Judge denies Harvey Weinstein's bid for mistrial after juror complains
Harvey Weinstein appears for his retrial at a Manhattan court, Wednesday, May 21, 2025, in New York. (AP Photo/Pamela Smith, Pool)
NEW YORK — A juror in Harvey Weinstein's sex crimes trial asked to be removed from the case Friday because he felt his fellow jurors were treating a member of their panel in an 'unfair and unjust' way, but the judge told him he had to keep deliberating.
Judge Curtis Farber later denied a defense request for a mistrial, saying he believed the juror was simply expressing discomfort in the deliberation process, noting that he's the youngest on the 12-person panel.
'This is nothing other than normal tensions during heated deliberations,' Farber told the lawyers after the juror rejoined his peers. 'Perhaps his youth makes him uncomfortable with conflict.'
The second day of deliberations ended Friday without a verdict. Jurors are expected back in court Monday.
Jurors reheard testimony from Weinstein's three accusers. They also reviewed other evidence, including medical records and emails.
Twice on Friday, though, a juror requested to address the court without the other jurors present.
The juror said he wanted to be excused from the trial because he was uncomfortable with how some jurors were acting toward another juror.
But Farber denied the request, saying there were no more alternate jurors to replace him and, in any case, his concerns did not warrant being dismissed.
The juror insisted, calling the treatment 'unfair and unjust' even as he described the tension as 'playground stuff' with jurors shunning another juror and talking behind their back.
Weinstein's lawyer Arthur Aidala argued that the jury should be told to stop deliberating while the court found out more about the concerns.
He criticized the judge's questions to the concerned juror as 'anemic at best.'
'You didn't ask him one follow-up question,' Aidala said.
Manhattan prosecutor Nicole Blumberg said the judge acted appropriately by reminding jurors about the expectations for them -- including that they not speak to anyone about the case unless all members of the jury are deliberating.
The issue, she noted, does not appear to be hindering the jury's work, as the panel requested a readout of other testimony even after he raised concerns.
Sexual misconduct allegations against Weinstein propelled the .MeToo movement in 2017.
The jury of seven women and five men is considering two counts of criminal sex act and one count of rape against the 73-year-old Oscar-winning movie producer, with the criminal sex act charges the higher-degree felonies. Weinstein has pleaded not guilty.
Weinstein was convicted of sex crimes in New York and California, but the New York conviction was overturned last year, leading to the retrial before a new jury and a different judge.
Jurors heard more than five weeks of testimony, including lengthy testimony from three accusers.
Article by Philip Marcelo.
Resources for sexual assault survivors in Canada
If you or someone you know is struggling with sexual assault or trauma, the following resources are available to support people in crisis:
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CTV News
an hour ago
- CTV News
Letters from a predator: The chilling words of a man who turns his wife into a doll
Warning: This story contains graphic details and allegations of sexual assault. This article is part of an ongoing W5 investigation that has infiltrated a global online network of men who are secretly drugging, raping, filming and sharing the videos of their unsuspecting wives and intimate partners. He signed every email with warmth. 'Best wishes,' 'Friendly, David,' or just a winking smile. His messages were polite, composed, sometimes even charming. But line by line, he revealed something else entirely: the mindset of a man who systematically drugs and rapes his own wife; a man who wanted to be my mentor so I could learn how to carry out the same sickening crime. For weeks, David shared his secrets with me, not knowing I was an undercover journalist. He believed I was a kindred spirit. What he gave me wasn't just evidence of a crime. It was a rare, disturbing window into evil. 'Your doll will do everything you want' David spoke about his wife not as a woman, but as an object. A doll. A canvas. A toy. He described how he prepared her, how he waited for her breathing to change, the signal that she was no longer aware, no longer present. From: ██████ Date: On Sun, May 18, 2025 at 11:38 PM To: ██████ It's not just an impression, in fact, about our common points! I shudder with pleasure ██████ of offering ██████ my wife's body, (transformed into an inanimate object, she belongs to everyone, it's the basic principle, she is no longer a person, really more than a tool of which we use each part to stimulate our desires without 'almost' any limits) My wife has developed a certain resistance to ██████ I think that treating her with ████████████ would be the minimum for her case... I should point out! I'm not afraid to push things further with her. This woman has a strong build, and you should know that even █████████████████ is not enough to dive sufficiently for my taste to enjoy it 100%. Keep me informed after your attempt, and don't hesitate to take screenshots with your camera... see you soon! Kind regards, David He emphasized control, even in the smallest details. He described how he used lighting and music to create 'an atmosphere of warmth and intimacy,' and noted that it was important that his wife looked 'sexy and relaxed' as she lay sedated. In any case what really motivated me to take action was the desire for possession, when possession takes hold of you you cannot resist its call, you just have to control your mind about it and be careful about what you give, █████████████████████ this will amplify these moments, just it will be will allow you all (or almost) the fantasies that you have always wanted to realize with her to do so... You see as you say a man who knows what he is doing, well just know that you can do exactly the same thing simply, do it kindly and carefully as I explained to you with ████████████ Have confidence in your ability to do it, you have nothing to be ashamed of, because you are like me a divergent, on the contrary be proud of your difference! It requires more difficulty to achieve than the easy and banal classic practice, certainly, but the reward in sensation will be so powerful x 1000, the pleasure which will free your head will be so strong, that afterwards you will wonder why you waited so long before doing it! Canadian criminal profiler, Jim Van Allen, who analyzed my email conversations, says this emphasis on domination and objectification is characteristic of drug-facilitated sexual assault offenders. 'He's a narcissistic type of person... motivated by sexually deviant desires and needs…to dominate.' What makes David so dangerous isn't only what he does, it's how he thinks about it. He never frames himself as violent or abusive. Instead, he calls himself divergent. Not a criminal, but misunderstood. Not evil, just 'different.' From: ██████ Date: On Thu, May 15, 2025 at 3:34 AM Subject: Fw: Re: Explication et recommandation To: ██████ Dear ██████, consider me as your trusted friend, because even if we have never met, we share the same need in our sexuality, and have no one to be able to talk about it, at least no one who can accept what I call our deviant sexuality, an appropriate term, rather than 'abnormal' or 'crazy' as unfortunately many narrow-minded people say... I even went to see a psychologist specialized in the issue, and in addition doctor, on this subject to discuss it with my wife... the psychologist admits that we may need to take pleasure in our own way (but as a doctor cannot accept that we must sedate our partner) My wife refuses to lend herself voluntarily and so I do without her agreement! As simple as that... Doctors wrongly think that there is a health risk in doing this practice. I refute it, being a practitioner for more than 20 years on sedation I have never endangered the women in question. As I told you, I can't speak the same way for drugs like ██████. Because there, the line is thinner between deep sleep and coma, that's my friend, why you should be careful about the dosage ████████████. The product that should ideally be used for us is ████████████ it acts in less than a minute ██████████████████....But we don't have access to this type of product without risk and 100% effective for direct deep sleep! Unless you are a ██████ There you knows ██████ what the future holds for us, but don't be ashamed of your needs, you are not alone. Good luck, I await your news and see you soon. D. 'They justify, they rationalize what they do,' Van Allen explained. 'They minimize what they've done to people.' Van Allen says this is a common psychological defense, a way predators preserve a positive self-image while continuing their crimes. That rationalization ran through every one of David's messages. He wasn't just confessing, he was teaching. Encouraging. Offering me detailed instructions and techniques and expressing delight at the idea of me joining him to 'share' his unconscious wife, as a bonding experience between men who 'understand' each other. From: ██████ Date: On Sun, May 25, 2025 at 3:47 PM Subject: ██████ To: ██████ Dear ██████, I'm really glad that it's possible for you to come and stay here in ██████ this summer, ██████████████████████████████, but to be able to ensure this total takeover of ██████, I insist that we meet a few days ██████████████████ which I am 100% certain will allow us to realize together all our mutual will be enough for me to come to your hotel you find in your room ██████████████████ I know that by dint of seeing her you really want I will be really fulfilled by this sharing between us, despite what you have been able to see on the video extracts, the control is not total despite my rather strong doses....██████████████████....it is not 100% manipulable....████████████...and once I have made sure of her deep coma, you can join me without risk for our common sharing. When do you say? ████████████████████████.....I can already imagine administering your product in a glass of wine or spirits to my female dog of a a few moments later once unconscious, preparing her for your arrival, dressed manicure as putting her on the sofa with a good bottle in her hands, thighs spread while waiting for transformed into a toy for our pure me what you plan to do, while waiting for your news, my best feelings for you, David;-) From: Date: On Wed, May 28, 2025 at 10:49 AM Subject: ██████ Passion commune To: ██████ My dear ████████████████████████████████████ we'll have to make do with the time you have available once you arrive in ██████. I hope you'll understand that it's the best thing for both of us. With my best regards, your friend David ;-) PS: The next ██████ party (limp play special^^) is already tonight, too bad you missed it, but it will be for the next one. Don't worry, just be patient, see you soon my friend. According to Van Allen, this escalation indicates a complete breakdown of empathy and morality. He said it shows not only a willingness to harm, but a desire to celebrate and expand the abuse. 'That just goes to show you… that there's an anti-social component going on in this individual's personality. That this is a disregard for his wife's rights, her safety, her sexual integrity... a total betrayal of that.' A private horror, hidden in plain sight In everyday life, David works multiple jobs. He talks about financial stresses. There's no outward sign of the secret he's keeping. But Van Allen says that's common. 'We refer to it as having a social mask. We only present… what we want them to see about ourselves. And there are times when we remove the social mask, let our hair down and we're more of who we are.' David's pride in his deception is palpable. He often marvels at how his wife has never suspected anything. That secrecy, Van Allen said, becomes its own source of gratification. ██████ you must actually make sure that you have all the ideal conditions. That is to say that she should ████████████████████████ because the 3rd method will actually completely erase her recent memory, she will be much more sensitive to the drug, after passing through ██████, she will be deeply, really deeply asleep, and will have no memory of what happened during the night. Your alibi will be good, as for the possible negative fatigue still upon the ██████ is really perfect. Listen, you should not be ashamed of your failures ████████████ It's about your balance in your sexuality that you need to satisfy just like me! You see a good example recently last Saturday, I drugged my wife, I made her take about ██████████████████████████████ (And my wife asked me in the morning if we had made love, she didn't remember and without surprise, I told her: 'normal darling, ██████ If she ever has questions in the morning now. There you go, it's up to you to ask yourself what you want to do at that level. Courage... Result of this night I had a lot of fun with my wife transformed into a see on the me patient and do it step by D. 'There's narcissism here,' Van Allen explained. ''I'm so clever, I'm getting away with this.' ' Why victims don't know Men who commit these crimes often go undetected for years, even decades, because their partners would never imagine their ailments are connected to the man they love. The drugs used do more than sedate; they erase memory, induce confusion, and inhibit the formation of new memories. The objective isn't merely unconsciousness, but complete silence. Gisèle Pelicot's recent case in France, exemplifies this harrowing reality. Over nearly a decade, her husband secretly drugged her and facilitated her rape by dozens of men. Gisèle experienced alarming health issues: significant memory lapses, extreme fatigue, hair loss, and unexplained gynecological symptoms. She never connected the physical ailments to what her husband was secretly doing. Canadian criminal profiler Jim Van Allen says these predators are often charismatic and manipulative. 'You're going to wake up with an unusual loss of memory that's not explained by the context. You might be gaslighted... 'Oh, of course you don't remember what went on, you drank way too much, you mixed four different types of alcohol.'' Van Allen listed red flags women should be aware of: Unusual loss of memory/difficulty creating new memories Feeling nauseated or woozy Sexual pain or discomfort in the mornings Problematic or illogical alibis after memory blackouts Repeated experiences of the above that don't match normal sexual activity 'Ain't no pill gonna cure this ill' David refers to himself as an 'expert' with 20 years of experience sedating women. But he's no doctor. The consequences of his confidence could be deadly. Van Allen says the emotional consequences, when a woman finds out she has been betrayed are catastrophic. 'We're talking about complete trauma , betrayal, confusion, grief, a shattered sense of safety, possibly for life,' Van Allen said. Men like this don't stop. They have to be stopped. Van Allen explains that this kind of crime is repetitive and fantasy-driven and compulsive. 'Ain't no pill gonna cure this ill…. behind bars is going to stop it.' More from this series:
CTV News
10 hours ago
- CTV News
Prosecutors describe their evidence in Wander Franco trial as ‘convincing' and ‘compelling'
Tampa Bay Rays shortstop Wander Franco sits in court during his trial on charges of sexually abusing a minor, in Puerto Plata, Dominican Republic, Monday, June 2, 2025. (AP Photo/Ricardo Hernandez) Warning: This story contains graphic details SANTO DOMINGO, Dominican Republic - Key prosecution witnesses testified on Friday in the trial of Tampa Bay Rays shortstop Wander Franco, who faces charges of sexual abuse against a minor, before the Puerto Plata Collegiate Court in the Dominican Republic. The trial that was initially scheduled for Dec. 12 was postponed until earlier this week and three hearings have been held. On Thursday, the teenage girl testified behind closed doors. Prosecutors described the evidence presented on Friday as 'convincing' and 'compelling.' 'Franco Aybar kidnapped the victim for sexual purposes for several days and then sent large sums of money to her mother,' prosecutors stated. Documents that prosecutors presented to the judge last year and were viewed by The Associated Press alleged that Franco, through his mother Yudelka Aybar, transferred 1 million pesos or US$17,000 to the mother of the minor on Jan. 5, 2023, to consent to the purported abuse. The mother of the minor has been charged with money laundering and is under house arrest. Franco also has been charged with sexual and commercial exploitation against a minor, and human trafficking. Prosecutors say that the minor's mother went from being a bank employee to leading an ostentatious life and acquiring assets that she cannot justify using the funds she received from Franco. Franco, who turned 24 on March 1, was in his third major league season when his career was halted in August 2023. He agreed to an 11-year, $182 million contract in November 2021. He is currently on Major League Baseball's restricted list after initially being placed on administrative leave. Franco, who was charged in July 2024 and is on supervised release, could face up to 30 years in prison if found guilty. The trial is scheduled to continue Monday. Martin Adames, The Associated Press Resources for sexual assault survivors in Canada If you or someone you know is struggling with sexual assault or trauma, the following resources are available to support people in crisis:
CBC
10 hours ago
- CBC
Man mistakenly deported to El Salvador back in U.S. to face criminal charges
Kilmar Abrego Garcia, whose mistaken deportation to El Salvador became a political flashpoint in the Trump administration's stepped-up immigration enforcement, is being returned to the United States to face criminal charges related to what the U.S. says was a massive human smuggling operation that brought immigrants into the country illegally. Photo credit: Abrego Garcia Family
