EU leaders agree the situation in Gaza is ‘dire' – but that's where agreement ends
European Union
leaders have been discussing the situation in
Gaza
and are expected to recognise the 'dire humanitarian situation' in the enclave, according to a draft statement thrashed out by officials from the 27 member states in recent days.
It is expected to be approved by the leaders either late on Thursday or early on Friday.
There the agreement is likely to end, though; the bloc remains deeply divided on what if anything it should do about Gaza, with a group of countries including Germany, Italy, Austria, the Czech Republic and Hungary blocking any action against
Israel
.
Ireland and a group of other countries – whose numbers have grown significantly in recent months – want the EU's trade agreement with Israel suspended, but that is strongly opposed by the pro-Israel faction.
READ MORE
In discussions over the past week on the summit's conclusions – these are generally agreed between diplomats and then tweaked and/or approved by the leaders – some countries did not even want to acknowledge the EU's own review of the agreement which concluded that
Israel was breaching its human rights standards in its treatment of the Palestinians in Gaza
.
The EU agrees there should be a ceasefire and that sufficient humanitarian aid should be immediately allowed into Gaza to alleviate the obvious suffering there.
But it does not agree what to do to persuade Israel to make that happen. And that is not going to change at this summit.
[
EU summit: Divisions remain over 'catastrophic' Gaza war
]
Micheál Martin
was visibly frustrated at this when he spoke to reporters on his way into the summit venue on Thursday morning.
The Taoiseach said the attitude of other EU countries was 'difficult to comprehend' in the face of the suffering of the Palestinians in Gaza.
'I'll be saying to my European colleagues that the people of Europe find it incomprehensible that Europe does not seem to be in a position to [put] pressure on Israel and leverage on Israel to stop this war in Gaza,' he said.
Referencing the 'continuing slaughter of children and innocent civilians', Mr Martin wants the EU to take action against Israel to persuade it to stop attacks in the enclave and allow
United Nations
agencies to distribute food and give humanitarian assistance.
Ireland, he said, 'would be seeking some mechanisms to ensure that this war stops and that humanitarian aid gets into Gaza'.
One of those 'mechanisms' is to suspend the agreement that provides for free trade between the EU and Israel – something which would hit Israel economically and would worry the Israeli government by signalling to the rest of the world that the EU should treat the country as an international pariah in the way that apartheid South Africa was once regarded.
But Israel's supporters in the EU will block that.
There is an internal argument about whether such a move would require unanimity as a foreign policy issue or qualified majority voting as a trade matter, but the EU's realpolitik means that either way it is not going to happen any time soon.
Mr Martin is also likely to raise the possibility of sanctioning individual Israeli ministers, including some of the hardliners in
Binyamin Netanyahu's
government who have made the most bellicose statements about the Palestinians. But he knows that's unlikely to go anywhere either.
The reality is the EU is and will remain divided in its attitude to Israel. Despite Mr Martin's admonishments – on Wednesday night he said
the EU's attitude was a 'huge stain' on the bloc
– there is little prospect of that changing. Taking action against Israel will remain a matter for individual member states.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
37 minutes ago
- Irish Times
Situation in Gaza is ‘abhorrent and unbearable', Ursula von der Leyen says
The humanitarian situation facing Palestinian people inside Gaza is 'abhorrent and unbearable' and aid needs to be allowed into the territory immediately, European Commission president Ursula von der Leyen has said. Speaking after a summit of EU leaders, Ms Von der Leyen said Israel needed to let aid flow into Gaza 'immediately and unimpeded'. European leaders remain divided on how best to put pressure on Israel to address the humanitarian conditions in Gaza. The European Union 's 27 leaders signed off on a joint statement deploring the 'dire' humanitarian situation in Gaza, caused by Israel's ongoing military campaign. The communique went on to criticise the 'unacceptable' number of civilians killed and the levels of starvation in the Palestinian enclave. READ MORE Negotiations at the EU summit did not bridge the significant difference of opinion in the room about pushing Israel to allow aid into Gaza. 'We cannot remain passive … The union cannot remain inactive,' António Costa, president of the European Council who chairs the summits, said afterwards. 'Nobody can ignore what we watch on TV and what we read in the press; the humanitarian situation in Gaza is completely unacceptable.' Spain , Ireland, Belgium , Slovenia and others want firmer action from the EU, which could include suspending a free trade deal with Israel, or putting sanctions on hardline Israeli ministers. Germany , Italy , Austria and others advocate for the bloc to continue to raise its concerns with Israel through diplomatic channels. Spain's left-wing prime minister Pedro Sánchez said the EU had put together 18 packages of economic sanctions targeting Russia since the full-scale invasion of Ukraine. The fact the bloc's trade deal with Israel had not been suspended despite the 'genocide' in Gaza pointed to a double standard, he said. [ Israeli bond investors risk complicity in genocide, TD claims in letter to Central Bank governor Opens in new window ] Suspending the EU-Israel agreement would not improve the situation for Palestinian civilians, said Austrian chancellor Christian Stocker, who spoke with Israeli prime minister Binyamin Netanyahu on the phone the day before the summit. 'The civilian population must not pay the price for Hamas terror. Netanyahu has pledged to step up all efforts in this direction so that humanitarian aid can be delivered,' he said. Renewed focus has been put on the EU's response to Israel's invasion of Gaza, which has levelled much of the besieged territory and killed more than 56,000 Palestinians. Several 'like-minded' European countries should move ahead on their own if the EU fails to agree to take action as a bloc, Slovenian prime minister Robert Golob said. 'It is high time that we do not show just solidarity, but we put some real pressure on the Israeli government,' Mr Golob said. Taoiseach Micheál Martin said the refusal of some EU states to consider action against Israel to address the 'catastrophic' humanitarian crisis in Gaza was 'difficult to comprehend'. A recent EU review concluded Israel had committed human rights violations during its war in Gaza, leading to calls for the bloc to use what leverage it has to push Mr Netanyahu to change course. It is understood the EU's foreign affairs chief Kaja Kallas was asked to prepare options to take in response to the review to table at a meeting of foreign ministers next month. The summit also discussed the war in Ukraine , tariff negotiations involving the United States, the ceasefire between Iran and Israel and defence spending. [ AG says he cannot help on legal query over Shannon flights that may aid Israel's Gaza war Opens in new window ] Slovakia's populist prime minister Robert Fico threatened to withhold support for a further package of sanctions on Russia, which needs unanimous approval, if he did not get concessions on new EU proposals to phase out reliance on Russian gas. Separately, Hungary's far-right prime minister Viktor Orban said he would continue to block Ukraine moving forward in its bid to join the EU. Brussels started what will be years-long negotiations with Kyiv last June to consider accepting Ukraine into the 27-state bloc, but Hungary has since vetoed the process moving forward. Speaking before the summit, Mr Orban said he did not want Ukraine to advance into more detailed accession talks while it remained at war with Russia. 'If we integrate [Ukraine] into the European Union, we would integrate the war and we would not like to be together in a community with one country who is at war,' he said.
Irish Times
2 hours ago
- Irish Times
EU leaders discuss response to Donald Trump's latest trade proposal
European Union leaders are discussing their response to US president Donald Trump's latest proposal on trade after a briefing from Ursula von der Leyen . The European Commission president told EU leaders at summit talks in Brussels on Thursday evening that she has received the latest US tariff offer, according to officials briefed on the discussion who declined to give any more detail. The question dogging the leaders and the commission, which handles trade matters for the bloc, is whether to accept an asymmetrical trade deal with the US or risk escalation by striking back, provoking Mr Trump's ire. Several member states argued against retaliation, with most suggesting that reaching a quick deal with the US is better than holding out for a perfect one, even if many of Mr Trump's tariffs remain in place, according to two people briefed on the discussions. READ MORE But there is still division, with Paris categorically rejecting any deal skewed in favor of the US and pushing for a complete removal of tariffs, another official said. The EU needs to reach an agreement with Mr Trump by July 9th, when tariffs on nearly all of the bloc's exports to the US increase to 50 per cent. The US president says the EU takes advantage of the US with its goods surplus and perceived barriers to American trade. 'We hope that the discussions with the US continue in an energetic mood in the coming days — the July deadline is coming soon,' Luxembourg prime minister Luc Frieden told reporters on his way into the summit. 'I wish the commission good luck.' Detailed discussions with the US are taking place on tariffs and non-tariff barriers, as well as on key sectors, strategic purchases and regulatory matters the EU is hoping to address through its simplification agenda, said the people, who spoke on the condition of anonymity. The US is asking the EU to make what the bloc's officials see as unbalanced and unilateral concessions. Discussions on critical sectors — such as steel and aluminum, automobiles, pharmaceuticals, semiconductors and civilian aircraft — have been particularly difficult. Officials believe the best-case scenario remains an agreement on principles that would allow the negotiations to continue beyond an early July deadline. Alongside a 10 per cent universal levy on most goods — which is currently facing a US court challenge — Mr Trump has introduced 25 per cent tariffs on cars and double that on steel and aluminum based on a different executive authority. He is also working to expand tariffs on other sectors, including pharmaceuticals, semiconductors and commercial aircraft. Many of those duties are expected to stay, regardless of an agreement with the Trump administration, according to the sources. The EU will assess any end-result and at that stage decide what level of asymmetry — if any — it's willing to accept. The EU's industry chief, Stephane Sejourne, told Bloomberg this week that the EU would need to respond to any tariffs — including a baseline 10 per cent levy — with countermeasures. But some EU leaders, including Italy's Giorgia Meloni have indicated they could live with some levies if it allows for a rapid deal that avoids an escalation in the conflict. 'When we discussed 10 per cent with companies, it isn't particularly impactful for us,' Ms Meloni told reporters in The Hague on Wednesday. 'I think a decision at 10 per cent would enable us, as far as we're concerned, to keep working on things that we care about.' —Bloomberg
Irish Times
3 hours ago
- Irish Times
EU to use network of fact-checkers against disinformation that threatens democracy, says Michael McGrath
The European Commissioner responsible for justice, Michael McGrath , has warned of 'creeping authoritarianism' in Europe and the undermining of judicial independence. He said the concern was not sudden coups or dramatic power grabs, but rather a slow process that can lead to a concentration of power in the hands of a few. 'This erosion often proceeds quietly through a systematic dismantling of safeguards designed to protect our rights and freedoms, such as changes to legal and constitutional frameworks, manipulation of electoral processes and the weakening, or indeed silencing, of an independent media,' he said. 'Closely aligned to such development is the undermining of judicial independence.' READ MORE Mr McGrath, commissioner for democracy, justice, the rule of law and consumer protection, was speaking at a seminar on emerging threats to democracy at the Law Society of Ireland in Dublin on Thursday. He said that in the absence of independent judges, laws were subject to 'the whims of those in power'. Citizens in Europe, he said, felt disconnected from the democratic processes that had shaped their lives. 'This disconnection can lead to apathy, and worse, create space for harmful ideologies to take hold,' he said. The European Union had an important role in making its politics simpler and more accessible and that included protecting societies against disinformation, he said. A European 'democracy shield', which he is developing, would help in protecting institutions and freedoms of expression while tackling disinformation. 'Ultimately, we must ensure that voters have access to facts, not fiction when making the decisions that shape our future.' A network of fact-checkers would be part of this approach and would help 'pre-bunk and debunk' manipulated information, he said, while upholding the fairness and integrity of elections. 'Users of online platforms should be clearly informed when algorithms are being used to promote political content, especially when these algorithms are driven by personal data or target individuals based on their characteristics,' he told delegates at the conference. 'They also have a right to know whether political content is sponsored or paid for and by whom. 'The effective enforcement, therefore, of the Digital Services Act and the regulation on political advertising, will be essential to achieving this transparency.' The European Commission has launched several infringement proceedings in recent years, and Mr McGrath cited the case to protect Polish judges from threats to their independence. 'The EU stands as a beacon for democracy and the rule of law,' he said. 'People look to us to set the standard and to promote and defend democratic values wherever they are under threat and so in a world facing the rise of authoritarian regimes and political instability the leadership of the European Union has never mattered more.'
