Woman who denies mushroom murders of her in-laws accepts that she served them death caps for lunch
Erin Patterson, the woman accused of serving her ex-husband's family poisonous mushrooms, is photographed in Melbourne, Australia, on April 15, 2025. (James Ross/AAP Image via AP)
WELLINGTON, New Zealand — An Australian woman accused of murdering three of her estranged husband's relatives with poisonous mushrooms told a court on Tuesday she accepted that the fatal lunch she served contained death caps.
But Erin Patterson said the 'vast majority' of the fungi came from local stores. She denies three counts of murder and one of attempted murder over the beef Wellington meal she served to her parents-in-law and her estranged husband's aunt and uncle at her home in July 2023.
Don Patterson, Gail Patterson and Heather Wilkinson were hospitalized and died after the lunch in the rural town of Leongatha in the Australian state of Victoria. Heather's husband, Ian Wilkinson, was gravely ill but survived.
Patterson's lawyer earlier told the Supreme Court trial that the poisoning was a tragic accident but prosecutors said it was deliberate. If convicted, she faces a sentence of life imprisonment on the murder charges and 25 years in jail for attempted murder.
Long queues formed outside the Latrobe Valley Courthouse on Tuesday after Patterson took the stand late Monday, which was the first time she had spoken publicly since the deaths.
Accused foraged mushrooms for years
During several hours of evidence on Tuesday, Patterson, 50, told the court she began foraging fungi during the COVID-19 lockdown of March 2020, witnessed only by her children.
'I cut a bit of one of the mushrooms, fried it up with some butter and ate it,' she said. 'They tasted good and I didn't get sick.'
Patterson said she also fed foraged mushrooms to her children, chopped up 'very, very small' so they couldn't pick them out of curries, pasta and soups.
She developed a taste for exotic varieties, joined a 'mushroom lovers' Facebook group, and bought a dehydrator to preserve her finds, Patterson said. Her lawyer, Colin Mandy SC, asked if she accepted that the beef Wellington pastries she had served to her lunch guests in 2023 contained death caps.
'Yes, I do,' said Patterson.
The accused told her lawyer most of the mushrooms she used that day came from local supermarkets. She agreed she might have put them in the same container as dehydrated wild mushrooms she had foraged weeks earlier and others from an Asian food store.
Mandy in April told the court his client had lied when she initially told investigators that she had never foraged before. But he denied that she had deliberately sought out death cap mushrooms and said she disposed of her dehydrator in a panic about the accidental deaths.
Regrets over 'venting' messages about in-laws
Earlier Tuesday, Patterson became tearful when she was asked about expletive-filled messages she had sent about her in-laws in December 2022 in a Facebook group chat that she described as a 'safe venting space' for a group of women.
'I wish I'd never said it. I feel very ashamed for saying it and I wish that the family didn't have to hear that I said it,' said Patterson. 'They didn't deserve it.'
Patterson, who said she had tried to have her parents-in-law mediate a dispute with her estranged husband, Simon, about school fees, said she was feeling hurt, frustrated and 'a little bit desperate.'
The couple formally separated in 2015 after earlier temporary splits, the court has heard. Simon Patterson was invited to the July 2023 lunch but did not attend.
Accused said she was still close with husband's family
Tuesday's evidence also traversed Patterson's health after prosecutors' suggestions that her lunch invitation was unusual and that she'd organized it on a false pretense of receiving a cancer diagnosis. The mother of two admitted she never had cancer, but had been worried enough by symptoms to seek tests.
Despite her separation from Simon, Patterson said she had hoped to reunite with her estranged husband and said she had remained close to her in-laws.
'It never changed. I was just their daughter in law,' said Patterson, through tears. 'They just continued to love me.'
Evidence follows lengthy prosecution case
The 14-member jury has heard five weeks of prosecution evidence, including what the lunch guests told relatives before they died. Heather Wilkinson said shortly before she died that Patterson ate her individual beef wellington pastry from a different colored plate to the other diners, said prosecutor Nanette Rogers.
Opening her case in April, Rogers said the poisoning was deliberate but that her case would not suggest a motive for the alleged killings. The prosecution says Patterson lied when she told investigators she had eaten the same meal as her guests and fed her children the leftovers.
Patterson is due to continue giving evidence on Wednesday. Her evidence Tuesday did not include her account of the day of the lunch, or cross-examination from prosecutors.
Charlotte Graham-mclay, The Associated Press
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CBC
3 hours ago
- CBC
A book prescription for mental health?
On the surface, it may seem that bibliotherapy is another personal wellness trend. The practice promotes books and literature as touchstones, to aid mental health and healing. While it's true that anyone can offer book recommendations, there is evidence in the scientific literature to support its clinical use by mental health practitioners. "It's recommended in the Canadian guidelines for treatment of depression and anxiety," said Victoria-based psychiatrist Martina Scholtens. Bibliotherapy is one of the mental health approaches that she makes use of in her private practice, for certain patients. She might prescribe poetry or a memoir, a novel or workbook. "I want the prescription to be evidence-based and tailored to the recipient of the book and their very particular circumstances," she said. Dr. Scholtens, who is a clinical assistant professor of medicine at the University of British Columbia, put together a list of recommended titles, based on evidence. "I wanted to make book prescriptions more accessible to patients and their caregivers by reviewing, organizing, and disseminating recommended reading lists." She first published the extensively-researched list as an academic paper in 2024, but has now created a website for it, divided by diagnosis, at Bibliotherapy as an art Bibliotherapy can range from a science-based approach, to one that is primarily literary. Brooklyn journalist Cody Delistraty sought out an arts-based bibliotherapist when researching ways to address the prolonged grief he felt after the death of his mother. Then in his early 20s, Delistraty undertook a number of experiments and therapies. "I love to read, I love to write. So [bibliotherapy] made sense for me to dive into," said the author of The Grief Cure: Looking for the End of Loss. After an "odd, not-your-usual therapy session" and an intensive reading questionnaire, English bibliotherapist Ella Berthoud furnished him with an annotated and personalized list of international fiction. He particularly resonated with Sum, a collection of surreal and witty short stories by neuroscientist David Eagleman. "Grief can feel so sacred and so scary," said Delistraty. "To realize that it's just part of the wildness and the absurdity of life had the peculiar effect of helping me to really see the world through a new lens." Literary caregiving A Hundred Years of Bibliotherapy: Healing Through Books, is a new essay collection edited by three researchers from the UK's Open University. It takes a historical survey of the practice. "The term bibliotherapy was coined by an American Unitarian minister called Samuel McChord Crothers in 1916," said 20th-century literature professor Sara Haslam. "The First World War is certainly a key inflection point." America's institutionally-backed Library War Service set up military camp libraries at the start of the First World War. At U.S. military hospitals, books were prescribed and dispensed to wounded soldiers by uniformed librarians. The British version of bibliotherapy was somewhat less prescriptive and medicalized. Sara Haslam calls it "literary caregiving." In places like the female-run Endell Street Military Hospital, "it wasn't about medicalizing books as part of soldiers' recovery. It was about freeing wounded and sick soldiers to identify the kind of reading that they wanted to do." Haslam discovered archival proof that a substantial UK war library was amassed by 1917, spearheaded by one woman. Donations poured in from the public after May Gaskell's emotional call-out asking for meaningful books for soldiers. "I see these books as invested with caregiving from the donating public. They gave things that were precious, that they loved. So it went a long way to meeting the need that was being expressed by those who were fighting." Reading in a digital era A hundred years later, it seems that bibliotherapy has been experiencing a renaissance. Two more new books about bibliotherapy are being published this spring: one by bibliotherapist Bijal Shah, and another from social worker Emely Rumble. Edmund King, a co-editor of A Hundred Years of Bibliotherapy, is a historian of reading. He has a theory for the resurgence. "I think the reason that we're so obsessed now with the idea that books can heal, or are good for us, is because we also fear the end of reading." Despite the rise of BookTok, the books community populated by users of TikTok, King worries about the decline of time young people spend with books. "The literary culture that we value so much might be coming to an end." Yet throughout the history of reading, he says, it has been imbued with "this great power to change people's minds, change the way we see the world, transfer thoughts from one mind to another, preserve ideas, transmit ideas to different times and different contexts." For Sara Haslam, books remain powerful. In her view, opening a book is always surprising, and inherently conducive to mental health. "It's a moment when you are in the present. You have slowed down," she said. "I think it's fair to say that there is a wide readership of all ages who still recognize that that moment in engagement with a book is irreplaceable. "And long may that continue." *Written and produced by Lisa Godfrey. Guests in this episode: Martina Scholtens is a psychiatrist in Victoria, and a clinical assistant professor at UBC Faculty of Medicine. She is the author of Your Heart Is the Size of Your Fist: A Doctor Reflects on Ten Years at a Refugee Clinic.
CBC
6 hours ago
- CBC
Lots of COVID booster appointments available, says pharmacy manager, with 3 weeks left in spring campaign
It's been slow going for some Victoria-area pharmacies offering COVID boosters these past few months, as the Ministry of Health is reporting a steady increase in the latest variant of the virus. Linda Gutenberg, who is in charge of pharmacy operations for Heart Pharmacy Group, which operates seven locations in the Greater Victoria Area, said the current vaccine campaign has been particularly slow since it started on April 8. "We were kind of like all ramped up and ready to go and nobody really showed up," she said during an interview on CBC's On The Island. She said last week, pharmacists administered about half the booster shots they did compared to one year ago. However, as of June 1, the province said 287,294 people in B.C. have been vaccinated for COVID-19, up slightly from 282,911 at a similar time last year. Gutenberg isn't entirely sure why there's a dip in interest, but she has a hunch. "I think there's a little bit of vaccine fatigue, where people are just kind of tired of just coming in and getting vaccines all the time." With only a few weeks left in the campaign, which ends June 30, she said there are lots of appointments available. The latest variant of COVID-19, called NB.1.8.1, may be more transmissible than previous mutations, according to the World Health Organization. The organization's latest risk assessment, which covered July to December of last year, found the health risk from COVID-19 is still high, but suggests the impact is decreasing. The Ministry of Health said COVID-19 has been increasing globally since February. PCR and wastewater testing have shown low levels of the virus in B.C., but it has been rising since March. It said the best way to prevent severe illness from the virus is to stay up to date on vaccines. The ministry recommends anyone over 65, Indigenous adults aged 55 and older, long-term care home and assisted living residents and anyone over six months who has been diagnosed as extremely vulnerable, get a COVID-19 booster this spring.
CBC
10 hours ago
- CBC
Australian woman denies weighing 'fatal dose' of poisonous mushrooms in murder trial
Social Sharing An Australian woman accused of murder denied measuring out a "fatal dose" of poisonous mushrooms on her kitchen scales to kill three elderly relatives of her estranged husband, as she was cross-examined by the prosecution on Thursday. Erin Patterson, 50, is charged with the July 2023 murders of her mother-in-law Gail Patterson, father-in-law Donald Patterson and Gail's sister, Heather Wilkinson, along with the attempted murder of Ian Wilkinson, Heather's husband. The prosecution accuses her of knowingly serving the guests lethal death cap mushrooms as part of a Beef Wellington at her home in Leongatha, a town of about 6,000 some 135 km (84 miles) from Melbourne. She denies the charges, which carry a life sentence, with her defence calling the deaths a "terrible accident." Under cross-examination on Thursday by the prosecution, Erin Patterson was asked whether a series of photos of mushrooms placed on weighing scales in her kitchen was evidence she had been measuring a "fatal dose" to serve to her lunch guests. "I suggest that you were weighing these death cap mushrooms so that you could calculate the weight required for the administration of a fatal dose for one person. Agree or disagree?" barrister Nanette Rogers said. "Disagree," Patterson replied. Patterson accepted under cross-examination that she had lied to police and medical professionals following the lunch when she was asked whether she had ever foraged for mushrooms or owned a food dehydrator, which was later found in a waste disposal plant containing traces of death caps. The accused has previously admitted she lied about being diagnosed with cancer, but on Thursday denied doing so in order to lure her guests to have lunch at her home. "I suggest that you never thought you would have to account for this lie about having cancer, because you thought that the lunch guests would die," Rogers said. "That's not true," Patterson replied. While being examined by her own barrister Colin Mandy, Patterson said earlier on Thursday that she did not intentionally pick death cap mushrooms, or knowingly serve them to her lunch guests. Nor had she pretended to be sick after the lunch to avoid becoming a suspect in the case, she said. The trial has captured public attention across Australia, where such cases are exceedingly rare. Podcasters, journalists and documentary-makers from local and international media have descended on the town of Morwell where the trial is being held, about two hours east of Melbourne. State broadcaster ABC's daily podcast about the proceedings is currently Australia's most popular, while many domestic newspapers have run live blogs on trial developments. Justice Christopher Beale, the judge presiding in the case, told the jury the cross-examination of the accused would probably continue into next week. The prosecution rested its case on Monday after a month of evidence from relatives and medical, forensic and mushroom experts. After the defence rests, the parties will discuss whether the prosecution might seek to reopen its case in light of defense evidence, Beale told the jury. The trial, set to conclude this month, continues.
