TD tells Dáil he is ‘lucky' to have declined surgery suggested for son by consultant under investigation
A Government TD has spoken in the Dáil of his family's personal experience with the consultant under investigation for the implanting of unapproved springs into three children during spinal surgery.
Fine Gael Wicklow-Wexford TD Brian Brennan said he has two children aged seven and six. His young son has cystic fibrosis and was called to see the consultant under investigation, he said.
'We met the consultant. He told us literally straight away that my son needed surgery. I asked straight away, like any parent would ask, 'what are the pluses and what are the minuses'.'
'He explained about them. I said, 'leave the decision with us' ... I told my wife we're not going ahead."
READ MORE
Mr Brennan said his son had already been through enough with his cystic fibrosis.
'So I am a lucky parent, but my heart – and I'm emotional on this – my heart goes out to every other parent who has been affected.'
'How someone can stand there and look a child in the eyes and say, 'we need to do surgery on you' when it's not needed,' Mr Brennan asked
'It's simply horrific. It's unfair, I'm upset, but I'm also annoyed,' he said. appealing to the Dáil 'to let justice take its course'.
He was speaking during a debate on the surgeries in which Minister for Health Jennifer Carroll MacNeill offered her 'deepest regret for the distress and anxiety caused to the families'. The HSE and CHI (Children's Health Ireland) have apologised to the children and families affected by these issues, she said.
She said children were 'failed in process, duty and responsibility'.
'We must confront this failure openly, honestly and with a determination to make sure it does not happen again and to regain trust.'
The Minister said a Health Information and Quality Authority (HIQA) report into the use of unauthorised springs in spinal surgeries was a 'stark reminder of what happens when safeguards fail'. The report found that springs implanted in surgeries between 2020 and 2022 were not CE-marked and that the controls in place 'did not provide adequate safeguards at each stage of the process'.
She said 'what happened to the children involved was wrong ... should not have been allowed to happen.' The chair of the board has resigned and a new chairperson is expected to be appointed 'in the coming weeks'.
She added: 'I assure everyone here and outside of this House that I am totally committed to dealing with these issues.'
The HSE's chief executive and his team are regularly meeting the CHI's chief executive to ensure the 19 HIQA recommendations 'are being implemented without delay'.
Sinn Féin health spokesman David Cullinane said 'the story of CHI has been a sorry saga of dysfunction and crisis.
A separate audit is continuing into hip dysplasia amid reports that 561 children were recalled after claims that surgeries were carried out unnecessarily and in some cases children did not have the condition at all.
Mr Cullinane said parents of children who had surgeries 'don't know if the osteotomies were needed or not and are still in the dark'. Many people got a second opinion and were told their child did not have the condition or need the surgery.
The procedure involves cutting into the child's bone 'so it's a really invasive surgery'. He said 'there has to be accountability' in CHI and very similar issues happened concerning surgeries for children with scoliosis and spina bifida. 'It's the same people, it's the same culture, it's the same failures.'
The Minister said she had not received the audit report into hip dysplasia and could not verify the details Sinn Féin had based on media reports that 60 per cent of surgeries at Temple Street were not indicated, 79 per cent at Cappagh were not indicated, and 2 per cent at Crumlin were not indicated.
She pledged to publish the audit when she received it and to hold a debate in the Dáil.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Independent
4 hours ago
- Irish Independent
Tipperary eatery ordered to close over food safety breaches
Shake Dog restaurant-café, located at Unit 23, Showgrounds Shopping Centre, Clonmel, Co Tipperary, was ordered to close on May 14, and the order was lifted on May 19. The order was served under the EU's Official Controls in Relation to Food Legislation regulations, 2020, the Food Safety Authority of Ireland (FSAI) reported on Tuesday this week. The closure order was served on Clonmel Diner Ltd by the Health Service Executive (HSE), and directed that all of the activities of the business, its establishments, holdings or other premises, be ceased. The HSE officer noted that the hazard analysis and critical control point (HACCP) based procedures which had been put in place were not effectively implemented in practice. 'To control the growth of food poisoning bacteria in cold food, the HACCP based procedures in place state: safe storage of food is to be chilled and stored between 0C to 5C. 'Some high risk chilled foods were being held at potentially unsafe temperatures (above the critical limit of <5C for cold display established in the Shake Dog HACCP plan), in the server area.' The HSE officer reported that evidence of non-compliance with legislation included 'garlic mayonnaise and salsa in middle of counter top unit opposite to grill: 13.6C. 'Cooked bacon at back of counter top unit adjacent to grill: 9.2C. Raw chicken breasts in milk at back of counter top unit adjacent to grill: 12.6C. Raw sausage at back of counter top unit adjacent to grill: 10C. 'These potentially unsafe holding temperatures had not been identified as part of part of your temperature monitoring procedures. 'Temperature monitoring records must accurately reflect actual food temperatures and corrective action (s) must be taken and recorded whenever temperature monitoring indicates that a critical control point (such as storage) is not under control.' ADVERTISEMENT Business operators are to maintain and provide evidence of an appropriate food safety culture by fulfilling certain requirements, such as the safe production and distribution of food, noted the inspector. 'There has been repeated non-compliance with regulatory requirements,' stated the HSE officer. 'An unsatisfactory level of compliance with food safety legislation was observed during previous inspection.' The legislation stipulates that all articles, fittings and equipment with which food comes into contact with are to be effectively cleaned and where necessary, disinfected. Evidence of non-compliance included that food contact equipment had evidence of food residue present. Additionally, the wash basin behind the counter in the milkshake drinks area was covered with plastic film as the hand basin was blocked. 'Stagnant water pooling within the wash basin,' was observed. 'There was no material for cleaning and or drying hands at the wash hand basin in the rear preparation area.' 'There was a small amount of liquid soap available which appeared to be watered down at the hand basin in the main food preparation area,' concluded the inspection report.
Irish Examiner
10 hours ago
- Irish Examiner
Parents of boy with muscular dystrophy to hold rally at Dáil to campaign for vital drug
The mother of a child with a muscle-wasting disease is to hold a rally at the Dáil on Wednesday, urging the Government to support the introduction of a vital drug here that will help slow progression of the disease. Archie Ennis, aged 8, from Dublin, was diagnosed with muscular dystrophy before Christmas — a condition that affects about 120 boys in Ireland. There is no cure for it. The schoolboy's parents, Una and Kenneth, launched a GoFundMe campaign to help pay for specialist gene therapy in the US, which costs at least €3.2m. Meanwhile, the couple had also been campaigning for the Government to sanction pay for a new drug called givinostat, which has just been approved by the European Medicines Agency. Ms Ennis told the Irish Examiner: 'This drug will slow down Archie's muscle-wasting disease, but it also means it will help other children here. Archie Ennis: The rally outside the Dáil will take place at 1pm and Ms Ennis will be joined by family, friends and the other parents of boys with muscular dystrophy who are all supporting the call for the rollout of givinostat here. 'The drug was approved by the EMA recently, now the pharmaceutical companies can apply to the Government to see if they will refund the drug. 'But that will take time as they have to wait for the Government to decide if they will pay for this in order to make it free here. 'It makes sense for it to be made available free here, if the Government doesn't pay for the drug, they will be paying for other things such as more equipment for a child with the disease, they'll be paying for the care of that child, and carer's allowances — it all balances out,' Ms Ennis said. The rally outside the Dáil will take place at 1pm and Ms Ennis will be joined by family, friends and the other parents of boys with muscular dystrophy who are all supporting the call for the rollout of givinostat here. 'Time is muscle' she said. 'Archie's muscles are weak; he needs help going up the stairs and he gets tired when we are out on walks. This drug will slow down the progression of the disease, keep him on his feet for longer, keep his heart and lungs healthier longer and he will do better. She said the drug givinostat was something 'that the country needs,' but Archie will also need gene therapy — for which they are fundraising. The GoFundMe has so far raised €600,000 for Archie's treatment abroad, but it not even half of what he needs. 'We have been to Miami to get tests done but we really need the drug introduced here to start the process. 'We are hoping to follow Scotland, which is pushing to have the drug in pharmacies within five months. 'We have booked the AV room in Leinster House for 2:30pm on Wednesday and have invited all of the TDs, including the health minister to come along and hear our stories.'
Irish Times
15 hours ago
- Irish Times
From 20 cigarettes a day for 55 years to finally quitting: ‘I took it up, thinking I was the big man'
For 55 years, Mick Staunton smoked more than 20 cigarettes a day. His wife, Olivia, wasn't far behind him, having taken up smoking 46 years ago and smoking at least 10 a day ever since. However, proving that you are never too old to quit, the Roscommon couple have finally ditched the habit and are feeling much healthier as a result. 'I took it up, like every young fella, thinking I was the big man,' said the 74-year-old. 'Olivia (71) was similar, and with the two of us smoking, it became harder and harder to quit, even though we tried a few times.' The retired garda says that he and his wife, who used to work in the Civil Service, attempted to stop smoking on numerous occasions throughout their lives, but knew they needed support to stop for good. READ MORE 'Whenever I tried, I would only last a few months before going back on them [cigarettes] and Olivia was the same,' said the father of five. 'We tried to go cold turkey and were using sweets and chewing gum whenever we wanted a cigarette, but they were a poor substitute. So last year we contacted the [ HSE ] QUIT team and the support we got was the biggest thing to help us through.' More than 17 per cent of the Irish population are smokers, with 14 per cent smoking daily, and 4 per cent occasionally. With 20 per cent of the 25- to 34-year-old age bracket smoking, this demographic has the highest number of smokers. However, these figures have declined since the first Healthy Ireland Survey in 2015, when the figure was 32 per cent. This decrease could be down to more available supports, as, according to the HSE, smokers are four times more likely to quit successfully if they use a combination of nicotine replacement therapy (NRT) in the form of sprays, mists, lozenges and patches, along with support from a 'stop smoking adviser'. Smoking is a leading cause of preventable death and significantly impacts physical and mental health, so giving up can lead to improved health, reduced disease risk, and better overall wellbeing, including increased life expectancy and reduced stress. 'Smoking is dangerous, and the odds facing people who smoke are stark - 1 in 2 will die of a smoking-related disease; on average, people who smoke will die 10 years earlier and are at increased risk of cancer, heart attack, stroke, lung disease and many other debilitating diseases,' said Dr Paul Kavanagh, HSE public health consultant and clinical adviser to the Tobacco Free Ireland Programme. [ Smoking ban has important lessons for Ireland's approach to climate issues Opens in new window ] However, Dr Kavanagh says it's not all bad news, as these odds can be changed when people stop smoking. 'We see changes in physiological measures like heart rate, blood pressure and exhaled carbon monoxide within days; breathing and exercise tolerance will improve within weeks; and over the coming months and years, the risk of smoking-related disease reduces dramatically.' Mick Staunton with his wife Olivia in their garden in Castlerea. Photograph: Arthur Ellis According to the HSE, other health benefits include increased life expectancy as smoking takes an average of 10 to 15 years off a person's life, reduced risk of life-threatening diseases, improved respiratory function, circulation and oxygen levels, and better skin, teeth and hair. Quitting smoking also helps with improved mood and reduces feelings of stress, anxiety and depression. Giving up also helps to improve fertility, reduces risk of pregnancy complications, offers protection for loved ones from second-hand smoke and creates financial savings as it can 'free up a significant amount of money'. Research from Healthy Ireland Statistics shows that 17 per cent of the population smokes cigarettes, while another 8 per cent uses e-cigarettes, either daily or occasionally. These figures have not changed since 2023, and Martina Blake, national lead for the HSE Tobacco Free Ireland Programme, says NRTs can help more people to quit. 'These licensed medicines safely give you just enough nicotine to relieve cravings and withdrawal symptoms, while reducing your dependence on nicotine gradually,' she said. 'They help you to cope with cravings and withdrawal symptoms, but do not contain the poisonous and cancer-causing chemicals in tobacco smoke, such as tar and carbon monoxide.' [ Quitting smoking isn't easy, but these tricks could help Opens in new window ] Men remain more likely to smoke than women (20 per cent of men smoke as opposed to 15 per cent of women), and Mick Staunton says it's never too late to think about giving up. 'We both wish we did it years ago, as we're flying it now.'
