Scottish oil and gas firm fined £300,000 after 'terrifying incident'
The episode happened on the FPF-1 offshore platform, owned by Aberdeen-based Ithaca Energy (UK) Limited, during a night shift on December 10, 2020.
The men had been descending in a lift inside one of the platform's legs to carry out routine inspection work at the base of one of the sub-sea columns when they experienced a 'rush of air'.
Before the lift reached the bottom of the shaft it started to fill with water, which was up to the men's knees by the time they were able to stop the lift by pressing the emergency button, the Health and Safety Executive (HSE) said.
READ MORE: SNP to consider banning football fans caught using flares at games
They returned to the main deck safely and none of the men sustained any injuries.
An HSE investigation found that hardware failures and incorrect operating procedures had caused the bottom of the lift shaft to flood while the inspection site was being cleared of standing water.
The HSE also found that a lack of water alarms at the bottom of the lift shaft also meant the control room was unaware that water was flooding into the shaft.
The investigation found that water marks on the lift door showed the water had reached a level of just under 1.5m before the lift was stopped.
Meanwhile, Ithaca's own investigation found the water level could have reached more than three metres – which would have made it difficult for the men to have escaped through the top hatch of the lift if the workers had used the lift later, or not been able to stop it as quickly as they did.
Ithaca pleaded guilty to safety failings at a hearing at Aberdeen Sheriff Court on June 12, and were issued with a £300,000 fine, the HSE said.
HSE inspector Ian Chilley said: 'This was a terrifying incident for the workers involved, we are just thankful that no physical harm came to them.
'This fine should send a message and reminder to those operating offshore facilities for them to be extra vigilant.
'It was only a matter of good fortune that this incident didn't result in serious injury, or worse.'
READ MORE: Search concludes after man goes overboard from Clyde ferry
The HSE added that when passing sentence, the sheriff said the case marked 'another reminder of the need for rigorous adherence to health and safety in the oil and gas industry'.
The HSE also issued an improvement notice in the immediate aftermath of the incident, and work in confined spaces was halted until February 2021 while a full review of the incident was carried out.
An Ithaca Energy spokesperson said: "Ithaca Energy takes its responsibilities in relation to the health, safety and welfare of its employees and contractors extremely seriously, and takes considerable pride in its excellent safety record.
"The company has treated the matter with the utmost seriousness and accepts its responsibility for the failings that led to the incident, where thankfully no individual was harmed.
"A thorough internal investigation was launched immediately, and the Company has worked closely with the HSEx to implement and comply with the recommendations of their findings."
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Wales Online
3 hours ago
- Wales Online
Air India crash investigators reveal new breakthrough theory on cause of tragedy
Air India crash investigators reveal new breakthrough theory on cause of tragedy Investigators probing the crash of Air India flight AI171 in Ahmedabad have given an insight into their investigation The fuselage of the crashed Air India jet after leaving Ahmedabad (Image: Copyright 2025 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. ) The ill-fated Air India flight that tragically crashed last Thursday may have had an emergency-power generator in operation at the time of the crash, according to investigators. This revelation raises questions about whether the engine of the AI171 flight was functioning correctly during take-off. The aircraft met its tragic end in a residential area just seconds after departing from Ahmedabad airport. The Wall Street Journal reported that the failure of both engines during take off was being looked into as the cause of the devastating loss of at least 270 lives in the crash, including 241 out of the 242 people on board the plane and several individuals on the ground in the Indian city. The emergency system, known as a ram air turbine, is designed to deploy automatically in flight if both engines fail or if all three hydraulic system pressures are low, as per the instruction manual for Boeing 787 planes. This back-up system is typically activated if a pilot believes that both engines have failed. Engine failure can be triggered by a variety of factors, such as bird strikes or fuel issues. Anthony Brickhouse, a US-based aerospace safety consultant, told the Wall Street Journal that twin engine failures were extremely rare, reports the Express. Mr Brickhouse told the WSJ: "Engine failures can result from a variety of causes, including bird strikes or problems with fuel. Article continues below 'In commercial aviation, a dual engine failure is extremely rare. Our engines today are more efficient and reliable than ever.' The flight only reached a maximum altitude of 625 feet after leaving the airport in Ahmedabad. It stopped submitting location data just 50 seconds into the flight. The investigation is probing whether the flight suffered a loss or reduction of thrust but, despite the finding about the ram air turbine, investigators have not confirmed exactly what happened or why the emergency system was triggered. It is the first time that one of the Boeing 787 Dreamliner jets have suffered a fatal incident since the airliner went into service in 2011. A Foreign Office spokeswoman said: "Our staff continue to work around the clock in the UK and India to support the families and loved ones of all those impacted by the crash. "We have set up a reception centre at the Ummed Hotel, near the Ahmedabad airport, and have a dedicated helpline to provide support and advice for the families and friends of British nationals - friends or family should call 020 7008 5000. Article continues below "If you are in India, you should call +91 (11) 24192100 for support, including through in-person consular staff who are available to support families of British nationals, including accompanying them to the hospital. "Furthermore, the UK Air Accidents Investigation Branch has deployed an investigation team to support the Indian-led investigation on the ground, and UK forensic experts are there to support the consular response."
Daily Mirror
13 hours ago
- Daily Mirror
'Terrifying' North Sea rig incident saw workers lowered into flooded lift shaft
Ithaca Energy (UK) Limited pleaded guilty to safety failings at a hearing at Aberdeen Sheriff Court on June 12, and were issued with a £300,000 fine, the HSE said An oil and gas operator has been fined £300,000 following a"terrifying incident" on a North Sea rig that saw three workers lowered into a flooded lift shaft. The episode happened on the FPF-1 offshore platform, owned by Ithaca Energy (UK) Limited, during a night shift on December 10, 2020. The men had been descending in a lift inside one of the platform's legs to carry out routine inspection work at the base of one of the sub-sea columns when they experienced a "rush of air". Before the lift reached the bottom of the shaft it started to fill with water, which was up to the men's knees by the time they were able to stop the lift by pressing the emergency button, the Health and Safety Executive (HSE) said. They returned to the main deck safely and none of the men sustained any injuries. An HSE investigation found that hardware failures and incorrect operating procedures had caused the bottom of the lift shaft to flood while the inspection site was being cleared of standing water. The HSE also found that a lack of water alarms at the bottom of the lift shaft also meant the control room was unaware that water was flooding into the shaft. The investigation found that water marks on the lift door showed the water had reached a level of just under 1.5m before the lift was stopped. Meanwhile, Ithaca's own investigation found the water level could have reached more than three metres – which would have made it difficult for the men to have escaped through the top hatch of the lift if the workers had used the lift later, or not been able to stop it as quickly as they did. Ithaca pleaded guilty to safety failings at a hearing at Aberdeen Sheriff Court on June 12, and were issued with a £300,000 fine, the HSE said. HSE inspector Ian Chilley said: "This was a terrifying incident for the workers involved, we are just thankful that no physical harm came to them. "This fine should send a message and reminder to those operating offshore facilities for them to be extra vigilant. It was only a matter of good fortune that this incident didn't result in serious injury, or worse." The HSE added that when passing sentence, the sheriff said the case marked "another reminder of the need for rigorous adherence to health and safety in the oil and gas industry." The HSE also issued an improvement notice in the immediate aftermath of the incident, and work in confined spaces was halted until February 2021 while a full review of the incident was carried out.
The Independent
17 hours ago
- The Independent
Fine issued after ‘terrifying' incident on rig saw workers lowered into water
An oil and gas operator has been fined £300,000 following a 'terrifying incident' on a North Sea rig that saw three workers lowered into a flooded lift shaft. The episode happened on the FPF-1 offshore platform, owned by Ithaca Energy (UK) Limited, during a night shift on December 10 2020. The men had been descending in a lift inside one of the platform's legs to carry out routine inspection work at the base of one of the sub-sea columns when they experienced a 'rush of air'. Before the lift reached the bottom of the shaft it started to fill with water, which was up to the men's knees by the time they were able to stop the lift by pressing the emergency button, the Health and Safety Executive (HSE) said. They returned to the main deck safely and none of the men sustained any injuries. An HSE investigation found that hardware failures and incorrect operating procedures had caused the bottom of the lift shaft to flood while the inspection site was being cleared of standing water. The HSE also found that a lack of water alarms at the bottom of the lift shaft also meant the control room was unaware that water was flooding into the shaft. The investigation found that water marks on the lift door showed the water had reached a level of just under 1.5m before the lift was stopped. Meanwhile, Ithaca's own investigation found the water level could have reached more than three metres – which would have made it difficult for the men to have escaped through the top hatch of the lift if the workers had used the lift later, or not been able to stop it as quickly as they did. Ithaca pleaded guilty to safety failings at a hearing at Aberdeen Sheriff Court on June 12, and were issued with a £300,000 fine, the HSE said. HSE inspector Ian Chilley said: 'This was a terrifying incident for the workers involved, we are just thankful that no physical harm came to them. 'This fine should send a message and reminder to those operating offshore facilities for them to be extra vigilant. 'It was only a matter of good fortune that this incident didn't result in serious injury, or worse.' The HSE added that when passing sentence, the sheriff said the case marked 'another reminder of the need for rigorous adherence to health and safety in the oil and gas industry'. The HSE also issued an improvement notice in the immediate aftermath of the incident, and work in confined spaces was halted until February 2021 while a full review of the incident was carried out.
