US judge says prisons must provide gender-affirming care for inmates
NEW YORK, June 3 (Reuters) - A U.S. judge on Tuesday ruled the U.S. Bureau of Prisons must keep providing transgender inmates gender-affirming care, despite an executive order President Donald Trump signed on his first day back in office to halt funding for such care.
U.S. District Judge Royce Lamberth in Washington, D.C., allowed a group of more than 2,000 transgender inmates in federal prisons to pursue a lawsuit challenging the order as a class action. He ordered the Bureau of Prisons to provide them with hormone therapy and accommodations such as clothing and hair-removal devices while the lawsuit plays out.
The ruling does not require the bureau to provide surgical care related to gender transitions.
White House spokesperson Harrison Fields said the Trump administration expects to ultimately prevail in the legal dispute.
"The District Court's decision allowing transgender women, aka MEN, in women's prisons fundamentally makes women less safe and ignores the biological truth that there are only two genders," Fields said in an email.
The American Civil Liberties Union, which represents the inmates, said the ruling was "a critical reminder to the Trump administration that trans people, like all people, have constitutional rights that don't simply disappear because the president has decided to wage an ideological battle."
About 2,230 transgender inmates are housed in federal custodial facilities and halfway houses, according to the U.S. Department of Justice. About two-thirds of them, 1,506, are transgender women, most of whom are housed in men's prisons.
The named plaintiffs, two transgender men and one transgender woman, sued the Trump administration in March to challenge Trump's January 20 executive order aimed at combating what the administration called "gender ideology extremism."
The executive order directed the federal government to only recognize two, biologically distinct sexes, male and female; and house transgender women in men's prisons. It also ordered the bureau to stop spending any money on "any medical procedure, treatment, or drug for the purpose of conforming an inmate's appearance to that of the opposite sex."
Lamberth, appointed by Republican President Ronald Reagan, said in Tuesday's ruling that the plaintiffs were likely to succeed in their lawsuit because the bureau did not perform any analysis before cutting off treatment that its own medical staff had previously deemed to be medically appropriate for the inmates.
Even if it had extensively studied the issue before deciding to stop gender-affirming care, the decision might still violate the U.S. Constitution's Eighth Amendment's protections against "cruel and unusual" punishment, Lamberth wrote.
The Department of Justice had argued that the judge should defer to the policy decision of a democratically elected president, but Lamberth said a functioning democracy requires respect for "all duly enacted laws," including those that blocked the executive branch from acting in an "arbitrary and capricious" manner.
Democratic self-governance "does not mean blind submission to the whims of the most recent election-victor," Lamberth wrote.
The executive order said it was meant to promote the "dignity, safety, and wellbeing of women, and to stop the spread of "gender ideology" which denies "the immutable biological reality of sex." But the inmates receiving hormone treatments had little interest in promoting any ideology, and were instead taking "measures to lessen the personal anguish caused by their gender dysphoria," Lamberth wrote.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Independent
10 minutes ago
- The Independent
Salmonella outbreak tied to eggs sickens dozens across 7 states
A salmonella outbreak linked to a large egg recall has made dozens of people sick in seven states in the West and Midwest, federal health officials said Saturday. The August Egg Company recalled about 1.7 million brown organic and brown cage-free egg varieties distributed to grocery stores between February and May because of the potential for salmonella, according to a posted announcement Friday on the Food and Drug Administration's website. At least 79 people in seven states have gotten a strain of salmonella that was linked to the eggs, and 21 people have been hospitalized. the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention said. The recall covers Arizona, California, Illinois, Indiana, Nebraska, New Mexico, Nevada, Washington and Wyoming. A list of brands and plant codes or Julian dates can be found on the FDA and CDC websites. Symptoms of salmonella poisoning include diarrhea, fever, severe vomiting, dehydration and stomach cramps. Most people who get sick recover within a week. Infections can be severe in young children, older adults and people with weakened immune systems, who may require hospitalization. The CDC advises people to throw away recalled eggs or return them to the store where they were purchased. Consumers should also wash and disinfect any surfaces that came in contact with the eggs. ___ The Associated Press Health and Science Department receives support from the Howard Hughes Medical Institute's Science and Educational Media Group and the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation. The AP is solely responsible for all content.
Daily Mail
24 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
ICE chief's brutal takedown after Democratic mayor compares his agents to neo-Nazis
The acting director of Immigration and Customs Enforcement attacked high-profile Democrats for 'putting my people in danger' after they criticized how agents do their jobs - with one liberal mayor comparing ICE officers to a neo-Nazi group. Todd M. Lyons took specific aim at Boston Mayor Michelle Wu and New York Congressman Hakeem Jeffries in a recorded statement. Wu had previously commented about how ICE agents and the white supremacist group Nationalist Social Club-131 both wear masks. 'I don't know of any police department that routinely wears masks. We know that there are other groups who routinely wear masks. NSC-131 routinely wears masks,' the progressive mayor told reporters this week. The Nationalist Social Club-131, better known as NSC-131, is a neo-Nazi group based in the New England area that claims to have chapters in France, Hungary and Germany, according to the Anti-Defamation League. Last week, Wu described ICE agents as a 'secret police' force that has 'snatched' illegal immigrants off the streets of Boston. Lyons said the rhetoric of Wu and other Democrats is dangerous to ICE agents in the field, some of whom have been doxxed by communities facing immigration raids. 'Politicians need to stop putting my people in danger. I'm not asking them to stop. I'm demanding that they stop,' he said in his video message. 'Here's what I have to say to Boston Mayor Michelle Wu, Congressman Hakeem Jeffries, and anyone else stirring up outrage about ICE does,' Lyons said. 'These are real people with real families that you're hurting with your ridiculous rhetoric and inflammatory comments.' Jeffries, the House Minority Leader, said Tuesday during a press conference that ICE agents concealing their identities with masks is a futile exercise. 'Every single ICE agent who is engaged in this aggressive overreach and are trying to hide their identities from the American people will be unsuccessful in doing that,' he said. 'This is America. This is not the Soviet Union. We're not behind the Iron Curtain. This is not the 1930s. And every single one of them, no matter what it takes, no matter how long it takes, will of course be identified. That, in fact, is the law,' Jeffries added. Federal regulations stipulate that any US official making an immigration-related arrest must identify themselves as an immigration enforcement officer. There is nothing in federal code requiring them to share their name with suspects, nor are there any rules about face coverings. A May 23 joint letter penned by Democratic Senators Mark Warner and Tim Kaine accused the Trump administration of allowing ICE agents to wear masks when arresting 'nonviolent individuals without a prior criminal history.' In the letter addressed to Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem, Border Czar Tom Homan and Lyons, the Democratic senators said the practice of ICE agents covering their faces used to be 'reserved for undercover or sensitive operations.' 'We remain deeply concerned that ICE's lack of transparency will lead the public to intercede in enforcement efforts, escalating an already tense interaction, and risking an entirely avoidable violent situation,' the letter read. 'Increased use of face coverings and lack of prompt and clear identification by ICE officers and agents in public is also having unintended consequences. Criminals are taking advantage of ICE's anonymity and impersonating law enforcement officers and ICE agents,' the senators claimed. A May 23 joint letter penned by Democratic Senators Mark Warner and Tim Kaine accused the Trump administration of allowing ICE agents to wear masks when arresting 'nonviolent individuals without a prior criminal history' Lyons, who has been leading ICE on an acting basis since March 9, has an explanation for why his agents have been covering their faces since Trump took office. At a Monday press conference in Boston, he talked at length about how people leaked the personal information of ICE agents conducting a raid in Los Angeles, leading to death threats against them. 'People are out there taking photos of the names, their faces and posting them online with death threats to their families and themselves,' he said. He described a joint operation between ICE and the Secret Service where they arrested a person who was 'going online, taking [ICE agents'] photos, posting their families, their kid's Instagram, their kids' Facebooks and targeting them.' 'So let me ask, is that the issue here, that we're just upset about the masks? Or is anyone upset with the fact that ICE officers' families were labeled terrorists,' he said while holding back tears. Senator Marsha Blackburn, a Tennessee Republican, introduced a bill Wednesday that would make it a crime to dox federal law enforcement officials. The bill would impose a maximum criminal penalty of five years in prison for anyone convicted.
Daily Mail
37 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
Sculpt your complexion with the tinted stick moisturizer available in 20 shades that leaves skin FLAWLESS: 'My skin looks like I have a filter on!'
We all know the magic of a multitasking beauty product. Finding that hero product, though, can be a challenge. The unicorn that conceals, nourishes, and strengthens skin all at once is (unsurprisingly) really tough to find. In fact, until the Ogee Sculpted Complexion Stick, there was nothing else out there that could successfully do all of that while perfecting skin so flawlessly that it almost looked unreal. The sleek formula is absolutely everything you could want in mineral makeup and skin care combined — and it's available in a whopping 20 shades. Ogee Sculpted Complexion Stick Transform your complexion with this multipurpose stick that works overtime as a tinted moisturizer and anti-aging treatment in one. Available in 20 shades, it offers buildable coverage and blends right into the skin to leave it soft and supple. With regular use, skin looks smoother and more youthful. Shoppers absolutely love it, sharing that it looks like they're using a filter and that it's 'buttery' soft. $46 Shop The stick is like a concealer and tinted moisturizer in one, offering the benefits of buildable coverage coupled with the potency of an anti-aging skin care product that also happens to impart lasting moisture. As with everything in the Ogee lineup, the product is formulated with clean, high-performance ingredients you can feel good about applying to your skin. Among them is pracaxi seed oil, known for boosting hyaluronic acid production to improve hydration levels and leave skin softer and more resilient. Patchouli leaf extract helps too, delivering a dose of healthy fatty acids that have a calming effect. Did we mention the stick is an anti-aging powerhouse, too? You have green coffee oil to thank for that, as the ingredient ramps up the production of collagen and elastin. With age, it naturally decreases and leaves skin lax and more prone to wrinkles. The caffeine in green coffee oil works like a charm, especially coupled with elderberry extract. This antioxidant-packed fruit protects skin from harmful free radical damage — another culprit responsible for aging skin — while tightening. Because the ingredients work both instantly and in the long term, the moisturizing stick levels up your routine in the best way. It conceals those imperfections while improving your complexion so that it only gets better and better the more you use it. Using it is as simple as gliding it onto your skin and blending with your fingers, or if you prefer you can buff it on using a brush. Add just a bit more to achieve the right amount of coverage. It should come as no surprise that shoppers have dubbed the Ogee Sculpted Complexion Stick 'perfect' and 'so buttery.' 'It leaves your skin looking and feeling youthful,' raved one shopper. 'My skin looks like I have a filter on! People tell me they can't even tell I'm wearing makeup. Great coverage.' 'Amazed,' praised another. 'Wow, did it blow my mind when it blended RIGHT into my face. Perfect match and coverage!' If you've been searching everywhere for your holy grail makeup, your search ends with the Ogee Sculpted Complexion Stick. This is truly all you need to give your skin a quick makeover — with impressive results that last.
