Judge Orders Trump Admin to Facilitate Return of Wrongfully Deported Guatemalan Man
A federal judge ruled on Friday that the Trump administration must facilitate the return of an illegal immigrant from Guatemala who was deported to Mexico in February, after the government admitted to an error in its court statements about his case.
The Guatemalan native, referred to as O.C.G. in court documents, left his homeland in March 2024 and entered the United States without prior authorization to seek asylum. He was sent back to Guatemala, and two months later, O.C.G. tried to reenter the United States through Mexico.
According to
The judge subsequently ruled that O.C.G. should not be returned to Guatemala due to his fears of persecution. Two days after being granted withholding of removal, he was placed on a bus to Mexico without being given the chance to speak to his attorney, court documents stated.
After arriving in Mexico, O.C.G. was given a choice of whether to remain in detention while applying for asylum in Mexico or be sent back to Guatemala. He chose to return to Guatemala, where he has remained since, according to court documents.
U.S. District Judge Brian Murphy said that government lawyers initially said that O.C.G. had verbally expressed that he was not afraid of being sent to Mexico, citing data entries from immigration officers.
Related Stories
5/21/2025
4/24/2025
The attorneys later admitted they could not identify any immigration officers to support that claim.
'No one has ever suggested that O.C.G. poses any sort of security threat,' Murphy stated in a 14-page order. 'In general, this case presents no special facts or legal circumstances, only the banal horror of a man being wrongfully loaded onto a bus and sent back to a country where he was allegedly just raped and kidnapped.'
Murphy acknowledged that mistakes can happen but said, 'the events leading up to this decision are troubling.'
'The Court was given false information, upon which it relied, twice, to the detriment of a party at risk of serious and irreparable harm,' he stated. Murphy ordered discovery, including depositions of those involved in giving the false information and related data entries.
Trina Realmuto, a lawyer for O.C.G. at the National Immigration Litigation Alliance, said that his legal team was 'elated' by Murphy's ruling and would work to facilitate a return plan.
The Department of Homeland Security did not return a request for comment at the time of publication.
The ruling came just days after Murphy
In another case, the government said it
The Supreme Court has ordered the administration to facilitate his return to the United States. The administration said it lacks the authority to return him because he is now in the custody of Salvadoran authorities.
Reuters and Jacob Burg contributed to this report.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
41 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Trump Admin Laments South Sudan Deportation Debacle It Created
A lot of things happened. Here are some of the things. This is TPM's Morning Memo. Sign up for the email version. It had been two weeks since U.S. District Judge Brian Murphy of Massachusetts ordered the Trump administration to allow the detainees it was trying to ship off to South Sudan to talk to their lawyers – and as of Wednesday, the lawyers told the Supreme Court, they had still not heard from the detainees who have been stuck in Djibouti this whole time. Then yesterday the Trump administration filed a perplexing declaration telling Judge Murphy about all the hardship ICE agents are enduring trying to guard the detainees in the harsh conditions of the U.S. base in Djibouti. The WaPo headline captured the administration-centric perspective: 'ICE officers stuck in Djibouti shipping container with deported migrants.' Who is stuck with whom exactly? The decisions to deport them to South Sudan and to keep them temporarily in Djibouti are entirely the administration's, despite what it has told the Supreme Court. It was the administration's idea in the first place, as an incensed Murphy has pointed out. He's already called out the Trump DOJ on this for claiming he forced them into this predicament. In the May hearing, the Trump DOJ floated this solution as an alternative to bringing the detainees back to the United States. Murphy took them up on it, but explicitly said the administration could always bring them back stateside. The NYT has new reporting on how all this unfolded. As of yesterday, the detainees' legal team had still not heard from them. As the government stonewalls in another of the 'facilitate' cases, U.S. District Judge Stephanie Gallagher of Maryland has ordered weekly status reports and expedited discovery into what the Trump administration is doing to retrieve Cristian, the anonymous Venezuelan wrongfully deported under the Alien Enemies Act in violation of an existing settlement agreement. Gallagher also told Cristian's lawyers that they are 'free to seek sanctions on an expedited basis' if the Trump administration doesn't engage in discovery in good faith. The case is proceeding in striking parallel alongside another Maryland case. It was two months ago when an irate U.S. District Judge Paula Xinis ordered expedited discovery in the Abrego Garcia case. At the time it was a huge deal that portended contempt of court proceedings against the Trump administration for defying her order to 'facilitate' the wrongfully deported Salvadoran's return. But that proceeding has dragged on and almost become background noise. Still, this week Xinis granted leave to Abrego Garcia's lawyers to file a motion for sanctions for the government's discovery violations. Some of that dispute is under seal, but we know from some public proceedings in the case that the Trump administration has been barely responsive to the discovery Xinis ordered to determine whether she should find government officials in contempt of court. I go deeper on the ruling here. Roger Parloff unpacks it here. ICE agents mistakenly detained a U.S. marshal last month during an immigration sweep at a federal building in Tucson Even amid all the other lousy conduct by the Trump administration in the anti-immigration cases, this case stands out. The administration has refused to accept a judge's proposal that lawyers for Columbia University student Yunseo Chung, a pro-Palestinian protestor who has avoided arrest for months, simply accept service, which would trigger that start of removal proceedings. 'The government is simply refusing to take yes for an answer,' her lawyer quipped. The government's insistence that it will only accept arresting Chung has baffled U.S. District Judge Naomi Reice Buchwald of the Southern District of New York. Yesterday, she put a stop to it, issuing an injunction prohibiting the government from arresting Chung or transferring her out of jurisdiction of her court. The judge then went further in suggesting what this is all really about, ordering the government to give 72-hours notice before the detain Chung on new trumped-up charges to give her a chance 'to be heard regarding whether any such asserted basis for detention constitutes a pretext for First Amendment retaliation.' U.S. District Judge Allison Burroughs of Boston issued a temporary restraining order against the Department of Homeland Security blocking it from enforcing a ban on international students trying to enroll at Harvard. Harvard immediately filed suit over Trump's proclamation on Wednesday, was in court by Thursday, and won the TRO later in the day. The Guardian: 'The University of Michigan is using private, undercover investigators to surveil pro-Palestinian campus groups, including trailing them on and off campus, furtively recording them and eavesdropping on their conversations, the Guardian has learned.' Secretary of State Marco Rubio gave life to President Trump's February executive order targeting the the International Criminal Court by sanctioning four of its judges. The sanctions freeze any U.S. assets of the judges in retaliation for two of the judges voting to authorize an ICC investigation of U.S. military actions in Afghanistan and for the other two authorizing arrest warrants for Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and former Israeli defense minister Yoav Gallant. DNI Tulsi Gabbard has installed one of her top advisers in a position within the office of the inspector general of the intelligence community, which is investigating the Signal group chat fiasco in which Gabbard participated. The Trump-Musk blowup is dominating political news coverage today, and I'd feel remiss not noting it. But I'm not sure what to do with it. Both men are so inauthentic and their transactional 'relationship' so contrived, that nothing about the public rupture feels any more real than their bromance did. I can't get any more invested in it than I would a pro wrestling story arc. I will grant that the performative breakup is emblematic of the current moment both in its inauthenticity and in the Gilded Age histrionics of the billionaire man-child v. billionaire man-child. Adam Bonica continues his trenchant analysis of the DOGE rampage by comparing its layoffs to the budget increases in the House GOP's big bill: The executive director of the Skadden Foundation has resigned after the Skadden law firm struck a deal with President Trump to avoid being targeted with a punitive executive order. 'My hope is that Skadden charts a path that respects the rule of law and honors the core values of the Skadden Foundation,' Kathleen Rudenstein wrote in a post announcing her resignation.
Bloomberg
an hour ago
- Bloomberg
What Trump's FEMA Cuts Mean for Hurricane Season
The Atlantic hurricane season started June 1 and is predicted to be more active than usual this year. A busy hurricane season would test the Federal Emergency Management Agency in the aftermath of President Donald Trump's dramatic cuts to its disaster programs. FEMA — the nation's top agency for response and recovery work — has endured significant upheaval since Trump's return to the White House, including firings, voluntary staff departures, grant freezes and canceled initiatives. Instead of nominating a full-term administrator to lead FEMA, which sits under the Department of Homeland Security, Trump has selected a rotating cast of interim chiefs with little disaster response experience.
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
Mahmoud Khalil responds to 'grotesque' charges in new legal filing, says arrest caused 'irreparable harm'
Mahmoud Khalil, a Columbia University student detained in March by immigration agents, responded for the first time to the charges against him and described the "irreparable harm" his arrest has had on him and his family. "I have suffered—and continue to suffer—as a result of the government's actions against me," he said in a declaration included in a letter his legal team filed on Thursday in support of his bid for a preliminary injunction in his federal case. "The most immediate and visceral harms I have experienced directly relate to the birth of my son, Deen. Instead of holding my wife's hand in the delivery room, I was crouched on a detention center floor, whispering through a crackling phone line as she labored alone," Khalil said. "I listened to her pain, trying to comfort her while 70 other men slept around me. When I heard my son's first cries, I buried my face in my arms so no one would see me weep." His wife, Dr. Noor Abdalla, was eight months pregnant when Khalil was arrested March 8 at his New York apartment building. She said she had requested his presence at the birth but was denied by U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement. Khalil said that not being able to see his family has been "devastating." In his declaration, he condemned the White House and President Donald Trump over the "grotesque and false" claims made against him. Khalil was targeted for deportation after he helped organize pro-Palestinian rallies on the university's campus. He is being held at a facility in rural Jena, Louisiana. A Department of Homeland Security spokesperson said in a statement that "it is a privilege to be granted a visa or green card to live and study in the United States of America." "When you advocate for violence, glorify and support terrorists that relish the killing of Americans, and harass Jews, take over buildings and deface property, that privilege should be revoked, and you should not be in this country," the statement added. DHS said Khalil was granted a contact visit with his wife and son before his court appearance and has been given the option of self-deporting. The Department of Justice declined to comment, and ICE did not immediately respond to a request for comment. "It is hard to describe the humiliation and pain of seeing mugshot-style images of myself circulated from the highest levels of the U.S. government—accompanied by inflammatory language, grotesque and false accusations, and open celebration of my deportation," Khalil said in the declaration. "These were not just attacks on my character; they were efforts to erase my humanity." Khalil said his wife and family have also been subjected to harassment after the government labeled him a "U.S. foreign policy concern" and accused him of supporting Hamas. He said the allegations against him are false and "deeply racist." Khalil's attorney said in the letter that his arrest has damaged his reputation and "severely" undermined his pursuit of one day working in international diplomacy and human rights advocacy. Khalil said he had accepted a position at Oxfam International as a policy advisor, but the job offer was revoked. "I strongly believe that the Rubio Determination, my arrest and detention—and the public stigma that followed— played a significant role in this decision," he said. "I was not surprised; roles like this depend on your reputation." Oxfam International said it does not comment on individual HR or personnel matters. In a separate declaration, Khalil's wife described how she is "afraid for our safety." "Mahmoud's case has impacted every aspect of our life," she said. "I have experienced Islamophobia my whole life as a Muslim woman who wears a hijab, but it has been amplified by Mahmoud's detention and ongoing case. Mahmoud's and my careers, our desire for a stable life, and Deen's future will forever be impacted by these false allegations against him." This article was originally published on
