Setback to Patanjali Ayurved, Allahabad High Court dismisses ₹273.5 crore GST penalty appeal — Details here
The Allahabad High Court rejected Patanjali Ayurved Limited's plea challenging the ₹ 273.50 crore goods and service tax (GST) penalty, reported the news agency PTI on Tuesday, 3 June 2025.
The high court bench comprising Justice Shekhar B Saraf and Justice Vipin Chandra Dixit dismissed Patanjali's appeal, citing that such cases are made up of criminal liability and can be imposed only after a criminal trial.
'After detailed analysis, it is clear that the proceeding under Section 122 of the CGST Act is to be adjudicated by the adjudicating officer and is not required to undergo prosecution,' said the judicial bench, cited the news agency.
The tax authorities can impose penalties on firms under Section 122 of the GST Act through civil proceedings without requiring criminal court trials, according to the report, citing the judicial bench.
Patanjali Ayurved's sister concern firm, Patanjali Foods, even though being a separate entity, is listed in the Indian stock market. Shares of Patanjali Foods were trading 0.44 per cent lower at ₹ 1,690.20 during Tuesday's stock market session, compared to ₹ 1,697.65 in the previous market close.
The Directorate General of GST Intelligence (DGGI), Ghaziabad, issued a show cause notice to Patanjali Ayurved on 19 April 2024 proposing a penalty of ₹ 273.51 crore under sections of the GST Act, reported the news agency.
Later, DGGI dropped tax demands under Section 74 in an order dated 10 January 2025. The department reportedly found that the quantities sold for all commodities were more than those purchased from the suppliers.
'For all the commodities, the quantities sold were always more than the quantities purchased from the suppliers, thereby making the observation that all the ITC which was availed in the impugned goods was further passed on by the petitioner,' cited the news agency.
Despite dropping the tax demand, the tax authorities decided to continue with the penalty proceedings under Section 122, prompting Patanjali to challenge the order in the high court.
Patanjali Ayurved operates three manufacturing units at Haridwar, Sonipat, and Ahmednagar. The company reportedly was under investigation following information received by authorities about suspicious transactions with high input tax credit (ITC) utilisation.
The investigation reportedly found that Patanjali was 'acting as a main person' who was involved in circular trading of tax invoices on paper without supplying actual goods.
According to an earlier Mint report, Patanjali Foods Ltd. rejected reports that Patanjali Ayurved Limited received notice from the Ministry of Corporate Affairs (MCA) on Sunday, 1 June 2025.
They also said that Patanjali Ayurved is not being investigated by the Centre.
'We may clarify that Patanjali Ayurved Limited has not received any communication from Ministry of Corporate Affairs('MCA') for the proposed investigation by MCA as appearing in mainstream media,' said the company in an official filing.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
3 hours ago
- Time of India
Lower wage growth impacting consumption; tax cuts and rate cuts tools to spur growth: Report
Weakening wage and job growth cycle is impacting consumption sentiment , and tax cuts and rate cuts will help accelerate momentum, according to a report by ICICI Bank Global Markets. The report highlights that wage growth for listed Indian companies nearly halved in the financial year (FY) 2025, slowing to 7.5 per cent from an average of 15 per cent year-on-year (YoY) between FY22 and FY24, impacting consumption. The deceleration in wage growth can be attributed to the tepid demand and global economic uncertainty. The report adds that the slowdown, coupled with high inflation and elevated interest rates, has eroded consumers' discretionary income, particularly in urban areas. Spending across sectors has dampened. "Lower interest rates should lead to further recovery in consumption as repo-linked loans get repriced lower and reduce the interest outgo for consumers," according to ICICI Bank Global Markets report . "We believe further monetary support is required to spur consumption when inflation is easing," it said. Backing its assertion, the report added that Fast-Moving Consumer Goods (FMCG) sales in urban centres are trailing rural markets. In contrast, passenger vehicle sales growth has sharply decelerated to 4.5 per cent in FY25 from 8.8 per cent the previous year. On the job growth front, the report added that once a strong hiring engine, the IT sector continues to grapple with demand challenges from tech disruptions, monetary tightening, and trade volatility. Net hiring peaked at 293,000 in FY22 and saw a net contraction of 70,000 by FY24. The Indian economy grew by 6.5 per cent in real terms in the recently concluded financial year 2024-25, according to the Ministry of Statistics and Programme Implementation's official data. While the economic growth was 7.4 per cent in the January-March quarter (Q4) of FY25. This was a sharp rise from the 6.2 per cent recorded in the previous quarter. Given the underlying weakness in urban demand , the government announced an income tax relief of Rs 1 trillion in the Union Budget 2025-26. The other factors favouring a consumption recovery are lower food inflation as well as the recent uptick seen in GST collections. In the last two months we have seen a visible acceleration in GST collections, with gross GST revenues increasing by 16.4 per cent YoY in May and 12.6 per cent YoY in April, respectively.
Mint
4 hours ago
- Mint
GST Slab Rates: Which items fall under the 12% rate that council may remove? Are they going to be cheaper or dearer?
The GST Council is likely to soon consider the slabs of the goods and service tax. As per a new report, the Council may reduce the GST slabs from four to three, doing away with the 12 per cent GST rate. As per the report by Hindustan Times, citing people with knowledge of the matter, officials and experts advising the Group of Ministers (GoM) over rate rationalisation have reached a 'near consensus' that the current 12 per cent tax slab does not hold much relevance now. 'This could be the most plausible way to undertake a revenue neutral tax rate rationalisation exercise. However, the GST Council has to take a final call,' HT reported quoting the sources. Most Union and state government officials, experts and GoM representative have supported the proposal to remove the 12 per cent GST slab, the report said. If the slab is removed and a rate rationalisation is done, the items falling under the 12 per cent slab will either be moved to the 5 per cent or 18 per cent category. Presently, there are four tax slabs under the GST regime in India – 5 per cent, 12 per cent, 18 per cent and 28 per cent. Here are the items that are placed under 12 per cent GST slab. Goods falling under 12 per cent GST slab: Butter, ghee, processed food, almonds, mobiles, fruit juice, preparations of vegetables, fruits, nuts or other parts of plants including pickle murabba, chutney, jam, jelly, packed coconut water, umbrella and more. Services falling under 12 per cent GST slab: Hotel accommodations (up to ₹ 7,500 oer night tariff), passenger transport by air in non-economy classes, certain construction works, some multimodal transport services, and certain professional works. Some of the items are likely to be placed under 5 per cent GST slab, while other will be moved up to the 18 per cent category, if the report is to be believed. However, it is not known yet which item or service will be placed in which slab. It will only be known after the GST Council takes a final decision regarding the matter. The GST Council is expected to meet either in June or July.
India Gazette
5 hours ago
- India Gazette
Indian equities poised for long-term growth
New Delhi [India], June 5 (ANI): The recent report by Morgan Stanley, named 'India Equity Strategy Playbook', reveals that Indian equities appear undervalued, presenting a compelling opportunity for long-term to the report, 'it will require patience, given the potential for bad news from outside India, but we believe rewards will come in time.'The Equity market of India has shown resilience since September 2024, digesting a lot of unprecedented amount of bad news, which includes overvaluations in small and mid-cap stocks (SMIDs), a broad market correction, US tariff volatility, and geopolitical events. Despite these hurdles, large-cap indexes remain within 5 per cent of all-time the report also points out various strong fundamental factors supporting India's positive outlook. The country exhibits strong macro stability, characterised by improving terms of trade, a declining primary deficit, and low inflation volatility. Additionally, Morgan Stanley sees mid-to-high teens earnings growth is projected annually over the next three to five years, fuelled by an emerging private capital expenditure cycle, deleveraging of corporate balance sheets, and a structural increase in discretionary geopolitical developments have instilled a new doctrine on terror, potentially deterring future attacks and empowering decisive government action. Furthermore, an unexpected upside in military performance highlights advancements in strategy and combat capabilities, the report said. The report adds that India will outperform other emerging markets in the coming months: 'India's real policy rate relative to the US is turning up in the coming months and could support India's relative outperformance to EM in the coming months.'While the outlook is largely positive, the report also identifies several risks and catalysts. India-specific catalysts include potential dovish actions from the RBI, stimulus through GST rate cuts, a trade deal with the US, and positive incoming growth data. Globally, US policy and growth rates will be crucial cues, alongside China's deflationary impulses and broader geopolitical risks. Given India's low beta, it is expected to outperform in a global bear market but underperform in a bull Morgan Stanley recommends a portfolio strategy favouring Domestic Cyclicals over Defensives and External-facing sectors. (ANI)
