UN criticises failure to appoint language and culture commissioners
A failure by the executive to appoint commissioners for the Irish language and Ulster-Scots has been criticised by a United Nations (UN) committee.The UN Committee on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights (CESCR) also criticised "inadequate funding" for cultural and language rights.New language laws for Northern Ireland were passed in the Identity and Language (Northern Ireland) Act 2022.But an Irish language commissioner and a commissioner for the Ulster-Scots and Ulster British tradition have not yet been appointed.
The roles, along with an Office of Identity and Cultural Expression, were originally promised in the New Decade, New Approach deal in 2020.But the office has not been set up, and there are no commissioners yet in place.
The president of the Irish language and culture group Conradh na Gaeilge, Ciarán Mac Giolla Bhéin, welcomed the UN report.He said he hoped commitments previously agreed by the Democratic Unionist Party and Sinn Féin to appoint an Irish language commissioner would soon be delivered."I hope we'll have them in place before the end of this [Stormont] mandate, I do not for the life of me understand what the delay is," he told BBC News NI.Mr Mac Giolla Bhéin said Irish language campaigners were deeply disappointed that a timetable for the appointment was not spelled out in the executive's programme for government but insisted that organisations would continue to put pressure on politicians to appoint someone to the role.
The commissioners are meant to monitor the services public bodies deliver to Irish and Ulster-Scots speakers.Proposals from the language commissioners have to be approved by the first minister and deputy first minister before taking effect.CESCR is a body of 18 independent experts that monitors how states are implementing international agreements on social and cultural rights.Its latest report, which has just been published, monitors the UK government's actions and those of the devolved governments, including Northern Ireland."The committee regrets that the institutions created to protect and promote the Irish language and to promote and develop the Ulster-Scot tradition have not yet been established," the committee's report said.It recommends that the executive "expedite the establishment of the institutions and policies envisaged for the protection and promotion of the Irish language and Ulster-Scots culture and heritage."
A penal law dating from 1737, which prohibited the use of languages other than English in court, was recently repealed.It cleared the way for Irish to be used in legal proceedings in Northern Ireland.But there has been political disagreement over cuts to cross-border funding for the Irish language.That led to a recent strike by some Irish language organisations and activists."The committee is concerned at the inadequate funding for culture and culture-related activities, which hampers the right of all to participate in cultural life, to express one's own identity, values and way of life without fear of discrimination," the UN report said.
Mr Mac Giolla Bhéin said the UN committee was "echoing what we have been saying, not just with recent announcements around cuts to Foras na Gaeilge, but this something that's been 20 years in the making.""We have way more kids now enrolled in Irish medium education, we've much deeper demand for services across the whole strata of society, yet groups are expected to do more and more with less and less," he said."That isn't sustainable, groups are really staring into the abyss as things stand."We welcome that the report has highlighted this but more importantly it needs to be on the radar of Stormont to ensure a solution is found urgently to address this crisis."The UN Committee also highlighted other rights in its report, including expressing concern about the controversial Troubles Legacy Act and recommending "access to safe abortion services".It also called for more schemes to help women, people with disabilities, young people, ethnic minorities and migrants into employment.While it cannot force the UK government or the Northern Ireland Executive to act, the governments will have to report to the UN committee on what steps they are taking to implement its recommendations.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Independent
18 minutes ago
- The Independent
Draft climate plan proposes hundreds of actions to protect Northern Ireland
Hundreds of actions are being considered in the latest proposed plan to tackle climate change in Northern Ireland. The draft third Northern Ireland climate change adaptation programme (NICCAP3) includes more than 250 actions suggested by government departments, councils, academia, NGOs, businesses and the public. These are aimed at improving resilience against the impacts of climate change to protect the economy, communities and environment from the worst impacts over the next five years. An eight-week public consultation will gather views on the proposals. Agriculture, Environment and Rural Affairs Minister Andrew Muir said the impacts of climate change are widespread and action is needed. 'In recent years, Northern Ireland has witnessed new record temperatures, significant fires in our countryside, widespread severe flooding events and damage to coastal infrastructure, impacting upon farming and food production, roads and other infrastructure such as our electricity and broadband networks,' he said. 'It is evident that the impacts of climate change are widespread and effective adaptation action to improve our resilience is required. 'I very much welcome the collaborative effort from across all government departments and wider society in developing the draft NICCAP3.' Ciaran Fox, the director of the Royal Society of Ulster Architects and chairman of Climate NI, said key stakeholders can help improve resilience to climate change. 'I welcome the proactive approach that has been taken to the development of the draft NICCAP3 through both the inclusion of actions from outside departments and the co-design approach that has been taken to the development of the high-level vision and aims,' he said. 'This approach recognises the important role key stakeholders from across all sectors can play in building and improving our resilience to climate change. 'The draft NICCAP3, through the series of short case studies included in it, demonstrates some of the positive work that has already been progressed. These help to demonstrate the role all sectors of society can play.' He added: 'It is crucial that we ensure our current processes and infrastructure take account of and are equipped to face the climate impacts highlighted in the Met Office's UK climate change projections and those impacts which are now already locked in.' The public consultation on NICCAP3 will close on August 4 2025. It can can be accessed now at
Daily Mail
26 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
BREAKING NEWS Israel speedboats 'are circling the freedom flotilla' after vowing to intercept vessel and stop 'Greta Thunberg reaching Gaza'
Israeli speedboats are reportedly circling the Freedom flotilla after vowing to intercept the vessel and stop Greta Thunberg reaching Gaza. Five vessels are said to be surrounding Freedom flotilla, with the captain instructing the team to stay calm and seated with their passports and lifejackets on, according to a UN special reporter with the group. Francesca Albanese wrote on X: 'I hear them speaking with Israeli soldiers as I type... telling [them] they are carrying humanitarian aid and going in peace. For the time being they are just circled. I am with them, recording everything.' The group previously claimed they 'will not turn back' as they journey to Gaza despite Israel vowing Ms Thunberg will never arrive at the war-torn city. Taking to Instagram, member Yasemin Acar defiantly said the activists would not be returning to Catania, Sicily, from where they set off last Sunday. 'We are unarmed, we are peaceful, we are carrying only humanitarian aid, food, medicine, and supplies desperately needed by the starving population in Gaza,' she said. 'We are not a threat here, the threat is the blockade, the threat is the bombs, the threat is the ongoing starvation of an entire population. 'The threat is the systematic killing of civilians, the threat is genocide. If Israel was not occupying Palestine, if there wasn't nearly 80 years of ethnic cleansing, if our own governments weren't giving Israel full impunity, arming it instead of holding it accountable, if they sent aid instead of bombs we would not be here,' Acar added. 'We are here because our leaders have failed, because silence is complicity, because human lives are being treated as expendable. 'We are here for Gaza. If Israel uses violence against us, a peaceful humanitarian mission, it will be yet another war crime added to the long and growing list of Israel. 'We refuse to be intimidated, we refuse to be silent, we stand with Gaza, we stand with the people, we stand for justice, dignity and life. The blockade must end, the killing must stop, the world must act,' she concluded. The Israeli army have reportedly announced the deployment of three commandos and 25 soldiers to attempt to stop the flotilla, which is now less than 24 hours away from the coast of Gaza. The message comes after Israel issued an ominous warning to Greta Thunberg, claiming the environmental activist will not make it to the Gaza Strip on her 'freedom flotilla'. Ms Thunberg, 22, is among 12 activists on board the ship, hoping to 'break [Israel's] siege on the Gaza Strip' with a delivery of humanitarian aid. She is joined by Game of Thrones actor Liam Cunningham and Rima Hassan, a French MEP, aiming to raise awareness of the ongoing crisis in the region. The vessel is expected to reach Gaza this weekend, having set off from Catania in Sicily last Sunday. But the Israel Defence Forces has now been ordered to stop the ship in its tracks and has accused Ms Thunberg of being an 'antisemite travelling with Hamas propogandists'. Defense Minister Israel Katz said that Israel would not allow anyone to break its naval blockade of the Palestinian territory, which he said was aimed at preventing Hamas from importing arms. 'I have instructed the IDF to act so that the hate flotilla … does not reach the shores of Gaza – and to take all necessary measures to that end 'To the antisemitic Greta [Thunberg] and her friends who echo Hamas propaganda, I say clearly: You'd better turn back – because you will not reach Gaza,' he said. 'Israel will act against any attempt to break the blockade or to assist terrorist organisations – by sea, by air, and by land.' Responding to Katz on Sunday, they said: 'The statement by Israel's defence minister is yet another example of Israel threatening the unlawful use of force against civilians – and attempting to justify that violence with smears. 'We will not be intimidated,' it added. 'The world is watching.' 'We are monitoring the situation closely,' the Freedom Flotilla Coalition said. 'We remain calm, resolute, and prepared for the possibility of an Israeli attack. We reiterate our call to world governments to demand that Israel stand down. Israel has no right to obstruct our effort to reach Gaza.' The activists had said they planned to reach Gaza's territorial waters as early as Sunday. Thiago Ávila, a Brazilian activist on board the boat, posted a video on social media on Sunday afternoon saying someone appeared to be jamming their tracking and communication devices about 160 nautical miles from Gaza. Ms Hassan, who is of Palestinian descent, is among the others onboard. She has been barred from entering Israel because of her opposition to Israeli policies toward the Palestinians. It was previously reported that the IDF had begun deploying security forces in the area the vessel was due to land in, according to the Jerusalem Post. A senior Israeli defence source told the outlet that Israel will not allow the ship to enter Gaza, and that the activists face arrest if they disobey the military. Military sources said the activists will be told clearly not to enter the area, and that the elite forces are preparing for the eventuality they defy the order or 'provoke' the IDF. The IDF may take control of the vessel, arrest the protestors and transfer them to the port in Ashdod to be deported, the outlet reports. The Israeli Army said previously that it is 'prepared' to raid the ship, as it has done with previous freedom flotilla efforts. 'For this case as well, we are prepared,' IDF spokesman Brigadier General Effie Defrin said. 'We have gained experience in recent years, and we will act accordingly.' The activists have already raised concern for their safety, noting a drone attack on a Freedom Flotilla Coalition ship off the coast of Malta in May. Thunberg's shipmate issued a drone alert on the 'third day of our journey to Gaza to break the siege'. An Israeli drone operated by Greece's Hellenic Coastguard reportedly followed the Madleen flotilla, hovering above it for two consecutive nights on Tuesday and Wednesday. The Heron drone, developed by Israel Aerospace Industries (IAI), is capable of carrying payloads up to 1,000kg and flying for 52 continuous hours. The Madleen, still crossing the Mediterranean east towards Gaza, reportedly changed course this morning to respond to a migrant distress call. Sources told Al Jazeera the ship had detected a migrant boat, estimated to be carrying around 40 asylum seekers. Ahead of their departure on Sunday, Thunberg said: 'We are doing this because, no matter what odds we are against, we have to keep trying'. 'Because the moment we stop trying is when we lose our humanity. And no matter how dangerous this mission is, it's not even near as dangerous as the silence of the entire world in the face of the live-streamed genocide,' she added. Israel, which was founded in the aftermath of the Holocaust, has adamantly rejected genocide allegations against it as an anti-Semitic 'blood libel'. Fellow activist Thiago Avila said: 'We are breaking the siege of Gaza by sea, but that's part of a broader strategy of mobilizations that will also attempt to break the siege by land.' Avila cited the upcoming Global March to Gaza - an international initiative also open to doctors, lawyers and media - which is set to leave Egypt and reach the Rafah crossing in mid-June to stage a protest there, asking Israel to stop the Gaza offensive and reopen the border. Israel imposed a blockade on supplies into Gaza on March 2, and limited aid began to enter again late last month after pressure from allies and warnings of famine. Food security experts one in five people in Gaza now face starvation after Israel enacted its blockade. Gaza is almost completely reliant on international aid because Israel's offensive has destroyed nearly all food production capabilities. In April, ActionAid reported that the price of flour in Gaza had soared to $300 a bag after more than 50 days without new aid deliveries. Most people are now surviving on a single meal per day, consisting mostly of pasta, rice or canned food, it reported. More than 3,700 children were newly admitted for treatment for acute malnutrition in March alone, it said, an 80 per cent rise on the previous month, per UNOCHA. UN Security Council members criticised the US on Wednesday after it vetoed a resolution calling for a ceasefire and unrestricted humanitarian access in Gaza, which Washington said undermined ongoing diplomacy. It was the 15-member body's first vote on the situation since November, when the United States - a key Israeli ally - also blocked a text calling for an end to fighting. The draft resolution had demanded 'an immediate, unconditional and permanent ceasefire in Gaza respected by all parties.' It also called for the 'immediate, dignified and unconditional release of all hostages held by Hamas and other groups,' and demanded the lifting of all restrictions on the entry of humanitarian aid into Gaza. But Secretary of State Marco Rubio said in a statement after Wednesday's 14 to 1 vote: 'Today, the United States sent a strong message by vetoing a counterproductive UN Security Council resolution on Gaza targeting Israel. 'The United States will continue to stand with Israel at the UN.' The war began when Hamas-led militants stormed into southern Israel on Oct. 7, 2023, killing around 1,200 people and abducting 251. They are still holding 58 hostages, a third of them believed to be alive, after most of the rest were released in ceasefire agreements or other deals.
BBC News
28 minutes ago
- BBC News
'Discrimination' concerns over Stormont constituency jobs
Dozens of Northern Ireland Assembly members are recruiting staff in a way that could risk claims of unlawful discrimination, a BBC News NI investigation has include First Minister Michelle O'Neill, as the "essential criteria" for some jobs in her constituency office suggested applicants should hold certain political guidance issued to members of the legislative assembly (MLAs) says they should give "equality of opportunity to all candidates irrespective of... political opinion". The Equality Commission for Northern Ireland said that, while there are "exceptions" in employment law, the job ads could be "open to a claim for unlawful discrimination". An assembly spokesman said MLAs are given "advice on best practice" and "it is for each MLA to appoint employees on merit after a fair and open competition".Sinn Féín said staff are employed by MLAs to "pursue their priorities for constituency and assembly business", and "these priorities may legitimately be influenced by their own political perspective".MLAs claimed more than £8m in expenses in 2023-24 for constituency office staffing costs including job ads and criteria for almost 300 constituency office posts were examined by BBC News documents for many of them stated that applications were welcomed from "all backgrounds" regardless of "political opinion". Some said candidates should have an "understanding of" the objectives or values of the MLA's political others suggested applicants must hold those political of those jobs were with Sinn Féin the "essential criteria", they said candidates should have a "strong" or "proven commitment to Sinn Féin's values".This included posts with Michelle O'Neill, the party's deputy jobs with MLAs for the Ulster Unionist Party (UUP) and Social Democratic and Labour Party (SDLP) had similar wording. Caseworker jobs in former UUP leader Doug Beattie's office said candidates needed a "strong commitment" to the party's jobs for Cara Hunter also said candidates should have a "strong commitment to SDLP principles and values".Belfast-based employment solicitor Cormac Rice expressed concern over job vacancies being "contingent upon a predisposition towards a specific political persuasion".He said it "may undermine equality of opportunity and the need to ensure that the best candidate is appointed". Stormont's "best practice guidance" issued to MLAs for recruitment of their office staff advises that "equality of opportunity is integral".It said recruitment should be "solely on the basis of merit" and provide "equality of opportunity to all candidates", irrespective of protected characteristics including gender, religion and "political opinion".The Equality Commission said all employers must "operate within our equality laws"."Any employer who states or implies in a job advertisement that an applicant must hold, or not hold, a particular political opinion to be eligible for the role, may leave themselves open to a claim for unlawful discrimination," a spokeswoman she said the Fair Employment and Treatment (NI) Order 1998 "includes an exception in relation to political opinion" where the "essential nature of a job requires it"."We advise employers to contact us for advice before publishing job advertisements that rely on this exception," she added. A Sinn Féin spokesman said: "Every MLA is resourced to employ staff to support them to serve their constituents and pursue their priorities for constituency and assembly business."These priorities may legitimately be influenced by their own political perspective."MLAs can seek HR support from the institution to ensure fair and consistent recruitment processes that promotes equal opportunities." An assembly spokesman said MLAs employ staff to support their work."This is distinct from support that may be provided centrally by their political party," he added."Guidance published to MLAs by the Assembly Commission provides advice on best practice in recruitment, including the need to ensure that no unlawful discrimination occurs when making employment decisions."Taking this guidance into account, it is for each MLA to appoint employees on merit after a fair and open competition."The UUP was approached for SDLP said it "remains committed to ensuring a fair and transparent process for all job applicants and appointments are made solely on merit"."We are confident we have upheld these principles throughout," a party spokesman added. 'Social media officers' The recruitment documents were obtained through Freedom of Information also give an insight into who is being recruited by MLAs, and the kinds of jobs being of the 90 MLAs have declared employing family than 60% of the staff recruited since May 2022 were members of their MLA employer's political of the jobs advertised have titles such as constituency caseworker, manager or policy 50 had "communications" in their title, while a further 19 were "social media officers".Pat McCartan, a former member of an independent Stormont panel which set rules on MLA expenses, expressed concern about some of the job titles."It's very far removed from assisting people with their constituency enquiries," he said."They're not paid to be extra party workers."Mr McCartan said there was a need for a "serious audit of the financial arrangements".An assembly spokesman said MLAs employ staff for "a range of roles such as casework, research and communications"."This is distinct from support that may be provided centrally by their political party," he said staff support MLAs "to serve their constituents and pursue their priorities for constituency and assembly business"."Those specific priorities will differ for each member and may be naturally influenced by their political perspective."
