Accused in Cobh murder trial didn't account for his movements at relevant time to gardaí
The tattoo artist on trial for murdering a young man in Cobh by slashing his leg with a sword was questioned by gardaí around a week afterwards but he made no comment when asked to account for his movements at the relevant time.
31-year-old Dylan Scannell of O'Rahilly Street, Cobh, County Cork, spoke to gardaí following his arrest on March 22, 2024, for murdering Ian Baitson and he described being a tattoo artist, his drug use, mental health and a head injury he sustained in a fall.
He was also questioned about key aspects of the investigation and warned in legal terms that inferences could be drawn from a failure to answer.
Sergeant Diarmuid O'Neill and Detective Garda Dave Barry put it to him that blood of Ian Baitson was found on the passenger footwell mat of a car in which he (the accused) was present at 20.53 on March 15, 2024, after - gardaí believed - he seriously assaulted Ian Baitson with a sword.
Asked if he wished to say anything about that, he replied, 'No'.
Ian Baitson (pictured) died on March 19, 2024. File picture
Similar inference explanations were given to him when he was asked why he was present at the Eurospar car park at the relevant time when Ian Baitson was subjected to a brutal assault by him with a sword. He replied: 'No comment.'
This evidence emerged from memos of interviews on March 22 and March 23, 2024, at Midleton garda station.
In the murder trial which ran throughout this week Dylan Scannell denied murdering 33-year-old chef, Ian Baitson, in Eurospar car park, Newtown Road, Cobh, on March 19, 2024, but admitted his manslaughter. The prosecution case is almost finished, prosecution senior counsel Donal O'Sullivan said on Friday.
Ms Justice Eileen Creedon said to the jury of six men and six women at the Central Criminal Court sitting in Cork: 'We will go into the final stages of this trial next week.' She asked the jury to return on Tuesday, June 3.
In earlier parts of the interviews talking about his life and background, the accused said he was engaged to be married and that he had worked for years as a tattoo artist and had his own studio at different times, in Cobh and Tralee, and was still doing it at that time in early 2024 on a freelance basis.
In relation to his own body tattoos, he referred to one on his head of an Egyptian demon. He had an interest in American show dogs and fishing, he said during interviews.
He also said: 'My mental health is not great.' He spoke of falling from a roof six weeks previously for which he received hospital treatment.
Regarding drugs, he said:
I am taking cocaine – half a lump a day, maybe more.
He also spoke of taking other drugs including, 'acid, mushrooms and ecstasy'. He said his drug-taking began at the age of 13 or 14.
Defence senior counsel Tom Creed said reference was also made to the defendant taking medication, including anti-depressants.
Before the evidence of memos of interviews, there was evidence from two forensic scientists from Forensic Science Ireland.
Dr Alan Magee said blood samples on a car mat taken in evidence from a rented Skoda Octavia matched the profile of the deceased, Ian Baitson.
Dr Stephen Clifford said that a sample taken from a sword matched the DNA profile of Ian Baitson, using a different type of DNA test than his colleague used on the mat.
He explained that the sword-matched DNA could also match a person's siblings and maternal relatives.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Sunday World
14 hours ago
- Sunday World
Self-declared Michael Gaine murder ‘suspect' gave court ‘untrustworthy testimony'
American was involved in a bitter dispute with his ex partner over their two daughters The district court findings were made against failed asylum seeker and father-of-two Michael Kelley, who is originally from Waldo County, Maine in the US, during a bitter custody dispute with former partner Alicia Snow in 2009. Publicly available documents obtained by the Sunday World confirm the former US soldier made 'unsupported' allegations against Ms Snow during the dispute of 'practising witchcraft on the couple's children'. Kelley, who has denied any involvement in Michael Gaine's murder, was arrested on May 18, just over 36 hours after the victim's body parts were discovered in slurry being spread on his farm. Mike Gaine went missing on March 20 He was later released without charge. Gardai believe Mr Gaine was dismembered after he was killed and that the body parts were dumped in a 50,000-gallon slurry tank on the property. As part of the garda investigation, a full background check is being carried out on Kelley, who had been living 'underground' on Mr Gaine's farm and working as a 'farmhand'. Enquiries carried out by this newspaper have now established that Kelley is a father-of-two who was involved in a bitter dispute with his former partner Alicia Snow, which was ultimately decided in her favour by Maine's Supreme Judicial Court in 2009. Legal documents outlined Michael Kelley's 'untrustworthy' statements News in 90 Seconds - June 1st Records of this nature in the US are, unlike in Ireland, publicly available. According to court documents, Kelley and Ms Snow were involved in a romantic relationship and are the biological parents of two daughters. After they separated, Kelley brought a parental rights action. In 2006, a family law magistrate held a hearing and issued an order allocating shared parental rights between the parties, but stated 'in the event the parties are not able to agree, final decision-making is allocated to Ms Snow'. The order also awarded primary residency to Ms Snow. The 2006 order included a written agreement which afforded reasonable rights of contact with the children and stipulated that Kelley would not pay child support. After the original order was made, the former couple maintained a cordial relationship. Gardai on site Ms Snow was able to attain a nursing degree and begin a relationship with a new partner. Ultimately, however, the situation began to deteriorate, culminating in a series of miscommunications between Kelley's wife and Ms Snow. After a disagreement over a brief trip to Chicago for the children, Kelley filed a motion to enforce the 2006 parental rights order which he alleged prevented Snow from sending the children out of state without his consent. Kelley also filed a motion for contempt, alleging that Ms Snow violated the 2006 order by taking the children to visit their grandfather in Chicago. The court held a hearing on all of the motions on January 14, 2009. After hearing testimony from Kelley, his then wife, Snow, and Snow's father, the court made a number of 'findings of fact.' These included: Snow, meanwhile, was found by the court to be 'logical and rational and her abilities to act as an effective parent are far superior to those of Kelley'. Mike Gaine captured on CCTV before he disappeared The court ordered that Snow have sole parental rights. In his appeal to the Supreme Judicial Court, Kelley argued that the District Court erred when it awarded sole parental rights to Ms Snow. But the Supreme Judicial Court found: 'After a review of the record, it is evident that the court's findings are supported by the record as a whole. 'Because there is competent evidence in the record to support the court's decision, and it is clear that the court considered the best interests of the children in its award of parental rights, the judgment must be affirmed.' Mike Gaine's wife and sister The investigation into the murder of Michael Gaine is now in its tenth week. The popular farmer vanished on March 20. Mr Kelley worked on Gaine's farm for a number of years.
The Irish Sun
15 hours ago
- The Irish Sun
‘Mummified' baby found at dry cleaners wrapped in dirty laundry from funeral home as cops probe ‘disturbing' mystery
A MUMMIFIED baby wrapped in dirty laundry was found by a horrified employee at a dry cleaner. Cops have now launched a probe to investigate the sickening ordeal and figure out how the baby was shipped with soiled linens to a cleaning facility in Louisiana. Advertisement 3 A mummified baby was found wrapped in dirty clothes at a dry cleaner Credit: Local 12 3 Cops rushed to the chilling scene at Alsco Uniforms Credit: Local 12 3 The shipment was received from Golden Gate Funeral Home, in Dallas, Texas Credit: Local 12 The embalmed infant was But in a haunting twist, the The nightmarish mix-up occurred despite the baby having had a funeral on May 17 at Golden Gate Funeral Home & Crematory. Cops said the linens which were holding the corpse were sent from this same funeral home. Advertisement READ MORE WORLD NEWS Preliminary findings indicate that the Local cops said the Tuesday morning , at around 5:30am. The employee who first found the tot was seemingly unaware of the fact that they had uncovered a human baby at first. They reportedly believed the disturbing find was a doll wrapped in linen. Advertisement Most read in The US Sun The local Violent Crimes Unit was immediately dispatched to the scene in the 500 block of Hollywood Avenue. Authorities are currently investigating how the remains were misplaced, and whether any parties were aware of the horrifying error. Driver who took 'at least 20 lines of cocaine' before killing girl, 3, in horror tram crash is jailed Shreveport Police Chief Wayne Smith said: "This is a deeply distressing situation. "Our thoughts are with the family of the child as this investigation unfolds." Advertisement Local cops ruled out foul play for the time being, but this could change as the probe goes on. In February, a teenager was arrested after she The baby plummeted 30ft to his death in the senseless killing. American Mia McQuillin, 18, was charged with "child homicide" after her baby boy from the second floor of the Ibis Styles hotel in Advertisement The
RTÉ News
2 days ago
- RTÉ News
Suspect in Gaine case claims he is being framed by criminals
The suspect in the Michael Gaine murder case has denied having any involvement in the killing of the Co Kerry farmer. Michael Kelley, a former US Army soldier, claims he is being framed by a subversive criminal organisation. Mr Kelley, who is an American citizen in his 50s, has told RTÉ News that he was the man arrested and questioned by gardaí on suspicion of murdering Mr Gaine. Having been detained and questioned for a period of 24 hours in Killarney Garda Station he was released without charge on 19 May. RTÉ News has spoken to Mr Kelley on two occasions. The first interview took place in early April in the old farmhouse where Mr Kelley had been living on Mr Gaine's farm. This interview was conducted before Mr Kelley was arrested and when Mr Gaine's disappearance was still being treated as a missing persons case. Mr Kelley also spoke to RTÉ News last Monday, in the apartment where he now lives in Tralee. During this meeting, Mr Kelley confirmed on the record that he had since been arrested and questioned. He also reaffirmed aspects of this case discussed in the initial meeting. Mr Kelley said he worked as a labourer on Mr Gaine's farm for almost three years. "We worked hand and glove. Doing the sheep or whatever, dosing them and stuff. I had already handled animals. I was fixing cars and tractors for him." Mr Kelley said he last saw Mr Gaine "around 10am" on 20 March when they met in the farmyard. Mr Gaine had indicated to him that he was planning to meet somebody that day, before giving Mr Kelley a list of chores to complete during the day. Mr Kelley said he then returned to the old farmhouse to make coffee, adding that was the last time he saw Mr Gaine. "Around 10am. He was as normal as ever. He was doing his chores. Redistributing the silage and things. Just ordinary chores. "He said 'look after the chores for me. I'm just going to meet a man. I'll be back later'. "He didn't come back that night. He said he would be back. Then they came looking for him at about 10am the following morning." The Kerry farmer disappeared on 20 March. Mr Gaine's vehicle, which contained a number of personal items, was found on the farm at Carrig East, situated between the town of Kenmare and Moll's Gap. In an effort to establish the whereabouts of Mr Gaine, an extensive search of Mr Gaine's farm, surrounding valleys and lakes was initiated. Mr Gaine's disappearance was upgraded by gardaí from a missing person case to a homicide investigation on 29 April. Human remains were discovered on Mr Gaine's farm on 16 May, as workers were spreading slurry on fields. The farm was immediately sealed off and declared a crime scene. Further human remains are believed to have been found in a slurry spreader and in a slurry tank on the farm in the following days. Gardaí say DNA tests have since confirmed that the human remains are those of Mr Gaine. Mr Kelley was arrested on suspicion of murder by gardaí in Tralee on 16 May. He had relocated to an apartment there two weeks previous to his arrest. Mr Kelley denies any involvement in the murder of Mr Gaine and believes Mr Gaine may have been lured to his death by sinister elements. "If he wasn't around the barn during the day, it's possible that somebody lured him, maybe at gun point, in to an area of concealment. You could walk 100 yards from the barn and be totally out of sight." Mr Kelley has his own theories about how Mr Gaine was killed and how his body was disposed of. He also believes there are questions to be answered about the way the investigation is being conducted by gardaí. Mr Kelley said he was taken to Sneem Garda Station shortly after Mr Gaine's disappearance to make a voluntary statement. Mr Kelley was arrested on 18 May, two days after human remains were discovered on Mr Gaine's farm. Questioned by RTÉ News about his relationship with Mr Gaine, Mr Kelley described it as "transactional" and "a good working relationship." "I wouldn't describe us as great friends, but we got on. Our relationship was transactional. He gave me accommodation, food and paid me. In return I worked on his farm. "We had a good working relationship. A civil relationship. We got on and understood one another. "We are both farmers. We are getting along because we are grown men and we have work to do. "We were brothers of the land, around the same age, with similar interests, and I liked that sense of brotherhood." Mr Kelley said he repaired and maintained farm machinery and vehicles for Mr Gaine. Mr Kelley also showed RTÉ News an old range [stove] in the farmhouse which he said he had repaired and plumbed to provide hot water in a makeshift sink. Mr Kelley was using what appeared to be a tractor battery to charge his personal devices. He said there was no electricity in the house, but that he was comfortable. "The arrangement got me out of the limbo I was in where I needed a job and I needed a place to stay. I was doing the work and we were getting along alright. Mr Kelley is originally from a rural part of Maine in the United States. He said he served in the US military as an infantry private and spent an extended period of his service in Germany. Mr Kelley, who is separated and has three daughters, said he arrived in Ireland in late 2017. He claims he was forced to flee the United States as he had been investigating criminal activity there and feared his life was in danger. Mr Kelley said he remains in danger and he is of the belief that he continues to be monitored by sinister elements here in Ireland. "It's an organised crime network. It's co-ordinated on the internet," he said. After an unsuccessful attempt to secure asylum status in Ireland, Mr Kelley said he spent prolonged periods living in the forests in Killarney National Park and in another wooded area between Sneem and Kenmare. He said he held a number of jobs in the Glenbeigh and Sneem/Kenmare areas, including as a seaweed harvester and as a landscape gardener, before he went to work for Michael Gaine. Mr Kelley said he is a mechanic and also designs prototypes. During the interview in the old farmhouse on Mr Gaine's farm, Mr Kelley showed RTÉ News a sketch book which contained many detailed drawings of various pieces of equipment which he had designed. He said he hopes to share these designs with MI5 or other military entities. Mr Kelley is also a musician who plays the flute and tin whistle along with other instruments. He was recently seen busking in Tralee. During the course of his interview with RTÉ News he played a traditional Irish air, An Cúilfhionn. Mr Kelley said he first met Mr Gaine when he approached the farmer seeking work in 2022. He had been living in a makeshift camp in the woods a few kilometres from Mr Gaine's farm when Mr Gaine offered to let him stay in the old farmhouse: "It suited me. Firstly, it offered me access to food and it gave me a roof over my head," he said.
