'Flawed' Test Championship reveals world cricket's underlying problems
Reigning champions Australia face South Africa in the World Test Championship final at Lord's starting on Wednesday amid a chorus of criticism over the competition's format.
Wisden, cricket's 'bible', was scathing in its assessment, with editor Lawrence Booth writing in this year's edition that the WTC is a "shambles masquerading as a showpiece".
Meanwhile, former England captain Michael Atherton said "everyone knows the WTC in its present guise is flawed".
One fundamental problem is that political tensions mean India and Pakistan, two of cricket's leading nations, have not played a Test against each other since 2007.
The nine-nation WTC is further skewed because the teams are not being required to face each other or to play the same number of matches, unlike most sports leagues.
Countries are free to decide how many Tests they would like to play in the two-year qualifying cycle -- something Booth wants doubled to four years, with the top nine in the rankings all playing each other, home and away, over series that last at least three Tests.
Positions are calculated on the percentage of available points won by teams.
South Africa have played just 12 Tests in the current cycle -- all of them two-match series -- compared to England's 22 -- and have not played either England or Australia.
South Africa also sent a third-string side to New Zealand in early 2024, and lost. They kept their best players at home to appear in a domestic T20 competition. That was a financial sign of the times, as is Cricket South Africa not scheduling any home Tests for 2025/26.
South Africa reeled off six straight wins to book their place in this year's final, only for former England captain Michael Vaughan to say they had got there "on the back of beating pretty much nobody".
But Proteas coach Shukri Conrad objected that South Africa had beaten teams who had beaten the 'Big Three' of India, Australia and England.
"One of the nobodies we beat won a Test match in Australia -- West Indies beat Australia in a Test match. They are not nobody," insisted Conrad.
"New Zealand beat India: three-zip in India. New Zealand is not a nobody.
"Sri Lanka won Test matches (against England and New Zealand).I don't buy this thing about us beating nobody."
Victory in the final would be a boost to South Africa following years of hurt in ICC white-ball tournaments, with Conrad saying after qualification was secured. "I'm never going to apologise for getting into the final.
"It's the biggest thing in this team's existence. It's the biggest thing for South African cricket at the moment."
One of those involved in devising the points system, speaking on condition of anonymity, told AFP: "It's difficult to come up with a solution where everyone is happy given the barriers to an 'orthodox' table that exist, such as the India-Pakistan situation.
"Commercial considerations will also mean the 'Big Three' will want to play each other in five-Test series."
He added this was just as much a choice as England incurring the over-rate penalties that hampered their chances -- they've yet to reach a WTC final despite the first three editions all taking place on home soil -- with skipper Ben Stokes almost disdainful in his assessment of an "utterly confusing" format.
Yet, New Zealand's win in the inaugural 2021 World Test Championship final was welcomed as a long overdue global triumph for a popular side. Australia's failure to qualify for that match was labelled a "big missed opportunity" by skipper Pat Cummins, who made amends with victory at in an Oval final two years ago.
That India were beaten finalists in both the 2021 and 2023 WTC finals indicated there was still a place for the five-day game in world cricket's economic powerhouse, for all T20 events such as the Indian Premier League are the financial driving force.
Indeed former India captain and batting star Virat Kohli, speaking after securing his long-awaited first IPL title following Royal Challengers Bengaluru's triumph in last Tuesday's final, said: "If you want to earn respect in world cricket all over, take up Test cricket and give your heart and soul to it."
But the awkward question for cricket chiefs is whether the WTC is helping or hindering that aim.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Int'l Cricket Council
2 hours ago
- Int'l Cricket Council
WTC25 Final: Both XIs named as Australia and South Africa finalise preparation
Selection conjecture surrounding both Australia and South Africa's Playing XIs have been put to rest. As the World Test Championship finalists finish off their preparation, the two competing teams have named their XIs. The nations will face off for the coveted mace in what stands to be one of the most important Test matches these players will ever be a part of. Just ask some of the South Africans. It ends what was a gripping World Test Championship cycle, where the Proteas won seven straight Test matches to seal their spot in the decider, while Australia will look to become the first team to claim back-to-back championships, with the concept commencing in 2019. South Africa and Australia prepare for the WTC25 Final The finalists are prepping up for the Ultimate Test as the countdown for June 11 begins. South Africa XI: 1. Aiden Markram, 2. Ryan Rickelton, 3. Wiaan Mulder, 4. Temba Bavuma (c), 5. Tristan Stubbs, 6. David Bedingham, 7. Kyle Verreynne (wk), 8. Marco Jansen, 9. Keshav Maharaj, 10. Kagiso Rabada, 11. Lungi Ngidi Ryan Rickelton headlines a batting order full of fire power. He'll open alongside Aiden Markram, with Wiaan Mulder getting the nod at three. In the bowling department, experience worked in the favour of Lungi Ngidi, who will join spearhead Kagiso Rabada, Marco Jansen and spinner Keshav Maharaj. Ngidi beat out Dane Paterson, who played five Tests in this current World Test Championship cycle. Lungi Ngidi on playing in the Ultimate Test | WTC25 Final South Africa speedster Lungi Ngidi describes what a shot at glory in the ICC World Test Championship 2025 Final means for his country. Australia XI: 1. Usman Khawaja, 2. Marnus Labuschagne, 3. Cameron Green, 4. Steve Smith, 5. Travis Head, 6. Beau Webster, 7. Alex Carey (wk), 8. Pat Cummins (c), 9. Mitchell Starc, 10. Nathan Lyon, 11. Josh Hazlewood. The defending champions have named a familiar lineup, with Josh Hazlewood propelled back into the bowling attack after niggling injuries interrupted his participation in the Border-Gavaskar Series over the summer down under. Scott Boland filled in admirably, earning Player of the Match honours in the fifth and final Test against India in Sydney, taking 10 total wickets. Travis Head the hero with critical century - POTM Highlights | WTC23 Final Player of the Match: Australia batter Travis Head earned the POTM award following his decisive 163 runs in the first innings of the ICC World Test Championship Final 2023 against India Hazlewood joins captain Pat Cummins, Mitchell Starc and spinner Nathan Lyon as the recognised bowlers. They will also be supported by Beau Webster, who earned all-rounder duties after his impressive display in Sydney and then in the two-Test series in Sri Lanka. Marnus Labuschagne has moved up the order to open alongside Usman Khawaja, while Cameron Green will return to the mix at first-drop after his extensive layoff following a stress fracture in his lower back which required surgery. The West Australian has been picked as a designated batter. Temba Bavuma and Pat Cummins photoshoot chat before the Lord's clash | WTC Final 2025 BTS from the captains' photoshoot ahead of the WTC25 Final. Several international broadcast partners have come on board to bring live and highlights coverage of the ICC World Test Championship Final to a global TV audience. India: Star Sports & Jiostar Australia: Amazon Prime Video South Africa: SuperSport TV UK: Sky Sports Cricket USA & Canada: Willow TV and Willow TV app Caribbean & South America: ESPN Caribbean and ESPN Play Caribbean New Zealand: Sky Sport Network Middle East & North Africa: TSM via Nagorik TV, e& Pakistan: PTV and Ten Sports Afghanistan: Ariana Television Sri Lanka: Maharaja TV Singapore: StarHub Malaysia: Astro Hong Kong: PCCW Pacific Islands: PNG Digicel Rest of the World: Keshav Maharaj and Nathan Lyon's mutual admiration | WTC25 Final Mutual Admiration Society ft. Nathan Lyon and Keshav Maharaj
Khaleej Times
12 hours ago
- Khaleej Times
From containers to learning hubs: How DP World turns shipping steel into golf dreams
What do redundant shipping containers and young golfers have in common? Thanks to a bold new initiative from DP World, the answer might just be: a future full of possibilities. Known for moving thousands of containers across the globe every day, Dubai-based DP World has found a creative way to give some of those steel boxes a second life. Instead of retiring them, the company is transforming them into mobile 'Clubhouses' for aspiring young golfers. These custom-built hubs offer equipment, training tools, and safe spaces to play and grow your game. It's more than a nod to recycling. It's about opportunity. The first Clubhouse landed this week in Cape Town, South Africa, delivered in partnership with the Sally Little Golf Trust, an organisation that empowers young women through golf. The Trust teaches values like honesty, respect, perseverance, and self-motivation alongside swing mechanics. Each Clubhouse is tailored to the needs of its community. Some will house gear and training aids, and others will serve as gathering spaces or mini-learning centres. All will help bring golf to places where access to the sport is limited. "At DP World, we believe in creating opportunities to empower young people, as they are our future,' said Daniel van Otterdijk, the company's Chief Communications Officer. 'The Clubhouse initiative is a brilliant example of how we can use our resources and global sports partnerships to open doors for the next generation—bringing golf, and the life skills it teaches, to communities that might not otherwise have access. 'We're especially proud to have launched this programme in partnership with the Sally Little Golf Trust, whose incredible work empowering young women through golf aligns perfectly with our values,' he added. The Clubhouse programme builds on DP World's earlier success with the Second Life Container Initiative, which has already redistributed some 350,000 golf balls worldwide. Now, the goal is to scale even further. Future Clubhouses will roll out alongside major moments in the golf calendar, including the prestigious DP World Tour and the Ryder Cup at Bethpage Black in New York this September. It's all part of a broader effort to make golf more inclusive, accessible, and inspiring for the next generation of players.
Khaleej Times
13 hours ago
- Khaleej Times
WTC final: Australia's Hazlewood returns for big game against South Africa
Marnus Labuschagne will open the batting for Australia and Josh Hazlewood has been selected in the bowling line-up for the World Test Championship final against South Africa at Lord's, captain Pat Cummins said on the eve of the game on Tuesday. Labuschagne has been moved up the order to accommodate the return of Cameron Green, who underwent back surgery in October and was ruled out of the home season, while Hazlewood is fit again after a calf injury to replace of Scott Boland. "Cam Green has been coming back in great form in the last few weeks and we thought he deserved a spot in the batting lineup. We thought three probably suits him best," Cummins told a press conference. "For Marnus moving one spot up, it's not too different to batting at three. He's done well here in England in the past." Leaving out Boland, who had been one of the heroes of Australia's 3-1 Test series win over India this year, had been a difficult decision. "There are some guys where you genuinely say, you've done nothing wrong, don't change a thing and that's Scotty. He is just really unfortunate to miss out. "The message to Scotty is there's a lot of Test cricket coming up in the next couple of years and just because your mid-30s doesn't mean that's the end of your career. "By having a squad of fast bowlers, hopefully we can extend all our care for an extra couple of years." An element of selection criteria was to reward those who had contributed to defending champions Australia winning 13 of 19 Tests in the two-year WTC cycle and reaching yet another final. "I think our selectors have probably shown you that they're happy and they'd rather give someone an extra little run than pull the pin too early. I think it's partly rewarding those guys that got us here.' Cummings said defending the title was high on the Australian priority list, even after all their success in the limited-overs formats. "It's a trophy we've spoken a lot about over the last couple of years. "Test cricket is my favourite format. You've got to basically win in all different conditions to make it into this final. If we can retain that mace, that's a pretty awesome thing for this team." Australia team: Usman Khawaja, Marnus Labuschagne, Cameron Green, Steve Smith, Travis Head, Beau Webster, Alex Carey (wicketkeeper), Pat Cummins (captain), Mitchell Starc, Nathan Lyon, Josh Hazlewood.
