Auckland Grammar principal calls out Sport NZ over 'Year 14' athletes
1st XV rugby match between Nelson College and Marlborough Boys. Nelson College, Nelson.
Photo:
Chris Symes / www.photosport.nz
Auckland Grammar principal Tim O'Connor has challenged Sport NZ to take a stand on extra-year students returning to schools on sporting grounds.
The issue of 'Year 14' athletes has raised its head again, with Marlborough Boys' College
admitting it has five such players in its First XV
, which scored a historic - and controversial - win over Nelson College last month.
That 28-26 result came after Marlborough were awarded a first-half penalty and instead of aiming for the posts, the goalkicker struck for the corner, where one of his teammates chased it down for a try that was eventually awarded.
O'Connor told
Checkpoint
that bringing students back for an extra year for sporting purposes was a distortion of their roles as educators and openly wondered where the national sporting administrators were in this debate.
"Really, our role as principals and our role as schools is to educate young people," he said. "Sport NZ talks about balance is better, but where are they in this discussion?
"They haven't come out to say, 'why are we allowing this to occur?'
"I'd love to see them being more proactive and having the courage to speak up on this.
"Perhaps there are organisations that want to turn a blind eye to what is the pathway for young men and rugby in this country frankly. We need to get beyond that."
RNZ has approached Sport NZ for reaction to O'Connor's comments.
Auckland's 1A competition has put is members on notice that Year 14 players will not be permitted from next season. O'Connor admits two of the 12 teams currently have two such players each on their rosters.
"We discussed that at the beginning of the year and felt the fair thing to do was give everyone 12 months' notice, and then we wouldn't be allowing that to occur again."
Earlier this year, the issue led to a
ban on extra-year rowers at the prestigious Maadi Cup regatta
at Lake Karapiro.
School Sport NZ is now
considering a total ban on the Year 14 athletes
.
"There is no doubt there is a distinct advantage - muscle co-ordination and technical ability - in a sixth-year student," O'Connor said. "They're taking away positions from students who are coming through their natural schooling years.
"For example, Rieko Ioane could have returned - we could have encouraged him to return, because he would have met all the other criteria, and he could have returned to play rugby for another year, which would have been a huge advantage to our school.
"Our view was Rieko should actually carry on with his life and move to the next stage, and we'd fully support him in doing so."
Now an 81-test All Black, Ioane debuted for Auckland and the NZ sevens team the year after leaving Auckland Grammar, and made his test debut aged 19.
O'Connor insisted his school would not take the field against Marlborough with their Year 14 players.
"I don't know why there would be a reason to play them," he told
Checkpoint
. "I'd rather play in a competition where we know there is a level playing field and we're treating each other with respect.
"In the 1A competition, mid-season, we have about six teams who could still win it - that's a great competition, that keeps it alive across multiple schools."
Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero
,
a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RNZ News
40 minutes ago
- RNZ News
Former test lock Bryn Evans joins All Blacks as specialist lineout coach
Bryn Evans last played for the Highlanders three years ago. Photo: TREVOR COLLENS/AAP Former test lock Bryn Evans will join the All Blacks coaching team for 2025, as a specialist lineout coach. Just three years after retiring as a professional player, Evans has been rewarded for his contributions as an assistant coach at the Hurricanes and Hawke's Bay. He will join the All Blacks for their full 13-test calendar this year, before rejoining the Hurricanes for their 2026 campaign. All Blacks forward coach Jason Ryan said he and head coach Scott Robertson had been impressed by Evans' methods, which would provide a "point of difference". "He brings a unique skillset with his work with the Hurricanes and Hawke's Bay," Ryan said of Evans, 40. Bryn Evans debuts for the All Blacks against France. Photo: Simon Watts/Photosport "What I like is he's got a lateral thinking ability about him. He's an ex-lineout caller, and he had 12-plus years playing in the UK and France, which gives him a broad range of experience and an understanding of the northern hemisphere approach. "It's going to be a good complement for us. Bryn brings a skillset that I haven't got in terms of how they call lineouts, what pictures they see. "We believe it's a real point of difference having him, and making sure our skills are dialled in and leading the way in that area. "We believe having Bryn in this space, analysing us and the opposition, is just what we need." Evans played twice for New Zealand, coming off the bench in home tests against France in 2009. Meanwhile, in-form midfield back Peter Umaga-Jensen has announced he will leave the Super Rugby Pacific team with a year to run on his contract to take up a club deal in Japan. Peter Umaga-Jensen played one test for the All Blacks against Australia. Photo: John Cowpland/Actionpress The attack-minded Wellington provincial player debuted for the Hurricanes in 2018, going on to make 54 appearances in a tenure spoiled by injury. His only test appearance came off the bench against Australia in 2020, but he was unable to remain near the front of a logjam of contenders after that. Umaga-Jensen, 27, finished the current season on a high, scoring two tries in a final-round hammering of Moana Pasifika, including a brilliant 50m solo score. "I started here as a young fella chasing a dream and it's been an incredible ride ever since," he said. "I've made memories that will stay with me forever and built lifelong friendships that I'll always treasure. "One day, I hope I'll be sitting down with all the boys, sharing a beer and a laugh, as we look back on everything we experienced together." Umaga-Jensen has not disclosed which Japanese club he will join nor the length of his contract. Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
RNZ News
4 hours ago
- RNZ News
Earl Bamber to start from two on 24 Hours of Le Mans grid
The Cadillac Hertz of Earl Bamber, Sebastien Bourdais and Jenson Button, in action during qualifying for the 24 Hours of Le Mans in France. June 11, 2025. Photo: AFP New Zealander Earl Bamber will start from two on the grid for the 24 Hours of Le Mans race, with Cadillac locking out the front row in qualifying. Britain's Alex Lynn secured pole position, setting a best time of three minutes 23.166 seconds in the number 12 Team Jota Cadillac at the Sarthe circuit Bamber putting the sister 38 car alongside and 0.167 slower. Bamber has won the race twice, in 2015 and 2017 with Porsche. Fellow Kiwi Brendon Hartley, who has won the event three times, will start from 10 on the grid after team-mate Sebastien Buemi locked up the Toyota Gazoo car and drove into the gravel and was not able to finish the qualifier Lynn shares his car with compatriot Will Stevens and Frenchman Norman Nato while Bamber's teammates are 2009 Formula One world champion Jenson Button and French four-times Champ Car champion Sebastien Bourdais. "I can't tell you how much I wanted this," said Lynn, who missed out on pole last year by a mere 0.138, over the team radio. "One tenth last year hurt a lot. "I'm truly honoured to be able to put in a performance like that in front of everyone and deliver for Cadillac in the way they deserve," he added after getting out of the car. "This is a magical circuit and this is a special feeling. I can't describe it. We will enjoy this tonight, have a good sleep and re-set." GM-owned Cadillac are the first American marque to take outright pole at Le Mans since Ford in 1967. The number five Porsche Penske was third fastest, after threatening to take pole, with France's Julien Andlauer, Denmark's Michael Christensen and France's Mathieu Jaminet. The number 15 BMW qualified in fourth place with Belgian Dries Vanthoor, Swiss-Italian Raffaele Marciello and Danish former F1 driver Kevin Magnussen. Defending champions Ferrari, outright winners for the past two years, had Italian Antonio Fuoco, Denmark's Nicklas Nielsen and Spaniard Miguel Molina in seventh place in last year's winning car number 50. The 93rd edition of the race starts on Sunday at 2am NZT. - Reuters/RNZ Sport
RNZ News
4 hours ago
- RNZ News
Boxing: Sonny Bill Williams, Paul Gallen eye fitting end to decade-long war of words
Sonny Bill Williams and Joseph Parker promote Williams' fight against Paul Gallen. Photo: RNZ/Marika Khabazi In a war of words that has lasted nearly a decade, former All Black Sonny Bill Williams wants to put a fullstop on exchanges with Australian rugby league legend Paul Gallen. Williams is clear about the finale he plans for the long-awaited boxing bout between the two that will take place on 16 July at Sydney's Qudos Bank Arena. "God willing, give him a good hiding and walk off into the sunset. "It's not a Rugby World Cup or NRL title or Super Rugby title, but I don't want to lose him. He can say this, I can say that, but it just comes down to who's worked hard, who's taking shortcuts and who lands the better punches on the night." Williams is not a fan of trash-talk, but he said keeping quiet had not always served him well. Both boxers have won world cups and premierships on the footy field, and they have knocked opponents out in the ring. They are two "proper household names" who do not have much left to prove, but this bout of eight two-minute rounds is personal for Williams. "I think, for myself to get back in the ring after three years to actually do something of this magnitude, there needed to be that animosity just to light that fire up. Otherwise, what's the point of doing it?" "The way that he conducts himself and he carries himself, and how he speaks about me, Williams said. "I look at it like, for me, I'm representing my Polynesian brothers. For example, calling me a dummy... I see it playing alongside these type of individuals and being in the sheds with these type of individuals, where they suck up all the oxygen. "As Polynesians, we're taught to be quiet and be respectful, and don't speak unless you're spoken to, and because we don't say anything, all of a sudden, it means that we're dumb. "Doesn't mean that we don't have opinions, it doesn't mean that we don't have brains, but we just let them speak. I think him looking at that, speaking like that, really observing the way that he's conducted himself, I really think that he thinks he's better than us." Williams has that motivation against a man four years his senior and someone he sees as a polar opposite, when it comes to the publicly promoting a fight. Sonny Bill Williams: "When it comes to trash-talking, that's not my go." Photo: RNZ/Marika Khabazi The former NZ heavyweight boxing champion, with a nine-win, one-loss career record, has been left to promote this bout by himself. Gallen has not fronted alongside Williams on either side of the Tasman. "When it comes to trash-talking, that's not my go. I don't get involved in that kind of game, I never have in any of my fights. "With Paul, it's second-hand nature - this flows off the tongue. "All I did was speak the truth, speak facts and, all of a sudden, I've hurt him," Williams said of the first time he spoke, when Gallen was a no show. "I've upset him with one low blow of attack on this and that, you know - it's just facts." Williams has been training on the Gold Coast with Australian professional boxer Jai Opetaia for four weeks, away from his wife and five children. "I'm a real visual learner," he said. "Although I've had 10 fights, it's been over the space of 15 years, so every time I get back in the ring, it's like doing it again, starting all over again. "This camp, I wanted to be around world class fighters, so I could learn the skillset needed, but also the mental side of things. "You don't have to be a rocket scientist to understand that he wants to fight in close and I want to fight at distance, but at the same time, we'll train accordingly. He won't have to go looking for me in the ring. "I'm prepping to stop him, but I'm prepping for eight rounds as well." Like Williams, Gallen retired from the ring in 2022, after a lucrative second sporting career for the man who played 348 NRL games and won the 2013 Rugby League World Cup with the Kangaroos . Gallen had 18 fights - most against former footy players - but he also stopped a former heavyweight champion and knocked out New Zealand's Junior Fa. Former world heavyweight champion Joseph Parker believed Williams was doing the right things to prepare for a fight billed as the biggest trans-Tasman grudge match of all time. "[Gallen's] a brawler," Parker said. "He throws big shots, but Sonny can learn from the best. "He's training with Jai and his team, learning from the best and picking up what he needs to pick up on, so he can come out there and dominate." Parker's advice for Williams: "Just stay calm. "Start calm and composed, because if you switch on the Samoan side, which we both have, then that's brawling back. "In moments like that, you just have to remain calm, remember what you've been learning, remember what you've been working on and and put it all on display, because this is his time to put it all on display." Williams and Gallen are big personalities that are still drawcards, despite their sporting peaks being in the rearview mirror. Their fight is a boxing promoter's dream and Duco Events' David Higgins said "there's a few magic ingredients at play" for this bout. Gallen v SBW - a boxing promoter's dream. Photo: PHOTOSPORT "First of all, you've got two proper household names, legends... people who've been at the very top of the highest level of sport, and incredibly competitive athletes that almost everyone in New Zealand and Australia knows who these guys are. "Second magic ingredient is you've got history. This fight has been brewing, probably for 10 years, with callouts and negotiations that fall apart, and on again, off again, on again... it just makes things bigger, when it brews so long. "Third, it's a proper 50/50 fight. Most pundits can't pick who they think will win. "There's a really good argument why Sonny Bill will win this fight - he's got height, his reach, he's a good boxer. In another life, he could have been a top boxer with that skillset. "Then you've got Paul Gallen, who never quits rough and tumble, so flip a coin and I think that gets people intrigued as well. "Then there's parochialism - you've got a New Zealand v Australia ingredient, you've got rugby union v rugby league. "There's quite a lot going on with this promotion and, as it reaches its crescendo, I think everyone's going to be talking about it and is going to tune in." For Williams, getting back in the ring has not been an easy road, but one he believes needed to happen. "The one thing I've missed since retiring is just that nervous energy, that nervous buzz, when you go out, and it's either sink or swim. It'll be a nice way to finish off, to close the chapter." Two other Kiwis will face off on the undercard, with David Nyika taking on Nik Charalampous . Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
