Scheme to boost access to NHS dentists 'comprehensively failed', MPs say
A scheme meant to boost access to NHS dentists under the last government appears to have "comprehensively failed", MPs have said
Introduced in February last year by Conservative health ministers, the Dental Recovery Plan promised to introduce 1.5 million new treatments for patients and offered dentists a "bonus" to take NHS patients.
According to the Public Accounts Committee (PAC), the scheme appears to have "resulted in worsening the picture" more than a year later.
Under the Dental Recovery Plan, practices were offered a new patient premium (NPP) - which the PAC found cost at least £88m since it was introduced and resulted in 3% fewer new patients seeing an NHS dentist.
2:07
The plan's "golden hello" recruitment scheme had also been found to have appointed fewer than 20% of the expected 240 dentists by February this year.
Their report, published today, also said vulnerable patients "continue to suffer the most" and that the dental contract "remains unfit for purpose".
Current arrangements are only sufficient for about half of England's population to see an NHS dentist over two years, it added.
The PAC report also said "it does not appear" that NHS England or the Department of Health and Social Care "have a sense of what level of funding would provide a realistic incentive for dentists to prioritise NHS work".
'NHS dentistry is broken'
PAC chairman Sir Geoffrey Clifton-Brown said: "It is utterly disgraceful that, in the 21st century, some Britons have been forced to remove their own teeth.
"Last year's Dental Recovery Plan was supposed to address these problems, something our report has found it has signally failed to do.
"Almost unbelievably, the government's initiatives appear to have actually resulted in worsening the picture, with fewer new patients seen since the plan's introduction."
He added: "NHS dentistry is broken. The government could hardly fail to agree on this point, and indeed I am glad that it is not in denial that the time for tinkering at the edges is over.
"It is time for big decisions."
A Department of Health and Social Care spokesperson said the Labour government "inherited a broken NHS dental sector" and was fixing it through its Plan for Change.
It said that in February, it had delivered on its manifesto pledge by rolling out 700,000 extra urgent appointments and pledged to introduce a new supervised toothbrushing scheme for three to five-year-olds.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Record
38 minutes ago
- Daily Record
Rutherglen MSP welcomes £6.6 million of funding to reduce waiting times in Lanarkshire
This investment is part of the Scottish Government's £200 million commitment in the Programme for Government to increase NHS capacity, reduce delayed discharge, and improve the flow of patients through hospitals. Rutherglen MSP Clare Haughey has welcomed the Scottish Government's announcement of £6.6 million of targeted funding to reduce waiting times in Lanarkshire, as part of £106 million new investment across NHS Scotland. This investment is part of the Scottish Government's £200 million commitment in the Programme for Government to increase NHS capacity, reduce delayed discharge, and improve the flow of patients through hospitals. Ms Haughey said: 'This is another clear example of our SNP Government delivering for our NHS, with real action to cut waiting times and get patients in South Lanarkshire the care they need faster. 'By focusing funding where it's needed most, like orthopaedics, cancer, and diagnostics, we're helping tackle the longest delays head-on. 'This will mean quicker, diagnoses, more procedures, and better outcomes for people in South Lanarkshire. 'South Lanarkshire communities deserve timely access to care, and this SNP Government is making the investment to deliver that. While we know some people have to wait too long for treatment, the SNP is getting on with the job of driving improvements for patients.' *Don't miss the latest headlines from around Lanarkshire. Sign up to our newsletters here.
The Independent
an hour ago
- The Independent
What we know about the new NHS cervical screening guidelines
New NHS guidelines in England will invite women aged 25-49 with negative HPV tests to cervical screenings every five years instead of every three, starting next month. The change follows recommendations from the UK National Screening Committee and aligns England's screening intervals with those of Wales and Scotland. Analysis from King's College London indicates that extending the screening interval to five years for HPV-negative women maintains a similar rate of cancer detection as the current three-year interval. Health Minister Ashley Dalton stated the change aims to increase testing opportunities for women with HPV while extending screening intervals for those with negative tests, emphasising early detection and treatment. Experts encourage women to attend screenings when invited, with the NHS implementing measures like phone reminders to improve participation, while Cancer Research UK highlights the impact of screening and HPV vaccination on reducing cervical cancer rates.
Daily Mirror
an hour ago
- Daily Mirror
‘People thought I was nine months pregnant - it was a giant ovarian cyst'
WARNING: DISTRESSING CONTENT Robyn McGhee, 28, went to the doctors after people mistakenly thought she was pregnant - and discovered she had a giant ovarian cyst that made it hard for her to walk In February 2024, Robyn McGhee noticed that she was gaining weight. However, with Christmas and New Year 's just gone, she put it down to overindulging over the festive period and resolved to hit the gym and cut back. 'I spent a few months eating healthy and trying to lose weight but the weight wasn't shifting, I was actually getting bigger,' she said. 'I could physically see it, it wasn't all in my head.' Then the tiredness came, and the pressure she felt to lose the weight intensified - worsened by the fact that strangers on the street were asking her when she was due to give birth. The 28-year-old from Glasgow told The Mirror: 'I just had to say 'no I'm not pregnant' and just leave so they didn't feel awkward. It kind of highlighted how extreme my stomach actually looked.' Looking back at the pictures now, Robyn said, it's hard to feel angry at the people who presumed she was pregnant. 'I looked about eight or nine months pregnant, the weight had shot up. But I couldn't eat at all, I'd lost my appetite." At one point, despite knowing she wasn't, Robyn thought: 'Maybe I am pregnant, maybe that's what is going on and I just don't have the usual symptoms that you would expect.' None of her clothes would fit, she couldn't go out, and was struggling to walk. After returning from a holiday in June during which she didn't feel like herself, Robyn decided it was time to see a doctor. 'At that point, I could feel a ball in my stomach and it was causing a lot of pain. I went to the doctor and explained my symptoms and they off the bat said 'are you pregnant',' she said. 'I knew I wasn't, I'd taken a few pregnancy tests.' Robyn added: 'I felt like I was getting dismissed by the doctor, I explained my symptoms and said I was worried it was something more than weight gain and they said 'like what?' I thought, 'I don't know, that's why I'm here'.' After getting a second opinion, Robyn was referred for urgent CT scans and blood work, which was when they found the cyst. It was about 25cm and weighed more than a stone. The NHS describes an ovarian cyst as a fluid-filled sac that develops on an ovary. Symptoms can include pelvic pain, heavy or irregular periods, a swollen tummy, pain during sex, a frequent need to urinate, and feeling full after only eating a little. Despite knowing an operation was imminent, Robyn felt that she could finally breathe. 'I was relieved, because I had an answer for why I was feeling this way. It was confirming that it wasn't all in my head, it was actually happening to me.' In September, Robyn underwent a three-hour operation. While keyhole surgery is usually used for cysts, the size of Robyn's meant that open surgery was the only option for her, and she now has a large scar down the centre of her stomach. But there was another surprise in store when surgeons found that she had endometriosis as well - which is a disease in which tissue on the inside of the uterus grows outside of it. According to Endometriosis UK, 10% of women (176 million) worldwide have endometriosis, which can cause severe period pain, heavy periods, and pain when going to the toilet. 'I thought my period symptoms were normal, the pains and cramps I had were the type that everybody had,' she said. Doctors removed the cyst, along with one of Robyn's ovaries and fallopian tubes, and her appendix. The recovery took about 12 weeks and the first part was 'really tough' with 'ridiculous' amounts of pain. 'I also felt a lot lighter, obviously,' she said. Taking her experience to social media was her next step, and the decision to open up came from the lack of stories or resources on the topic out there, she said. 'I was trying to research the type of surgery I was getting online and on TikTok but there wasn't that much about it. I thought 'I don't have any reference point of anybody going through a similar situation to what I am'.' Since posting her story on her TikTok page (@_robynmcghee), Robyn has had messages from people all over the world. 'It's been wild, I feel like I have helped people', she explained. While the operation was 'absolutely terrifying', she insists to others going through the same thing that it was 'better than any other outcome'.
