logo
Isla Bryson demands to be moved back to female jail after slamming court ruling

Isla Bryson demands to be moved back to female jail after slamming court ruling

Daily Record11 hours ago

Despite the sex offender admitting that life in male jails has meant being able to forge romantic relationships with male prisoners, Bryson says a challenge of the legal ruling could see a move from the male estate.
Isla Bryson has slammed a court ruling on biological sex and demanded to be moved back to a female prison.
The convicted double rapist, born Adam Graham, began to identify as a woman called Isla while awaiting trial for rape.
The case caused political waves after the rapist was sent to female jail Cornton Vale before then FM Nicola Sturgeon announced a switch to all-male HMP Edinburgh and later HMP Glenochil.
In April, the Supreme Court ruled a woman is defined by biological sex under equalities law and the Scottish Government is facing calls to move all biological men out of women's jails.
The decision came after feminist group For Women Scotland (FWS) challenged the Scottish Government's 2018 ruling that transgender women could be included as female in laws requiring 50/50 representation on public boards.
Bryson backs plans by Victoria McCloud, the UK's only judge to ever publicly say they are transgender, to challenge the government at the European Court of Human Rights over the ruling and plans her own appeal there.
Despite the sex offender admitting last week that life in male jails has meant being able to forge romantic relationships with male prisoners, Bryson says a challenge of the legal ruling could see a move from the male estate.
Speaking to the Sunday Mail in a phone call from jail, Bryson said: 'No matter what you think or how you look at it, trans women will always be women.
"Even if you don't agree with it, then that's your opinion. We are not going to go away. Sooner or later judges will have to put trans women back in women's prisons because if they don't, trans women have the right to take it to the ­European court and they will.
'If they win and the courts say women have to go to women's prisons, I will probably get moved to a women's prison.'
After the outcry over Bryson, trans prisoners faced a move to male jails but prison chiefs opted to let them stay if they had not shown violence to women.
However, Alba MSP Ash Regan said: 'The perversity of a double rapist demanding access to women's prisons sums up why we must end this dangerous ­experiment of gender ideology eroding sex-based rights – male entitlement masquerading as rights must never be at the expense of women's safety, dignity and consent.
'Eight weeks after the Supreme Court ruling, ministers dither while lobbyists stoke the mis-information they helped create.
'Now even Isla Bryson/Adam Graham – the double rapist who shocked the nation – joins a small but vocal chorus in demanding the law be overturned to allow him access to a woman's jail.
'If this is not the wake-up call needed for John Swinney's ­government, then a third first minister may be sacrificed on the altar of gender ideology.'
Scottish Tory shadow minister for victims Sharon Dowey said: 'These abhorrent comments from a double rapist will anger Scots. Not only is this call deeply insulting to his victims, it also highlights how the SNP's gender self-ID policy has become so embedded in ­Scotland's justice system.'
FWS's Susan Smith said: 'For all the activists and politicians who've been trying to undermine the Supreme Court ruling and claim this about walking groups and toilets, this intervention from a notorious double rapist highlights it is vulnerable women whose safety would be threatened by any challenge or change to the law.'
The Scottish Prison Service said it had received the Supreme Court ruling and is 'considering any potential impact it may have'.
The Scottish Government said it 'has been clear that we accept the Supreme Court judgement'.

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Labour peer George Foulkes calls for second Holyrood chamber
Labour peer George Foulkes calls for second Holyrood chamber

The National

timean hour ago

  • The National

Labour peer George Foulkes calls for second Holyrood chamber

George Foulkes, who has previously served as an MP and MSP, said that an assessment of how the Scottish Parliament works is 'long overdue'. Writing in the Scotsman, Lord Foulkes of Cumnock said that Holyrood is 'not living up to the hopes and expectations' of Donald Dewar, Scotland's inaugural first minister, and John Smith, the former labour leader, who he described as its 'architects'. He claimed that Holyrood committees have 'largely failed' as a check on the Scottish Government. READ MORE: UK jets being sent to the Middle East as Keir Starmer refuses to rule out defending Israel 'This situation is compounded by the absence of a second chamber in Scotland, which could revise, improve and very occasionally throw out defective legislation,' Foulkes wrote. He reiterated his long-standing opposition to Scottish politicians 'pontificating on global crises, which Scotland has no chance of resolving', and claimed the SNP is unwilling to 'seriously engage with the current devolution framework'. After calling for tunnels to be built between Scotland's islands, Foulkes, who was made a Labour peer in 2005, criticised the SNP's 'centralisation' of services such as police and fire services. 'We need to look at greater devolution across Scotland - possibly creating new democratic institutions, such as mayors - to bring power closer to the people,' Foulkes said. 'And finally, we come to Holyrood itself. A major review is long overdue and should be prioritised by whichever government comes next. (Image: PA) 'Some key questions which need answered, include - would another electoral system be better? Is there a case for a second chamber? Should there be a limit on the size of the executive? And do MSPs privileges and the role of the Presiding Officer need to be reviewed? 'I am sure that there are many more issues that others would want to look at, but I doubt if there are many now who disagree with the need for change. 'Indeed, sadly, an Abolish Holyrood movement is growing, with the threat to stand candidates for list seats next year. 'To rescue Holyrood, people need to see that their money is being spent wisely and effectively, especially since we have decided to impose higher tax rates than in other parts of the country.' SNP MSP Kenneth Gibson responded to Foulkes' comments, telling The National: "Lord Foulkes wanting a second chamber in Holyrood is bold from someone who sits in an unelected, unaccountable retirement home for Westminster politicians." READ MORE: Ian Murray 'does not understand how devolution works', minister says Last year, Foulkes attacked Scottish Government spending and said there should be 'consequences' for the SNP if it is deemed there is spending in reserved areas. He has long called for the Scottish Government to be prevented from spending in areas such as independence and foreign engagement. Labour have repeatedly said they would abolish the House of Lords, but after coming to power in Westminster following the General Election, instead abolished the 92 seats reserved for peers who are there by right of birth, known as hereditary peers. In a National investigation in 2021, we revealed that Scottish peers had claimed a 'grotesque' £1 million in expenses during the pandemic. Foulkes topped the list for the biggest claim of combined allowance and expenses with £64,643, and for the highest daily allowance alone at £55,936, between April 2020 and July 2021.

Early release scheme being examined
Early release scheme being examined

Edinburgh Reporter

timean hour ago

  • Edinburgh Reporter

Early release scheme being examined

Thousands of justice sector workers are being quizzed over the impact of The Scottish Government's prisoner early release scheme. Police officers, prison and probation staff, along with courts and tribunal, government and youth justice workers are being asked for their views on how well the scheme is working after scores of offenders – including violent criminals – had their sentences reduced in a bid to cut prison overcrowding. The prisoner early release scheme survey is being carried out among justice sector staff to quantify the impact on workloads, effectiveness, stress levels and pressure demands after hundreds of convicts were granted early release. Skills for Justice, a UK Government quango, wants to hear from workers directly involved to 'gauge how service demand and workloads across the justice system have been affected' and what could be improved as a result. They say: 'The views of staff in policing, prisons, probation and more will be sought in order to explore how service demand and workloads have changed since the intervention and what may be improved in terms of workforce planning and training to help support them in their roles.' Justice workers are being asked if they have personally experienced increased workload or demands, as well as if they feel additional training such as safety and security would help them to do their jobs more effectively. They are also asked if they would welcome the introduction of a 'points based system' to replace the current automatic early release scheme. Separately, a recent poll by Survation found a majority of Scots were against the early release of prisoners with 50% opposed and almost 30% 'strongly' opposed. Only 28% of respondents were in favour of the policy with just 8% strongly supporting it. While the early release scheme was intended to address overcrowding it has faced criticism over its impact on public safety and rehabilitation, with some arguing the policy is a 'quick fix' rather than a long-term solution to overcrowded jails. The scheme involves prisoners sentenced to less than four years in jail with fewer than 180 days still to serve. Some 477 were released early last summer and another 390 freed in three tranches earlier this year. It emerged in September that the prison population was already higher than before the early release scheme kicked in. Association of Scottish Police Superintendents – President Rob Hay The Association of Scottish Police Superintendents (ASPS) has been among the scheme's harshest critics. ASPS's president Chief Superintendent Rob Hay says: 'We have grave concerns about the early release of prisoners back into Scotland's communities. 'The public is being put at risk. Every crime committed and every victim who suffered at the hands of those criminals represent an avoidable consequence of this misguided Scottish Government policy. 'To release prisoners early, knowing further offending is likely to occur, piles pressure on a police service already stretched to breaking under unsustainable demand.' Chief Supt Hay added: 'The only comfort I can offer the public is that where police officers encounter released prisoners who remain involved in crime, we will do all we can to ensure they end up back in custody, where they belong.' Like this: Like Related

Minister ‘hopeful' for ‘positive' announcement on Grangemouth soon
Minister ‘hopeful' for ‘positive' announcement on Grangemouth soon

STV News

time3 hours ago

  • STV News

Minister ‘hopeful' for ‘positive' announcement on Grangemouth soon

The UK's energy minister has said he is 'hopeful' that an announcement on investment in Grangemouth will come soon. Michael Shanks said more than 80 potential investors had come forward since the UK Government pledged £200m for the site. The UK Government is looking for another £600m from private investment in the area, following the closure of Scotland's last oil refinery there. Mr Shanks said the investment, announced by the Prime Minister at the Scottish Labour conference earlier this year, will help provide a 'long-term, sustainable future' for the site. More than 400 jobs were lost at the oil refinery as owners Petroineos transitioned it to a fuel import terminal. The company said the facility was losing large amounts of money every day. PA Media More than 400 jobs have been lost at the Grangemouth site. Speaking on BBC Scotland's The Sunday Show, the energy minister said his Government was engaging with businesses on new projects for the area. 'We've had some really positive meetings around potential investors,' he said. 'In fact, there's more than 80 potential investors come forward. 'Scottish Enterprise is driving forward due diligence on that. 'There's a number of really credible projects that we're developing at the moment. 'We hope we'll have some really positive announcements to say soon.' Mr Shanks said the 'unprecedented' £200 million investment from the National Wealth Fund would help 'create the jobs of the future' while providing the security of long-term investment. He added: 'I'm hopeful we will have announcements soon. 'I'm not involved in the due diligence, as you wouldn't expect, but there are some really exciting, viable projects coming forward that will deliver jobs in Grangemouth long into the future.' Following the announcement by Petroineos to close the plant, the Scottish and UK governments funded Project Willow, a report which laid out the potential future of the site in areas such as sustainable aviation fuel. Earlier this week, Jan Robertson, Grangemouth director for Scottish Enterprise, said he had received a 'mixture of inquiries' from businesses, including those interested in the site as well as some which 'have a good opportunity to become projects in the relatively near-term'. PA Media Scotland's Net Zero Secretary Gillian Martin said the 'door's not closed' on Grangemouth. 'What I mean by that is the next three to four years,' she told Holyrood's Economy and Fair Work Committee. 'Our approach very much at the moment is working with those and working as closely and quickly as we can to make the progress that we want to see in Grangemouth.' Scotland's Net Zero Secretary Gillian Martin said at the committee that the 'door's not closed' to companies and inquiries could still be made about working at Grangemouth, adding that Petroineos had also received approaches. Ms Martin said she was hopeful for the future of Grangemouth. 'We could look back five years and start pointing fingers, but the most important thing is that in the last year – actually the last six months – Project Willow and the task force have moved things along in a way that's been swift, agile, focused,' she said. 'I am feeling so much more confident than I did this time last year in the prospects for that site.' Ms Martin added that she hoped, with approval from the cabinet, a just transition plan for Grangemouth would be published next week. Get all the latest news from around the country Follow STV News Scan the QR code on your mobile device for all the latest news from around the country

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store