Prison officers warned about risks of using pepper spray on inmates
A government paper on the use of pepper spray in jails warned that some prisoners would become more violent and that it should not be used on crowded landings, on females, or inmates with mental health issues.
The paper was prepared by the Department of Justice against the backdrop of an overcrowding crisis and an increase in violence in Irish prisons.
It said there was a case for incapacitant spray and that prison officers in Ireland were 'unique' among European jailers in not being allowed to carry 'defensive weapons or compliance tools'.
The State Claims Agency – which manages compensation on behalf of the government – advised spray could be used by appropriately trained personnel in the right circumstances.
It said their research showed it caused no long-term health effects and that its use by gardai had not led to any claims for damages despite being deployed around 1,000 times a year.
However, the State Claims Agency said it was not without risk and after it was introduced, it could lead to an increase in 'use of force incidents'.
The policy paper said: 'Where it is deployed too soon or too often this can have a detrimental effect on prisoners' perceptions of legitimate authority.'
It said the use of spray would not work in every situation and that around 10% of people would be unaffected, and some would become 'more rather than less aggressive'.
The research also said prisoners would try to prepare for its use against them when planning a violent act.
The document said the Irish Prison Service would need to have an additional governance procedure for managing incidents. This would include healthcare for staff and prisoners as well as monitoring, debriefing, and secure storage of spray.
It added: 'There are definite limitations on its use in certain circumstances: in crowded public areas; on female prisoners; on pregnant prisoners; in cases of passive resistance; on prisoners with mental health issues; on prisoners when at a height.'
The policy paper was prepared last autumn with then Minister Helen McEntee giving the go-ahead for use of incapacitant spray. An accompanying submission said most jails were operating well above capacity with growing pressure from prison staff for personal protection.
It detailed how at one stage the female prison in Limerick was at 150% capacity, the women's Dochas Centre at 124%, and the male facility in Limerick at 121%.
The submission suggested that a pilot project take place, but legislation would be needed to use pepper spray.
It said the State Claims Agency had said the increase in prisoner-on-prisoner assaults and an increased risk of injury to staff justified its introduction.
Last week, it was reported Justice Minister Jim O'Callaghan would proceed with the plan with an announcement due in the next few weeks.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Examiner
an hour ago
- Irish Examiner
Charity offers counselling to Irish soldiers who have endured the ‘horror' of war in Ukraine
Seven former members of the Defence Forces who have returned from fighting in Ukraine are undergoing counselling for post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) for the 'horrors' they experienced. The charity One (Organisation for National Ex-Service Personnel) has confirmed its staff is providing support services to the soldiers who witnessed 'appalling stuff' while battling Russian forces on and near Ukraine's frontlines. The seven are all men ranging in age from mid-20s to late 40s. However, the charity said it is aware of more veterans who have returned from Ukraine but have not yet sought its help. The charity is aware of other former members still in Ukraine, while the Irish Examiner understands one Irish woman is also helping Ukraine's troops, though she is not a former Defence Forces member. One of the seven who has received PTSD counselling from ONE told the Irish Examiner he is considering returning to the frontline. Peter (not his real name), who is in his 30s and from the south of the country, told the Irish Examiner: 'To say I saw appalling stuff is an understatement. It got gradually worse as the war went on as there was heavier and heavier combat. Quite a few of my friends died.' Despite the horrors, he said he is considering going back to fight again. Audra Larkin, a veteran support officer with One, is providing counselling to three ex-Defence Forces veterans who fought in Ukraine. She said the desire to return is not uncommon, as those who return to Ireland feel 'guilty for leaving' their Ukrainian comrades. Ms Larkin said: They have said they would all go back tomorrow — they are all open about this. 'We outline the risks and possible consequences of doing this, but there is an overwhelming camaraderie.' One of the veterans Ms Larkin was helping to cope with PTSD — who is aged in his 20s — returned to Ukraine in January. 'He felt a deep commitment to his comrades. This person felt guilty not being with them,' said Ms Larkin. So far, five Irish people have died fighting in Ukraine, including Robert Deegan, a former member of the elite Army Ranger Wing, since Russian troops invaded the country in February 2022. Meanwhile, a large-scale exchange of prisoners and bodies of the dead due to occur on Monday now seems to be in doubt after each side accused the other of breaking the terms of the agreement.
Irish Examiner
an hour ago
- Irish Examiner
Hip surgery becoming necessary for many children 'due to late diagnosis' amid lack of screening
Questions are being raised as to why 'worrying' gaps in care for children with hip dysplasia — first identified in 2017 and again in a Hiqa report last year — have not been addressed. Healthcare workers were raising alarms about diagnosis, including through a HSE steering group in 2017, even before the latest crisis around surgeries under Children's Health Ireland (CHI) hospitals. By January 2023, concern was so high two medical bodies made a submission to the National Screening Advisory Committee (NSAC). The National Child Health Public Health Programme and the National Clinical Programme for Paediatrics and Neonatology called for ultrasound screening for the condition for all babies instead of only those at high risk. Hiqa was then asked by the NSAC to compare the benefits of selective and universal screening. The NSAC reports directly to the health minister. Hiqa's report team included people from the HSE and Department of Health. The report advised against expanding screening, saying there is 'significant uncertainty' over benefits. However, it found existing systems are not a formal screening programme and not in line with HSE steering group recommendations. It said: Current practice is therefore not supported by the governance, end-to-end care, quality assurance, and monitoring of outcomes that would be associated with such a programme. It is not known how many babies are born annually with hip dysplasia, it said, citing Irish studies showing a range of 'between 400 and 1,800 babies'. Funding was provided by 2017 for ultrasound programmes in maternity hospitals. However, it is not mandatory to report patient numbers, diagnosis, or treatment. One consultant familiar with hip dysplasia care warned: 'So, essentially the steering group was there as spectators, helplessly trying to get information but not actually having the power to gather it and not having the power to act on it.' The urgency was highlighted by the CHI hip surgery audit. The consultant said: In the recent CHI report, if you subtract the unnecessary operations from the overall number, you are left with a lot of necessary operations. In many cases it is likely that they were necessary because of late diagnosis. This is because 'problems arise when the diagnosis is made late. The sooner you spot it, you can treat it in a harness or a brace. And the children respond very well and have excellent results'. However, without a national register, the doctor said 'we have no idea what the national rate of late diagnosis is. I would guess there are probably 80 to 100 babies per year who are presenting with late diagnosis'. Sinn Féin health spokesman David Cullinane questioned long delays in implementing the recommendations or a national audit, saying 'astonishingly the working group has now been disbanded'. 'The recent scandal into unnecessary hip procedures on children demonstrates the importance of the recommendations of the working group,' he said. 'It is worrying that these recommendations were not implemented and this has caused understandable concern for those involved in this valuable work.' The HSE said the steering group was disbanded this year. Its role was to identify ways to find babies at risk. 'These pathways are now in place nationally,' a spokesman said. Responsibility for this is now under the 'relevant clinical and operational governance lines' under each regional executive officer in the new HSE health regions. The Department of Health pointed to communication from the NSAC last month to the two bodies which raised concerns saying the best approach 'would likely be the systematic application of the current selective screening programme'. A spokeswoman said NSAC wrote to the health minister in March 2024 recommending against expanding screening. 'The NSAC Chair noted that the condition would be kept under review as new evidence emerges. This will be considered later this year,' she said. Hiqa confirmed its advice was submitted to NSAC.
Irish Examiner
9 hours ago
- Irish Examiner
The frightening breakdown of animal health across Europe's farms
A huge bird flu epidemic in the EU's main poultry meat-producing member state is part of a scary breakdown of animal health on European farms. Poland produces 21% of the EU's poultry meat, but Highly Pathogenic Avian Influenza (HPAI) has left it struggling to rebuild its poultry stocks. Along with bird flu, over the past decade, outbreaks of African swine fever, bluetongue virus, foot-and-mouth disease, ovine rinderpest, and lumpy skin disease have followed one after the other in the EU, with livestock losses, financial cost, reduced food production, and trauma for farmers. Poland's poultry industry developed rapidly since 2004, when Poland joined the EU. Flocks have also been hit by Newcastle disease, for which vaccination has been made mandatory. Poland's annual poultry production of 2.9 million tonnes comes from about 67% broiler chickens, 22% laying hens, 7% turkeys, 3% ducks, and 1% geese. Polish producers have been able to export broiler meat cheaper than other member states. The EU accounts for around 60% of Polish broiler meat exports, with 40% directed to non-EU countries. Poultry meat production increased by about 6.5% in 2024, a trend which continued into 2025, but the bird flu and Newcastle disease has now affected expansion. By May 6, Poland had reported 85 HPAI outbreaks in poultry this year. In 2024, 50 HPAI outbreaks in farmed poultry were confirmed. People in protective clothing walk through a farm in Hoppegarten, Germany impacted by a foot and mouth outbreak. The Mazowieckie and Wielkopolskie provinces have the largest poultry population in Poland, accounting for 22 and 23%, respectively. In 2025, most of the outbreaks (43) were in Wielkopolskie province, followed by Mazowieckie (21). The 2025 outbreaks led to the culling of 7.7 million birds on the infected farms, and an additional four million poultry in 65 in-contact farms. Although most of the HPAI outbreaks were reported on 29 slaughter turkey farms, egg production was the worst impacted part of the industry, with laying hens making up 48% of all culled birds. Five outbreaks were confirmed on broiler farms, with 1.2 million birds culled. But even more significant were 12 outbreaks on hen reproductive farms, where over 865,000 birds were culled. Such a big loss of reproductive hens poses a threat to the Polish potential to rebuild poultry stocks. Previously, HPAI detections decreased in the spring and summer, but the winter infection peak has been prolonged in Poland this year, with the highest HPAI outbreak numbers recorded in March. As a result, at the beginning of April, the European Commission informed the Polish Chief Veterinary Officer of its deep concern at the disease situation. It said Polish measures to limit the bird flu epidemic were insufficient, which threatened the intra-EU market. EU measures were threatened against Poland, such as banning restocking with new birds by commercial poultry farms in four provinces, including Wielkopolskie and Mazowieckie, and restricting the movement of poultry, except to slaughterhouses. The four provinces have 64% of Poland's poultry production. Instead, negotiations resulted in an agreed action plan, in co-operation with the leading poultry industry associations and poultry and egg producers. Thirteen key directions were jointly agreed upon. For example, farms where outbreaks occur must break production for 40 days after a final disinfection, with restocking subject to inspection and verification of cleanliness tests, confirming the absence of HPAI and Newcastle disease. Other poultry farmers must wait 14 days before restocking, which is subject to additional official disinfection control. Stocking density limits will also be imposed. Surveillance zones around outbreaks are expanded by an additional five kilometres. No farmer compensation will be awarded without adherence to biosecurity plans verified by veterinarians. Weekly monitoring is to be introduced in restricted areas. Employees will be allowed work on only one farm. These and other agreed measures were implemented immediately in the worst-affected areas in Poland since mid-April. Meanwhile, there were 24 outbreaks of Newcastle disease (ND) on commercial poultry farms in Poland up to May 6, leading to culling of more than two million birds. In 2024, 21 ND outbreaks were confirmed. Since April 29, extra ND biosecurity requirements, and the obligation to vaccinate chickens and turkeys kept on commercial farms and poultry hatcheries, have been imposed. For example, commercial farms must apply enhanced biosecurity measures, such as disinfection when entering and leaving poultry buildings and farms. With rising meat prices and falling feed costs, Polish poultry farmers were set for another year of expansion, but disease has brought the booming sector down to earth suddenly. It is becoming an all-too-familiar setback for EU farmers, including cattle and sheep farmers hit by last year's outbreak of a new strain of bluetongue virus. This year, African Swine Fever (ASF) is also in the rise again, with Estonia, Croatia, and Ukraine reporting fresh outbreaks, and outbreaks continuing in 13 other member states. Germany, Hungary and Slovakia have been hit by this century's worst EU outbreak of foot-and-mouth disease (FMD), and an exotic viral strain of the same disease in Iraq and other countries in the Near East adds to the threat. Hungary has also been hit (for the first time ever) by ovine rinderpest, also commonly known as peste des petits ruminants (PPR). Causing severe mortality rates, PPR frequently devastates areas of Africa, the Middle East, and Asia, where farmers depend heavily on small ruminants. Since 2012, lumpy skin disease spread from Africa and Asia into cattle herds in Greece and Bulgaria. Its spread was controlled by a large, co-ordinated vaccination campaign co-funded by the EU. Vaccination is the answer to the EU's rising livestock disease problem, according to Emmanuelle Soubeyran, director general of the Paris-based World Organisation for Animal Health. However, the EU resists wider use of vaccination, because of the expense involved, and because countries the EU exports to may refuse to import meat and dairy products from vaccinated herds. Slovakia has used emergency FMD vaccines, but Germany and Hungary opted for animal lockdowns and epidemiological tracing. France adopted mass vaccination of ducks after 2023 bird flu outbreaks, and has successfully restored poultry production to its highest level in years. The Netherlands may launch vaccination for egg-laying flocks. Vaccination is unlikely in the USA, struggling to contain a massive bird flu epidemic.
