logo
CNRL was fined $278K after hundreds of birds died in a tailings pond. Now it has launched an appeal

CNRL was fined $278K after hundreds of birds died in a tailings pond. Now it has launched an appeal

CBC10-02-2025

A major operator in Alberta's oilsands is appealing a $278,000 regulatory fine it was issued after hundreds of birds died in one of its toxic tailings ponds.
Canadian Natural Resources Ltd. was sanctioned last year by the Alberta Energy Regulator for not stopping the birds from nesting on an island that emerged from a pond at the Horizon oilsands mine, about 60 kilometres north of Fort McMurray.
Throughout the spring and summer of 2022, more than 400 California gulls died from exposure to the contaminated water.
CNRL was convicted of a single count under the Environmental Protection and Enhancement Act for failing to safely contain the hazardous substances that are found in their tailings ponds.
Six months since the fine was levied, the AER has now granted the Calgary-based company leave to appeal the sanction.
Critics say CNRL should take accountability for the environmental infractions.
'The wrong message'
"It sends the wrong message," said David Spink, an environmental consultant and former industry regulator with the Alberta government.
"There's no question that the birds died and there's no question that it was your facility that was responsible."
In a statement to CBC News, AER said the sanction is eligible for an appeal under the regulations laid out in the Responsible Energy Development Act but a hearing date has not yet been set. CNRL declined to comment, citing the pending review.
Spink, who once served as a director of air and water approvals for Alberta, said the fine is small price to pay for an oil and gas giant such as CNRL. The Calgary-based operator reported a net income of $8.2 billion in 2023.
The appeal demonstrates that CNRL is unwilling to answer for its infractions, he said.
"They may not be eager to accept this blemish on their environmental record," he said.
The contravention is among a string of mass bird deaths in the oilsands.
The high-profile landings prompted years of research and monitoring aimed at preventing flocks from dying in Alberta's expanse of tailings ponds.
The Athabasca oilsands are at the centre of a major migratory pathway for birds and protecting the species that fly over the region is a condition of licence for all oilsands producers.
A 'standard of perfection'
CNRL has previously denied its negligence in the 2022 bird deaths. At the time, the company argued that it should not be held to a "standard of perfection" in its efforts to protect the birds.
The regulator in turn, ruled that CNRL did not take reasonable steps to prevent the deaths by failing to destroy the island before it became a nesting site.
Colleen Cassady St. Clair, a University of Alberta biologist and expert in bird deaths in the oilsands, said CNRL should have known that islands in tailings ponds were attractive to birds and posed a risk to passing flocks.
St. Clair was the lead researcher of the Research on Avian Protection Project, a three-year study that examined how to better protect birds in Alberta's oilsands after 1,600 died at a Syncrude tailings pond in 2008.
She said the industrial hazards to birds have been well understood for decades.
"They had lots of warning," she said. "They don't have to be perfect, but they should be trying to absolutely minimize those mortalities.
"It's hard to see an argument that they couldn't have anticipated this problem."
The case dates back to the spring of 2022 when workers at the mine discovered birds on the island in an area known as Tar River Valley on the north side of the Horizon mine.
The island had taken shape the previous spring, at the centre of a tailings pond, due to receding waters and re-emerged the following year.
According to the CNRL's formal bird protection protocols, such islands should be destroyed to prevent birds from touching down. But the company failed to act in this case. They considered the island low risk as birds had initially shown no interest.
The small stretch of land soon became a nesting and hatching site for colonies of birds.
By May 21, 2022, CNRL workers counted a single Canada goose nest and 271 California gull nests along its beaches.
The company informed the regulator on June 7, more than two weeks later. By then, CNRL reported that it had installed bird deterrents on the island, including pyrotechnics and rockets.
But the hazing efforts were unsuccessful. Each day, the gulls would disperse and land again.
On July 12, CNRL reported that between 60 and 70 California gull chicks had been discovered on the island, covered in oil.
As the weeks went on, workers kept finding carcasses and gull chicks fouled with bitumen. Predators including wolves and coyotes passed through the shallow water to hunt on the island, feeding on the contaminated flocks and flushing more birds into the toxic waters.
The situation continued until Aug. 4, when the surviving chicks were old enough to fly away.
According to the regulator, 411 birds died before the island was finally destroyed that September.
Even a light oiling can threaten their survival, interfering with their ability to eat, fly and protect themselves from the elements.
Soiled birds can become trapped in the thick liquid, often drowning from the weight on their feathers.
The toxic slurry found in tailings can not only make the birds sick, it can also prove toxic to other wildlife which consume them.
'Evasion of responsibility'
The company argued that, due to the Migratory Bird Convention Act, there was little they could do once the nests were established.
St. Clair described that argument as "slippery" and said the findings of the AER investigation were clear.
"Many months of inaction is not consistent with an attitude of due diligence," she said.
It's hard to fathom why CNRL has launched an appeal and it will erode public confidence in the operator, she said.
"I think the public has some tolerance for mistakes, whether it's this industry or any other industry, and less tolerance for evasion of responsibility."

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

G7: Why there is hope of a Carney-Trump tariff breakthrough at Alberta summit

time34 minutes ago

G7: Why there is hope of a Carney-Trump tariff breakthrough at Alberta summit

Global trade will be a major focus at next week's G7 summit as world leaders gather in Alberta, including U.S. President Donald Trump, who will be making his first appearance at a major international event since returning to the White House in January. Experts and ambassadors are expressing some optimism that this type of event could be a difference-maker in convincing Trump to reduce the amount of tariffs charged on imports to the U.S. Any possible concessions on the trade front would be welcomed by countries such as Canada, that are facing economic hardship because of tariffs. It's issue No. 1, said John Kirton, director of the G7 Research Group at the University of Toronto. On Wednesday, CBC News (new window) and Radio-Canada reported (new window) that talks between Prime Minister Mark Carney and Donald Trump are advanced enough that a document containing a draft economic and security agreement has been exchanged between the Prime Minister's Office and the White House. Ottawa is stepping up its efforts in recent weeks to reach an agreement before the end of the G7 summit. Global trade has slowed as a result of the ever-changing tariffs announced by Trump that have targeted various countries and also certain materials, such as steel and aluminum. In response, many countries, including Canada, have enacted their own tariffs. Canada's unemployment rate has climbed to seven per cent, which economists say is a sign the trade war with the U.S. is taking a toll on the job market, especially the manufacturing sector. Trade and tariffs are the make or break issue that will determine whether the summit in the Alberta Rocky Mountain village of Kananaskis Country is a success or not, said Kirton. The G7 leaders' summit is coming to Kananaskis Country, Alta., this month. The region is known for its forests, lakes and mountains. Photo: Radio-Canada / Lyssia Baldini For now, he's hopeful the various leaders' meetings and one-on-one conversations could produce results. [Trump] likes to deliver big wins and the other G7 leaders are smart enough to deliver agreements which are real wins, said Kirton, pointing to how countries could pledge to increase defence spending and make other commitments, in exchange for lower tariffs on imports into the U.S. World leaders, including Carney, Trump and leaders from France, Germany, Italy, Japan and the United Kingdom, as well as the European Union, are meeting in Alberta from June 15 to 17 for talks on a variety of other issues, including climate change and managing rapidly evolving technology. What you need to know about the G7 summit in Alberta (new window) The summit is a high-profile event, yet only involves a handful of world leaders, which is noteworthy, said Gary Mar, CEO of the Canada West Foundation, an Alberta-based think-tank. One of the reasons the G7 is effective is because it's a small group. It's small enough that it's focused and can really be productive, said Mar, who was part of the welcoming party at the Calgary airport when world leaders arrived for the last summit held in Kananaskis in 2002. Trade was not nearly as contentious at that gathering, but rather promoted as having a profound impact on economic growth and development around the world. At the time, U.S. President George Bush even highlighted the value of trade with Canada during the opening press conference. We've got a significant relationship together. It's a vibrant, positive friendship, said Bush. Trade is in the interests of all of us. There are some problems on occasion, but we've got the kind of relationship where we can be very frank about it and try to work them out. The 2002 summit was held less than 12 months after the terrorist attack on the Pentagon and World Trade Center, which is why the main focus was to discuss the war on terrorism and responding to the threat of weapons of mass destruction. Geopolitical tension and conflicts are expected to be one of the talking points at this year's G7, but the tariff situation will likely top the agenda. Trade policy needs to be discussed urgently, said Matthias Lüttenberg, Germany's ambassador to Canada, while on stage at a recent event in Calgary to discuss the G7. Free trade and open markets for Germany is one of the most important pillars of our economic world view and it's the foundation of prosperity and sustainable growth for all of us, he said. The G7 has an important role to play and the summit has value in producing results on global issues, Lüttenberg said, a sentiment shared by other ambassadors attending the G7 event. We know how it works and we have achieved so much together already. And I'm not only talking about leader statements, but it's also the practical work, he explained, pointing to the example of how the G7 agreed on certain sanctions against Russia following its invasion of Ukraine, while also working toward how to help Ukraine rebuild. Global economic growth is slowing more than expected only a few months ago as a result of the Trump administration's trade war, the Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development said earlier this month. The global economy is on pace to slow from 3.3 per cent last year to 2.9 per cent in 2025 because of the tariff fallout, the agency (new window) said, trimming its estimates from March for growth of 3.1 per cent this year. Kyle Bakx (new window) · CBC News

MEG Energy ramping up operations at Christina Lake after nearby wildfires
MEG Energy ramping up operations at Christina Lake after nearby wildfires

CTV News

timean hour ago

  • CTV News

MEG Energy ramping up operations at Christina Lake after nearby wildfires

CALGARY — MEG Energy Corp. says it's ramping up operations at its Christina Lake oilsands project after recent wildfires south of the operations. The company says all personnel have returned to site and its connection to Alberta's electric grid has been restored. MEG also says it has commenced restarting Phase 2B operations after successful completion of a turnaround. Last month, the company withdrew non-essential personnel from the Christina Lake project due to the fires. The wildfire caused an outage to third-party power line infrastructure connecting the project to Alberta's electric grid, prompting the company to disconnect from the grid. The power outage delayed startup of the Phase 2B operations, which represent about 70,000 barrels per day of production. This report by The Canadian Press was first published June 12, 2025.

Northland Power Achieves First Power on Hai Long Offshore Wind Project
Northland Power Achieves First Power on Hai Long Offshore Wind Project

Toronto Star

timean hour ago

  • Toronto Star

Northland Power Achieves First Power on Hai Long Offshore Wind Project

Hai Long offshore substation in the Taiwan Strait. TORONTO, June 12, 2025 (GLOBE NEWSWIRE) — Northland Power Inc. (TSX: NPI) today announced first power from its Hai Long Offshore Wind Project in Taiwan, marking successful energization of the project and connection to Taipower's grid. This achievement comes ahead of the second half of 2025, underscoring the project's strong construction momentum. The milestone also includes the commissioning of both onshore and offshore substations, further demonstrating the project's progress toward full commercial operations, anticipated in 2027. 'Achieving first power is a significant milestone for Northland and reflects the dedication of our team and partners,' said Christine Healy, President and CEO of Northland Power. 'We extend our deepest appreciation to our joint teams, partners, and contractors for their extraordinary efforts.' ARTICLE CONTINUES BELOW Since the commencement of construction, Hai Long has made substantial progress, including the production of jacket foundations and pin piles, installation of the Hai Long 2 and 3 offshore substations, installation of all 219 pin piles, assembly of Taiwan's first locally manufactured 14 MW wind turbine nacelle and the installation of 14 out of 73 turbines. With a planned capacity of 1 GW, Hai Long will play a vital role in supporting Taiwan's renewable energy target of 15 GW of offshore wind between 2026 and 2035. Once operational, Hai Long will be among the largest offshore wind farms in the Asia-Pacific region, providing clean electricity to over one million Taiwanese homes. 'This milestone is a testament to the teamwork, technical excellence, and shared commitment from all involved,' said Toby Edmonds, Executive Vice President, Offshore Wind. 'First power represents real progress, not just for Hai Long, but for Taiwan's broader offshore wind ambitions. We're excited to keep building on this momentum.' ABOUT NORTHLAND POWER Northland Power is a Canada-based global power producer dedicated to accelerating the global energy transition. Founded in 1987, with almost four decades of experience, Northland has a long history of developing, owning and operating a diversified mix of energy infrastructure assets including offshore and onshore wind, solar, battery energy storage, and natural gas. Northland also supplies energy through a regulated utility. Headquartered in Toronto, Canada, with global offices in seven countries, Northland owns or has an economic interest in 3.5 GW of gross operating generating capacity, 2.2 GW under construction and an inventory of early to mid-stage development opportunities encompassing approximately 10 GW of potential capacity. Publicly traded since 1997, Northland's Common Shares, Series 1 and Series 2 Preferred Shares trade on the Toronto Stock Exchange under the symbols NPI, and respectively. ARTICLE CONTINUES BELOW ARTICLE CONTINUES BELOW FORWARD-LOOKING STATEMENTS This news release contains statements that constitute forward-looking information within the meaning of applicable securities laws ('forward-looking statements') that are provided for the purpose of presenting information about management's current expectations and plans. Readers are cautioned that such statements may not be appropriate for other purposes. Northland's actual results could differ materially from those expressed in, or implied by, these forward-looking statements and, accordingly, the events anticipated by the forward-looking statements may or may not transpire or occur. Forward-looking statements include statements that are predictive in nature, depend upon or refer to future events or conditions, or include words such as 'anticipates', 'expects,' 'believes,' or negative versions thereof and other similar expressions or future or conditional verbs such as 'may,' 'will,' 'should,' 'would' and 'could.' These statements may include, without limitation, statements regarding Northland's expectations for the completion of construction and anticipated timing thereof, the anticipated sequence of construction operations, the timing for and attainment of commercial operations, the expected generating capacity of the project, and the future operations of the project, all of which may differ from the expectations stated herein. These statements are based upon certain material factors or assumptions that were applied in developing the forward-looking statements, including the design specifications of development of the project, the current construction schedule of the project, the provisions of contracts to which Northland or a subsidiary is a party, as well as other factors, estimates, and assumptions that are believed to be appropriate in the circumstances. Although these forward-looking statements are based upon management's current reasonable expectations and assumptions, they are subject to numerous risks and uncertainties. Some of the factors include, but are not limited to, those described in the 'Risks Factors' section of Northland's Management's Discussion and Analysis and Annual Information Form for the year ended December 31, 2024, which can be found at under Northland's profile and on Northland's website at Northland has attempted to identify important factors that could cause actual results to materially differ from current expectations, however, there may be other factors that cause actual results to differ materially from such expectations. Northland's actual results could differ materially from those expressed in, or implied by, these forward-looking statements and, accordingly, no assurances can be given that any of the events anticipated by the forward-looking statements will transpire or occur, and Northland cautions you not to place undue reliance upon any such forward-looking statements. The forward-looking statements contained in this release are, unless otherwise indicated, stated as of the date hereof and are based on assumptions that were considered reasonable as of the date hereof. Other than as specifically required by law, Northland undertakes no obligation to update any forward-looking statements to reflect events or circumstances after such date or to reflect the occurrence of unanticipated events, whether as a result of new information, future events or results, or otherwise. For further information, please contact: Adam Beaumont, SVP, Capital Markets 416-962-6262 investorrelations@ Victor Gravili, Head of Global Brand & Integrated Communications 647-288-1105 communications@ A photo accompanying this announcement is available at

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store