
Man feels 'let down' after refused son's army allowance
A man whose son was killed while serving with the Irish Defence Forces has found that he is not entitled to keep an allowance which was granted to his wife.
John McNeela's son Private Michael McNeela was killed in Lebanon in 1989 by an by an Israeli-backed militia while on peacekeeping duties.
His mother Kathleen was given a dependents allowance following his death.
She died last year and Mr McNeela asked the State to transfer that allowance to him, but his request was refused.
Speaking on RTÉ's This Week, Mr McNeela called for the Army Pensions Act to be amended.
He said the monthly allowance of €340 "would make a difference to him".
Mr McNeela said that the Defence Forces "couldn't have done enough" for his family after his son's death, but that at the moment he feels "let down and disappointed" and called on Tánaiste and Minister for Defence Simon Harris to act.
"Not many cases like this comes up. I think there is more the Tánaiste could do," he said.
He added that the military pension system is "not right and is obsolete".
"I would ask the minister to do all he can as he's the only man that can change it," Mr McNeela said.
Sinn Féin TD Ruairí Ó Murchú described the situation as "unfair and mean".
"We require the Government to step up to the mark," he said, as the State should be looking after the families of soldiers who made the ultimate sacrifice
"I would much prefer that this was dealt with quietly, that there wasn't a need to do it in the public domain. But unfortunately, that is not the case.
"We've all seen pension anomalies before. We're all open to some sort of interim solution, and there is a requirement to change the legislation".
In a statement, the Department of Defence said it "treats any case involving a deceased soldier with the utmost of sensitivity".
"In this specific case, under the current law, the Army Pensions Act, there is no provision to transfer a Dependants Allowance to another person, at any stage.
"The Secretary General of the Department of Defence will this week raise this case with her colleagues in the Department of Social Protection to see what other supports may be available to Mr McNeela.
"Like all families of deceased soldiers, we will do all we can to support them," it said.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Irish Examiner
3 hours ago
- Irish Examiner
Aid is being utterly weaponised, and the result is chaos
It's difficult to imagine things getting worse, but at every turn they do. Israel has inflicted a brutal and inhuman campaign against the people of Gaza, the charge of genocide laid bare. A population deliberately and cruelly starved by an occupying power hell bent on death and destruction. Since March 2, Israel enforced a near-total siege on the Gaza Strip, cutting off food, water, electricity, fuel, and medicine. The resulting humanitarian catastrophe shocked the world with the inevitability of famine becoming reality. The Integrated Food Security Phase Classification (IPC) warned that 1.1 million people, around half of Gaza's population, are experiencing catastrophic hunger. 930,000 children - 93% of the children in Gaza - are at risk of famine. An estimated 95% of Gaza's water is unfit for human consumption, with people forced to drink polluted water, leading to soaring rates of disease and child mortality. And at least 60 children have died of starvation and dehydration in recent weeks. Although aid agencies believe the real number is far higher and growing. Generations of children, their lives destroyed beyond repair. But instead of scaling up humanitarian access in response, Israel has doubled down on control. It has repeated its attacks on the UN and sidelined aid mechanisms that are established, effective and desperately waiting to get in. Just kilometres away from the suffering, over 9,000 trucks are desperate to get in across the border. The only legal and humane solution to alleviate the suffering is total and unfettered aid access, north and south, a flooding of the Gaza strip with food, shelter, medicines and clean water. Rather than really address the issue of starvation, Israel, through the US-backed Gaza Humanitarian Fund, will now control all aid distribution. Rather than focusing on what the starving population needs, it will decide where, when and to who aid is distributed to. They are using aid - one of the world's means of expressing care and humanity in crisis - to displace and control. Israel has made clear its intention to clear the north of Gaza. Already controlling almost 80% of the Gaza Strip, this aid distribution is another means to forcibly transfer the population illegally to certain areas and make humanitarian access conditional on screening or political and military criteria. In the last 10 days, 180,000 were displaced. Palestinians gather to receive a hot meal at a food distribution point in the Nuseirat camp for refugees in the central Gaza Strip on May 21. Up to 1.1 million people, around half of Gaza's population, are experiencing catastrophic hunger. Photo: Eyad Baba / AFP via Getty Images Deliberately designed to facilitate forced displacement from the north of Gaza, the Gaza Humanitarian Fund will have distribution hubs in central and southern Gaza, forcing starving families - many of them desperately injured, elderly and too ill to undertake long, dangerous journeys through militarized zones - to collect aid for their families. The UN described this as 'engineered scarcity', secured by private US security contractors, where those Palestinians who can reach them will receive rations. Since last week, about 900 truckloads were submitted for Israeli approval, and 800 were approved. But just over 500 could be offloaded on the Israeli side of Kerem Shalom, and even fewer made it to the Palestinian side, where the UN and others could collect just over 200 of them, limited by insecurity and restricted access. This is organised chaos inflicted upon a starving people. The core principle that aid must reach people where they are is ignored, with deadly results. It compounds the despair, desperation and trauma for people who have already borne too much to imagine. In the clamber to rush and get food, Al Jazeera reported that Israeli forces killed seven people and wounded 47, using gunfire to shoot at a group of starving and desperate families. There are huge concerns about Israel using biometric screening as part of their aid distribution. This is surveillance masquerading as humanitarian assistance. It's a calculated attempt to weaponise hunger and to reduce relief to a tool of control. Palestinians carry boxes containing food and humanitarian aid packages delivered by the Gaza Humanitarian Foundation on May 27. Photo: AP/Abdel Kareem Hana This blurring of military and humanitarian roles endangers aid workers and civilians alike. We've already seen the cost. The humanitarian principles of impartiality, neutrality, and independence are not optional, but are binding under international law. Yet Israel is systematically eroding them. And while hunger and chaos grow, every day brings new atrocities. Just last week, Israeli forces killed nine of paediatrician Dr Alaa al-Najjar's 10 children in shelters designated as safe. Israel's war in Gaza has killed at least 54,000 people to date - mostly women and children - and displaced almost the entire population. What is happening is not just a war. It is the slow obliteration of an entire people. Ireland has a role to play and must act. Our long-standing tradition of supporting human rights and international law compels us to do more than offer words of concern. We must finally pass the Occupied Territories Bill, first proposed by Senator Frances Black in 2018. The decision by the Government this week to draft the heads of the Bill is welcome, but long overdue. An Israeli strike in Gaza City on Sunday. Israel has inflicted a brutal and inhuman campaign against the people of Gaza, the charge of genocide laid bare. Photo: AP/Jehad Alshrafi The outrageous atrocities we see over the last 20 months are the worst expression of a 70-year occupation of Palestinian territory. The level of violence is shocking, but it comes with this context of apartheid and occupation. This makes the exclusion of a ban on services from the Bill unacceptable. This is a vital and substantial element which would cover online platforms such as Airbnb which have a significant presence in some of the territories, offering tourist accommodation. Legal experts have verified this can be done. Meanwhile, many powerful countries, including the United States and EU members, continue to fund, arm, and diplomatically shield the Israeli government from accountability. At the same time, they issue platitudes about humanitarian concern. Karole Balfe: '[Israel is] using aid - one of the world's means of expressing care and humanity in crisis - to displace and control.' As well as passing the Occupied Territories Bill the Irish government must lead calls for sanctions, suspension of the EU-Trade Agreement and push for an EU arms embargo. If the Bill is passed at least Ireland can say it took action and gave example to the world at a crucial time when powerful nations were turning a blind eye. We can stand as a beacon of principled action, reminding the world that small nations can lead boldly when justice is on the line. Karol Balfe is CEO of ActionAid Ireland which supports humanitarian response in Gaza Read More Ireland lodges formal protest after Israeli gunfire near peacekeepers in Lebanon


Irish Examiner
3 hours ago
- Irish Examiner
Irish Examiner view: Right's win in Poland will impact EU
The tiny margin of the victory for the hard right in Poland's presidential election is going to place a heavy strain on the government of Donald Tusk, but for the media to describe Karol Nawrocki as 'pro-Trump' is to miss the point. In all right versus left political battles these days, every single one is judged on the similarity to, or popularity with, the current American president, irrespective of their actual policies. So it has been with Nawrocki, who did actually receive an endorsement from the White House, but whether or not that helped convince the notoriously fractious Polish electorate — he won by 50.89% to centrist candidate Rafal Trazskowski's 49.11% — is doubtful. Rather, it was the former's boxer and revisionist historian's position on issues such as abortion, the restoration of the independence of the Polish judiciary, migration, climate issues, and Ukraine's accession to the EU that saw him home. For the 42-year-old, who has never before held public office, his ascension to the presidency marks a huge upheaval in domestic politics, which will also be keenly felt in Brussels. It marks the beginning of a worrying time in which he could use his powers of veto to destabilise an already jittery Tusk coalition government. Backed by the Law and Justice (PiS) party, which was only ousted from power in 2023, his victory will be touted as a full-scale repudiation of the Tusk government's progressive and reformist agenda and it is expected his term will be far more aggressive than that of his fellow PiS-backed predecessor, Andrzej Duda, who only selectively vetoed legislation. It is expected Nawrocki will be more aggressive and systematic. With the ultimate aim of undermining Tusk and his colleagues before the next general election in 2027, Nawrocki will also aim to complicate the EU's united pro-Ukraine stance and his country's relationship with fellow Nato members and their collective shift away from dependence on the US. His was not a 'pro-Trump' victory, but is nevertheless one which will impact greatly on Warsaw and across the wider expanses of Europe and further afield. Room to improve The Irish hotel sector is a hugely valuable element in our vibrant and ever-expanding tourism reach — not to mention the wider economy — and it is perfectly right to add its muscle to a Europe-wide lawsuit against online booking services which overinflate commission rates. Across Europe, hotels have banded together to seek 'substantial financial compensation' from following a European Court of Justice (ECJ) ruling that the platform's so-called parity clauses breeched EU competition law. Their legal action maintains that the contested clauses in the contracts they had to sign effectively prevented them from offering lower prices or better availability through other channels and other online platforms. The collective legal case is being supported by the European hospitality association and some 25 national hotel associations across Europe, including the Irish Hotels Federation. More than 900 Irish hotels and guest houses are eligible to join an action which covers the period from 2004 to 2024. In seeking compensation for significant financial harm due to inflated levels of commission charged, the sector is finally challenging what it sees as unfair business practices. And so it should. The tourism industry is going through an unprecedented period of uncertainty due to world political and economic insecurity. Thus, profitability margins are thinner. For it to be hectored out of vital margins by booking firms is unacceptable, and that is what the ECJ judgment found. Compensation levels will be decided in the coming months in a court in Amsterdam, where is headquartered. It is always the case that any unacceptable business practices should be questioned, in whatever sector they occur, but in this instance the hotels have proven the validity of their case and now await rightful compensation. It is to be hoped they get it. Peddling hatred We all know that those far-right agitators, who attempt to stir up hatred and division in their countries and communities across the globe, pay little heed to the veracity of the fact-less claims they make in their attempts to sow dissent and fear. In the wake of the deadly shooting in a Carlow shopping centre on Sunday, far-right activists such as Derek Blighe dug into their predictable playbook to misrepresent the facts of the incident and inject into the local community a parable of retribution and vengeance. Seeing their best interests served by stoking hatred and disaffection with the status quo — as well as stirring up racial tensions — these people and their grimy ideals use tragedy to weaponise shock and fear to their own ends. They mine people's insecurities pitilessly. Their attempts to bend truth for the sole purpose of fracturing opinion and separating reason from reality is as commonplace as it is unwelcome. It is deeply unhelpful, too, for those authorities upon whom the wider community place their faith to defend our society in a modern and splintered world. The claims they make — in this case asserting that the gunman killed as many as seven innocent people, including a nine-year-old girl — are aimed solely at widening existing fissures and open misguided terror in local communities. Theirs is a deadly game with potentially appalling repercussions — they play it with blithe wilfulness and a craven interest only in festering rancour and hatred. They know the consequences of their vile actions on the wider society and do not care about the wellbeing of the communities they swear to defend. They themselves are the enemies of society, not its protectors, as they so vehemently claim. Their opportunism is not only deceitful and ugly, it is very dangerous. Read More Irish Examiner view: Reaching outward is in the Irish nature


The Irish Sun
6 hours ago
- The Irish Sun
Irish woman facing deportation after being arrested by Israeli police in Palestine as son tells of his pride
AN IRISH woman has been detained by Israel in the West Bank, according to an activist group. Deirdre 'D' Murphy, 70, was arrested by Advertisement 2 Israeli security forces block the entrance to the village of al-Tuwani in the Masafer Yatta area in Occupied West Bank on June 2, 2025 Credit: AFP Originally from Douglas in After Israeli soldiers ordered the activists to leave, the female activists were reportedly stopped while leaving the village by Israeli settlers serving as reservists with the military. The Israeli police were called and subsequently detained Murphy and Björk for being in a closed military zone. According to the International Solidarity Movement, Björk is now due to be deported while Murphy is fighting a deportation order while detained at Ben Gurion Advertisement Read more in News Murphy is a founding member of Swansea Palestine Community Link and was previously detained in Israel in 2011 when she travelled to the Jewish state with the Welsh pro-Palestine group. The 120-person community at Khalet al-Daba'a is one of a dozen Palestinian hamlets in Masafer Yatta located inside an area which the Israeli authorities designated as a military firing zone in the 1980s. After a long legal battle, Israel's Supreme Court approved the eviction of 1,000 residents from the villages in the occupied West Bank in 2022. Amnesty International says ongoing settler attacks and demolitions place communities in Masafer Yatta at risk of forcible transfer. Advertisement Most read in Irish News International law prohibits both the expropriation of occupied land for purposes that do not benefit the people living there, and their forcible transfer. Murphy's son, Dale Ryan, said: 'As far as I can see her only Israeli military says it began extensive ground operations in northern and southern Gaza 'D has always had a strong sense of justice and I know she could not sit at home while she knew her friends in Masafer Yatta and all of Palestine were suffering unnecessarily. 'I am very proud of my mother for sticking up for the basic human rights of her friends and trying to raise awareness of the injustices the Palestinian people are experiencing.' Advertisement The Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade confirmed it is aware of the case and is providing consular assistance. In 2024, the far-right Israeli security minister Itamar Ben Gvir established a special task force within Israel's West Bank police unit to target left-wing activists in the West Bank including foreign nationals and supporters of the Boycott, Sanctions and Divestment (BDS) movement. According to the Israeli outlet Haaretz, at least 16 foreign activists working with Palestinians in the West Bank have been detained and deported from Israel since October 2023. Activists often accompany Palestinian shepherds and farmers who are at risk of forced displacement, as well as violence from the IDF and local settlers while they work. Advertisement In 2024, the 2 Deirdre 'D' Murphy, 70, was arrested by Israeli police on Saturday in Masafer Yatta in the occupied region