Australian airline Captain Byron Bailey details why he believes 'pilot error' the reason behind crash of Air India Flight 171
An experienced Australian airline captain has explained why he believes pilot error is to blame for the crash of Air India Flight 171 which has left hundreds of people dead.
The Boeing 787-8 Dreamliner departed Ahmedabad airport, in India's north-west, on Thursday but came down in a densely populated neighbourhood seconds later.
Footage showed the 11-year-old aircraft slowly descending about 15 seconds after lifting from the runway before it hit a medical college hostel and exploded into flames.
Speaking to Sky News Australia, former commercial pilot Captain Byron Bailey said pilot error was "highly likely" the cause of the crash after he watched the video.
He pointed to a "remarkable" part of the clip which showed the landing gear was still down, despite the plane reaching 190 metres in the air, according to Flightradar24.
Captain Bailey said pilots are in constant communication during the takeoff process and when the required speed is reached for takeoff, they pull back on the yoke.
"And the pilot flying will say 'gear up' and that's it for that moment. That occurs at a couple of hundred feet. So why, it's 600 feet, the undercarriage is still down means they haven't selected the gear," he told Sky News.
"The other thing that's remarkable is it appears the flap, which is the high lift devices that enables you to fly slower, they appear not to be down.
"Now, you can't take off without flap."
Captain Bailey suggested it was around this time a fatal error was made.
"But my own suspicion is that when the pilot flying called for gear up, the other pilot inadvertently grabbed the flap lever and pushed it through to zero," he said.
"And once you've done that, immediately you're in a deep stall and at 600 feet you cannot recover. There's not enough height even though the engines are at full power."
The Dreamliner had been labelled as the safest plane up until the crash of Air India.
The 787-8 had not been in a fatal incident since its introduction.
It is one of the most advanced jets and was brought into service in 2011, with Boeing selling more than 2,500 of the model to airlines, including 47 to Air India.
Boeing CEO Kelly Ortberg has offered his deepest condolences to the families of the victims and has spoken to Air India's chairman to offer his "full support".
He was due to attend an air show in Paris, but cancelled his appearance. The company was last year plagued with a series of incidents around the world involving its aircraft.
Boeing shares fell about 4.2 per cent after the crash.
India's Aircraft Accident Bureau Investigation has started a formal investigation.
The National Transport Safety Board said a team of US investigators will be flown over to India to support local authorities to find the exact cause which led to the fatal incident.
British Air Accidents Investigation Branch has also offered its assistance.
Air India on Friday confirmed 241 of the 242 passengers and crew were killed.
It said there were 230 passengers and 12 crew on board, including 169 Indian nationals, 53 British nationals, one Canadian, and seven Portuguese nationals.
The sole survivor has been named as Vishwash Kumar Ramesh, 40, a British-Indian national who was assigned seat 11A, according to officials and media on the ground.
Police have taped off the scene at the site of the crash.
Medical technicians transported blue boxes, which contained human remains, to be forensically tested to confirm their identity as most bodies were badly burnt.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


West Australian
2 hours ago
- West Australian
Air India crash: Woman says traffic jam meant she missed being on doomed flight by minutes
A woman has revealed she missed boarding the doomed Air India plane by mere minutes after being delayed in a traffic jam. Bhoomi Chauhan, 28, says she was meant to be on the flight that crashed soon after take-off from Ahmedabad on Thursday, killing all but one person on board. The Bristol woman told BBC Gujarati that she had been in India on holiday and was scheduled to fly home on the flight headed to Gatwick Airport but airline officials would not let her board after she arrived late. Ms Chauhan said she was initially angry at missing her flight but now calls it a 'miracle'. 'We got very angry with our driver and left the airport in frustration,' she told BBC . 'I was very disappointed. We left the airport and stood at a place to drink tea and after a while, before leaving... we were talking to the travel agent about how to get a refund for the ticket. 'There, I got a call that the plane had gone down.' BBC reports it checked the business administration student's digital boarding pass and it showed she had been allocated seat 36G. The airline said 230 passengers and 12 crew were on board when the plane went down — 169 Indian nationals, 53 British, seven Portuguese and one Canadian. Just one passenger, British national Vishwashkumar Ramesh, survived the crash. 'When I missed the flight, I was dejected,' Ms Chauhan said. 'Only thing that I had in mind was, 'If I had started a little early, I would have boarded the plane'. 'This is totally a miracle for me.'


Perth Now
2 hours ago
- Perth Now
‘Miracle': Reason woman missed doomed flight by minutes
A woman has revealed she missed boarding the doomed Air India plane by mere minutes after being delayed in a traffic jam. Bhoomi Chauhan, 28, says she was meant to be on the flight that crashed soon after take-off from Ahmedabad on Thursday, killing all but one person on board. The Bristol woman told BBC Gujarati that she had been in India on holiday and was scheduled to fly home on the flight headed to Gatwick Airport but airline officials would not let her board after she arrived late. Bhoomi Chauhan says it's a 'miracle' she wasn't on the doomed flight. Credit: x Ms Chauhan said she was initially angry at missing her flight but now calls it a 'miracle'. 'We got very angry with our driver and left the airport in frustration,' she told BBC. 'I was very disappointed. We left the airport and stood at a place to drink tea and after a while, before leaving... we were talking to the travel agent about how to get a refund for the ticket. 'There, I got a call that the plane had gone down.' The Air India plane went down minutes after take-off. Credit: Unknown / X formerly Twitter BBC reports it checked the business administration student's digital boarding pass and it showed she had been allocated seat 36G. The airline said 230 passengers and 12 crew were on board when the plane went down — 169 Indian nationals, 53 British, seven Portuguese and one Canadian. Just one passenger, British national Vishwashkumar Ramesh, survived the crash. PM Narendra Modi meets crash survivor Vishwaskumar Ramesh. Credit: x 'When I missed the flight, I was dejected,' Ms Chauhan said. 'Only thing that I had in mind was, 'If I had started a little early, I would have boarded the plane'. 'This is totally a miracle for me.'

ABC News
4 hours ago
- ABC News
Just one man survived the Air India crash. What's it like to survive a mass disaster?
Viswashkumar Ramesh, a British citizen returning from a trip to India, has been confirmed as the only survivor of Thursday's deadly Air India crash. "I don't know how I am alive," Ramesh told family, according to his brother Nayan, in a video call moments after emerging from the wreckage. Another brother Ajay, seated elsewhere on the plane, was killed. The Boeing 787-7 Dreamliner crashed into a medical college less than a minute after taking off in the city of Ahmedabad, killing the other 229 passengers and 12 crew. Several more people were killed on the ground. Surviving a mass disaster of this kind may be hailed as a kind of "miracle". But what is it like to survive — especially as the only one? Past research has shown disaster survivors may experience an intense range of emotions, from grief and anxiety to feelings of loss and uncertainty. These are common reactions to an extraordinary situation. Some people may develop post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) and have difficulty adjusting to a new reality after bearing witness to immense loss. They may also be dealing with physical recovery from injuries sustained in the disaster. Most people recover after disasters by drawing on their own strengths and the support of others. Recovery rates are high: generally less than one in ten of those affected by disasters develop chronic, long-term problems. However, being a sole survivor of a mass casualty may have its own complex psychological challenges. Survivors can experience guilt they lived when others died. My friend, Gill Hicks, spoke to me for this article about the ongoing guilt she still feels, years after surviving the 2005 bombings of the London underground. Lying trapped in a smoke-filled train carriage, she was the last living person to be rescued after the attack. Gill lost both her legs. Yet she still wonders, "Why me? Why did I get to go home, when so many others didn't?" In the case of a sole survivor, this guilt may be particularly acute. However, research addressing the impact of sole survivorship is limited. Most research that looks at the psychological impact of disaster focuses on the impact of disasters more broadly. Those interviewed for a 2013 documentary about surviving large plane crashes, Sole Survivor, express complex feelings — wanting to share their stories, but fearing being judged by others. Being the lone survivor can be a heavy burden. "I didn't think I was worthy of the gift of being alive," George Lamson Jr told the documentary, after surviving a 1985 plane crash in Nevada that killed all others on board. People who survive a disaster may also be under pressure to explain what happened and relive the trauma for the benefit of others. Viswashkumar Ramesh was filmed and interviewed by media in the minutes and hours following the Air India crash. But as he told his brother: "I have no idea how I exited the plane." It can be common for survivors themselves to be plagued by unanswerable questions. Did they live for a reason? Why did they live, when so many others died? These kinds of unanswerable questions reflect our natural inclination to look for meaning in experiences, and to have our life stories make sense. For some people, sharing a traumatic experience with others who've been through it or something similar can be a beneficial part of the recovery process, helping to process emotions and regain some agency and control. However, this may not always be possible for sole survivors, potentially compounding feelings of guilt and isolation. Survivor guilt can be an expression of grief and loss. Studies indicate guilt is notably widespread among individuals who have experienced traumatic events, and it is associated with heightened psychopathological symptoms (such as severe anxiety, insomnia or flashbacks) and thoughts of suicide. Taking time to process the traumatic event can help survivors cope, and seeking support from friends, family and community or faith leaders can help an individual work through difficult feelings. My friend Gill says the anxiety rises as the anniversary of the disaster approaches each year. Trauma reminders such as anniversaries are different to unexpected trauma triggers, but can still cause distress. Media attention around collectively experienced dates can also amplify trauma-related distress, contributing to a cycle of media consumption and increased worry about future events. On July 7 each year, Gill holds a private remembrance ritual. This allows her to express her grief and sense of loss, and to honour those who did not survive. These types of rituals can be a valuable tool in processing feelings of grief and guilt, offering a sense of control and meaning and facilitating the expression and acceptance of loss. But lingering guilt and anxiety — especially when it interferes with day-to-day life — should not be ignored. Ongoing survivor guilt is associated with significantly higher levels of post-traumatic symptoms. Survivors may need support from psychologists or mental health professionals in the short and long term. Erin Smith is an associate professor and discipline lead (Paramedicine) at La Trobe University. This piece first appeared on The Conversation.