Experts say royal visit was meant to send a message to Trump — and to London
OTTAWA – Prime Minister Mark Carney meant to send a message to U.S. President Donald Trump by inviting King Charles to Ottawa this week, foreign policy experts say — but Trump may not have been the only target audience.
Multiple experts in foreign policy say they're convinced Carney arranged the whirlwind royal visit to reaffirm Canada's sovereignty and distinct political culture before a global audience in response to Trump's ruinous trade policy and repeated calls for Canada's annexation.
Roy Norton, a fellow at the Balsillie School of International Affairs, said he also doubts Carney would have invited the King had British Prime Minister Keir Starmer not made the controversial decision to invite the president for a second state visit to the United Kingdom.
That invitation was formally issued by King Charles but would have been offered on Starmer's advice.
'I think Trump isn't the only audience internationally, but I think Trump's an important one,' Norton said. 'Starmer is also on notice as he's been reminded that the King has these responsibilities beyond simply serving the interests of the United Kingdom.'
Carney told Britain's SkyNews in an interview earlier this month that Canadians 'weren't impressed' by London's invitation to Trump, 'given the circumstance.'
Norton said the visit also may have been intended to remind the King of his own responsibilities to Canada.
While many Canadians were disappointed that the King made no direct statement pushing back on Trump's annexation talk, the throne speech he read in Ottawa emphasized Canada's sovereignty and his close personal relationship with the country.
While Trump was relatively quiet about the royal visit itself — which saw the King welcomed by cheering crowds in Ottawa — he called again Tuesday for Canada to become part of the United States.
In a post on social media, Trump said Canada would pay billions of dollars to take part in his unbuilt Golden Dome missile defence system if 'they remain a separate, but unequal, Nation, but will cost ZERO DOLLARS if they become our cherished 51st State.'
Fen Hampson, a Carleton University professor and an expert on Canada-U.S. relations, said that while he thinks the royal visit was 'all about Trump,' the president remains 'immune to messaging or persuasion of any kind.'
'In extraordinary times, you have to pull out all the stops and call on friends to send a strong message that Canada is not for sale, now, tomorrow or ever,' he said.
Hampson said he doesn't think the visit itself did much to unify Canadians beyond the effect Trump is having already.
'It's the threat of Trump that's unifying Canadians, not the King,' he said.
This was only the third time a sitting monarch had read the speech from the throne in Canada. Queen Elizabeth II did so in 1957 and 1977.
A Liberal government official, speaking on background, told The Canadian Press that the goal of the royal visit was to help Canadians reconnect with their cultural and political roots at a time when the country's sovereignty is being threatened.
Daniel Béland, director of the McGill Institute for the Study of Canada, said the visit served as 'a way to draw attention to the distinctiveness of our political institutions.'
'It's also about PR and about raising the profile of Canada and, in a way, of the government's policies,' he said, noting that the visit received international attention. 'It's certainly sending a message about the fact that Canada is in a way not isolated, that it has its own identity.'
Asked by reporters Tuesday if he thinks the throne speech will help the federal government in its negotiations with the Trump administration, Conservative Leader Pierre Poilievre said it's hard to tell what moves the president.
'I think it's important that the world recognize that we have those ancient traditions and the Americans recognize that we are an independent and free country that will make its own decisions,' Poilievre said.
— With files from Craig Lord
This report by The Canadian Press was first published May 28, 2025.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CBC
14 minutes ago
- CBC
Northern First Nations call for firefighting equipment to protect communities as they wrap up evacuations
First Nations in northern Manitoba are asking for more equipment as they continue battling wildfires that helped trigger a provincewide state of emergency last week. People in Pukatawagan Cree Nation resorted to fighting the fire with hoses "no bigger than a garden hose," Chief Gordie Bear said at a news conference Tuesday morning. "We have root fire, we have fire hot spots coming out of some places two, three days later because we got no water," Bear said. "If we had water to [douse] these little hot flames out, we'd catch up to the fire." The fire in Pukatawagan — also known as Mathias Colomb Cree Nation — has been active since May 27 and was reported at 10,000 hectares in the Monday fire bulletin. As of Monday evening, the community was working to fight the out-of-control flames with only two fire trucks, three MARK-3 fire pumps and about 2,000 feet of hose, Bear said. "Years ago … we had shovels, we had pickaxes, we had Pulaskis. We don't have any of that," he said, "absolutely nothing from the Department of Natural Resources for fire suppression. Again, we say we have nothing but hose for our gardens, rakes for the lawns — nothing to fight fires with." Fifty pumps, 1,500 1.5-inch hoses and 500 sprinklers were moved into Manitoba on Monday, according to rough estimates in the Canadian Interagency Forest Fire Centre's latest daily fire situation report. South of Pukatawagan, Pimicikamak Cree Nation Chief David Monias said his community is working with only one fire truck as it looks to protect local property with a wildfire "by our doorstep." "For a community of 10,000 people, that's ridiculous.… We're fighting even just to get water bombers," Monias said. "We have a state of emergency provincewide, and we're still fighting for resources when they should be coming readily." The wildfire near Pimicikamak — also known as Cross Lake — was about 3,300 hectares in size as of the latest bulletin. Monias said Pimicikamak was working to get the last members out of the community on Tuesday. Military evacuation flight out of the wildfire zone 15 hours ago Duration 5:15 As out-of-control wildfires threaten communities in northern Manitoba, The National's Adrienne Arsenault travels with the Canadian military on a critical evacuation flight out of Pukatawagan. Pukatawagan has evacuated everyone but about 50 essential workers, Chief Bear said. Emergency co-ordinator Tobi Bighetty said 1,350 people were relocated, with only a few still remaining in The Pas. Bighetty said besides those who drove themselves, 240 evacuees were sent south on Via Rail, 600 were bussed out and the remainder were flown out on Hercules and King Air planes. Pukatawagan is about 700 kilometres northwest of Winnipeg as the crow flies. Pimicikamak is about 500 kilometres north of the Manitoba capital.
CBC
17 minutes ago
- CBC
'Remote terrain of Kananaskis' presents unique challenges for G7 security operation
Social Sharing With the G7 leaders' summit coming to Kananaskis in less than two weeks, preparations are well underway for what has been described as "the largest domestic security operation" a country can take on. During a media briefing on Monday, reporters were told by the Integrated Safety and Security Group (ISSG) that the task force is currently in the process of bringing in personnel and setting up camps ahead of the summit, which takes place from June 15 to 17. WATCH | Strict security measures in place for G7: RCMP highlight security measures for upcoming G7 summit 20 hours ago Duration 11:35 While ongoing preparations have drawn inspiration from previous high-stakes security operations like the 2010 Winter Olympics in Vancouver and the 2018 G7 leaders' summit in Charlevoix, Que., the unique challenges posed by the Kananaskis wilderness require special considerations. "The remote terrain of Kananaskis adds to the complexity of the operation," said Canadian Armed Forces Brig.-Gen. Liam Wade Rutland, commander of the joint task force. "Our immediate focus is on environmental familiarization, getting to know the terrain, our partners, and [understanding] the unique conditions of the area we're working in," he said. Encompassed within the Bow Valley's expansive forests, the Kananaskis controlled access zone in effect from June 10 to 18 presents risks such as weather, wildfires and encounters with wildlife. RCMP chief superintendent and ISSG event security director David Hall told reporters that "the potential that we may need to evacuate the summit site" has been taken into account, but that "maybe the summit itself [is] not of concern" when it comes to wildfires. "I would just say that all of our respective agencies are mindful of the wildfire threat nationally and how that may draw resources from the security partners to support evacuations like we're seeing in Manitoba or Saskatchewan right now, or parts of Alberta," he said. "All I'll say is our resourcing strategy for all of our agencies took that into account." Backcountry patrols, wildlife monitoring Wildlife, on the other hand, is being actively monitored to prevent interactions between humans and animals, with security personnel undergoing what Rutland called "numerous scenario-based exercises" involving wildlife encounters. Alberta Forestry and Parks superintendent Bryan Sundberg said personnel will be "conducting wildlife patrols and backcountry patrols" before and during the summit. Sundberg said the team will be looking to prevent wild animals, "especially the bears in the area," from getting too close to people. When the G8 leaders' summit was held in Kananaskis in 2002, a bear was tranquilized and inadvertently killed. "Our collective approach to wildlife mitigation is proactive and grounded in subject matter expertise," he said, adding that attractants such as food are being managed to avoid negative interactions with wild animals. Sundberg said officers will be deployed outdoors 24 hours a day, and that field personnel are being given wilderness safety training, including how to use bear spray, to protect both officers and wildlife. "Alongside our partners, Alberta Sheriffs are using real-time monitoring tools and on-the-ground patrols to track wildlife movement near the summit venues," said Sundberg. He said personnel from multiple agencies will be patrolling the backcountry to monitor not only wildlife but also human activity. "Our officers know the local trails, the terrain, the environment, and how people that use the area typically behave and interact in and along the trails and in the area," said Sundberg. "This key local knowledge helps keep the overall operation safe and efficient." "Officers will be out in the field, on the trails and at key locations and checkpoints where people might be hiking or working to provide guidance and advice to those recreationalists in the areas, and how we could avoid and lessen their impact," said Sundberg. Rutland emphasized that "environmental stewardship" has been top of mind for the ISSG throughout the planning process. "We recognize that Kananaskis is a national treasure and we're committed to mitigating and minimizing our impact, leaving the area in a pristine condition," he said. "This includes all our management plans and remediation of the area."
CBC
17 minutes ago
- CBC
Calgary Refugee Health Clinic avoids closure with 2-year emergency bridge funding
After facing the threat of closure, a Calgary health clinic that treats thousands of refugees annually will be able to stay open for another two years — though on a much smaller scale. Since last fall, the Calgary Refugee Health Clinic team has been scrambling for resources after learning its long-time funding of $1.6 million a year was pulled by the Mosaic Primary Care Network because the clinic's "patient volume and complexity of care have grown significantly," according to the network at the time. The clinic, which takes in up to 1,500 new refugees a year, helps patients access health, social and settlement services and, after some time, helps them transition to permanent care. After learning the clinic was on the verge of shutting down, the Calgary Health Foundation stepped forward with a promise of $550,000, ensuring the northeast facility can keep its doors open for two more years. "It's been an absolute thrill that we've been able to make this happen," the clinic's medical director and family physician, Dr. Rachel Talavlikar, told CBC News. "It was heartbreaking, what we went through." She's referring, in part, to the loss of dozens of staff. While 27 physicians still work at the clinic part-time, they now only have five support staff — down from the 30 nurses, social workers, mental health therapists and more they used to have. Those people are still employed with Mosaic Primary Care Network, Talavlikar added, but now patients must be referred and sit on long waitlists to see them. "We are learning what it looks like to see these patients without that extra support. And we definitely have a bit of a backup starting to form," said Talavlikar. Talavlikar said that means they now have to transition patients out of their clinic and to permanent family doctors more quickly — especially if they have the English skills to navigate the health care system. They've also had to shut down their mobile support program, and they no longer have a nurse in-house at the Margaret Chisholm Resettlement Centre to treat new arrivals. For Calgary Health Foundation CEO Paul Rossmann, the clinic's work is more important than ever, now that Calgary is a direct entry point for refugees. "Many of these people arrive with complex medical and social needs. If those needs don't get met, people fall through the cracks and then ultimately they have the potential to end up in emergency rooms with more acute health challenges," said Rossmann. "This is a far more proactive way to ensure the health and settlement of the refugee population." Rossmann said the foundation is still fundraising to round up the $550,000 commitment they've made to the clinic. What happens after the two years? Talavlikar said she sees this funding scare as an opportunity to rebuild the clinic to be more effective and cost-efficient. Her goal is to treat each refugee that arrives in Calgary at least once. Meanwhile, as she actively hunts for funding opportunities to hire more nurses in the near term, she's also looking to the province for some long-term solutions. Talavlikar said she's been speaking with the leadership of Primary Care Alberta — one of the province's four new health agencies created amid the health care system overhaul — to see how a specialized clinic like hers will fit in the long-term. "The team at Primary Care Alberta were very keen to see us be part of the health system," she said. According to Talavlikar, this could be an opportunity to shape the new agency. "Those of us that did work with those communities, all those equity-deserving populations, we have to fight all the time to be like, 'Don't forget about them,' right? Whereas this new system is really being structured with them at the forefront," she said. "I'm very optimistic that we'll find a place to be anchored. I guess I won't stop until they do."
