Trump's deportation campaign won't ‘make a dent,' Idaho lawmakers say. They want to help
Idaho lawmakers expressed support Friday for President Trump's mass deportations from the U.S. of immigrants without documentation. They also voiced concern that his policies weren't going far enough.
At the current rate that the administration is conducting deportations, 'we're looking at only 728,000' people deported over the next four years, out of the millions of undocumented immigrants living in the U.S., said Rep. Jaron Crane, R-Nampa. More than a quarter of foreign-born people — about 14 million — living in the U.S. are undocumented, PBS News reported.
'We're not even going to make a dent,' Crane told a Senate committee Friday.
Ahead of a public hearing for House Bill 83, which would make illegal entry into the state by a noncitizen a state crime that could be enforced by local law enforcement. Crane told lawmakers that Idaho would need to help fill the gap.
'States are going to have to start leaning into this, pressing forward and taking action to help the federal government with this issue,' he said.
Crane's bill is one of multiple pieces of legislation this session that seek to grant local law enforcement more purview over immigration enforcement, which has traditionally been under federal jurisdiction, the Idaho Statesman previously reported. Crane sponsored a similar bill last year, which overwhelmingly passed the Idaho House, but failed in the Senate.
On Friday, Crane and Sen. Todd Lakey, R-Nampa, proposed combining an updated version of Crane's bill with Senate Bill 1039, sponsored by Senate Pro Tem Kelly Anthon, R-Burley. Anthon's bill would make it illegal for a 'dangerous illegal alien' to be present in or smuggled into Idaho, and would disallow their release on probation.
'I saw this particular bill being introduced in the House, and I recognized there was considerable overlap,' Anthon, an attorney, told committee members Friday. 'I thought that it would be better just to work together.'
The proposal would test federal supremacy over immigration matters by deputizing local police and giving local judges authority to issue deportation orders, the Statesman reported. A similar law in Texas, after which the Idaho bill is modeled, has so far not been allowed to take effect by federal judges.
The Idaho bill aims to create new state crimes of illegal entry and reentry, but calls for them to be enforced only if someone is detained on suspicion of first having committed a separate crime.
'This isn't just random out there looking for folks,' said Lakey, also a lawyer.
But James Ruchti, D-Pocatello, a fellow attorney, raised concerns about targeting people merely 'suspected' of a crime, rather than convicted of one.
'It just seems to me that law enforcement could use lots of reasons to detain or investigate for suspected commission of an independent crime,' he told the committee Friday. 'Those words together just are so soft that it creates, maybe, a temptation for a law enforcement individual to profile.'
Geoffrey Heeren, a University of Idaho law professor who specializes in immigration, told the Statesman in January that an earlier version of Crane's bill was likely to prompt costly litigation and had little chance of passing constitutional muster.
Law enforcement agencies in the Treasure Valley cannot enforce immigration laws, but they do work with federal officials, including U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement, or ICE, if a person detained lacks legal status, according to spokespeople for several area police departments, the Statesman previously reported.
The committee voted Friday to send Crane's bill to the Senate floor to amend it and incorporate portions of Anthon's bill.
Dueling Idaho Republican immigration bills aim to expand state reach, create new crimes
Idaho police could arrest immigrants without legal status in proposed law to mirror Texas
Idaho has about 35,000 undocumented immigrants. Who are they? Here are 8 things to know
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Boston Globe
an hour ago
- Boston Globe
Trump's actions in Los Angeles spur debate over deportation funds in his ‘big, beautiful' bill
'All you have to do is look at what's happening in Los Angeles to realize that our law enforcement needs all the support that we can possibly give them,' said Senate Majority Leader John Thune, R-S.D. Get Starting Point A guide through the most important stories of the morning, delivered Monday through Friday. Enter Email Sign Up The focus on some $350 billion in national security funding comes as action on the massive package is lumbering along in Congress at a critical moment. Trump wants the bill on his desk by the Fourth of July. But Senate Republicans trying to heave it to passage without Democrats are also running up against objections from within their GOP ranks over the details. Advertisement At the same time, Democrats are warning that Trump's executive reach into California — sending in the National Guard over the governor's objections and calling up the Marines — is inflaming tensions in what had been isolated protests in pockets of LA. They warned the president's heavy-handed approach has the potential to spread, if unchecked, to other communities nationwide. Advertisement 'We are at a dangerous inflection point in our country,' said Rep. Jimmy Gomez, who represents the Los Angeles area. 'Trump created this political distraction to divide us and keep our focus away from his policies that are wreaking havoc on our economy and hurting working families,' he said. 'It's a deliberate attempt by Trump to incite unrest, test the limits of executive power and distract from the lawlessness of his administration.' At its core, the bill extends some $4.5 trillion in existing tax breaks that would otherwise expire at the end of the year without action in Congress, cutting some $1.4 trillion in spending over the decade to help offset costs. The Congressional Budget Office found the bill's changes to Medicaid and other programs would leave an estimated 10.9 million more people without health insurance and at least 3 million each month without food stamps from the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program. At the same time, CBO said the package will add some $2.4 trillion to deficits over the decade. One emerging area of concern for Republican leaders has been the bill's status before the Senate parliamentarian's office, which assesses whether the package complies with the strict rules used for legislation under the so-called budget reconciliation process. Late Monday, Republicans acknowledged potential 'red flags' coming from the parliamentarian's office that will require changes in the House bill before it can be sent to the Senate. Leaders are using the reconciliation process because it allows for simple majority passage in both chambers, were GOP majorities are razor-thin. House Majority Leader Steve Scalise said Republicans are preparing to address the concerns with a vote in the House, possibly as soon as this week, to change the package. Advertisement Senate Democratic Leader Chuck Schumer seized on the House's upcoming do-over vote as a chance for Republicans who are dissatisfied with the package to reassert their leverage and 'force the bill back to the drawing board.' 'They say they don't like parts of the bill — now is their opportunity to change it,' Schumer said. On Tuesday, Vice President JD Vance was dispatched to speak with one GOP holdout, Sen. Ron Johnson of Wisconsin, who has pushed for deeper spending reductions in the bill to prevent skyrocketing deficits from adding to the nation's $36 trillion debt load. Other Republican senators have raised concerns about the health care cuts. But Republicans are in agreement on border security, deportation and military funding, over the objections of Democrats who fought vigorously during the committee process to strip those provisions from the bill. The package includes about $150 billion for border security and deportation operations, including funding for hiring 10,000 new ICE officers — with what Johnson said are $10,000 hiring bonuses — as well as 3,000 new Border Patrol agents and other field operations and support staff. There's also funding for a daily detention capacity for 100,000 migrants and for flights for 1 million deportations annually. The package includes $46 billion for construction of Trump's long promised wall between the U.S.-Mexico border. Additionally, the bill includes $150 billion for the Pentagon, with $5 billion for the military deployment in support of border security, along with nearly $25 billion for Trump's 'Golden Dome' defense system over the U.S. Separately, the bill adds another $21 billion for the Coast Guard. Advertisement Democrats have argued against the deportations, and warned that Trump appears to be stirring up protests so he can clamp down on migrant communities. Rep. Nanette Barragan — whose district represents the suburban city of Paramount, where the weekend Home Depot raid touched off protests — implored Americans: 'Listen to the words of this administration: They're using words like insurrection. They're using words like invasion.' She warned the administration is laying the groundwork for even steeper actions. 'That's a concern,' she said. 'That is dangerous. It's wrong.' Associated Press writer Michelle L. Price contributed to this report.
Epoch Times
an hour ago
- Epoch Times
Mikie Sherrill, Jack Ciattarelli Win the Democratic and Republican Primaries for Governor of New Jersey
WASHINGTON—U.S. Rep. Mikie Sherrill (D-N.J.) and former State Assemblyman Jack Ciattarelli (R-Somerville) won the Democratic and Republican primary contests in the New Jersey gubernatorial election on June 10 and will advance to the general election. Ciattarelli easily beat out his Republican opponents, leading with 66.3 percent of the vote with 28 percent counted. The Associated Press called the race for him at 8:17 p.m. ET. Sherrill's race took slightly longer to call, being declared the winner at 8:39 p.m.
Yahoo
2 hours ago
- Yahoo
Nathan Boyles easily secures District 3 state House seat with win over Democrat Dondre Wise
The rough and tumble April 1 Republican primary turned out to be the biggest obstacle Holt resident Nathan Boyles would face on his way to securing the District 3 seat in the Florida House of Representatives. Neither Democratic opponent Dondre Wise nor a healthy dose of voter indifference could prevent Boyles from securing election to the office in a June 10 special election. In an unofficial tally with all precincts counted but some mail in votes still outstanding in Santa Rosa County, Boyles had received 8,175 votes to 4,013 for Wise. The district is composed of all of Santa Rosa County except the southwestern edge, which includes Gulf Breeze and Navarre Beach. District 3 also extends into North Okaloosa to encompass rural areas north of the county seat of Crestview. In a break down by county, Boyles received 6,756 (66%) votes to 3,438 (34%) in Santa Rosa County and 1,419 (71%) votes to 575 (29%) in Okaloosa County. Boyles accepted the victory with humility. "Obviously it's overwhelming to see the report we received. Having served as an elected official you know you can't take that kind of support for granted," he said. The dismal final unofficial accounting showed that of the 118,401 registered Santa Rosa County voters just 10,199 or 8.6% cast ballots this cycle, while in Okaloosa County, where 22,449 voters were eligible, 1,997, or 8.9%, voted. Boyles attributed the low turnout to voter fatigue created by a special election held in the immediate wake of a hectic 2024 election cycle. "I'll take every vote we got," he said. Due to the late date of the special election vote Boyles did not get to participate in the bulk of the 2025 Legislative session. He will, however, be sworn in on June 16 and have the opportunity to vote in the overtime period of the session when the state House and state Senate come to agreement on a balanced state budget, probably some time next week. Boyles is an Okaloosa County resident who served three terms as a county commissioner. In District 3 he will represent a constituency made up primarily of Santa Rosa County residents. Though a sizeable segment of the Santa Rosa population argued early on that a county resident should hold the seat, Boyles has insisted all along the election was not about Okaloosa or Santa Rosa counties, but about finding someone suitable to represent District 3 in Tallahassee. The state representative elect has been preparing for his role in Tallahassee since emerging victorious April 1 over a slate of seven GOP candidates, all of whom competed in the primary knowing the winner would be a heavy favorite to replace Joel Rudman in the super conservative district. Boyles spent time in Tallahassee during the 2025 legislative session familiarizing himself with lawmakers and the legislative process and has stopped in to address the Santa Rosa County Commission as well as the governing bodies of the city of Milton and town of Jay. "It's been exciting to go over there and see the process and the people who make it run," he said. "It helps to understand the rules. I've enjoyed the opportunity of a running head start and hopefully I'll be educated and be the best representative of the district I can be." Boyles burst upon the Santa Rosa County scene in 2020 when his upstart Adams Sanitation business began luring customers in the north end of the county away from established WastePro which, as the only service provider, had decreased weekly pickups to one time a week while at the same time raising fees. After a protracted legal squabble, Adams Sanitation emerged victorious from litigation with both WastePro and the county itself. It now services thousands of customers county wide and employs 75 Santa Rosa County residents. The familiarity Boyles has gained in Santa Rosa showed in the Republican primary where Jay mayor Shon Owens, the popular choice among Santa Rosa County leadership, only outpolled him by 441 votes. In contrast, Boyles captured 1,399 more Okaloosa County votes than Owens, who ultimately finished 949 votes behind the winner. Boyles relied on his experience as a county commissioner to campaign for the District 3 seat. He spoke of his "significant experience in prioritizing infrastructure while keeping taxes low" and touched on key Okaloosa County achievements Santa Rosa residents could relate to. Those included paving dirt roads, improving rural broadband, preserving contaminant free drinking water, providing adequate stormwater treatment, protecting the environment and offering modern sewage treatment and disposal. Wise, who fielded no opposition on the Democratic side of the special election ticket, had moved just last month from Pensacola to Navarre. He has said that he knew he was facing an uphill battle in the heavily Republican District 3, but he was hopeful he'd been able to demonstrate through his campaign the importance of the election process. "I most wanted to make people aware of the election process and advocate for voter registration. I want real change and I believe this community does too," he said. "Regardless of the election outcome, I think people are starting to understand." The special election, which Gov. Ron DeSantis waited until Jan. 21 to schedule, was necessitated when Rudman resigned his seat to run for the Florida First Congressional District seat which was left empty after the November 2024 resignation of former U.S. Rep. Matt Gaetz. Rudman lost the congressional race to former Florida Chief Financial Officer Jimmy Patronis. This article originally appeared on Pensacola News Journal: Nathan Boyles wins Florida House District 3 special election
