Real killer of Diane Sindall 'was KNOWN' after arrest of Peter Sullivan but locals refused to tell police -leading man wrongly branded Beast of Birkenhead to serve 38 years for murder he didn't commit
The real identity of the 'Beast of Birkenhead' who brutally murdered Diane Sindall was known to residents of local estates, according to a charity set up in her memory.
But no-one from the 'tribal' and 'tight-knit' communities was willing to come forward and name the killer to police 'for fear of repercussions', staff said today.
As a result, Peter Sullivan spent 38 years behind bars before his conviction for beating the 21-year-old to death in 1986 was quashed by the Court of Appeal earlier this week.
Police have now reopened their investigation into the florist's murder, which caused shock and revulsion across the Wirral and beyond.
However they say there is no match on the national database for the newly-analysed DNA recovered from the scene which led to 68-year-old Mr Sullivan's name being cleared.
RASA Merseyside – short for rape and sexual abuse support – was set up after Ms Sindall's killing to help victims of sexual violence.
Now Josephine Wood from the charity has told the BBC it was approached by several local people who told them police had the wrong man.
However they would not reveal the true identity of her killer to detectives, she added.
'We were told on several occasions that the police had the wrong man,' she said.
'But we didn't have evidence, we didn't have anything to offer, we just knew what we'd been told and the people are adamant that you've got the wrong person.
'But without any evidence, without names, without people willing to come forward which is a really big deal, seriously what could be done?'
Ms Wood said communities in deprived areas around Birkenhead were 'tribal' and 'tight-knit' in the 1980s, making it difficult for people to come forward.
She told the broadcaster that it would be 'really hard' for someone to tell police 'we know who this is' due to the fear of 'repercussions' and 'what might happen'.
'I would like to think that maybe 40 years down the line we can actually now go back to those people and say 'Come on tell us what you know',' she added.
'Tell us what happened, you must feel safer now, you must feel a way that you can come forward, because if this guy hasn't done it somebody else has and we need to find out who that was.'
Former labourer Mr Sullivan was released from Category A Wakefield Prison on Tuesday after finally being exonerated following years of campaigning.
Lawyers have said it was 'completely inappropriate' that the maximum payout the 68-year-old can receive for his decades behind bars and wrongly being dubbed the Beast of Birkenhead stands at £1million.
Yesterday his brother David told MailOnline: 'We are absolutely ecstatic that Peter has been freed but we knew 1000 per cent from the start that he was an innocent man.'
Miss Sindall's van had broken down on her way home from a pub shift and she was walking to a petrol station to get some more fuel.
She had been working late to pay for her forthcoming wedding to David Beattie.
She was ambushed, sexually assaulted and then beaten to death, her body left partially clothed and mutilated in an alleyway where it was discovered the following day.
Mr Sullivan's case was referred to the Court of Appeal by the Criminal Cases Review Commission after samples taken at the time of the murder were re-examined and produced a DNA profile that did not match his.
Mr Sullivan – who has learning difficulties - initially confessed to the murder, before retracting the claims.
Merseyside Police say they are 'proactively trying to identify the person the DNA profile belongs to', saying they believe it 'could be a vital piece of evidence linking the killer to the scene'.
The DNA does not belong to any member of Diane's family, nor her fiancé at the time or hundreds of other men identified during the original investigation, the force has said.
Det Ch Supt Karen Jaundrill, head of investigations at Merseyside Police, told the BBC she wanted people in Birkenhead to 'try and reflect on any individuals that you weren't happy with at the time'.
Appealing for anyone to contact them 'regardless of how insignificant you think the information is', she added: 'It may be that somebody has passed away and you weren't happy with their behaviour at the time and you think they were linked.'
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
BBC News
an hour ago
- BBC News
Avon and Somerset Police join national bike road safety campaign
Motorbike riders have to ride "defensively" because drivers do not look out for them, some have told the highlight these issues with road safety Avon and Somerset Police has joined a national campaign to reduce fatalities on two-wheeled to the force, there have been 28 fatal collisions involving powered two-wheel vehicles since January Tucker, 22, from Somerset said everyone around him always warn him to "go safe - don't push it too hard". "You get some car users who don't see the bikes," he said."It is part of the risk of having a bike - you have to ride quite defensively otherwise you will come to grief."Mykel Brereton, 23, from Watchet who has had a few "near misses" said it is "all great until you need to pull out somewhere"."People don't look out you and think you're small so think they can beat your bike. It's not good at all," he said. Alaistair Lockwood, 24, from Taunton said a "big part of biking" is the "kind" community that looks out for each other."Just don't be another statistic - as long as you're aware that other road users are a hazard to you," he part of the national road safety campaign Avon and Somerset Police said it would take on extra measures including, patrols of high-risk routes and use of drones. Matt Boiles from Avon Somerset Police explained that the campaign is not just "focusing on bikes and prosecuting bikers"."It's about educating the public as a whole to the risks that bikers are exposed to and the risks they expose themselves by their riding," he campaign takes place from 2-15 June.
Daily Mail
an hour ago
- Daily Mail
Terrifying Google search 'killer dad' Travis Decker made before allegedly murdering his three daughters
The dad accused of murdering his three daughters in Washington State searched how to move to Canada just days before they were found dead. Authorities started searching for Travis Decker's children, Paityn, nine, Evelyn, eight, and Olivia, five, after they failed to return home from a scheduled visit with him on May 30. On Monday, the sisters' lifeless bodies were discovered at a campsite in Leavenworth - about 20 miles from their home. Their wrists had been bound with zip ties and each of them had been suffocated with a plastic bag. After finding the girls, investigators 'obtained and served multiple search warrants for records contained in Decker's Google accounts,' leading them to discover that the 32-year-old appeared to be planning how to relocate to Canada, according to an affidavit reviewed by the Independent. In the affidavit, Deputy U.S. Marshal Keegan Stanley wrote that Decker made several searches on May 26, including: 'how does a person move to Canada,' 'how to relocate to Canada' and 'jobs Canada.' The father, who remains on the run, then visited the website 'Find a job - Stanley detailed. His daughters' remains were also found 'relatively close to the Canadian border and approximately 11 miles from the Pacific Crest Trail, a well-established trail that leads directly to Canada,' per the affidavit. Decker, who is wanted on three counts each of first-degree murder and first-degree kidnapping, also 'has training in navigation, woodland/mountainous terrain, long distance movements, survival and numerous other disciplines needed to be able to flee,' the affidavit continued. 'Prior to the above alleged crimes, Decker frequently recreated in outdoor, woodland and mountainous areas throughout the Eastern District of Washington and surrounding states,' it read. 'Amongst other outdoorsman activities, Decker frequently engaged in hiking, camping, survival skill practice, hunting and even lived off the grid in the backwoods for approximately 2.5 months on one occasion.' Decker is also facing an additional federal charge of unlawful flight to avoid prosecution. The charges against him 'are all very serious violent felonies which all carry significant prison sentences if convicted,' the affidavit stated. The legal statement also noted that 'those facing significant prison sentences have a propensity' to run. There is currently a 'very public national campaign to locate Decker' and 'it is publicly known there is a warrant for his arrest,' the affidavit stated. He is considered very dangerous given his extensive military training and propensity for violence. Whitney Decker, the fugitive father's ex-wife and mom of their late daughters, never imagined he might have been on the verge of carrying out a heinous act after he arrived to pick up their girls for a scheduled three-hour visitation last week. To Whitney, it was a routine handoff. But those around Decker expressed to the grieving mother after her daughters did not return home that they had seen the warning signs. According to Whitney's attorney Arianna Cozart, a supervisor at his construction job told Whitney shortly after Travis vanished that he had seemed 'on the brink of something extreme' earlier that day while on the job. Even her ever-reliable neighbor, who Whitney trusted with the messy details of their divorce, recalled that Travis appeared 'very sad' during a brief exchange outside the house just before he abducted them. Yet, as Whitney's lawyer told Daily Mail in an exclusive interview on Thursday, there was nothing in Travis's behavior at the time of the 5pm pickup that raised any red flags. 'She had no reason to suspect anything was wrong,' the attorney said. Whitney did know, however, that he was having a hard week, having crashed his uninsured vehicle days earlier. Travis, who was living in his truck at the time, spent about 15 minutes talking with her, mostly about what to do with his pet dog for the hot summer, wondering if she'd take care of the animal, as she had in the past, or whether he should just give it to the Humane Society. It was only after Travis failed to return with the kids that night did she learn that he'd had some sort of mental health breakdown at his construction job earlier in the day. 'The supervisor told her he was acting like he was on the brink of something extreme on Friday,' Whitney's lawyer said, but said Whitney still doesn't know the specifics Decker did to raise such alarm in his higher-ups. After her daughters were found, Whitney said through her lawyer that she initially begged police to issue an Amber Alert for them but was told the case did not meet the requirements. The grieving mother alleged it 'was a tragedy that could've been completely' avoided had officials intervened. She believes 'something broke inside' of her ex-husband and that he 'would not have done what he did if he was himself', Cozart revealed in a heartbreaking statement early Thursday morning. 'He clearly had some sort of break and everything that he had been living with, everything that had been bottled up inside of him for so long as far as trauma, just won out,' Cozart told the Seattle Times. Following their tragic deaths, a GoFundMe campaign, created by Whitney's friend, has gone on to raise more than $1 million. 'Their light touched so many, and the pain of this loss is immeasurable,' Amy Edwards wrote. Authorities are offering a $20,000 reward for any information leading to Decker's arrest. Police believe he is hiding out in the woods along the Canadian border. Officers have urged locals, specifically those in remote areas of Okanogan County, to lock all doors and windows while he remains at large.
BBC News
2 hours ago
- BBC News
Samantha Murphy death: Suspects bailed as investigation continues
Two men arrested on suspicion of murdering a 32-year-old woman found dead at a house in Portsmouth have been released on Murphy was discovered by police early on Thursday following reports of a body at the property in Wadham 32-year-old men, from Havant and Petersfield, have been released on conditional bail while enquiries continue, Hampshire police previously appealed to trace a gold suitcase which they said could be in the Portsmouth area. You can follow BBC Hampshire & Isle of Wight on Facebook, X (Twitter), or Instagram.
