logo
In Menendez Brothers' Case, a Reckoning With the 1990s

In Menendez Brothers' Case, a Reckoning With the 1990s

New York Times15-05-2025

After Lyle and Erik Menendez were resentenced on Tuesday, paving the way for their possible release after more than three decades in prison, one of the first things their lawyer, Mark J. Geragos, did was make a phone call.
Leslie Abramson, the brothers' defense attorney at their trials in the 1990s who found herself parodied on 'Saturday Night Live,' had in recent years warned Mr. Geragos that his efforts to free the brothers were doomed, in spite of the groundswell of support on social media.
'No amount of TikTokers,' he recalled Ms. Abramson telling him, 'was ever going to change anything.'
Facing the bank of television cameras staking out the courthouse, Mr. Geragos told reporters he had just left a message for his old friend.
'And so, Leslie, I will tell you it's a whole different world we live in now,' he said. He continued, 'We have evolved. This is not the '90s anymore.'
Indeed, over the last many months, the culture and politics of 1990s America seemed as much under the legal microscope as the horrific details of the Menendez brothers' crimes and what witnesses described as the exemplary lives they led in prison ever since.
At times, putting that decade on trial felt like a legal strategy by the brothers' lawyers. In court, Mr. Geragos often invoked the criminal justice policies of the era — three-strikes laws, punitive long sentences and a rising prison population — to argue that under today's mores the brothers merited a second chance. During his closing argument at Tuesday's hearing, Mr. Geragos described the time as a 'crazy, collective, lock-em-up-and-throw-away-the-key mentality we had.'
When the brothers stormed into the den of their family's Beverly Hills mansion in the summer of 1989 and shotgunned their parents to death, Los Angeles was on the cusp of a tumultuous era. By the time the brothers went on trial for the first time, in 1993, the city was still reeling from the deadly riots that followed the acquittal of the police officers in the Rodney King case.
The first trial was one of the first to be televised gavel to gavel to a national audience and foreshadowed the public's obsession with the O.J. Simpson trial, and the explosion of true-crime programming today. The brothers were tried together but each with their own juries, which heard the brothers' assertions that they had been molested by their father and had killed out of fear. Neither jury could reach a verdict, so a mistrial was declared.
By the time their second trial began, just after the acquittal of Mr. Simpson in 1995, the judge changed the rules, banning cameras in the courtroom and limiting testimony about sexual abuse. The changes were seen at the time as a reaction to the acquittals of Mr. Simpson and the officers in the Rodney King case, which had embarrassed law enforcement officials. (Years later a federal appeals court judge suggested that the rules were unfairly changed to improve the chances of a conviction.)
Without being able to consider a lesser charge of manslaughter, as the jurors in the first trial could, the brothers were convicted of murder and sentenced to life without parole.
'It was clear politics had a major impact on the second trial,' said Robert Rand, who has covered the case since 1989 and has written the book, 'The Menendez Murders.' 'Because the D.A.'s office had suffered a string of major high-profile case defeats.'
How popular culture treated the story, regularly mocking the brothers as spoiled kids who invented the claims of sexual abuse and killed for their inheritance, regularly came up in court during the resentencing process.
'It has been a relentless examination of our family in the public eye,' said Anamaria Baralt, a cousin who testified on the Menendez brothers' behalf and spoke about their being 'the butt of every joke' on 'Saturday Night Live' and other late-night shows in the 1990s. 'It has been a nightmare.'
Another cousin, Tamara Lucero Goodell, said the vilification of late-night talk show hosts, like Jay Leno, left her 'incredibly private' and 'closed off.'
Mr. Rand said he was one of the few reporters at the time who took the sexual abuse claims seriously. 'I was dating another reporter who was covering the case, and she would tell me that the other reporters covering the trial were ridiculing me behind my back because I was going on Donahue and Oprah and these '90s TV shows and saying I believed Lyle and Erik Menendez,' he said.
Today, the media landscape looks very different, and the brothers have arguably benefited from that new landscape. Two shows on Netflix last year helped inject momentum into a slow-moving legal process, and new interest in the brothers' fate was fueled by campaigns on TikTok and other social media by younger people who felt the brothers were mistreated in the 1990s.
Last fall, George Gascón, then the district attorney of Los Angeles, filed a petition asking a court to resentence the brothers. But Mr. Gascón, who had come into office promising to unwind many of the policies of the 1990s by focusing on rehabilitation and less punitive sentences, lost his re-election bid to Nathan Hochman, a former federal prosecutor.
Mr. Hochman is a more traditional prosecutor, emphasizing the rights of victims and taking a tougher line on sentencing. He came out against the resentencing of the brothers, saying they had not demonstrated 'full insight' into their crimes.
In court, Mr. Geragos has called the prosecutors ''90s Neanderthals.' In an interview with NewsNation, he said that Mr. Hochman 'was elected because the '90s were calling, and they wanted their D.A.'s office back.'
One of the witnesses who testified in support of resentencing was Jonathan Colby, a retired judge from Florida who has worked with the brothers inside prison training puppies to work with wounded combat veterans and autistic children. Mr. Colby said that, as a judge overseeing criminal cases in the 1990s, he was a law-and-order judge who almost always imposed the toughest sentence possible. 'Unfortunately, I was proud of that,' he said.
He said that his association with the brothers changed his mind about the role of prison, and hoped that, if they were to be released, he could work with them to educate judges about the possibilities of rehabilitation. 'I never thought prisons were capable, or prisoners were capable, of rehabilitating themselves,' he said.
After California's prisons became so overcrowded during the 1990s, a U.S. Supreme Court decision ordering the state to reduce its inmate count led to a series of legislative reforms, including the resentencing law that allowed the brothers to have their case reconsidered in court.
When the brothers said they had killed because they had been sexually abused by their father, prosecutors and some in the media treated the claims with skepticism. (At trial a prosecutor said, 'Men cannot be raped since they lack the necessary equipment to actually be raped.')
'If they were the Menendez sisters they wouldn't be sitting here,' Mr. Geragos said in court, pointing to the brothers who appeared on a screen from prison, wearing blue jumpsuits.
When Lyle Menendez arrived in state prison in 1996 after his conviction, he said that one of the things that boosted his spirits during that dark time was the number of sexual abuse victims who sent him letters.
'I received a lot of ridicule in the '90s about it but also a lot of support, and a lot of victims reaching out, appreciating that, and finding their voice through mine,' Lyle Menendez said on a recent podcast interview with TMZ.
Last fall, as efforts to free the brothers gathered momentum following the release of a Netflix series from the producer Ryan Murphy, Gov. Gavin Newsom weighed in, saying on his podcast, 'I think our parents would remember Manson as an indelible thing. But for us, I think it was O.J. and the Menendez brothers, which were so much a part of the narrative of our lives.'
After Judge Michael V. Jesic said on Tuesday that he would reduce the brothers' sentences, making them immediately eligible for parole, and that the case was now in the hands of the governor. Governor Newsom has said he would also consider clemency.
'No doubt what Ryan Murphy did with this series really lit things up,' Mr. Newsom said on his podcast last year. 'I think social media has lit things up. I don't know about you, but I'll tell you, I can't even tell you how many times my kids online have said, 'Hey, what's going on with the Menendez brothers?''

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Brooklyn home that appeared in multiple shows asks $2.99M
Brooklyn home that appeared in multiple shows asks $2.99M

New York Post

timean hour ago

  • New York Post

Brooklyn home that appeared in multiple shows asks $2.99M

In Brooklyn's Ditmas Park, one home has taken center stage, stealing the spotlight again, again — and again. A wraparound-porch-clad Victorian at 500 E. 18th St. isn't just a showstopper — it's a frequent scene-stealer, appearing in more television and film credits than some of the actors who have shot there. Now listed for $2.99 million with Heather McMaster of Corcoran, the cinematic stunner is hitting the market after a decades-long real-life renovation story nearly as dramatic as the scenes it has hosted. 19 In Brooklyn's Ditmas Park, a grand Victorian home that has doubled as a beloved television and film set is now for sale at $2.99 million. Russ Ross for Corcoran 19 The property has been featured in multiple productions. Russ Ross for Corcoran From 'Saturday Night Live' to 'Boardwalk Empire' to 'Blue Bloods,' the six-bedroom dwelling has become a go-to for location scouts seeking old New York charm in the middle of the borough. 'Ditmas Park is actually quite famous for people filming out here because our homes are so large that they can do several locations in one spot,' said homeowner Dana Vance, who, along with husband Frank Gauthier, has owned — and painstakingly restored — the home since 1994. Set on one of the neighborhood's most picturesque blocks, the home boasts an ornate façade with spindle-trimmed gables and stained glass. Its porch alone has earned its share of screen time — Hugh Grant filmed a night scene on it for 'The Rewrite,' opposite J.K. Simmons, though Vance, 72, said, 'I love Hugh Grant, but I didn't get to meet him because they shot it at like 2 o'clock in the morning … I was so mad at myself because I couldn't stay awake.' 19 Known for its cinematic appeal — thanks to its expansive layout, ornate woodwork, stained glass and storybook wraparound porch — the home has become a sought-after location for directors looking to capture old New York charm. Russ Ross for Corcoran 19 Homeowners Dana Vance and Frank Gauthier, both actors, inherited the property in 1994 in a state of complete disrepair after Frank's reclusive cousin, Bill, passed away. Courtesy of Dana Vance Built in 1910, the house stayed in Gauthier's family for three generations, but fell into disrepair when a reclusive relative lived alone there for decades. 'He had no plumbing, no heat, no air conditioning. Fifty windows in the house, 28 were broken. Pigeons were living on the third floor,' Vance said. 'There were 10,000 pounds of newspapers, twigs, aluminum pipes, a piano, garbage cans collecting rainwater. It was a complete disaster.' When that relative, named Bill, passed away, the house was on the verge of demolition — until Vance, seeing potential through the wreckage, convinced Gauthier not to sell. 'I said, 'Oh, I think we're gonna fix this house up. I think it's got great bones,'' she said. 'And he thought I was completely crazy. And to tell you the truth, I was, because I had no idea what work was in front of me.' 19 The couple often remained in the house during filming, retreating to the top floor while scenes played out below. Image Entertainment 19 At the time, the house had no plumbing or heat, broken windows, pigeon infestations and was packed with decades of hoarded debris. Courtesy of Corcoran 19 Vance saw potential where others might have walked away, convincing Gauthier to renovate rather than sell. Courtesy of Corcoran What followed was a years-long gut renovation fueled by maxed-out credit cards, a single affordable contractor and the couple's own elbow grease. 'We took out probably well over 500 garbage bags,' Vance said. 'It was a labor of love and I view that house as if it's a part of me … every piece of wood, every pillar, [the] wainscoting.' Today, the result is a blend of restored craftsmanship and functional luxury. Inside, the home is flooded with natural light thanks to oversize windows — including a statement stained-glass pane on the main stair landing. Original mahogany doors, intricate woodwork and custom-designed oak floors with mahogany inlays run throughout. 19 What followed was a decades-long restoration project — one they took on themselves with limited resources and limitless perseverance. Russ Ross for Corcoran 19 Today, the home is filled with carefully restored original details, including oak floors with mahogany inlay. Russ Ross for Corcoran 19 A formal dining room wrapped in vintage wallpaper. Russ Ross for Corcoran The gracious living room, anchored by one of two woodburning fireplaces, opens into a formal dining room wrapped in vintage wallpaper and crowned by a statement chandelier. The updated eat-in kitchen overlooks one of the largest private backyards in the district. Upstairs, the primary suite boasts a bay window, a fireplace and even a built-in marble sink in its adjacent sitting room — a remnant of the home's turn-of-the-century design. 'It's lovely,' Vance said. 'It's got the little sinks in the bedrooms and beautiful mahogany doors, broom closets and linen closets that you don't see in a regular house.' Still, it's the home's distinctive character and ample space that has made it a favorite for film and TV production crews, who can move through its sprawling three floors and outdoor areas with ease. 19 The kitchen. Russ Ross for Corcoran 19 A breakfast nook. Russ Ross for Corcoran 19 One of the largest backyards in the district. Russ Ross for Corcoran 'There was a location scout that came by one day, maybe about 18 years ago … they take pictures, go to several houses, then bring back a team of like 10 people to scout it again,' Vance said. 'We have one of the largest backyards in Ditmas Park, and that served us. And we have a big wraparound porch, so those little things are interesting to film directors.' The house has since also played host to productions ranging from CBS dramas like 'The Equalizer.' But perhaps the most widely recognized appearance came courtesy of a viral 2014 'SNL' skit, 'Back Home Ballers,' that has garnered more than 14 million views over the years. 19 The dwelling starred in 'The Rewrite.' Image Entertainment 19 A scene from 'Back Home Ballers' on 'SNL.' NBC 19 The home's cinematic legacy has been built organically, one shoot at a time — thanks in part to its grand proportions and authentic historic charm. NBC 'I met all the girls from 'Saturday Night Live' and Cameron Diaz,' Vance said. 'They turned our living room into a discotheque … their green room was our bedroom. I took pictures with all of them. It was really great.' Though the couple often stays in the home during shoots, they make way for the crew when necessary. 'Sometimes the crew is so large that I just go to the third floor … and then we hear them go, 'cut,' and then we can go downstairs and grab a snack and go back upstairs again,' Vance said. Watching their home on screen remains a rush. 'A lot of the location scouts or the ADs will call and tell me when it's going to be aired. And I'm so thrilled to see either the front of my house … or the living room, and family will call and say, 'Is your house on 'The Equalizer?'' But after 30 years of loving care and on-screen cameos, the couple has decided it's time for a new act. 'We're old. We're seniors now, and it's time to move on,' Vance said. 'It's 3,400 square feet, just the interior — not counting the attic and the basement … When you're young, it's very easy. It's still easy for us now, but I can see myself huffing and puffing every once in a while.' The couple — both actors, now retired — plans to relocate out of state. 'Frank and I will always be New Yorkers. We love New York with all our heart. But we've done New York,' she said. 'We're looking for a new adventure.' 19 A sun-filled primary suite with a fireplace and a bay window. Russ Ross for Corcoran 19 A third-floor living space. Russ Ross for Corcoran 19 One of 2.5 bathrooms. Russ Ross for Corcoran As they prepare to say goodbye, Vance admits it's an emotional parting. 'I've been talking to the house this whole time, letting the house know how much I loved it … I hug the staircase or hug something and just say, 'Thank you. Thank you. Thank you so much.'' One visiting contractor may have said it best. 'He told me, 'You will find that once you start working on a house like this, it will not let you work on it. It will resist you until it knows that you have its best interests at heart.' And it's true,' Vance said. That same character — the kind that can't be fabricated on a soundstage — has kept filmmakers coming back, and may now captivate a new buyer. As Vance put it, 'If they appreciate it half as much as we do, then I'll be satisfied.'

Tina Fey and Kelli O'Hara honored at Trinity Rep's Pell Awards for lifetime achievement in the arts
Tina Fey and Kelli O'Hara honored at Trinity Rep's Pell Awards for lifetime achievement in the arts

Boston Globe

time3 hours ago

  • Boston Globe

Tina Fey and Kelli O'Hara honored at Trinity Rep's Pell Awards for lifetime achievement in the arts

Advertisement Several of the speakers and other guests at the event, which raised nearly $400,000 for Trinity Rep's artistic, education, and community engagement programming, shared how programs funded by the Get Globe Rhode Island Food Club A weekly newsletter about food and dining in Rhode Island, by Globe Rhode Island reporter Alexa Gagosz. Enter Email Sign Up 'I am concerned that the arts will be an afterthought as opposed to being one of the most important things we can do,' said actor and Rhode Island resident Related : Advertisement Longtime Trinity Rep supporter Bank of America recently made a $3 million commitment to the theater company, which was announced during the gala. The gift includes $2.75 million to support the Curt Columbus, Trinity Rep's artistic director, said, 'When you live in a country that is undergoing the kind of repression that we're seeing, the arts are more necessary than they have ever been.' Providence lawyer Arlene Violet, who once served as the state's attorney general, said she wanted to attend Tuesday night's gala to show her support for the arts in general, and more specifically, Trinity Rep. 'Places like Trinity Rep will continue to educate the heart, souls, and consciences of theatergoers,' she said. 'And without question, the arts are under attack. I think the president is trying to While accepting her award, Fey told those in attendance that she started her career directing children's theater in her hometown in Pennsylvania. 'We really served our community,' she said. Fey was critical of Trump, making jokes about him and his administration and pretending she was receiving repeated news alerts on her phone: 'The White House has declared Juneteenth canceled – we're just going back to Shark Week.' 'RFK Jr. says hurricanes likely caused by vaccines; we will have a hurricane cure by the weekend.' 'They just keep coming. Breaking news: All new music must emphasize beats one and three. Any syncopated rhythm will be considered DEI.' 'Also, the Russians have a Trump/Musk tape.' 'OK, the Trump/Musk tape has been debunked.' Fey ended her 'news flash' jokes with a clear crowd favorite: 'Trump just ate a Tide pod. It's going to be OK. His doctor said he ate it better than anyone had ever eaten a Tide pod, and the chemicals in it may cause him to live forever,' a joke that elicited prolonged laughter from the audience. Advertisement Fey, 55, who wore a pale pink pantsuit and white crew-neck shirt, was introduced by Kate Liberman, Trinity Rep's executive director, who shared a video message sent by Fey's friend, collaborator, and fellow 'Saturday Night Live' alum Amy Poehler, who joked that everyone at the event should look under their seats because one has the keys to a new car, courtesy of Fey. The 'Mean Girls' creator said she has worked in 'difficult eras' before, including performing on 'Saturday Night Live' just three weeks after the September 11, 2001, attacks. 'There was a time that we thought 'oh, maybe we can never do comedy again. Maybe it's not appropriate for us to ever laugh again' and it turned out that really, all it took was Will Ferrell in an American flag Speedo to be able to unite the country,' she joked. 'People love to ask me, 'Is it OK to be writing comedy right now?' And I say not only can we, we must,' Fey said. 'Humor is a vehicle for delivering truth. Humor is what will keep us tethered to our sanity through these dark times.' Related : Two-time Tony winner Judith Ivey, a longtime friend and mentor of O'Hara's, introduced her by singing a clever and amusing reworked version of 'Maria' from 'The Sound of Music,' that was all about O'Hara. Wearing a floor-length, spaghetti-strap forest green-hued floral dress, O'Hara said she was honored to receive the award, and promised those in attendance that she will do everything in her power 'to continue to make the world better through the arts' – even if it's just making someone's life 'a little better each time I sing a song or say something that I mean from my heart.' Advertisement 'I'll receive this tonight with such gratitude and such humility because I am determined to be worthy of it for the rest of my life,' said O'Hara, 49, who is touring the country with fellow Tony Award-winning actor Sutton Foster in full symphony concerts, including a O'Hara, who won a Tony Award in 2015 for best actress in a musical for her performance in a revival of 'The King and I,' shared with the audience that while growing up in a small town in Western Oklahoma, she and her family benefited from Trinity Rep established the Pell Awards in 1997 to honor artists whose careers exemplify the values of the late US Senator Claiborne Pell, a staunch champion of the arts and one of the principal founders of the National Endowment for the Arts. O'Hara and Fey join a long list of distinguished performers who have received the award, including last year's recipient,

Scarlett Johansson Says Dating Men Outside of Hollywood Caused 'Jealousy' Since Actors Get 'Very Intimate'
Scarlett Johansson Says Dating Men Outside of Hollywood Caused 'Jealousy' Since Actors Get 'Very Intimate'

Yahoo

time5 hours ago

  • Yahoo

Scarlett Johansson Says Dating Men Outside of Hollywood Caused 'Jealousy' Since Actors Get 'Very Intimate'

NEED TO KNOW Scarlett Johansson discussed strains in relationships with people who don't work as actors "I've had serious relationships with people that were not in the industry, and I found one of the challenges was that the person had no idea of what I needed to do my job," she said Johansson is married to Saturday Night Live's Colin Jost, and she was previously married to Ryan Reynolds and Romain Dauriac Scarlett Johansson is reflecting on relationship strains caused by dating someone outside the entertainment industry. During Johansson's Interview magazine conversation with Stranger Things and Thunderbolts* star David Harbour published on Tuesday, June 10, the actors discussed their proclivities toward dating actors and artists rather than "normal people," as Harbour, 50, put it. Advertisement "I've had serious relationships with people that were not in the industry, and I found one of the challenges was that the person had no idea of what I needed to do my job," said Johansson, 40. "Obviously, if I was dating an oncologist, I wouldn't know what they needed to do for their job. But it's not so abstract." Johansson shares son Cosmo, 3, with husband Colin Jost and daughter Rose, 10, with ex-husband Romain Dauriac. She also noted that romantic relationships between actors and those who do not work in entertainment sometimes see tensions rise due to the nature of actors' jobs. "I also think it's easy to create a lot of jealousy when a person is not involved in the industry, because actors by nature are very free-spirited and they create very intimate relationships with people at work," she said. "They can be loyal to a partner and also very engaged in all these other kinds of relationships, and I think it can be a blurry line for some people." Dave Benett/Getty Scarlett Johansson and Colin Jost on May 21, 2025 Scarlett Johansson and Colin Jost on May 21, 2025 Never miss a story — sign up for PEOPLE's free daily newsletter to stay up-to-date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer​​, from celebrity news to compelling human interest stories "Also, to have a relationship with the public can be a complicated thing for people outside of the industry to understand," Johansson added. Advertisement Prior to marrying Saturday Night Live star Jost in 2020, Johansson was married to French journalist and art dealer Dauriac, 43, from 2014 to 2017. She was also married to Ryan Reynolds from 2008 to 2011. Jamie McCarthy/WireImage Scarlett Johansson on May 28, 2025 Scarlett Johansson on May 28, 2025 "When I'm working, and you're probably like this too, I'm pretty hermetic," Johansson told Harbour during the Interview conversation. "If I'm in a town, I like to go to the little restaurant and movie theater, but I don't like a lot of variation. I like things to be, I don't want to say rigorous, but you want a routine." Johansson and Jost recently appeared together at the 2025 Cannes Film Festival in support of Johansson's directorial debut Eleanor the Great. She most recently appeared on the big screen in Wes Anderson's The Phoenician Scheme, and will star in Jurassic World Rebirth, in theaters July 2. Read the original article on People

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store