Van driver sentenced for 'distressing' crash at Perth Airport that left victim needing plastic surgery
A van driver who knocked down a pedestrian at Scone Airport, leaving him seriously injured, has been sentenced to unpaid work as a direct alternative to custody.
Paul Wishart struck the 61-year-old coffin factory worker as he made his way into work on the morning of October 3 2022.
Perth Sheriff Court heard how Wishart, 37, did not realise what had happened until he stopped his Renault Trafic and saw his victim lying on the road.
The man, who was described by witnesses as 'flying' through the air, suffered multiple injuries and required plastic surgery to his face.
Wishart, from Methven, was found guilty of causing serious injury by careless driving following a two-day trial in April.
He was banned from driving for three years when he returned to court for sentencing on Monday.
Sheriff Jennifer Bain KC told Wishart: 'You have expressed significant remorse and you appear to appreciate the consequences of your driving on that day.'
She said his victim 'suffered serious injuries and will be permanently impaired' but given his lack of criminal record – with one non-analogous traffic conviction – the sheriff said she was satisfied there was an alternative to custody available.
Wishart was ordered to carry out 250 hours unpaid work.
His solicitor Pauline Cullerton said: 'There had been nothing unusual as he drove to work that morning.
'He remembers hearing a thud and then saw the crack on his windscreen.
'He stopped the car and got out and was shocked to see (the complainer) lying on the road.'
Ms Cullerton stressed her client had not been speeding.
The court heard there were traffic calming measures including speed bumps on the road.
She said Wishart took responsibility for the 'distressing' injuries he had caused.
Jurors heard how Wishart had not seen the pedestrian as he crossed Spitfire Avenue, having stepped off a bus on the nearby A94.
The victim was 'propelled' through the air and landed on the carriageway.
Emergency services were scrambled to the scene just after 7am and the injured man was rushed to Ninewells Hospital.
The busy commuter route was closed off for about an hour.
Fiscal depute Jennifer Bairner read out a list of the victim's injuries, as recorded in a joint minute of agreed facts.
He suffered rib fractures, a cut to the right side of his face and a broken knee.
His left middle finger was also dislocated.
Ms Bairner said the victim underwent an operation to fix his knee, which involved a plate being inserted by an orthopaedic surgeon.
'The facial laceration was cleaned, sealed and closed by a plastic surgeon,' she said.
The man was discharged from hospital five days later.
Witnesses told the court of chaotic scenes in the aftermath of the early morning smash, with blood in the middle of the roadway.
Ms Bairner said in her closing statement to jurors: 'It is not suggested that Mr Wishart intended to hurt anyone but as a driver, you need to drive safely.'
Wishart was originally charged with causing serious injury by dangerous driving.
Jurors took less than an hour to convict him of a lesser charge involving driving carelessly.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Courier
a day ago
- The Courier
Thursday court round-up — Poor parking and park pervert
A slaughterhouse worker drunkenly struggled to reverse park at 2.20am on the same street as Montrose police station. , of Southesk Terrace in Brechin, admitted driving with excess alcohol (266mgs/ 67) on George Street on August 25 last year. At Forfar Sheriff Court, fiscal depute Sam Craib explained the 39-year-old was spotted attempting to park and narrowly missing another vehicle. Police who arrested him reported a strong smell of alcohol the driver slurring his speech. Solicitor Nick Markowski explained his client was going through a separation. 'Drinking too much was a factor of his life,' he added. Sheriff Jillian Martin-Brown fined Spadlo £470 altogether and banned him from driving for a year. A once-promising Perth chef who was offered the chance to work alongside TV cook Gordon Ramsay has been jailed for a 'seriously traumatic' assault outside a city chip shop. won awards and rave reviews for his food at restaurants in Dundee and Blairgowrie but Perth Sheriff Court heard how his career imploded and he ended up being threatened by a county line drugs gang who commandeered his home as a base for their supply operation. A park pervert who sexually assaulted one woman and flashed at another in Arbroath has been placed on the sex offenders register. , 23, appeared at Forfar Sheriff Court aided by a Bulgarian interpreter. He pled guilty to two offences on December 29 last year at Springfield Park in Arbroath. Brantanov, of the town's High Street, admitted sexually assaulting one woman by following her, stroking her arm and touching her buttocks. At the same place and on the same day, he admitted exposing his genitals in a sexual manner to a second woman by opening his jacket to reveal his erect penis. Sentencing was deferred until July 17 for reports. A businessman who spent a fortnight sticking posters portraying vile lies about Pakistani 'grooming gangs' around Fife has been hit with a 'substantial' fine. was caught on CCTV sticking up slur-laden posters around Leven, Methil and Kirkcaldy. , 43, of Ballingry Road, Ballingry, admitted dealing cocaine with a potential street value of more than £11,200 at an address in Weavers Row, Lochgelly, on January 13 2023. At Kirkcaldy Sheriff Court, prosecutor Sarah Smith said police searched the property after receiving intelligence Berry was involved in the supply of cocaine. The accused was in a vehicle in the driveway and made off before officers stopped him a short distance away. His partner was in the passenger seat and there was a child in the back, the court heard. A search of the property uncovered plastic bags containing drugs and other items including scales and £1,240 in cash. 130g of cocaine was found, with a potential street value of between £8,440 and £11,290, the fiscal said. Berry's defence lawyer said her client has one non-analogous previous conviction and is in full-time employment. Sheriff Krista Johnston deferred sentencing until July 7 at Dunfermline Sheriff Court for background reports and continued his bail meantime. A convicted stalker who embarked on a paranoid rampage across the Overgate Shopping Centre has been spared a return to prison. caused damage to the glass front at Fuel after threatening to stab staff at Sports Direct. A drug-driver from Dundee will serve another period of disqualification after being caught behind the wheel between Auchterhouse and Tealing. appeared at Forfar Sheriff Court to admit driving with excess Delta-9-THC, the main psychoactive ingredient in cannabis (6mics/ 2) on November 14 last year (6 mics/2). Reid, 35, of Grampian Gardens, was earlier banned for six months for driving while disqualified during the same journey, his solicitor Billy Rennie explained, having not reapplied for his licence before getting behind the wheel. Unemployed Reid was fined £160 and banned for another 12 months.
The Courier
a day ago
- The Courier
Conman who bought £140k Perth house through fraudulent scheme given unpaid work
A crooked landlord who exploited a Scottish Government scheme designed for first-time buyers to purchase a £140,000 house in Perth has been ordered to complete unpaid work. Raza Hussain used fake bank statements and lied about his employment to secure funding from the government's LIFT initiative. The scheme was set up to help first-time buyers get on the property ladder. But 31-year-old Hussain already owned a house in Aberdeen when he applied for funding. He further duped the Nationwide Building Society into giving him a mortgage. A criminal investigation later uncovered the father-of-two had not moved into the property at Glengarry Road but was instead renting it out to someone else. Hussain, from Perth, previously pled guilty to running a fraudulent scheme between July 1 and September 26 2019. He returned to the dock this week and was sentenced to unpaid work. Prosecutor Emma Farmer told Perth Sheriff Court: 'The Lift scheme is a low-cost initiative to help first time buyers get onto the property ladder. 'Shared equity owners are not permitted to let out their property under any circumstances.' She said Hussain's application was assessed by a Scottish Government agent and approved on July 25 2019. 'He stated on the form that he was a first-time buyer,' said Ms Farmer. 'But this appears not to be true as he had previously bought a property in Aberdeen.' Hussain secured £48,300 of government funding for the three-bedroom home in Perth's Glengarry Road. He later secured a £82,800 mortgage from the Nationwide Building Society, and bought the property with a £6,900 deposit from his parents. Ms Farmer said attempts were made by the Nationwide's financial crime department to contact Hussain's employer. 'This was to verify his employment,' she said. 'However, this was unsuccessful.' His application was put on hold and payslips were requested to show his income. However, the funding for the mortgage had already been released and could not be recalled. The fiscal depute said: 'During 2020, a member of the Scottish Government was contacted by police in relation to an investigation into Mr Hussain, regarding concerns about his banking activity. 'It transpired he was on the landlord register and was renting out the property.' When quizzed about this Hussain said he had served notice on the tenant and that he would move in after they had moved out but he was unable to provide any proof of this. Hussain also produced bank statements to government officials, showing monthly salary payments of £1,992 from a company in Paisley. 'It later transpired that the true bank statements did not disclose this income,' said Ms Farmer. 'He declared an income of £30,000 per annum but could provide no evidence of this.' The court heard Hussain now faces Proceeds of Crime action, although this has been put on hold until later in the year to give Police Scotland's financial investigations unit time to complete their probe. A lawyer for Hussain said: 'He fully accepts what he did and faces up to his responsibilities.' Sheriff David Hall told Hussain: 'Clearly this is a serious matter. 'You were fully aware that what you were doing was fraudulent, due to the fact that you had already purchased a property and were not a first-time buyer.' He added: 'You have no criminal convictions and this offence is quite old, so I can deal with it today in a way that allows you to remain at liberty.' Hussain, of Fairies Road, Perth, was sentenced to carry out 235 hours of unpaid work as a direct alternative to custody.
The Courier
2 days ago
- The Courier
Perthshire businessman fined for damaging badger sett in mum's field with digger
A workman who operated a 20-tonne digger on top of a badger sett has been fined £1,800. Matthew Rogers admitted he was reckless to carry out excavation work near the protected habitat on a field belonging to his mother in rural Perthshire. The 35-year-old business owner appeared at Perth Sheriff Court to plead guilty to interfering with and causing damage to part of the underground network, a breach of the Protection of Badgers Act 1992. The court heard his excavation bucket came within four metres of the sett entrance. Rogers, who runs a sound and lighting company, was reported to police after concerned locals took video recordings of his excavation job, which they described as 'horrendous'. The court heard the work was carried out in April 2022 on open ground between Dull and Camserney. Prosecutor Gerard Drugan said the land was being used for horses. He said a few years earlier, another person had started carrying out earthworks on the field but they stopped when they found the sett. 'In the early part of April, a witness became aware of work at the locus,' said Mr Drugan. 'They saw an excavator and flatbed truck present at the scene.' A week or so later, another witness noticed the work. 'She described the noise as 'horrendous',' said the fiscal depute. 'She goes to investigate and finds Mr Rogers driving the digger. 'She was concerned because the work was close to the badger sett.' Mr Drugan said: 'They exchanged words and Mr Rogers said he was nowhere near the sett, indicating that he was aware of it.' The court heard the witness began to video the work, filming from the perspective of badgers and other animals. When she walked towards the sett, Mr Rogers asked her what she was doing. 'She said she wanted to check the level of noise that the badgers were experiencing from the sett.' Mr Drugan said more noise was heard coming from the field a few days later, on April 29. Both locals went over to take a look. 'When they got to the site, they witnessed damage to the ground immediately above the sett entrance.' It was established the digger had been 'right on top' of the sett, causing damage to the ground. Its excavation bucket had been used to move vegetation near the sett. Mr Drugan said the closest damage was between two and four metres from the entrance. 'The possible disturbance and damage caused would have been deeply unsettling for badgers and could have destroyed the sett.' Solicitor Alan Davie, defending, said towards the end of the Covid lockdown his client's mother asked him to excavate some of the land and make it more suitable for horses and resolve some drainage issues. 'He candidly accepts he knows nothing about badgers' living arrangements. 'He did not know there were badgers on this land.' Rogers was 'clearing up' his work on April 29 and 30 when he caused damage. 'He accepts that he should have taken care and should have educated himself. 'He should not have returned to the work without that knowledge. 'Mr Rogers concedes he was reckless and he apologises.' Mr Davie said: 'This is a mistake he will not make again.' Sheriff Clair McLachlan told Rogers: 'I accept your explanation that you did not set out to cause damage and that this was very much out of character.' She fined him £1,800, reduced from £2,000 for pleading ahead of his trial.
