
Inside the legal battle for Poets' Neuk in St Andrews
It was first gifted to the town by Mary, Queen of Scots before her abdication in 1567, and was once the site of a medieval Greyfriars monastery chapel.
For the best part of two decades a community group has been seeking to acquire the plot and transform it into a poetry garden, complete with a statue of the monarch.
Plans for the poetry garden (Image: Poets' Neuk) Under the Land Reform (Scotland) Act of 2016, community bodies have the power to apply to the Scottish Government to exercise a compulsory purchase order (CPO) on land or a building for sustainable development.
Poets' Neuk applied under the act to buy the land and turn it into a community garden.
Ministers backed the application but landowner Forthtay Ltd, a trust controlled by Isle of Man based Optimus Fiduciaries, lodged an appeal alleging "apparent bias" toward the community group and accusing ministers of acting unlawfully.
This week though, Sheriff Timothy Niven-Smith concluded that ministers had acted lawfully in their decision, paving the way for the sale to go ahead.
Graham Wynd, chair of Poets' Group, tells The Herald: "The garden's been an eyesore for a very long time.
'Originally the St Andrews Preservation Trust campaigned and exhorted the owner of the land to clear it up, the council tried to do the same.
Read More:
'Then we decided that the thing to do would be to try and buy the land so we got in touch with the owner and offered well above market rate for the land - still he refused."
In 2018 the group secured a pre-emptive right to buy, but that only forced Optimus Fiduciaries not to sell to any other groups - it was under no obligation to sell at all.
Mr Wynd explains: "We put in a lot of effort, the owner claimed he was already selling the land to someone else, or was on the brink of a sale.
"As soon as you put in an application, that puts a stop on any buying or selling of the land. The owner was claiming to be in a position where he was just about to sell it, and that by applying for a community right to buy we'd put a stop on the sale.
'The way the government deals with that is to go through an accelerated process, which is more stringent. We got to the end of that process and the government awarded us the right to buy.
'The owner, as we soon discovered he was entitled to do, simply refused to deal with us."
With the owners refusing to sell, Poets' Neuk applied under section five of the act for a CPO.
The plot of land in question (Image: Google) In May 2024 it was granted, the first time the power had been used, but Optimus Fiduciaries instantly lodged an appeal at Dundee Sheriff Court.
The grounds for the appeal were based on ministers not having applied the test of there being a 'substantial benefit' to the community, rather than merely a 'benefit'; that they did not consider the benefits of not selling the land; that the CPO was in breach of article 1 protocol 1 of the European Convention on Human Rights which states "every natural or legal person is entitled to the peaceful enjoyment of his possessions"; that the Scottish Government was 'unduly influenced' by the wider implications of a successful compulsory purchase order which it described as "a serious, fatal, failure of impartiality"; and that ministers had not taken regeneration adequately into account given the proposal by the owners to build a café.
The appeals were all rejected.
Mr Wynd said: "We were confident we could meet the requirements, certainly in our opinion, but there was so much scrutiny that you can never be confident.
"I really cannot understand the accusation of bias. We have found the civil servants to be very helpful but scrupulously careful not to exercise bias toward us or the owner – sometimes we felt they were perhaps a little too cool with us!
'The government scrutinised our application and took a year over it, they produced a very long and comprehensive report.
"The next steps are to actually acquire the land. The price has been set by the district valuer, so there's no debate about that.
'We need to get the deeds to the land as the first formal step, we tried a year ago but the owner said that since they'd lodged an appeal they weren't going to hand them over.
'I think they will have no choice now, indeed the terms of the acts say that if the owner does not our recourse is to go to the Scottish Lands Tribunal who would then enforce a handover."
The CPO could pave the way for future takeovers, with land reform one of the thorniest issues in contemporary public life.
Close to 60% of rural land in Scotland is believed to be in private hands, with some estimates stating that 432 families own half of private land in the country as a whole.
Sheriff Niven-Smith was not asked to rule on the merits, or lack thereof, of the proposed poetry garden but whether ministers had acted within the law in granting the CPO.
In rejecting the appeal by Optimus Fiduciaries, the sheriff concluded that they had.
Mr Wynd said: "It's a very satisfying moment for us, because what it represents is that the people of St Andrews can actually have a say in that their town looks like, and that they can prevent someone like the owner from totally neglecting the land and turning it into an eyesore and a location for very unsocial activities.
"I hope other communities can follow suit. It is, however, a lot of hard work - in a sense this is only the end of the beginning.
"The next step is to acquire the land, then to implement the plan we've had for the garden for a very long time.
"We are expecting to receive a substantial grant from the Scottish Land Fund, which as I understand it is really lottery money, we put in an application some time ago and that is still live. If we're successful with that we could get a very substantial proportion of the acquisition cost.
'If that does not come through then I'm glad to say we have generous benefactors who would be prepared to provide a bridging loan.'
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Daily Record
34 minutes ago
- Daily Record
Campaigners welcome decision to call in Flamingo Land's controversial Loch Lomond plans after government U-turn
The Scottish Government has called in plans for a major development on the banks of Loch Lomond. Campaigners have welcomed a decision by the Scottish Government to call in Flamingo Land's controversial plans for a £43.5million resort on the banks of Loch Lomond. Yorkshire-based theme park operator Flamingo Land, through its subsidiary Lomond Banks, had proposed to construct two hotels, over 100 lodges, a waterpark and monorail at Balloch. After a long-running battle, initial proposals were shelved in 2019 due to significant local opposition and concerns from bodies such as the Scottish Environmental Protection Agency (SEPA), the Woodland Trust and the National Trust for Scotland. Subsequent revised plans were unanimously turned down by the Loch Lomond and Trossachs National Park authority - however, an appeal by Lomond Banks was upheld by a Scottish Government reporter, who imposed 49 conditions on the developer and required them to reach an agreement with the authority before commencing construction. Despite pressure from MSPs, Public Finance Minister Ivan McKee had previously declined to step in regarding the decision to proceed with the plans. But in a statement released on Tuesday evening, he confirmed that the government would now recall the plans. "I have decided to recall the Lomond Banks appeal as the proposed development raises issues of national significance in view of its potential impact on Loch Lomond and the Trossachs National Park," the minister said. "This means that the appeal should be determined at a national level." Mr McKee had previously mentioned that "technical planning issues" were involved in the application, stating it was right for "objective planning judgment" to be used, hence the Government would not intervene. Following his remarks, a campaign spearheaded by the Scottish Greens saw over 50,000 individuals petitioning him to reconsider. Loch Lomond South Community Development Trust (LLSCDT) welcomed the decision and said it is actively working to shape and promote a "positive, community-ledalternative vision for the area—one that supports sustainable tourism, protects theenvironment, and truly benefits the people who live, work, and visit Loch Lomond". LLSCDT chairwoman, Lynne Somerville said: 'The people who live here must have a real say in the future of this place—not as an afterthought, but as equal partners. "The overwhelming response from the community shows not only opposition to inappropriate development, but also a clear appetite for something better—something rooted in fairness, sustainability, and local benefit. "Under the 2015 Community Empowerment Act, communities like ours are legally entitled to be heard and treated with respect in decisions that affect our land and future. It's time that legislation was meaningfully upheld.' The announcement arrived just a day before Scottish Labour planned to initiate a debate urging Government intervention, with Dumbarton MSP and the party's deputy leader Jackie Baillie suggesting ministers were apprehensive about a potential defeat. "The SNP face a motion tomorrow from Scottish Labour demanding that the application is recalled," she commented. "Thanks to cross party support for our motion, the SNP has U-turned before it was defeated in the chamber." In her statement, Ms Baillie remarked: "This is a welcome U-turn by the SNP, though it shouldn't have taken the fear of a defeat in Parliament to force them to reach this decision. "The SNP has ignored concerns time and time again – from politicians across the chamber and from local campaigners. "It is not right that a single reporter was allowed to overrule the National Park Authority's unanimous decision to reject the bid of the Flamingo Land resort. "This decision requires proper democratic oversight and I'm pleased ministers have finally accepted our calls and agreed to step in." Reacting to the announcement, Scottish Green MSP Ross Greer commended the decision, saying it was the "right move". "The evidence of the damage it would do to one of Scotland's most iconic locations is overwhelming," he added. "Once ministers consider the flood risk, loss of ancient woodland, hundreds of additional cars which would be brought onto notoriously congested roads and the litany of other devastating impacts it would have, I am sure they will reject the mega-resort application and finally end this decade-long saga. "People across Scotland expect their Government to protect our natural heritage. "Given previous mistakes, including the approval of Donald Trump's golf course despite local objections and serious environmental concerns, this is an opportunity for ministers to show that they have learned and will now put people and planet ahead of greedy developers."


Scottish Sun
2 hours ago
- Scottish Sun
We've been trying to sell our flat for THREE YEARS – but smell from downstairs means nobody wants to buy
Darren has called on the council to do more about the situation, adding that 'it's been hell' for the family 'NIGHTMARE' We've been trying to sell our flat for THREE YEARS – but smell from downstairs means nobody wants to buy Click to share on X/Twitter (Opens in new window) Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) A HOMEOWNER has claimed he has struggled to sell his flat for three years because an overpowering smell of food is pouring into the home from a restaurant below the property. Darren Barrett, 53, says all potential buyers have been put off the flat in the west end of Edinburgh because of "pungent" cooking smells. 2 Neighbours have been complaining about the smell for years Credit: GOOGLE MAPS The property is located on Queensferry Street and sits directly above The Vietnam Food and Coffee Shop. Back in March, we told how the Vietnamese diner was ordered to close by the local council after neighbours lodged several furious complaints over two years. The local authority ruled that the restaurant had caused 'odour nuisance' to residents and was ordered to be shut down. Owner Kim Dinh appealed the decision to the Scottish Government, which upheld the original ruling. But Darren has told the Edinburgh Evening News that bosses have avoided the notice, adding that they are still cooking meals despite being told they can only serve soup and sandwiches. A report from Environmental Health stated the overpowering smell is leaking into their homes due to holes in the ceiling and around the ventilation system. It smells like a Vietnamese kitchen every day in our home... It is pungent. It's so stressful having that smell in our home every night Darren Barrett And Darren said the smell is so bad that the family struggles to sit in the living room without all the windows open - even during winter. The dad said they have been trying to move away from the restaurant for three years, but haven't been able to sell the property. He explained that there is an official notice online informing potential buyers about the odour issue, which has put people off. Darren said it has been "heartbreaking" for the family, adding that "It smells like a Vietnamese kitchen every day in our home." Kris Jenner's 'struggling to sell' her Hidden Hills mansion as interested buyers feel $13.5m price tag is 'way too high' He said: "We can't sit as a family in the living room, that's been two years now. It gets into the hall as well, but it's at its strongest and worst in the living room. 'We had to go through the winter just there with our living room windows open every day to let the smell out, so it doesn't stink out the rest of the flat. It is pungent. 'It's so stressful having that smell in our home every night. The boys are in their bedroom instead of sitting with us, and my wife and I sit in the kitchen and have to watch TV in our bedroom. 'But our biggest concern is not being able to sell this flat, and that's the third year now, it's a nightmare for us as a family.' Darren has called on the City of Edinburgh Council to do more about the situation, adding that "it's been hell" for the family. Our biggest concern is not being able to sell this flat, and that's the third year now, it's a nightmare for us as a family Darren Barrett He said: 'They now seem to have just ignored the orders and are still operating as a restaurant, with the smell still invading our home every day. 'We managed to get some communication with planning today, after a month of trying, to say the restaurant has been sent a letter to say they have to close by June 20, or it will be passed onto the legal department, but we just don't know what that means exactly. 'They have been told they can still operate while serving food like soup and sandwiches, but not fully cooked meals. They had earlier said they were not preparing hot food, which is just nonsense.' Owner Kim Dinh told the Edinburgh Evening News that they were unaware of the ventilation and odour issues when they took over the premises in 2023 from previous owners Noodles and Rice. Years of complaints DARREN isn't the only neighbour who has complained about the smell coming from The Vietnam Food and Coffee Shop over the last two years. Another local claimed he was suffering from the stench on a daily basis for over a year and that the problem was impacting his mental health. He said: "Having to be in the position of explaining to visitors or guests why there is a 'bad smell' time and time again is embarrassing, frustrating and unfair when this should quite simply not be in use as a restaurant. "At times, we are faced with making the decision to heat the home and bear with the smells or leave windows open and be cold. "The fact that this issue has persisted for well over 12 months is mentally draining and stressful." Owners initially appealed the decision to close, and submitted a document to Edinburgh Council's planning committee which read: " The Vietnam Food and Coffee Shop is not just a business but a vital source of livelihood for a family supporting a disabled child. "The enforcement notice and subsequent closure have caused significant financial and emotional strain on the family. "The business has also become a valued part of the community, offering authentic cultural cuisine and supporting the local economy." But Government reporter Trudi Craggs upheld the council decision. The council said: "The use as a restaurant has resulted in odour nuisance being evident in the residential flats located above the premises and has resulted in the matter being brought to the attention of planning enforcement." They added that they were always upfront with landlords about their plans for the restaurant and "at no point" were told about any issues or informed about the unit being "unsuitable for restaurant use". Kim also explained that they tried to fix the issues regarding the holes and problems with the ventilation system, explaining that "the structural limitations of this older building made a full technical solution extremely difficult". They also rejected claims that they are "ignoring" the notice to close. Kim said: "First and foremost, we would like to express our sincere sympathy to Mr Barrett and his family. "We understand how distressing this ongoing situation must be for them, and we never intended to cause disruption to anyone's home life." We will begin the process of closing the restaurant. This is a heartbreaking decision for us. We have poured our energy, savings, and passion into creating a business Kim Dinh They added: "We have never intended to ignore enforcement — rather, we awaited the outcome of our planning application before taking irreversible steps to close the business, which would have had serious financial consequences for our family. "We will, of course, comply with the latest directive and begin the process of closing the restaurant. "This is a heartbreaking decision for us. We have poured our energy, savings, and passion into creating a business that contributes to the local area. "We worry this will represent a loss of cultural diversity and community offering in the neighbourhood." Bosses also called on councils across Scotland to share "complex histories" with small businesses planning on moving into new premises. The City of Edinburgh Council has been approached for comment.


The Independent
3 hours ago
- The Independent
'We built what we couldn't find': How Feeld's CEO is redefining modern relationships
Q: Feeld emerged at a time when dating apps were already starting to crowd the market. What made you believe there was still space—and a need—for something different? Feeld came from a personal place—my partner and I were exploring non-monogamy, and there was no platform that supported that journey with respect and nuance. So we built what we couldn't find: a space grounded in curiosity, consent, and openness. From the beginning, it wasn't about competing with what already existed—it was about creating space for what didn't. A place where people could connect without fitting into predefined categories or expectations. Q: Your professional path has been a more unconventional one — how did your background in design turn into a CEO role at Feeld? My partner was actually the original founder and led Feeld from its launch in 2014. I supported him behind the scenes but, at the time, wasn't interested in participating in the business. Dimo's background is in design and advertising and we always shared a deep appreciation for intentional building, sensitivity for nuance and aesthetics. I joined Feeld to support Dimo a couple of years after the company's founding and quickly found out that my design background made me uniquely well positioned to evolve our product in our early days with a focus on the member experience. While design has always been my first language, I found myself becoming deeply immersed in the business. I pursued an MBA a little after I was appointed CPO — the business was growing and it demanded a deeper understanding from me of the implications of my decisions and vision. Pursuing my education at that time proved essential — my partner stepped down in 2021 and he proposed me as CEO. My journey has taught me a powerful lesson: true leadership often means charting an unconventional path, proving that authenticity, integrity, and putting humans first are the ultimate keys to building a thriving enterprise. Education and leaning on people with experience and knowledge as you change and grow is essential too. I try to embody that at Feeld every day. Q: How can an app like Feeld make a positive impact against the disillusionment that dating apps have created over time? That's where Feeld takes a different approach — we champion open communication and authenticity as integral to how our community navigates the platform. When designing key functions of Feeld, we ask ourselves what would inspire intimate, deep connection. Our team at Feeld intentionally avoids gamifying the in-app experience. We believe the less we interfere with prescriptive algorithms, the more authentic the connections our Members make—and at their own pace. This non-transactional approach allows them to explore intentionally, without the pressure of rushing to an end goal or quota. The ability to go back to a profile you may have previously skipped, for example, reflects our belief that attraction is a process, and human connection takes longer than a split second. Being on Feeld is part of an ongoing ****process to learn more about yourself, through connection with others. Life and love are always an evolving journey. Q: What drives you personally and how do you stay inspired and motivated as the company continues to grow globally? What truly drives me is the profound change I witness in people's lives because of Feeld. It's incredibly humbling to hear some of our Members' amazing stories about connections they've made that resonate with them. Seeing Members discover their authentic selves and explore new dimensions of intimacy – that's inspiring. I find immense motivation in working with a team of incredible people to provide a platform that supports this continuous evolution, where everyone can redefine what relationships mean for them. The fact that Feeld is a company built on human principles, putting people first, fuels me every day. We do our best to live our values inside and out, and continue to grow with our community. The sheer possibility that we can contribute to a world where love and intimacy are more openly and authentically explored keeps me motivated to lead Feeld's global growth, embracing our always-shifting ways of being. There's always something more to learn in relationships, and being at the forefront of that exploration is incredibly invigorating. And in practice, it takes a village (and more) to do what we do. Being fortunate to have the growth we do requires us to constantly change and evolve — and it would be impossible without the humans on the team. The passion, commitment, creativity and care I see day to day are incredible and continue to inspire me. Q: What is it you think people still have to learn about relationships? We've been conditioned to chase ideals that often have little to do with what we actually want or need. There's pressure to "perform" love, to meet timelines, to filter ourselves into palatable versions to gain approval. Add in endless choice and surface-level scanning, and it's no wonder people feel burnt out. There is absolutely nothing wrong with finding 'the one' — we just want people to understand that that is not their only option or that they're not enough in any way if they don't check that box. Since Feeld was founded over a decade ago, we've shifted away from prescribed realities and binary identities towards a world of autonomy and fluid self-expression. We see a real shift happening—people are starting to question old paradigms. They're valuing presence over perfection, fluidity over fixed roles. They're more open to curiosity and exploration. Feeld's growth is evidence of this change: people want space to explore connection on their own terms, and they're ready to do it differently. Dating has become a longer chapter in our lives, and it's becoming more of an open space where people are allowing themselves to be drawn to what feels joyful and true—not necessarily to reach an end point, but to be present in the experience itself and let people change us and explore together. Q: Looking ahead, what excites you most about Feeld's technological future and its continued role in redefining intimacy and relationships? The evolution of how we connect is only just beginning. I'm incredibly optimistic about technology's role in creating even more nuanced and authentic connection opportunities. What excites me most about Feeld's technological future is our unwavering commitment to putting the individual human first, even as technology advances. We're not chasing fleeting trends; we're deepening the core experience of human connection. Our goal is to continue building tools that empower radical authenticity. We want to consistently encourage people to question what's considered the norm and whether it's truly working for them. The future of connection, as shaped by tech, will be about creating an environment where individuals can endlessly learn, grow, and embrace how they're evolving personally. Feeld is ultimately about providing the tools for our Members to be fully present, explore their curiosities safely, and experience the wonder of connection in all its infinite shapes, because there's always something more to discover in relationships. For more information and to see the full E2E Tech 100 2025 list click here.