Doubt cast on claim of ‘hints' of life on faraway planet
The debate revolves around the planet K2-18b, which is 124 light years away. PHOTO: AFP
Doubt cast on claim of 'hints' of life on faraway planet
PARIS - When astronomers announced in April they might have discovered the most promising hints of alien life yet on a distant planet, the rare good news raised hopes humanity could soon learn we are not alone in the universe.
But several recent studies looking into the same data have found that there is not enough evidence to support such lofty claims, with one scientist accusing the astronomers of 'jumping the gun'.
The debate revolves around the planet K2-18b, which is 124 light years away in the Leo constellation.
The planet is thought to be the right distance from its star to have liquid water, making it a prime suspect in the search for extraterrestrial life.
In April , astronomers using the James Webb Space Telescope made headlines by announcing they had detected hints of the chemicals dimethyl sulfide (DMS) and dimethyl disulfide (DMDS) on the planet.
These chemicals are only produced by life such as marine algae on Earth, meaning they are considered potential 'biosignatures' indicating life.
The astronomers, led by Cambridge University's Nikku Madhusudhan, expressed caution about the 'hints' of a biosignature, emphasising they were not claiming a definitive discovery.
Their detection had reached a three-sigma level of statistical significance 'which means there is still a three in 1,000 chance of this being a fluke', Dr Madhusudhan said at the time.
Biosignatures 'vanish'
Two of Dr Madhusudhan's former students, Dr Luis Welbanks of Arizona State University and Dr Matthew Nixon of Maryland University, were among the researchers who have since re-analysed the data behind the announcement.
When deploying other statistical models, 'claims of a potential biosignature detection vanish', according to their preprint study published online late in April .
Like the other papers since the April announcement, it has not been peer-reviewed.
In one model, Dr Welbanks and colleagues expanded the number of possible chemicals that could explain the signals detected by Webb to 90 from the original 20.
More than 50 received a 'hit', Dr Welbanks told AFP.
'When you detect everything, did you really detect anything?' he asked.
They are not saying the planet definitely does not have DMS – just that more observations are needed, Dr Welbanks added.
'Arguments are healthy'
Dr Madhusudhan welcomed the robust debate, saying that remaining open to all possibilities is an essential part of the scientific method.
'These sort of arguments are healthy,' he told AFP.
His team even went further, releasing their own preprint study last week that expanded the number of chemicals even further to 650.
The three most 'promising' chemicals they found included DMS but not DMDS – a major part of the team's announcement in April.
The other two chemicals were diethyl sulfide and methyl acrylonitrile, the latter of which is toxic.
Dr Madhusudhan admitted that these little-known chemicals are likely not 'realistic molecules' for a planet like K2-18b.
Dr Welbanks pointed out that 'in the span of a month – with no new data, with no new models, with no new laboratory data – their entire analysis changed'.
'Closest we have ever been'
Telescopes observe such far-off exoplanets when they cross in front of their star, allowing astronomers to analyse how molecules block different wavelengths of light streaming through their atmosphere.
Earlier this week, a paper led by Dr Rafael Luque at the University of Chicago combined Webb's observations of K2-18b in both the near-infrared and mid-infrared wavelengths of light.
It also found 'no statistical significance for DMS or DMDS', the paper said.
An earlier paper by Oxford astrophysicist Jake Taylor using a basic statistical test also found no strong evidence for any biosignatures.
Dr Madhusudhan dismissed the latter paper, saying the simple exercise did not account for observing physical phenomena.
He also stood by his research, saying he was 'just as confident' in the work as he was a month ago.
More data about K2-18b will come in over the next year which should offer a much clearer picture, Dr Madhusudhan added.
Even if the planet does have DMS, it is not a guarantee of life – the chemical has been detected on a lifeless asteroid.
However, many researchers do believe that space telescopes could one day collect enough evidence to identify alien life from afar.
'We are the closest we have ever been' to such a moment, Dr Welbanks said.
'But we have to use the frameworks that are in place and build up (evidence) in a reliable method, rather than using non-standard practices and jumping the gun – as has been done in this particular case,' Dr Nixon added. AFP
Join ST's Telegram channel and get the latest breaking news delivered to you.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Straits Times
10 hours ago
- Straits Times
World coming up short on promised marine sanctuaries
Less than 10 per cent of the ocean has been designated as marine protected areas, despite the global target of 30 per cent by 2030. PHOTO: AFP BREST, France - A global target of having 30 per cent of the oceans become protected areas by 2030 is looking more fragile than ever, with little progress and the US backing away, conservationists say. 'With less than 10 per cent of the ocean designated as MPAs (marine protected areas) and only 2.7 per cent fully or highly protected, it is going to be difficult to reach the 30 per cent target,' said Dr Lance Morgan, head of the Marine Conservation Institute in Seattle, Washington. The institute maps the MPAs for an online atlas, updating moves to meet the 30 per cent goal that 196 countries signed onto in 2022, under the Kunling-Montreal Global Biodiversity Framework. The ambition is notably at risk because 'we see countries like the US reversing course and abandoning decades of bipartisan efforts' to protect areas of the Pacific Ocean, Dr Morgan said. That referred to an April executive order by President Donald Trump authorising industrial-scale fishing in big swathes of an MPA in that ocean. Currently, there are 16,516 declared MPAs in the world, covering just 8.4 per cent of the oceans. But not all are created equal: some forbid all forms of fishing, while others place no roles, or almost none, on what activities are proscribed or permitted. 'Only a third of them have levels of protection that would yield proper benefits' for fish, said Dr Joachim Claudet, a socio-ecology marine researcher at France's CNRS. Dr Daniel Pauly, a professor of fisheries science at Canada's University of British Columbia, said 'the marine protected areas have not really been proposed for the protection of biodiversity' but 'to increase fish catches'. A proper MPA 'exports fish to non-protected zones, and that should be the main reason that we create marine protected areas – they are needed to have fish', he said. When fish populations are left to reproduce and grow in protected areas, there is often a spillover effect that sees fish stocks outside the zones also rise, as several scientific journals have noted, especially around a no-fishing MPA in Hawaiian waters that is the biggest in the world. One 2022 study in the Science journal showed a 54 per cent increase in yellowfin tuna around that Hawaiian MPA, an area now threatened by Mr Trump's executive order, Dr Pauly said. For such sanctuaries to work, there needs to be fishing bans over all or at least some of their zones, Dr Claudet said. But MPAs with such restrictions account for just 2.7 per cent of the ocean's area, and are almost always in parts that are far from areas heavily impacted by human activities. In Europe, for instance, '90 per cent of the marine protected areas are still exposed to bottom trawling,' a spokesperson for the NGO Oceana, Alexandra Cousteau, said. 'It's ecological nonsense.' Dr Pauly said that 'bottom trawling in MPAs is like picking flowers with a bulldozer... they scrape the seabed'. Oceana said French MPAs suffered intensive bottom trawling, 17,000 hours' worth in 2024, as did those in British waters, with 20,600 hours. The NGO is calling for a ban on the technique, which involves towing a heavy net along the sea floor, churning it up. Governments need to back words with action, or else these areas would be no more than symbolic markings on a map, said the head of the World Wildlife Fund's European office for the oceans, Jacob Armstrong. AFP Join ST's Telegram channel and get the latest breaking news delivered to you.
Straits Times
14 hours ago
- Straits Times
Oceans feel the heat from human climate pollution
Marine heatwaves have doubled in frequency, become longer lasting and more intense, and affect a wider area. PHOTO: AFP PARIS - Oceans have absorbed the vast majority of the warming caused by burning fossil fuels and shielded societies from the full impact of greenhouse gas emissions. But this crucial ally has developed alarming symptoms of stress – heatwaves, loss of marine life, rising sea levels, falling oxygen levels and acidification caused by the uptake of excess carbon dioxide. These effects risk not just the health of the ocean but the entire planet. By absorbing more than 90 per cent of the excess heat trapped in the atmosphere by greenhouse gases, 'oceans are warming faster and faster', said Dr Angelique Melet, an oceanographer at the European Mercator Ocean monitor. The UN's IPCC climate expert panel has said the rate of ocean warming – and therefore its heat uptake – has more than doubled since 1993. Average sea surface temperatures reached new records in 2023 and 2024. Despite a respite at the start of 2025, temperatures remain at historic highs, according to data from the Europe Union's Copernicus climate monitor. The Mediterranean has set a new temperature record in each of the past three years and is one of the basins most affected, along with the North Atlantic and Arctic oceans, said Mr Thibault Guinaldo, of France's CEMS research centre. Marine heatwaves have doubled in frequency, become longer lasting and more intense, and affect a wider area, the IPCC said in its special oceans report. Warmer seas can make storms more violent, feeding them with heat and evaporated water. The heating water can also be devastating for species, especially corals and seagrass beds, which are unable to migrate. For corals, between 70 per cent and 90 per cent are expected to be lost this century if the world reaches 1.5 deg C of warming compared to pre-industrial levels. Scientists expect that threshold – the more ambitious goal of the Paris climate deal – to be breached in the early 2030s or even before. Relentless rise When a liquid or gas warms up, it expands and takes up more space. In the case of the oceans, this thermal expansion combines with the slow but irreversible melting of the world's ice caps and mountain glaciers to lift the world's seas. The pace at which global oceans are rising has doubled in three decades and if current trends continue it will double again by 2100 to about 1cm per year, according to recent research. Around 230 million people worldwide live less than a metre above sea level, vulnerable to increasing threats from floods and storms. 'Ocean warming, like sea-level rise, has become an inescapable process on the scale of our lives, but also over several centuries,' said Dr Melet. 'But if we reduce greenhouse gas emissions, we will reduce the rate and magnitude of the damage, and gain time for adaptation'. More acidity, less oxygen The ocean not only stores heat, it has also taken up 20 to 30 per cent of all humans' carbon dioxide emissions since the 1980s, according to the IPCC, causing the waters to become more acidic. Acidification weakens corals and makes it harder for shellfish and the skeletons of crustaceans and certain plankton to calcify. 'Another key indicator is oxygen concentration, which is obviously important for marine life,' said Dr Melet. Oxygen loss is due to a complex set of causes including those linked to warming waters. Combined Arctic and Antarctic sea ice cover – frozen ocean water that floats on the surface – plunged to a record low in mid-February, more than a million square miles below the pre-2010 average. This becomes a vicious circle, with less sea ice allowing more solar energy to reach and warm the water, leading to more ice melting. This feeds the phenomenon of 'polar amplification' that makes global warming faster and more intense at the poles, said Mr Guinaldo. AFP Find out more about climate change and how it could affect you on the ST microsite here.
Straits Times
15 hours ago
- Straits Times
In a hotter future, what comes after coral reefs die?
At 1.5 deg C of warming relative to pre-industrial times, between 70 and 90 per cent of coral reefs are expected to perish. PHOTO: AFP In a hotter future, what comes after coral reefs die? PARIS - The fate of coral reefs has been written with a degree of certainty rare in climate science: at 1.5 deg C of global warming, most are expected to die. This is not a far-off scenario. Scientists predict that the rise of 1.5 deg C will be reached within a decade and that beyond that point, many coral simply cannot survive. It is important to accept this and ask what next 'rather than trying to hold onto the past', said Dr David Obura, chair of Ipbes, the UN's expert scientific panel on biodiversity. 'I wish it were different,' Dr Obura, a Kenyan reef scientist and founding director of Cordio East Africa, a marine research organisation, told AFP. 'We need to be pragmatic about it and ask those questions, and face up to what the likely future will be.' And yet, it is a subject few marine scientists care to dwell on. 'We are having a hard time imagining that all coral reefs really could die off,' said Dr Melanie McField, a Caribbean reef expert, who described a 'sort of pre-traumatic stress syndrome' among her colleagues. 'But it is likely in the two-degree world we are rapidly accelerating to,' Dr McField, founding director of the Healthy Reefs for Healthy People Initiative, told AFP. When stressed in hotter ocean waters, corals expel the microscopic algae that provides their characteristic colour and food source. Without respite, bleached corals slowly starve. At 1.5 deg C of warming relative to pre-industrial times, between 70 and 90 per cent of coral reefs are expected to perish, according to the IPCC, the global authority on climate science. At 2 deg C, that number rises to 99 per cent. Even with warming as it stands today – about 1.4 deg C – mass coral death is occurring, and many scientists believe the global collapse of tropical reefs may already be underway. What comes next Dr Obura said it was not pessimistic to imagine a world without coral reefs, but an urgent question that scientists were 'only just starting to grapple with'. 'I see no reason to not be clear about where we are at this point in time,' Dr Obura said. 'Let's be honest about that, and deal with the consequences.' Rather than disappear completely, coral reefs as they exist today will likely evolve into something very different, marine scientists on four continents told AFP. This would happen as slow-growing hard corals – the primary reef builders that underpin the ecosystem – die off, leaving behind white skeletons without living tissue. Gradually, these would be covered by algae and colonised by simpler organisms better able to withstand hotter oceans, like sponges, mussels, and weedy soft corals like sea fans. 'There will be less winners than there are losers,' said Dr Tom Dallison, a marine scientist and strategic advisor to the International Coral Reef Initiative. These species would dominate this new underwater world. The dead coral beneath – weakened by ocean acidification, and buffeted by waves and storms – would erode over time into rubble. 'They will still exist, but they will just look very different. It is our responsibility to ensure the services they provide, and those that depend on them, are protected,' Dr Dallison said. Dark horizon One quarter of all ocean species live among the world's corals. Smaller, sparser, less biodiverse reefs simply means fewer fish and other marine life. The collapse of reefs threatens in particular the estimated one billion people who rely on them for food, tourism income, and protection from coastal erosion and storms. But if protected and managed properly, these post-coral reefs could still be healthy, productive, attractive ecosystems that provide some economic benefit, said Dr Obura. So far, the picture is fuzzy – research into this future has been very limited. Stretched resources have been prioritised for protecting coral and exploring novel ways to make reefs more climate resilient. But climate change is not the only thing threatening corals. Tackling pollution, harmful subsidies, overfishing and other drivers of coral demise would give 'the remaining places the best possible chance of making it through whatever eventual warming we have', Dr Obura said. Conservation and restoration efforts were 'absolutely essential' but alone were like 'pushing a really heavy ball up a hill, and that hill is getting steeper', he added. Trying to save coral reefs 'is going to be extremely difficult' as long as we keep pouring carbon into the atmosphere, said Dr Jean-Pierre Gattuso, an oceans expert from France's flagship scientific research institute, CNRS. But some coral had developed a level of thermal tolerance, he said, and research into restoring small reef areas with these resilient strains held promise. 'How do we work in this space when you have this sort of big dark event on the horizon? It's to make that dark event a little brighter,' said Dr Dallison. AFP Find out more about climate change and how it could affect you on the ST microsite here.
