Hamas Delays Response to US Ceasefire Proposal Amid Fears of ‘Lebanese Scenario'
As of Friday evening in Gaza, Hamas had yet to respond to a new ceasefire plan submitted by US Middle East envoy Steve Witkoff, a proposal Israel accepted within hours of receiving it. While Hamas says it is reviewing the plan carefully, sources within the movement indicate several serious concerns are holding up a response.
At the heart of Hamas's hesitation is fear that the proposal's language is too vague, particularly the section outlining a 60-day ceasefire. According to Hamas sources, the terms do not clearly obligate Israel to honor the full duration of the truce or extend it if negotiations succeed.
This ambiguity, they warn, opens the door for Israel to resume military operations in Gaza at will - much like its periodic strikes in Lebanon - especially after the first week of the deal, when a round of hostage exchanges is expected to conclude.
One Hamas official told Asharq Al-Awsat that the proposal is riddled with 'traps' and imposes conditions that complicate matters for the Palestinian side.
'It's not just about accepting or rejecting - the proposal needs clarification and likely some amendments,' the source said. Still, other figures in Hamas say the group may ultimately accept the deal if it receives guarantees on unresolved points, particularly regarding humanitarian aid.
The plan outlines the release of 125 Palestinian prisoners, all serving life or long sentences, in exchange for a phased handover of five living Israeli hostages and nine bodies.
Hamas considers this number insufficient, both in terms of proportionality and compared to past deals.
Furthermore, the proposal lacks mechanisms to ensure the war's end, instead leaving that decision to future negotiations, a process Hamas believes would remain under the control of Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, who has publicly resisted committing to any final resolution.
Humanitarian provisions in the proposal are another sticking point. The current draft does not guarantee the sustained entry of aid into Gaza and makes no reference to the protocols established during previous ceasefires.
Aid delivery would depend on the pace of negotiations and implementation of the agreement, with no assurance of critical items like heavy equipment for rubble removal. Distribution would also be limited to international organizations such as the UN and the Red Crescent, excluding Gaza's private sector entirely.
Hamas officials argue that Israel's swift acceptance of the deal is no surprise. They believe it was coordinated in advance with Washington and reflects Israeli interests above all. The proposal, they say, prioritizes Netanyahu's conditions while offering Palestinians little in return beyond vague promises.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Arab News
2 hours ago
- Arab News
Israeli court sentences widow of Walid Daqqa to house arrest
LONDON: Sanaa Salameh Daqqa, the widow of Palestinian political prisoner Walid Daqaa who died in custody last year, has been sentenced to 10 days' house arrest by an Israeli court in Hadera. Daqqa, who lives in the Israeli village of Baqa al-Gharbiyye, was arrested in occupied East Jerusalem last week on a charge of online incitement following a demand by Israel's Minister of National Security Itamar Ben-Gvir for her to be deported. The court on Thursday sentenced her to 10 days of house arrest at her mother's home in Tira and imposed a travel ban and bail of 20,000 shekels ($5,700), the Palestinian news agency WAFA reported. However, Sanaa remains in custody, as Israeli police are expected on Friday to appeal the court's decision to release her. Walid Daqaa died in Israeli custody in April 2024 after spending 38 years in custody. His body remains held by Israeli authorities.
Arab News
2 hours ago
- Arab News
International community has duty to help achieve a Palestinian state, UN chief tells Arab News
NEW YORK CITY: UN Secretary-General Antonio Guterres on Thursday told Arab News that the international community has a duty to do everything in its power to pursue a two-state solution to the conflict between Israel and Palestine, and to bring about the conditions that can make it happen. 'It is absolutely essential to keep alive the two-state solution perspective, with all the terrible things we are witnessing in Gaza and the West Bank,' he said. 'And for those who have doubts about the two-state solution, I ask what is the alternative? Is it a one-state solution in which either the Palestinians are expelled or the Palestinians will be forced to live on their land without rights? That would be totally unacceptable. 'I firmly believe that it is the duty of the international community to do everything to keep the two-state solution alive and then to materialize the conditions to make it happen.' His comments came as Saudi Arabia and France prepare to co-chair a global conference this month in an attempt to hasten the implementation of a two-state solution and end decades of conflict between Israelis and Palestinians. The effort gained further international support this week amid worsening conditions in Gaza as a result of Israel's continuing intensification of military operations following the collapse in March of a previous ceasefire agreement with Hamas, and its decision to block humanitarian aid from entering the territory. These actions have resulted in thousands of Palestinian deaths, the widespread destruction of civilian infrastructure, further mass displacements, and severe risk of famine, according to the Integrated Food Security Phase Classification, an initiative that aims to improve food security analysis and decision-making. The devastating toll of Israel's resumed assault on Gaza has sparked international anger, and Arab representatives have said the upcoming conference must look beyond mere diplomacy and deliver tangible steps on a path toward peace. Speaking at a meeting of the UN General Assembly this month in preparation for the forum, Saudi Arabia said official recognition of the State of Palestine was a 'strategic necessity' as 'the cornerstone of a new regional order based on mutual recognition and coexistence.' It added: 'Regional peace begins with recognizing the State of Palestine, not as a symbolic gesture but as a strategic necessity.' The high-level conference, scheduled to take place from June 17 to 20 at the UN headquarters in New York, aims to urgently adopt concrete measures to achieve the implementation of a two-state solution. Palestine is officially recognized by 147 of the UN's 193 member states and has held the status of nonmember observer state within the organization since 2012, but has not been granted full membership. More than 53,000 Palestinians have been killed since Israeli authorities unleashed its military operations in Gaza following a Hamas-led attack that killed 1,200 people in Israel in October 2023. On Wednesday, Guterres led a solemn tribute to 168 UN workers killed during 2024, describing the ceremony as not only a moment of mourning but a call for global reflection on the dangers faced by humanitarian workers. Of those who were honored, 126 were killed in Gaza and all but one of them served with the UN Relief and Works Agency. Guterres said 2024 was the deadliest year for UN staff in the organization's history and added: 'More than one in every 50 UNRWA staff in Gaza has been killed in this atrocious conflict. Some were killed delivering life-saving aid, others alongside their families, and others while shielding the vulnerable.' Families of the fallen were present at the annual memorial ceremony, during which Guterres described those who lost their lives as 'extraordinary individuals, each one a story of courage, compassion and service.' He emphasized the enduring commitment of UN workers despite growing global instability and said: 'They do not seek recognition. They seek to make a difference. When conflict erupts, they work for peace. When rights are violated, they speak out.' Guterres condemned the targeting of humanitarian workers and civilians in conflict zones and warned against what he called a growing tolerance for impunity. 'We will not accept the killing of UN personnel, of humanitarians, journalists, medical workers, or civilians as the new normal,' he said. 'There must be no room for impunity.' Despite increasing criticism of international institutions and growing shortfalls in funding for aid, Guterres said the dedication of UN staff remains unwavering. 'In a world where cooperation is under strain, we must remember the example set by our fallen colleagues,' he added. He pledged to uphold the core values of the UN, stating: 'We will not waver in our principles. We will not abandon our values. And we will never, ever give up.'
Asharq Al-Awsat
3 hours ago
- Asharq Al-Awsat
Israeli Finance Minister Says Banks Should Not Obey EU Sanctions on Settlers
Israel's Finance Minister Bezalel Smotrich on Thursday condemned the country's banks that have refused to provide services to Israeli settlers sanctioned by the European Union and warned they may have to pay compensation to them. The EU last year imposed sanctions on five Israeli settlers for violence against Palestinians and Smotrich said there were reports of sanctions being considered against other settlers. But in a letter to the banking supervisor, he said Israeli banks should not follow a "zero risk" policy since it leads to the abandonment of Israeli clients "under the guise of compliance with foreign sanctions." In a statement quoting his letter to the regulator, Smotrich called on banks to use their legal, economic, and international strength to fight "unjust sanctions", Reuters reported. "The banks' enormous profits enable them to take measured risks on behalf of their clients — especially when it comes to a national moral injustice," Smotrich, who leads the far-right Religious Zionism party, said. Should banks continue to comply with sanctions and harm clients, Smotrich said he intended to promote immediate legislation that would require banks to pay substantial compensation to affected customers. He also intends to require the Bank of Israel itself to offer banking services to citizens targeted by sanctions. Responding to the letter, the Bank of Israel said that while banks must comply with international sanctions to avoid an array of risks, a draft directive it published on Thursday aimed to ensure appropriate banking services were available for the affected customers. "Circumventing foreign sanctions regimes through the Israeli banking system exposes banking corporations to multiple risks, including compliance risks, anti-money laundering and counter-terror financing risks, legal risks, and reputational risks," the central bank said. But it said it has taken steps to comply with sanctions "without banks resorting to blanket refusals to serve such customers." While the sanctions in question concern Israeli settlers, the EU is reviewing its broad pact governing its political and economic ties with Israel in the face of mounting international pressure on Israel amid complaints about the lack of humanitarian aid reaching Gaza in the wake of the war triggered by Hamas' Oct. 7, 2023 attack.
