'No Other Land': Palestinian-Israeli film's Oscar win sparks outrage in Israel
Israeli government officials, actors and the media industry have lashed out at Hollywood and the directors of the Israeli-Palestinian film No Other Land after it won the best documentary film award at the 97th Academy Awards in Los Angeles on Sunday.
The film, co-directed by Palestinian journalist Basel Adra and Israeli journalist Yuval Abraham, chronicles the Israeli army's attempts to expel the residents of the occupied West Bank area of Masafer Yatta - Adra's hometown - from their land.
The film has received international critical acclaim for its documentation of Palestinian life under occupation and resistance to Israeli violence and attempts at displacement.
Various Israeli figures have accused the film and its creators of spreading false narratives, antisemitism and harming Israel's interests in the world.
Culture and Sports Minister Miki Zohar of the Likud Party said on Monday that the film's win was 'a sad moment for the world of cinema', adding that the film 'distorted' Israel's image on the international stage.
New MEE newsletter: Jerusalem Dispatch
Sign up to get the latest insights and analysis on Israel-Palestine, alongside Turkey Unpacked and other MEE newsletters
"Freedom of expression is an important value, but turning the defamation of Israel into a tool for international promotion is not art - it is sabotage against the State of Israel,' he continued on X, formerly Twitter.
Israel Bachar, Israel's consul general in Los Angeles, posted: "Israeli Jews have No Other Land", adding that Hollywood figures should watch "the real documentary" of footage from Hamas' 7 October attack on Israel.
Yoseph Haddad, a self-described Arab-Israeli activist, said that the winning speeches in Los Angeles were biased in favour of Palestinians.
"He [Abraham] deserves an Oscar for hypocrisy," he added.
"We live in a regime where I am free under civilian law, and Bassel is under military laws that destroy his life."
The powerful Palestinian-Israeli documentary 'No Other Land' has won the Academy Award for Best Documentary Feature.
On stage, Palestinian journalist and director… pic.twitter.com/CfEZWqthkP — Middle East Eye (@MiddleEastEye) March 3, 2025
Others urged the Israeli government to take action by investing more in hasbara (propaganda).
Journalist Shai Golden said that the film's Oscar win was a "warning sign" for Israel about its "failure" to "present... the Israeli story in a convincing" manner.
"Part of the Israeli hasbara should be the use of the example of 'No Other Land,' that Israel, unlike its neighbours – led by the Palestinians – knows how to give expression to voices like Abraham's among us," he said in his column for right-wing newspaper Israel Hayom.
'Brainwashed by hatred'
Yedioth Ahronoth journalist Yuval Karni stated that he would not watch the documentary, and said its win stemmed from hatred of Israel.
"The two filmmakers – like large parts of the Hollywood kingdom and the American Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences – are not really interested in the facts or the real story. Hatred of Israel is brainwashing them," he wrote.
A car crash Berlinale concludes with a German witch hunt against pro-Palestine filmmakers Read More »
This is only the third time in the history of the Academy Awards that Israeli filmmakers have been awarded a prize, but the film is not expected to be screened in Israeli cinemas.
As of now, it is only available to Israeli public through the left-wing news website Local Call.
Despite this rare achievement for Israeli cinema, the film and its creators received angry reactions from within the Israeli cinema industry.
Actor Aki Avni, who has appeared in a number of Hollywood films in the past, wrote: "You hear and understand how the Holocaust began in 1933, how in the 'enlightened and aware' world, the picture is still reversed in the most distorted way."
Another Israeli actor, Yadin Gellman, accused Abraham of 'selling out his people' for attention and priase.
This is not the first time that No Other Land has received angry reactions in Israel.
The film, which was shot over several years from 2019-2023, premiered at the Berlin Film Festival last year, where it won the Berlinale documentary award.
After winning the award in Berlin, the Israeli public broadcaster Kan defined Abraham's speech as "the antisemitic speech of the Israeli filmmaker". Afterwards, it was forced to apologise.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Gulf Today
5 hours ago
- Gulf Today
12 more Palestinians killed in Israeli attack on school in Gaza
An Israeli airstrike on a school housing displaced Palestinian families killed at least 12 people, including children, on Wednesday, local health authorities said. Residents said Israeli military escalated airstrikes and tank shelling on parts of Khan Younis, a day after it dropped leaflets warning residents to leave their homes and head west, saying forces would fight Hamas and other fighters in those areas. Reuters
Gulf Today
5 hours ago
- Gulf Today
Irish university to cut links with Israel over Gaza war
Ireland's prestigious Trinity College Dublin said on Wednesday that it would cut all links with Israel in protest at "ongoing violations of international and humanitarian law." The university's board informed students by email on Wednesday that it had accepted the recommendations of a taskforce to sever "institutional links with the State of Israel, Israeli universities and companies headquartered in Israel." The recommendations would be "enacted for the duration of the ongoing violations of international and humanitarian law", said the email sent by the board's chairman Paul Farrell, and seen by AFP. The taskforce was set up after part of the university's campus in central Dublin was blockaded by students for five days last year in protest at Israel's actions in Gaza. Among the taskforce's recommendations approved by the board were pledges to divest "from all companies headquartered in Israel" and to "enter into no future supply contracts with Israeli firms" and "no new commercial relationships with Israeli entities." The university also said that it would "enter into no further mobility agreements with Israeli universities." Trinity has two current Erasmus+ exchange agreements with Israeli universities: Bar Ilan University, an agreement that ends in July 2026, and the Hebrew University of Jerusalem, which ends in July 2025, the university told AFP in an email. The board also said that the university "should not submit for approval or agree to participate in any new institutional research agreements involving Israeli participation." It "should seek to align itself with like-minded universities and bodies in an effort to influence EU policy concerning Israel's participation in such collaborations," it added. Ireland has been among the most outspoken critics of Israel's response to the October 7, 2023 attacks on southern Israel by Hamas militants that sparked the war in Gaza. Polls since the start of the war have shown overwhelming pro-Palestinian sympathy in Ireland. In May 2024, Dublin joined several other European countries in recognising Palestine as a "sovereign and independent state." It then joined South Africa in bringing a case before the International Court of Justice in the Hague accusing Israel of committing genocide in Gaza -- charges angrily denied by Israeli leaders. In December, Israel's Foreign Minister Gideon Saar ordered the closure of the country's embassy in Dublin, blaming Ireland's "extreme anti-Israel policies". Agence France-Presse
Middle East Eye
6 hours ago
- Middle East Eye
Handful of US lawmakers demand Trump ban the Muslim Brotherhood
Calls on Capitol Hill are mounting to designate the Muslim Brotherhood a terrorist organisation after a suspect accused of attacking a pro-Israel rally in Colorado is alleged to have expressed support for a former Egyptian president who was a member of the group. Republican Senator Ted Cruz on Tuesday said he planned to re-introduce 'a modernized version of the Muslim Brotherhood Terrorist Designation Act, which I have been pushing for my entire Senate career', in a post on X on Tuesday. Cruz accused the Muslim Brotherhood movement of using the Biden administration 'to consolidate and deepen their influence. But the Trump administration and Republican Congress can no longer afford to avoid the threat they pose to Americans and American national security'. Meanwhile, US Congressman Jared Moskowitz wrote a letter to President Donald Trump asking him to carry out an 'investigation to designate the Muslim Brotherhood a Foreign Terrorist Organization.' He accused the organisation of having a 'documented history of promoting extremist ideologies and supporting terrorist activities through various affiliates'. New MEE newsletter: Jerusalem Dispatch Sign up to get the latest insights and analysis on Israel-Palestine, alongside Turkey Unpacked and other MEE newsletters He accused Hamas of being one such affiliate. Other politicians, such as self-proclaimed Zionist Congressman Randy Fine, took the opportunity to take a swipe at US organisations such as Muslim civil rights and advocacy group Council on American–Islamic Relations (Cair) and Students for Justice in Palestine (SJP), who he accused of being funded by the Muslim Brotherhood. Jewish Insider published an article on Wednesday saying that Fine accused the Muslim Brotherhood of funding Cair, SJP and other pro-Palestine groups. He also described Cair as the US 'mouthpiece' of the Muslim Brotherhood. Jewish Insider also reported that Fine had reached out to Cruz 'to offer to lead the Muslim Brotherhood legislation in the House'. Cair had not responded to a request for comment by the time of publication. Colorado attack The calls coincide with an incident on 1 June, where an Egyptian national, Mohamed Sabry Soliman, was accused of attacking protesters rallying in support of Israeli captives in Gaza. Eight people were injured during the attack. A profile by CNN said that Soliman had posted pictures on Facebook of Muslim Brotherhood leader Mohamed Morsi, who served as the democratically elected leader of Egypt from 2012 to 2013 before he was ousted in a military coup that the US is said to have tacitly supported. Morsi died in 2019 after collapsing during a court hearing on espionage charges. Egyptian state TV reported he died from a heart attack. The Muslim Brotherhood called the death a "murder". CNN said Soliman's Facebook was last updated 10 years ago. The attack has fuelled calls for mass deportations of Muslims and another Muslim travel ban by leading MAGA figures such as Laura Loomer. Loomer, who has been calling Soliman a 'Muslim Brotherhood terrorist' for days, has also been calling for Muslim immigrants to be deported. In a post on X, she said, 'We are being killed and maimed by Muslim immigrants because Republicans were too afraid of being called 'Islamophobes'. She added that elderly Jews and young Christian Zionists were being 'murdered by these Muslim imports who hate our country and who hate everything non Islamic. They need to be removed from our country if they hate us.' In another post, she wrote, 'We need mass deportations and an Islamic travel ban ASAP!' Loomer has spent days calling for Soliman and his family to be deported. The Trump administration has been swift in its response. The White House announced on X on Tuesday that the wife and five children of Soliman had been 'captured' and were in Immigration and Customs Enforcement custody and 'COULD BE DEPORTED AS EARLY AS TONIGHT'. Department of Homeland Security Kristi Noem called Soliman a 'terrorist' and 'illegal alien' in a video on Tuesday and said that they were 'investigating to what extent his family knew about this heinous attack, if they had knowledge of it, or if they provided support to it'. Muslim Brotherhood The Muslim Brotherhood was founded in 1928 in Egypt, and in the 1940s formed a secret, armed wing to fight against British colonial rule. It renounced violence in the 1960s and later embraced electoral democracy instead. It is one of the largest and most well-known Islamic movements. It has long maintained that it is a peaceful organisation that wishes to participate in politics democratically, but many autocratic governments in the Middle East and North Africa consider it a major threat. Saudi Arabia, the United Arab Emirates and Bahrain have all banned the Muslim Brotherhood. Jordan banned the organisation in April, allegedly after pressure from Saudi Arabia, the UAE and Israel. Jordan said they had arrested 16 members of the Muslim Brotherhood who had purportedly plotted attacks on targets inside the kingdom involving rockets and drones in April. In his first term, Trump toyed with the idea of banning the Brotherhood in the US, and could come under pressure to do so during his second term. The Trump administration considered designating the Muslim Brotherhood a terrorist organisation following Egyptian President Abdel Fattah el-Sisi's visit to the White House in 2019. The Muslim Brotherhood remains Sisi's main source of opposition in Egypt, and the Egyptian president reportedly asked Washington to crack down on the group. However, the Defence Department, career national security staff, government lawyers, and diplomatic officials raised legal and policy objections. Sisi led the Egyptian army's overthrow of Morsi in 2013. Egypt has jailed thousands of Muslim Brotherhood members, sentencing many to death. International rights groups have estimated that tens of thousands of political prisoners have been detained in Egyptian jails since 2014. Earlier this year, Jordan told Trump they would ban the Muslim Brotherhood. King Abdullah's move firmly places Jordan in the western camp's push against political Islam. The US is not the only western power looking to ban the Muslim Brotherhood. A new report by France's interior minister, Bruno Retailleau, revives the spectre of the Muslim Brotherhood as an underground Islamist threat poised to capture local and national institutions.
