Tariff hikes in City's draft budget face backlash from civic groups
Civic associations are pushing back against the City's 2025/2026 Draft Budget due to steep fixed charges, which they say will impose financial strain on middle income homes.
The public has until May 2 to comment on the R84.1 billion draft budget, which Mayor Geordin Hill-Lewis tabled in last month's Council meeting.
Video Player is loading.
Play Video
Play
Unmute
Current Time
0:00
/
Duration
-:-
Loaded :
0%
Stream Type LIVE
Seek to live, currently behind live
LIVE
Remaining Time
-
0:00
This is a modal window.
Beginning of dialog window. Escape will cancel and close the window.
Text Color White Black Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan
Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Background Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan
Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Transparent Window Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan
Transparency Transparent Semi-Transparent Opaque
Font Size 50% 75% 100% 125% 150% 175% 200% 300% 400% Text Edge Style None Raised Depressed Uniform Dropshadow Font Family Proportional Sans-Serif Monospace Sans-Serif Proportional Serif Monospace Serif Casual Script Small Caps
Reset
restore all settings to the default values Done
Close Modal Dialog
End of dialog window.
Advertisement
Next
Stay
Close ✕
The infrastructure investments include over R16.5bn for water and sanitation, R5bn for electricity grid upgrades, R3.4bn for roads, and a further R4.5bn for the new MyCiti bus route linking Khayelitsha, Mitchell's Plain and a host of other communities with Wynberg and Claremont.
As part of the City's R6.7bn Safety and Security budget, the mayor said over 700 new municipal police officers will be deployed.
Hill-Lewis announced major tariff restructuring reforms, which are expected to shield lower income households from financial pressures.
In this reform, water and sanitation fixed charges will now be determined by property values rather than connection size; while electricity rates will rise by 2% on average.
Residents will also see a City-Wide Cleaning Tariff explicitly reflected on their bills from July alongside refuse removal.
According to Hill-Lewis, this is not a new expense as customers previously helped fund this via property rates, and the tariff will be fully buffered by the reduction of electricity costs going to other forms of service delivery.
The increases from the tariff restructure have provoked strong opposition from civic associations.
Tokai Residents' Association chairperson, Don Kourie, says they are firmly opposed to the tariff restructure, noting that the City's Tariff Calculator shows a potential 20% increase in monthly rates bills for homeowners.
'The new cleaning tariff is unacceptable — it's based on property value, yet the service benefits all residents equally, not individual homes.
'The water connection tariff will also be based on property value. A fixed fee for every property, as there is for refuse collection, rather than a property value-based mechanism, would be more appropriate,' Kourie says, arguing that the current method is inequitable.
'Rates and refuse charges are going up by 7–8%, well above the current 2.8% inflation rate. These new tariffs fail the City's own promise of equity and fairness. Many residents, especially pensioners on fixed incomes, will face an unfair and disproportionate burden.'
Keith Barton, Bergvliet Meadowridge Ratepayer's Association chairperson, says the draft budget places the burden on middle- and upper-income households with sharp hikes in fixed charges — all tied to property value.
'If approved, this budget will cause financial strain for many middle-income homes.
"A typical R4.2 million property in our suburbs would pay R920 more per month in fixed charges — irrespective of the amount of electricity and water consumed. Households with solar and boreholes using minimal City services could see monthly municipal bills rise by over 30%.
'The City says this new structure ends the past practice of cross-subsidising other municipal services via electricity sales. We do not believe that municipal charges should be so heavily skewed towards a property's value instead of its consumption of services.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
IOL News
a day ago
- IOL News
Western Cape police refute City claims of low firearm conviction rates
RECEIPTS City of Cape Town Mayor Geordin Hill-Lewis Image: File Photo Western Cape police have dismissed as misinformation claims by the City which suggested an 'unacceptably low conviction rate", reported at just 5% for the illegal possession of unlicensed or prohibited firearms. According to police, the figures by the City were inaccurate. The City had implied that the 5% conviction rate was linked to the 1670 firearms confiscated by the City's law enforcement from January 2021 to date, which Saps maintained was 'misleading'. Police were responding to a statement issued by the City on May 23, where they said: 'Mayor Geordin Hill-Lewis announced this week that City policing operations are removing over 400 illegal guns from the streets every year, but a broken criminal justice system secures convictions in just 5% of these cases. The SAPS and prosecutors have secured just 81 convictions so far from the 1 670 guns seized by municipal officers from January 2021 - January 2025.' Provincial police spokesperson, Andrè Traut said this was incorrect. 'The Western Cape SAPS has noted with concern recent claims suggesting an unacceptably low conviction rate, reported at just 5% for the illegal possession of unlicensed or prohibited firearms. Firearm-related crime remains a top priority for SAPS in the Western Cape, where firearms are frequently used to commit serious and violent offences. In response, SAPS members are relentlessly pursuing armed criminals, aiming not only to remove illegal firearms from our communities but also to ensure the successful prosecution of those found in possession of them. Contrary to the inaccurate figures being circulated, an analysis of our conviction record paints a far more accurate and encouraging picture. Our detectives have consistently achieved strong conviction rates." Video Player is loading. Play Video Play Unmute Current Time 0:00 / Duration -:- Loaded : 0% Stream Type LIVE Seek to live, currently behind live LIVE Remaining Time - 0:00 This is a modal window. Beginning of dialog window. Escape will cancel and close the window. Text Color White Black Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Background Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Transparent Window Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Transparent Semi-Transparent Opaque Font Size 50% 75% 100% 125% 150% 175% 200% 300% 400% Text Edge Style None Raised Depressed Uniform Dropshadow Font Family Proportional Sans-Serif Monospace Sans-Serif Proportional Serif Monospace Serif Casual Script Small Caps Reset restore all settings to the default values Done Close Modal Dialog End of dialog window. Advertisement Next Stay Close ✕ Ad Loading According to Saps their numbers showed an over 80% conviction rate for the past three years: 2021/2022 financial year: 86% conviction rate for illegal possession of firearms 2022/2023 financial year: 86% conviction rate for illegal possession of firearms 2023/2024 financial year: 89% conviction rate for illegal possession of firearms 'These results reflect the dedicated efforts of the investigators, prosecutors, and the broader criminal justice system to hold offenders accountable and enhance public safety and are the rates for all firearms confiscated by SAPS and other law enforcement agencies. Our mission remains to foster safer communities across the Western Cape. Misinformation, especially when it undermines public confidence in policing and the justice system, can generate unwarranted fear and mistrust. It is therefore essential that accurate and verified data be shared responsibly to support, rather than hinder, our collective efforts in fighting crime,' Traut added. Mayco member for safety and security, JP Smith maintained their 5% conviction rate was calculated and derived from the number of arrests they recorded. 'When looking at the statistics presented by SAPS, it is clear that a fundamental component of their calculation is absent: they have not indicated exactly how many of the cases actually went to court. It is feasible to get a conviction rate between 80% and 90% when you are only measuring the portion of the cases that make it to court. 'According to the SAPS statistics for the period between January 2020 and December 2024 a total of 13 727 arrests were made for the illegal possession of firearms. If the average conviction rate of 85% is to be believed, that would mean that SAPS obtained a staggering total of 11 668 convictions if every arrest actually made it to trial,' he said. Mayor Georgin Hill-Lewis added that conviction rates of 80-90% are 'misleading' due to how many cases never go to trial. 'Our experience is that despite City policing operations removing over 400 illegal guns from the streets every year, the vast majority of these cases do not go to trial due to our broken criminal justice system, which secured convictions in just 5% of the 1 670 cases of illegal guns seized by City officers over four years.'
Daily Maverick
2 days ago
- Daily Maverick
‘Enough is enough' – Saftu threatens mass protests over NMB public fund mismanagement
The South African Federation of Trade Unions in Gqeberha said on Wednesday that it was 'deeply outraged, though not surprised' by the Auditor-General's damning findings on the Nelson Mandela Bay metro. The organisation has threatened mass action as a response to 'incompetence, mismanagement and a total disregard for working-class residents'. The South African Federation of Trade Unions (Saftu) has threatened the Nelson Mandela Bay municipality with mass action to protest against what it has called the current coalition government's 'incompetence, mismanagement and total disregard for working-class residents'. Saftu secretary Mziyanda Mcanda said a meeting had been held with the Speaker of Council, Eugene Johnson, who had promised to address their concerns. But, he added, the latest Auditor-General's report on Nelson Mandela Bay was deeply shocking. 'The report confirms what workers, the unemployed and the poor have long known — that this municipality is being run into the ground by incompetence, mismanagement and a total disregard for working-class communities,' said Mcanda. Grant spending Despite being the only metro to receive the Regional Bulk Infrastructure Grant (RBIG) — a critical intervention aimed at improving bulk water and sanitation infrastructure — the municipality underspent the grant by 41%, according to this report. 'This is criminal negligence in a city facing chronic water insecurity and failing sanitation systems. Communities in KwaZakhele, Motherwell and Chatty continue to suffer water cuts and sewerage overflows, while the money meant to fix these issues lies idle due to so-called implementation challenges,' Mcanda said. 'Even more damning is the fact that 67% of senior management posts are vacant, the highest of any metro in the country. This leadership vacuum reflects a collapsing state — one that is either unwilling or unable to deliver even the most basic services. Workers inside the municipality are overburdened, demoralized and left without leadership or direction, while politically connected elites scramble for tenders and positions,' he added. Motherwell housing project He highlighted the plight of residents who had been promised housing through the Motherwell NU30 housing project, calling it 'another insult to our people'. 'The Auditor-General confirms that houses were approved for handover despite structural defects and no electricity. These are not homes; they are shells. People are being handed keys to hardship, not dignity. This is a systemic crisis. It cannot be reduced to administrative failures; it is the direct result of a capitalist state that serves private profiteers and political elites, not the working class. While public money goes unspent or wasted, our communities suffer hunger, evictions, floods and disease,' he said. Mcanda said the organisation wanted the urgent filling of senior vacancies with competent, accountable and community-oriented personnel. 'No more cadre deployment for corruption,' he added. They are also demanding the institution of a forensic investigation into the RBIG underspending and NU30 housing project, 'with consequences for those responsible'. He said they also wanted an emergency summit of affected communities, labour and civil society 'to chart a democratic, people-centred turnaround strategy for the metro'. Saftu's concerns were also echoed in a letter by faith leaders in the metro which was sent to President Cyril Ramaphosa in May. 'Enough is enough. We will not allow this municipality to continue failing our people. If these demands are not urgently addressed, Saftu Gqeberha will mobilise for mass action,' Mcanda added. DA says budget is morally indefensible Meanwhile, the Democratic Alliance (DA) said the proposed 2025/26 Nelson Mandela Bay budget was unrealistic and morally indefensible, as it passes the buck to ratepayers to 'fund the mismanagement of our inept ANC-led municipality'. In a pre-budget press conference held on Wednesday, Odendaal said the metro was haemorrhaging millions of rands due to its inability to spend grant funding. The budget will be discussed in a council meeting on Thursday. 'Over the last two financial years, the ANC-led administration's dysfunction has lost a staggering R900-million in grant funding meant to build roads, and water and electricity infrastructure. 'This inability to spend is a crisis and, as of April this year, the municipality had only spent 38% (R752-million) of its R1.934-billion capital expenditure budget. 'Against the backdrop of this continued mismanagement, the tariff increases in the budget are morally indefensible. Imagine losing money and then asking ratepayers to balance the books,' Odendaal added. He further said that the budget as presented to council was only funded because it assumes a 76% collection rate while the average collection rate for the 2024/2025 financial year is 72.15%. 'Ward-based budgets are also a major concern as very little budget has been made available for certain wards. The DA believes every community has the right to a fair allocation of resources,' he said. Executive Mayor of Nelson Mandela Bay Municipality, Cllr Babalwa Lobishe, held a mayoral member committee meeting on Wednesday to address the findings of the Auditor-General, and stressed the critical importance of enhanced planning and accountability within all departments. She promised last week that she would address the vast underspending of Treasury grants at the city council meeting on Thursday. 'By Monday, a consultative report must be ready for virtual discussion to guide Wednesday's submission. With only three months left until the Auditor-General's review, we cannot afford to be caught off guard,' she said. Departments have also been directed to review current contracts, identify possible risks and define clear actions to avoid repeated deviations or contract extensions. 'Changing our culture doesn't take time; it takes consistency. If we focus on efficient, daily execution, our teams will adapt and we will start seeing real progress,' she concluded. DM
Daily Maverick
5 days ago
- Daily Maverick
The Finance Ghost: The retail lowdown on Lewis, Spar, Pick n Pay and Dis-Chem
There was a flurry of corporate activity in the past week as companies with February and March year-ends looked to get results out before the end of the month. Many companies manage to get results out within two months of the end of the reporting period, with others using the full three months that they are allowed by the JSE. Amongst all the noise, there were several retailers that released important results. As a major source of employment in South Africa and with businesses that everyone can relate to as you can easily visit the stores yourself, this sector is always deserving of attention. Lewis: the pick of the litter The narrative around furniture group Lewis is nothing like it used to be. For years, this was a story of tepid growth and a focus on cost control, with a capital allocation strategy that took full advantage of the benefits of share buybacks. Now, Lewis is behaving like a growth stock with double-digit revenue growth and a colossal jump in Heps of 60.3% for the year ended March 2025. Such has been the extent of share price growth that they didn't do any share buybacks at all in the second half of the financial year! advertisement Don't want to see this? Remove ads Can they keep it up? This is the question on everyone's lips. Somehow, they've managed to boost credit sales (up 12.1% versus cash sales up 3.4%) without sacrificing the quality of the debtors' book. This is a holy grail outcome, as retailers that sell on credit must always consider the benefit of additional sales against the risk of credit losses. So far, so good at Lewis. The market is still wary of how sustainable this growth path is, so investors will be paying a great deal of focus to the next interim period. Spar retreats from Europe – well, mostly With Spar having been through such a terrible time in recent years, it was always unlikely that the pain would end with the disposal of the business in Poland. Things got so bad there that Spar essentially paid someone to take that asset away, with the group incurring debt to recapitalise the business in Poland before selling it for next to nothing. It's the equivalent of begging someone to arrive with a trailer to drag your broken old car off your lawn. advertisement Don't want to see this? Remove ads To add to the headaches, the business in Switzerland had been showing some worrying signs for a while, as food is so expensive in that country that Swiss residents literally cross the border to buy their groceries instead of going to their local retailers like Spar. Risks like these are extremely hard for South Africans to foresee, which is why it's advisable to stick to familiar markets rather than doing business somewhere completely different. Unlike in the case of Poland where they waited until the very end to remove that tumour from the group, Spar has decided to sell the Swiss business. They are also letting go of AWG in southwest England, which came as a surprise as there weren't any obvious concerns around that business. This leaves them with only the businesses in Southern Africa and Ireland going forwards. Of course, there's a difference between simply deciding to sell something and actually getting it sold, so it will be a while until the group is so clean and simple. In the meantime, investors have to suffer through diluted Heps from total operations dropping by between -24% and -34% for the 26 weeks to 28 March 2025. If you look at only the continuing operations, it should be between 0% and -15% lower for the period – still a poor outcome. They have a lot of fixing to do at Spar. Pick n Pay is a reminder that turnarounds are hard Speaking of fixing, there's still a long way to go at Pick n Pay. In fact, with the results for the 53 weeks to 2 March 2025 now out in the wild, the group has noted that they only expect their core Pick n Pay segment to break even by 2028. CEO Sean Summers has agreed to extend his contract until then to help drive that outcome. advertisement Don't want to see this? Remove ads This leaves the group in a situation where the controlling stake in Boxer is doing the heavy lifting, with the plan being to stem the bleeding in Pick n Pay as quickly as they can. There are at last some encouraging signs, like an uptick in like-for-like sales, but Pick n Pay will have to fight every step of the way in a market that is a bloodbath of competition. advertisement Don't want to see this? Remove ads If you dig into the underlying earnings or read the company announcements, just be cautious of getting excited about the trading profit line. Due to silly accounting rules, lease costs (which are obviously substantial for retailers) are actually recognised in net finance costs, which come in below trading profit. In other words, trading profit ignores lease costs, so it's a very flattering view of profitability. This is why Pick n Pay clarifies that their breakeven goal for 2028 is based on trading profit net of lease costs, which is the correct way to look at things. Dis-Chem keeps delivering – but did the market want more? With Dis-Chem's share price closing 6.3% lower on Friday after the release of results for the year ended 28 February 2025, you would be forgiven for thinking that the numbers were weak. Instead, we find Heps growth of 20% and a similar increase in the total dividend for the year. Sure, Dis-Chem is now on a demanding Price:Earnings (P:E) ratio of 24.4x based on latest numbers, but could the market really have been expecting so much more than 20% growth in earnings? In such a case where the share price move isn't easily explained by the earnings, it's best to skip to the outlook section of the announcement to see if there are any clues there. Dis-Chem notes a constrained consumer environment, but we are hearing that story everywhere and it's not exactly anything new. Helpfully, they've also given a sales update for 1 March to 27 May (i.e. about the first quarter of the new financial year) that reflects 8.6% growth in group revenue. This is even better than the 8% full-year growth that they just reported! Comparable pharmacy store revenue has accelerated from 4.1% for FY25 to 4.6% for these past few months. Perhaps the worry was around growth in wholesale revenue to external customers, which slowed down significantly from 22.1% to 13.6%. Still, that really shouldn't be enough to drive a 6.3% drop in the share price. advertisement Don't want to see this? Remove ads advertisement Don't want to see this? Remove ads This share price dip comes after a strong 30-day performance in the market, so it may be due to profit-taking by punters in response to earnings. Regardless, the underlying business is strong and Dis-Chem has continued to deliver for investors despite the pressure on consumer spending. As local retail businesses go, this is one of the best. DM
