Times, art critic Waldemar Januszczak came to a strident conclusion on the painting's origins. 'The one thing all we doubters agree on is that the painting bought by the gallery for a staggering sum in 1980 is not by Rubens,' he wrote. He has since, reportedly, changed his mind. The same year, tired of deflecting questions on the subject, the National Gallery issued a press release hoping to offer evidence of the painting's legitimacy: 'Every technical test carried out to date has yielded results consistent with the date of about 1609 and the attribution to Rubens.' To settle the score once and for all, perhaps, the Gallery said it would host a public debate on the subject – a debate that never took place.
Speculation bubbled under the surface for decades until, in 2021, an authentication test conducted by a Swiss company called Art Recognition seemed to prove once and for all that the painting is fake. It used AI analysis to compare Samson and Delilah with other Rubens' paintings and concluded that it was 91 per cent likely to be a copy. Dr Carina Popovici, who carried out the study, said at the time: 'The results are quite astonishing… Every patch, every single square, came out as fake, with more than 90 per cent probability.' There is even a campaign group founded by Doxiadis, called 'In Rubens' Name,' which is calling for the National Gallery to apologise and 'admit an honest mistake'.
Doxiadis, now 78, said that on that fateful visit to the National Gallery, she knew something was wrong with the painting 'at first glance'. So much so, in fact, that she has dedicated her career to proving the Rubens scholars – who almost unanimously believe it is authentic – wrong. She has even alleged that, at a dinner party in Athens, a former National Gallery trustee told her he wanted 'the truth' about the artwork to come out.
'It has been a long time – 40 years – since I first saw the fake painting,' she says. 'There is a famous art historian called Max Jakob Friedländer, who said the first impression is the most important, and I believe in first impressions when you are someone who's trained to see.' She is emphatic: 'Everything is wrong about [the painting.] It's bad technique, bad colour. It is artless – there's no craftsmanship.'
But it is not just the National Gallery who refuses to challenge the orthodoxy on the subject, she argues. The Rubenianum, a centre and archive dedicated to the study of Rubens located within the Rubenshuis in Antwerp, has always maintained that the Gallery's Samson and Delilah 'is the lost Rubens… even though there is no proof whatsoever,' according to Doxiadis. To entertain any other possibility would be impossible, as 'Rubens is for Belgium what the Acropolis is for Greece.'
Many scholars, however, disagree entirely, regarding this recurrent debate as less of a mystery and more of a 'storm in a teacup'. '[Doxiadis] – who, by the way, has mostly published on ancient Greco-Roman artwork rather than the 17th century – had a hunch the quality of the picture wasn't good enough, but I think there are some misunderstandings about the painting,' says Dr Adam Busiakiewicz, an art historian who specialises in the Old Masters. 'It was made at a specific point in his career when he had spent a lot of time in Italy,' he adds, and his style had been influenced by the great Renaissance works he saw on his travels. For one, he says, 'the comparisons that are made between [Rubens other] paintings are comparing paintings made decades apart.'
'He's an artist that changes his style throughout his career… Art historians who specialise in paintings like Rubens' can track these changes. I would also say that when you work for an auction house like I have, when you start to see paintings en masse, you understand that copies have a dead quality that is nothing like a masterpiece. It's very easy to spot a 20th century copy – the pigments will feel different, and you don't see any of that here,' he continues. It is, without a shadow of doubt, 'a 17th century painting.'
A spokesman for the National Gallery said: 'Samson and Delilah has long been accepted by leading Rubens scholars as a masterpiece by Peter Paul Rubens. Painted on wood panel in oil shortly after his return to Antwerp in 1608 and demonstrating all that the artist had learned in Italy, it is a work of the highest aesthetic quality. A technical examination of the picture was presented in an article in the National Gallery's Technical Bulletin in 1983. The findings remain valid.'
If Doxiadis' theory – a blunder of this magnitude at the highest echelons of the British art world regarding one of the world's most revered artists and most valuable paintings – was proved true, the repercussions would be seismic.
More likely, though, is that its authenticity – or not – will remain a subject of debate, if not just a riveting story. Doxiadis herself is a mystery – a whistleblower regarded by much of the art establishment as a heretic. As confident as she may be, Busiakiewicz argues that Samson and Delilah could be in no one except Rubens' hand. 'It is a really stonking great picture,' he says. 'The textures, the sumptuous drapery, the muscular back – no one except Rubens could have painted that.'
Broaden your horizons with award-winning British journalism. Try The Telegraph free for 1 month with unlimited access to our award-winning website, exclusive app, money-saving offers and more.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
Lyna Khoudri & Lucas Bravo, Georgina Amorós & Omar Ayuso Among Duos To Play Elizabeth Bennet & Mr. Darcy In Multilingual Audible Versions Of ‘Pride & Prejudice'
EXCLUSIVE: Lyna Khoudri and Lucas Bravo, Georgina Amorós and Omar Ayuso, Emilia Schüle and Aaron Altaras, Julia Dalavia and Rodrigo Simas, and Ludovica Martino and Federico Cesari have been cast to portray Elizabeth Bennet and Mr. Darcy in the upcoming multilingual Audible Original adaptations of Jane Austen's Pride and Prejudice. The new audio series will be available in German, Italian, French, Brazilian Portuguese, and Castilian Spanish, from September 9 in Germany, France, and French Canada and on October 6, in Spain, Brazil, Italy, and for US Hispanic Audiences. More from Deadline 'From The Oasthouse: The Alan Partridge Podcast' Returning For Season 4 Winston Duke Set To Lead Audible Thriller Series 'Kingsland' From Kevin Hart & Charlamagne Tha God's SBH Productions Caleb McLaughlin To Star In Scripted Podcast 'Sacrilege: Curse of the Mbirwi' For Audible & QCODE The castings and schedule is as follows: Releasing September 9, 2025: German: Emilia Schüle as Elizabeth Bennet and Aaron Altaras Mr. Darcy French: Lyna Khoudri as Elizabeth Bennet and Lucas Bravo) as Mr. Darcy – releasing in France and French Canada Releasing October 6, 2025: Italian: Ludovica Martino as Elizabeth Bennet and Federico Cesari as Mr. Darcy Brazilian Portuguese: Julia Dalavia as Elizabeth Bennet and Rodrigo Simas as Mr. Darcy Castilian Spanish: Georgina Amorós as Elizabeth Bennet and Omar Ayuso as Mr. Darcy – releasing in Spain and the US. Today's casting follows the recently announced English language cast, led by BAFTA nominated Marisa Abela (Industry) as Elizabeth Bennet, and BAFTA and BIFA nominated Harris Dickinson (Babygirl) who will play Mr. Darcy, as well Will Poulter, Jessie Buckley, Toheeb Jimoh, David Gyasi, Rosalind Eleazar, Bertie Carvel, Charlotte Lucas, Bill Nighy, Marianne Jean Baptise, Sophie Wilde, Antonia Salib, Patricia Allison, Aasiya Shah and Glenn Close. Audible's Pride and Prejudice has been adapted from the original by writer Lulu Raczka (Women, Beware The Devil) and is produced in collaboration with production company Brock Media, was executive-produced by Sarah Brocklehurst (The Outrun) and produced by Nicole Davis. Produced in Dolby Atmos, the audio drama features cinematic sound design by Brain Audio and an original score by Grammy nominated producer and composer Morgan Kibby. The English language adaptation of Pride and Prejudice, also releases in the UK, US, Canada, India and Australia on September 9th, during the year of the 250th anniversary of Jane Austen's birth. Aurelie de Troyer, Head of Regional content Europe at Audible commented: 'Jane Austen's Pride and Prejudice continues to captivate audiences worldwide, and Audible is thrilled to delight audiences with our most ambitious multi-language audio adaptation yet, with six language editions launching globally in 2025. Each Elizabeth and Mr. Darcy pairing has been perfectly matched, bringing electric chemistry to their performances, as only the intimacy of audio can deliver.' The book's synopsis reads: 'When Elizabeth Bennet meets the handsome Mr. Darcy, she believes he is the last man she could ever marry, but as their lives become intertwined, she finds herself captivated by the man she has sworn to hate forever.' Best of Deadline List Of Hollywood & Media Layoffs From Paramount To Warner Bros Discovery To CNN & More Sean 'Diddy' Combs Sex-Trafficking Trial Updates: Cassie Ventura's Testimony, $10M Hotel Settlement, Drugs, Violence, & The Feds A Full Timeline Of Blake Lively & Justin Baldoni's 'It Ends With Us' Feud In Court, Online & In The Media
Yahoo
10 hours ago
- Yahoo
Over 300 Pieces of Princess Diana's Dresses, Handbags, and More Are Heading to Auction
There have been many Princess Diana-related auctions held over the years—Lady Di herself auctioned off than 79 of her dresses at Christie's in 1997, in fact—but the sale taking place at Julien's Auction later this month may be the biggest yet. The auction house claims the event will include the largest collection of the late royal's fashion to ever go under the hammer. Taking place at the Peninsula Beverly Hills on June 26, Princess Diana's Style & A Royal Collection will spotlight more than 300 extraordinary items of royal provenance. Included in the lots are some of the most memorable dresses, suits, and accessories ever worn by the Princess of Wales—many of which have never before appeared at auction, according to Julien's. More from Robb Report From Pappy Van Winkle to Macallan: An Epic Single-Owner Whiskey Collection Is Heading to Auction Art Dealer Barbara Gladstone's Elegant Manhattan Row House Lists for $12 Million Airstream's Newest Luxury Trailer Feels Like a Frank Lloyd Wright Home Inside Diana became a style icon soon after being thrust into the spotlight in the 1980s due to her high-profile relationship with Prince Charles. Her fashion evolved from modest and traditional to elegant and bold as she navigated her life in the public eye. She worked with many different designers, as illustrated by the diverse pieces on offer at Julien's. One of the auction highlights is a silk floral day dress designed by Belville Sassoon (pictured top). Expected to fetch between $100,000 and $200,000, the frock was a staple in Diana's wardrobe and was donned for many official visits and public appearances. It was actually dubbed the Caring Dress, as the princess often wore it to see patients in hospitals, according to designer David Sassoon. Another standout is a custom cream evening gown that Catherine Walker designed for Diana for her 1986 royal tour of Saudi Arabia. The elegant gown, which is expected to hammer down for between $200,000 and $300,000, features a high neckline and long Guinevere-style point sleeves to accommodate local dressing customs. At the other, more daring end of the spectrum is a two-piece Bruce Oldfield set that Lady Di wore to Royal Ascot in 1987. Oldfield began designing for the princess in the mid-1980s with more daring fashions, leading the press to dub her 'Dynasty-Di.' This silk ensemble carries a pre-sale estimate of $100,000 to $200,000. Accessories will abound at the auction, too. Highlights include Lady Di's stylish John Boyd hat (estimate: $20,000 to $40,000) and her coveted Lady Dior lambskin handbag (estimate: $20,000 to $30,000). That is just a taste of 300 rarities on offer. 'Princess Diana's legacy lives on not only through her humanitarian work but also in the timeless elegance of her style, which continues to inspire the world,' Martin Nolan, cofounder and executive director of Julien's Auctions, said in a statement. 'This unprecedented collection offers collectors and admirers a rare opportunity to own a piece of royal history and pay tribute to one of the most beloved figures of our time.' In keeping with Diana's philanthropic spirit, a portion of the proceeds from the auction will benefit Muscular Dystrophy UK. Bidding and registration are now open online. The live auction will take place in the Peninsula's Verandah Ballroom, with guests served Champagne and the hotel's signature afternoon tea, naturally. Click to see photos of the key auction lots. Best of Robb Report The 10 Priciest Neighborhoods in America (And How They Got to Be That Way) In Pictures: Most Expensive Properties Click here to read the full article.
Yahoo
12 hours ago
- Yahoo
Artistic head of Hamburg Ballet let go amid work culture complaints
Demis Volpi, a German-Argentinian choreographer, is to step down as artistic director of the world-renowned Hamburg Ballet Company following massive criticism from the ensemble over a "toxic work environment." Volpi's contract will be prematurely terminated following mutual agreement and the 39-year-old is set to leave the company at the end of the season, the local cultural authority in the northern German city said on Tuesday. As part of the agreement, Volpi is set to stop working at the ballet immediately, it said. Volpi, who succeeded the company's founder John Neumeier, a 86-year-old American, a year ago, has been the subject of widespread criticism, including from the company's dancers. In a letter to Hamburg's culture minister, 36 dancers - more than half of the company - accused him of creating a "toxic work environment" as well as a lack of competence. Seventeen former and current dancers at the Dusseldorf-based Ballett am Rhein, where Volpi worked previously, also sent complaints to the Hamburg minister. In response, management at the Hamburg State Opera, which includes the ballet company, launched a risk assessment to question all ensemble members anonymously about their work situation. "My vision - both in artistic terms and with regard to a contemporary structure that enables open and responsible collaboration within a ballet company - could no longer be realized under the current conditions at the Hamburg Ballet, despite intensive efforts," Volpi said. "In the interests of all those involved, we have therefore agreed to end my directorship by mutual consent." Following Volpi's departure, efforts are under way to find an interim artistic director to lead the company until the conclusion of the 2025/26 season.