logo
Disabled driver loses discrimination claim over delay at toll bridge

Disabled driver loses discrimination claim over delay at toll bridge

Irish Times16-05-2025

A disabled driver who made a statutory complaint over being held up for less than two minutes when a toll bridge camera misread his car's number plate has lost his discrimination claim.
The
Workplace Relations Commission
(WRC) has rejected a claim under the Equal Status Act 2000 against North Link M1 Ltd, the operator of the tolled section of the M1 motorway in counties
Meath
and
Louth
.
The claimant, David Tyrell, is a beneficiary of the Disability Toll Exemption Scheme (DTES), which allows adapted vehicles for disabled drivers to use toll roads for free, the WRC heard last month.
On October 2nd, 2024, Mr Tyrell arrived to a toll plaza on the M1 motorway and proceeded into an unmanned lane. His car's registration 'appeared on the screen', but the barrier did not open, he said in evidence.
READ MORE
The control room operator on the day, Louise McMullen, said she asked Mr Tyrell if he had paid because she 'did not know he was exempt'.
When an issue arose, she 'realised there had to be a digit missing' from the registration number captured on the system, and that was why she asked him to call out the number and proceeded to search the plate number on the motor tax system.
Ms McMullen said this took a minute to do.
She acknowledged that she did tell him: 'If you use the operator lanes in the future, it'll be quicker.'
Mr Tyrell's position was that he 'should be allowed to use unmanned toll lanes just as non-disabled drivers do'. He also contended that he should not have had to speak with the worker about his status as a beneficiary of the toll exemption scheme as it meant disclosing his disability to his passenger, he said.
Sinead Morgan of DAC Beachcroft, appearing for the toll operator, submitted that the DTES guidelines advised pass-holders to use a manned lane so that if a registration plate was misread by the system, 'a staff member can quickly see a DTES disc and lift the barrier without any questions being asked'. Mr Tyrell accepted under cross-examination that he had not read the DTES guidelines.
Adjudicator Emile Daly accepted Mr Tyrell 'did not know all this' in regard to how the system worked and that that he believed discrimination was at play when he took his claim.

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

SUVs with high bonnets ‘clear threat' to pedestrians, study finds
SUVs with high bonnets ‘clear threat' to pedestrians, study finds

Irish Times

time3 hours ago

  • Irish Times

SUVs with high bonnets ‘clear threat' to pedestrians, study finds

The height of Irish car bonnets is increasing every year, putting pedestrians' lives at risk, a new study has found. The report by Transport & Environment (T&E), a Brussels based advocacy group on sustainable transport, found that the average bonnet height of newly-sold cars in Ireland rose from 77.38cm in 2011 to 83.67cm in 2024. Ireland is 'very similar to the European average', which stood at 83.8cm in 2024, a representative from T&E said. When bonnet heights rise from 80cm to 90cm, it raises the risk of death by 27 per cent for road users such as pedestrians and cyclists, the report states, citing 2023 data from a Belgian road safety institute . READ MORE T&E also commissioned tests from Loughborough University in the UK to examine the risks to children from SUVs with high bonnets. It found that a driver of a Land Rover Defender is not able to see a child aged up to 4½, based on average height, at the front of the vehicle. High bonnets also compromise a driver's vision at junctions, which can increase crashes, particularly when turning, the study found. It describes the rising heights as a 'clear and growing threat to public safety, especially for children'. Asked about the findings, the director of Ireland's Medical Bureau of Road Safety Denis Cusack said that, while he had yet to consider the report, he was aware of the dangers that vehicles with high bonnets can have. He stressed the importance of having maximum speed limits in residential areas, saying that 'if children are out playing, the driver's up higher, so they've got to be very careful'. [ Sorry, kids. We blew your climate budget - but we really love our SUVs Opens in new window ] Dr Cusack said 'unlike an adult, who may end up being hit somewhere on the leg', a child 'could end up being hit, depending on their height, on the abdomen, the tummy, the chest, or even the head'. T&E has called on European lawmakers to cap bonnet heights by 2035. They are recommending a maximum height of 85cm for bonnets on new cars from 2035, subject to further study. There is no legal limit to bonnet heights in Europe. The organisation has also called on national governments to put higher vehicle and road taxes on bigger cars.

Driving testers working evenings, weekends and bank holidays to clear backlog, RSA says
Driving testers working evenings, weekends and bank holidays to clear backlog, RSA says

Irish Times

time4 hours ago

  • Irish Times

Driving testers working evenings, weekends and bank holidays to clear backlog, RSA says

The Road Safety Authority (RSA) is 'steadfast in its dedication' to lower the average waiting time for a driving test to 10 weeks by September, its chief executive told the Oireachtas Committee on Transport this morning. Sam Waide recognised the 'ongoing frustration' felt by the public on this issue and said it 'is not a situation that any of us consider acceptable'. Last week, the average waiting time to secure a test was 19.7 weeks, a slight drop from a May figure of 20.6 weeks, itself a notable decrease from 27 weeks in April this year. Recognising this goal as 'ambitious', he and fellow RSA representatives said they were 'very confident' it would be achieved due to the 'largest ever recruitment exercise in the history of the RSA' since its foundation in 2006. READ MORE [ About 600 learners fail to show for driving tests each month – RSA Opens in new window ] With a recruitment drive that aims to have 200 trained testers working full-time by September, an increase from the current figure of 152, testers have also been working extended hours and across different testing centres. RSA chief operations officer Brendan Walsh said testers are now working evenings and weekends, including bank holidays. He said 700 driving tests took place on the Monday of the June bank holiday weekend. They 'are working under significant pressure', however, the goal to increase supply is 'not just a target but a national imperative for the RSA', Mr Waide said. The organisation conducted 157,183 driving tests in 2021, which rose to 253,850 in 2024. Mr Waide cited growing population, delayed demand from the pandemic , and lack of rural public transport as causes for this 61 per cent increase. The RSA will soon be in a position to accommodate up to 360,000 tests a year, Fine Gael TD Michael Murphy said, when accounting for each tester conducting up to eight tests a day. Mr Murphy said 'we should be able to bring the waiting list significantly lower' than 10 weeks under these circumstances. However, Mr Walsh said 'I don't think it would be right from a driver education perspective [ ...] for someone to get a test in a week'. Fellow Fine Gael TD Emer Currie said people continuously not attending their driving test appointments is an 'extremely serious issue' which affects the availability of tests for others. [ Driving test logjam: how to beat the long waiting times Opens in new window ] Mr Walshe said 56,000 people are 'on three or more [learner's] permits' after failing to show up for their test, with 'a handful' of drivers on more than 10. Three hundred and seventy thousand people have a learner's permit in Ireland currently. The RSA also holds responsibility for the National Care Testing (NCT) service. The average national waiting time for an NCT assessment was 14 days last week, however the RSA expects to lower this to 12 days by the end of this month. There are currently 50 NCT testing centres across the State, with 'expansion to additional locations actively under way'.

New car owners increasingly opting for electric or hybrid over petrol or diesel
New car owners increasingly opting for electric or hybrid over petrol or diesel

Irish Times

time7 hours ago

  • Irish Times

New car owners increasingly opting for electric or hybrid over petrol or diesel

The popularity of electric vehicles (EVs) and plug-in hybrid electric vehicles continued last month as sales rose 12 per cent and 35 per cent respectively compared with the same period last year, new data from the Central Statistics Office (CSO) shows. The total number of new private cars licensed in May fell by 16 per cent from 10,055 to 8,403. The number of used cars licensed increased by 10 per cent from 5,592 to 6,144 over the same period. The number of new EVs licensed in May rose by 12 per cent from 1,234 to 1,382. This means the share of EVs among new private cars from January to May was 16 per cent compared with 13 per cent in the same period of last year. The number of new plug-in hybrid electric vehicles licensed grew by 35 per cent from 1,055 to 1,419. READ MORE Comparing the first five months of the year, the number of new electric cars licensed has increased 26 per cent from 9,458 to 11,877, while the number of new plug-in hybrid electric vehicles licensed increased by 74 per cent, from 6,300 to 10,988 over the same period. This increased the year-to-date share of plug-in hybrid electric vehicles among new private cars to 15 per cent from 9 per cent. [ EV Q&A: Why doesn't Ireland use roadside furniture for charging electric vehicles? Opens in new window ] The combined share of petrol and diesel cars among new private cars licensed from January to May has fallen to 44 per cent from 56 per cent last year. From January to May, some 19,717 new cars licensed were petrol compared with 24,009 in the same period of 2024, a fall of 18 per cent. Comparing the first five months of 2025 with 2024, the number of new diesel cars licensed fell by 26 per cent to 12,485 from 16,772. The data also shows that Volkswagen was the most popular make of new private car licensed in May at 1,405 vehicles, followed by Toyota (1,020), Hyundai (701), Kia (675) and Skoda (674). Together, these five makes represented more than half (53 per cent) of all new private cars licensed in the month. The most popular brand of new electric car licensed in May was Hyundai Getz (104), followed by Volkswagen ID.4 (92), and Skoda Elroq (64).

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store