Major projects bill amended to remove cabinet power to sidestep Indian Act
The federal government's major projects legislation was amended by opposition parties on Wednesday to withdraw the power the bill gave cabinet to sidestep the Indian Act, following weeks of criticism from First Nations leaders.
But Assembly of First Nations National Chief Cindy Nepinak Woodhouse said Thursday the 'limited changes' made to the bill don't go far enough. She still wants the government to give members of Parliament more time to study the legislation.
The Liberal government's controversial legislation, which would allow cabinet to quickly grant federal approvals for big industrial projects like mines, ports and pipelines, was introduced on June 6, and sailed through the committee study in about eight hours on Tuesday and Wednesday.
Amendments to the bill made in committee include removing the Indian Act from a list of laws the government can sidestep when determining whether a project should move forward.
Story continues below advertisement
Bloc Québécois MP Xavier Barsalou-Duval said in a media statement the change came from a sub-amendment his party posed, and that the Liberals did not vote in favour of it.
Get breaking National news
For news impacting Canada and around the world, sign up for breaking news alerts delivered directly to you when they happen. Sign up for breaking National newsletter Sign Up
By providing your email address, you have read and agree to Global News' Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy
In French, Barsalou-Duval said he regrets that the Liberals didn't vote for the amendment, but he is pleased it passed.
From the moment the bill was first discussed, First Nations leaders warned the bill could violate their constitutionally protected rights.
First Nations leaders also said Ottawa could face legal challenges, and its fast-tracked projects could be slowed down, if Indigenous communities are not meaningfully consulted.
1:54
More pushback for Bill C-5 from Indigenous groups
Some First Nations leaders are warning of a wave protests if the bill doesn't fundamentally change. Prime Minister Mark Carney said respect for section 35 of the Constitution, which recognizes and protects treaty rights is 'at the heart of this legislation.'
Story continues below advertisement
He said it's also important that the bill doesn't approve projects, it just 'creates the possibility of these projects,' which must undergo 'full consultation with Indigenous Peoples to define what is a nation-building project.'
'And then, if something is one of those projects, then what are the conditions in order for that project to move forward, including participation — obviously, I would think, in almost every case, environmental, other conditions — and then only if those conditions are met would the project move forward.'
Woodhouse Nepinak said it appears some other 'constructive suggestions' to amend the bill were voted down.
'These limited changes don't go far enough and were developed without input from rights-holders. We continue to call on Parliament to honour the Crown and have a full discussion with rights-holders before passing the bill, instead of ramming it through in a week,' she said.
'We will continue monitoring the debate closely and will have more to say as the situation develops.'
The legislation, which has support from the opposition Conservatives, is expected to pass Friday.
— With files from Michel Saba
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Global News
2 hours ago
- Global News
United Conservative Party releases CPP survey results 21 months late
It's taken nearly two years for the province to release results from a survey that asked Albertans if they wanted an Alberta Pension Plan (APP). The survey showed 63 per cent of respondents were opposed to an APP, while only 10 per cent were in support. More recent polling from Leger in February found 55 per cent of Albertan's opposed an Alberta Pension Plan. A May 2025 poll from Janet Brown found 55 per cent of Albertans were in support of the APP if there were more details. In May, Alberta Premier Danielle Smith said, 'I am seeing the results you are, I am not seeing that there is an appetite to put it to the people at the moment.' Duane Bratt, a political science professor at Mount Royal University, says the Janet Brown poll, commissioned by the government of Alberta, has interesting results with the number of people waiting for more information. Story continues below advertisement He adds people wanted answers to questions. 'Like, what is the amount that Alberta Pension Plan would start with? What would be the contribution rates? What would be the benefit rates? What would be the mobility between provinces? All of those sorts of questions haven't been answered,' said Bratt. 1:56 Alberta finance minister says he has not 'flip-flopped' on proposed pension change Bratt says the survey was not fair because it asked questions that assumed the respondent wanted an Alberta Pension Plan. 'The question itself was, would you want to leave the CPP if you had the exact same program. In the absence of any details, how do you know that that's the exact same program,' said Bratt. Get breaking National news For news impacting Canada and around the world, sign up for breaking news alerts delivered directly to you when they happen. Sign up for breaking National newsletter Sign Up By providing your email address, you have read and agree to Global News' Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy He adds the survey results are no longer accurate but the delay of the release of the results shows a lack of transparency from the provincial government. 'The bigger story is how and why the government of Alberta refused to hand over public survey data that they encouraged Albertans to fill out. They went to extreme measures to block it, because they realized it was going to embarrass them. They believed that this was a neutral process to just explore the idea of leaving the Canadian pension plan, but it wasn't,' said Bratt. Story continues below advertisement The province says they will continue to talk with Albertans on this topic and says nothing will change unless Albertans approve a new pension plan in a referendum. Bratt says by itself, majority of Albertans are against the province pulling out of CPP and creating the APP. He adds that he expects to see several referendum questions about Alberta's independence. Those might include questions on the APP, an Alberta police force, and Alberta independence. 'I think what the government is hoping for is maybe people might not want to separate, but they still want to send a message to Ottawa,' said Bratt.
Global News
3 hours ago
- Global News
BC NDP dragging heels on pledge to end privatization of HandyDART, union says
The union representing HandyDART drivers is voicing frustration with delays in a decision on whether to end privatization of the service. HandyDART, a door-to-door shared ride service for people with mobility issues and other complex needs, is currently operated by French for-profit contractor TransDev. Amalgamated Transit Union Local 1724, which represents about 600 workers, says the BC NDP promised to bring the service back into government before the last provincial election. 5:38 HandyDART union votes in favour of job action 'David Eby made a promise to end privatization of HandyDart, and we'd like to see him follow through with that promise,' union president Joe McCann said. Story continues below advertisement 'So far there has been a lot of empty promises, a lot of delays.' Get breaking National news For news impacting Canada and around the world, sign up for breaking news alerts delivered directly to you when they happen. Sign up for breaking National newsletter Sign Up By providing your email address, you have read and agree to Global News' Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy About 30,000 people rely on HandyDART, but a group representing riders says the quality of service has declined, and they feel like their voices aren't heard with it in the hands of private operators. 'It's a crapshoot trying to get through to the call centre, book a ride if you can seven days in advance — I don't know how anyone can run their life seven days ahead,' said Beth McKellar, co-founder of the HandyDART Riders' Alliance. 'I strongly believe if it is brought in-house, there is more accountability.' The union says HandyDART has become increasingly reliant on subcontracting out to taxis, which now account for about a quarter of rides, up from seven per cent. 'When you're waiting for public transit, you expect public transit. Our drivers are trained, well-trained,' McCann said. 'Taxi drivers aren't trained to that standard. And they have a different business model. They need to hustle. And get to the next client.' Asked about plans for the service Thursday, Premier David Eby was non-committal. 'The focus of our government has been ensuring we're bringing the most vulnerable along, but the group of people that really feels pressure has expanded, it includes the middle class, and concerns around housing and health care and safe communities, which are the focus of our government,' he said. Story continues below advertisement 1:59 Concerns raised over HandyDART service shift to taxis TransDev's current contract expires in 2026. TransLink was expected to announce a decision on HandyDART's future next week, but the move has been delayed yet again for further review. 'They're hiring more consultants, going to have more reviews, and I wonder how many millions of dollars are being wasted that could've been sent directly into HandyDART,' McCann said. Data shows HandyDART ridership grew six per cent last year, and that number is expected to continue climbing as B.C.'s population ages. TransLink says most trips are completed on time. But riders like McKellar believe something needs to change. 'None of us are getting any younger. A lot of people are born with disabilities and they need to get around and whatnot, and the service just won't be there,' she said.
Global News
3 hours ago
- Global News
B.C. Premier David Eby says it will be a busy summer as he reflects on past 8 months
B.C. Premier David Eby says it has been an 'eventful' period for British Columbians since he was re-elected in October. 'What we set out during the election campaign, which was in advance of the (Donald) Trump election, has shifted quite dramatically in terms of where we have to be,' Eby told Global News in a one-on-one interview. 'And so the focus has been on ensuring that B.C. can assume the role that we have assumed now, which is to be the economic engine for the country.' Eby said that while his government did not provide a $1,000 grocery rebate to residents, they did remove the carbon tax, as promised. 'The focus of our government has been ensuring that we're bringing the most vulnerable along, but the group of people that really feels pressure has expanded,' Eby added. Story continues below advertisement 'It includes the middle class, concerns around housing and health care and safe communities, which are the focus of our government.' Get daily National news Get the day's top news, political, economic, and current affairs headlines, delivered to your inbox once a day. Sign up for daily National newsletter Sign Up By providing your email address, you have read and agree to Global News' Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy Eby also said the province is working to diversify trading partners, especially in the Asia Pacific, including Malaysia, Korea and Japan. One of the big issues still facing Eby's government is housing. 'Rents are unacceptably high, which is why we continue to push on housing, why we're buying land around transit stations to build more rental housing, why we are giving direct support to more seniors through the Safer Programme so they can afford rent,' he said. 'The work needs to continue. The good news is we're finally pointing in the right direction. Rents are coming down. We've had eight months of decreases overall, we're the only province that's seen that. But we have to continue doing the work because they are too high.' 2:02 B.C. premier wants Ottawa to declare Indian gang a terrorist organization As summer gets underway, Eby said there is still a lot of work to be done. Story continues below advertisement 'First of all, it's advancing the economic work with the federal government, with the other provinces, whether it's corridors, internal trade, building major projects, ensuring that British Columbians have access to good jobs, as we see the direct attack on sectors like our forest sector here in British Columbia,' he said. 'The second is, I am hopeful we won't, but I am worried that we might see a significant wildfire season again, so supporting British Columbians through that, if we have to have large-scale evacuations like Manitoba and Ontario have had to do. 'The third, and I think a critical piece, is we have to continue to advance the work on a variety of other fronts, ensuring that our health-care system is strong.'
