McGill moves to cut ties with student union after protest led to classroom blockades, vandalism
McGill University is looking to cut its contractual relationship with the Students' Society of McGill University (SSMU) after pro-Palestinian protests last week led to blocked access to classrooms and vandalism.
Either party is permitted to end the relationship with no fault assigned, provided that mediation is attempted beforehand, according to the memorandum of agreement (MOA), interim deputy provost Angela Campbell said in an email. The school will begin that mediation process, she added, which will last for two weeks. An official decision will be made public in June.
While the SSMU plays an important and historic role in representing undergraduate students at McGill, the SSMU's "leadership has been neither unanimous nor explicit in dissociating itself from or rejecting groups without recognized status at McGill that endorse or engage in acts of vandalism, intimidation and obstruction as forms of activism," the email states.
"We reject this, unequivocally. Protest is indeed part of university life — our policies and the law protect peaceful assembly and freedom of expression," Campbell said. "But vandalism, obstruction, threats and violence do not fall within these protections."
The letter states that last week, SSMU allowed and, "at least tacitly," supported a three-day strike that led to dozens of classes being blocked or interrupted. Campbell cites one incident where individuals smashed a glass office door with a fire extinguisher filled with red paint. The paint was sprayed throughout the office and one staff member was hit directly, she says.
"No one at McGill … should ever have to experience this at their place of work or study," Campbell said.
The protest occurred during a three-day student strike over the university's investments linked to Israel. According to the SSMU, about 4,000 students participated in a referendum and the strike motion passed with 72 per cent support.
SSMU has no way to enforce rules, president says
Dymetri Taylor, SSMU president, said this decision comes on the heels of a student strike that overall stayed within the procedures, guidelines and bylaws in place. As for the actions that went too far, such as the incident with the paint, he said the SSMU did not encourage those behaviours.
"We strictly said at the beginning that students were expected to follow the code of student conduct — that it was a voluntary strike. We can't mandate anyone to participate if they don't want to," Taylor said.
"Blockading classrooms gets out of the voluntary aspect there."
He said the co-ordinated events fell within the guidelines, but some groups did their own thing. The SSMU doesn't have a way to enforce the rules, he said.
It's up to the school to enforce them. The SSMU can't hire security to stop certain behaviours, he said.
Barry Eidlin, an associate professor of sociology at McGill, supports the student union. He's also a labour expert, and said student associations like the SSMU aren't just another academic club or student advocacy group in Quebec. Comparing them to a labour union, he said they have more structure and representation in the province.
He sharply criticized the McGill administration for cutting ties with the SSMU, calling it an "astonishing violation of student freedom of speech and freedom of assembly."
He accused the university of taking steps to limit student freedom of expression on campus by determining which issues students are allowed to speak up about.
Lawyer says SSMU will remain accredited
Patrice Blais, a lawyer who specializes in non-profit law and accrediting student unions, also compared the SSMU to a labour union. They receive accreditation from Quebec's Ministry of Higher Education, giving them certain powers and rights such as appointing representatives and having office space.
He said the MOA is a contract that goes further than the accreditation, determining how the relationship with the university will work — including fees, office space and activities. There are ways to terminate or renegotiate the contract, Blais said, but when McGill says it will terminate the agreement, the SSMU still retains provincial accreditation.
"In no way will it be able to remove the rights under the accreditation act," said Blais. "It's not like McGill could defund the student union tomorrow. That would be against the law."
That means the SSMU still gets office space and its appointments to various student bodies must be recognized, Blais said. When it comes to terminating the MOA, he can't say exactly what will be affected because he hasn't seen the contract.
"But I think it's going to change very little overall," said Blais.
Students for Palestine's Honour and Resistance (SPHR) voiced its support for the SSMU in a statement, saying "the student body has never been more united and galvanized for Palestine, and that is precisely why the administration is insistent on penalizing everyone for a democratic strike instead of simply divesting."

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Global News
5 hours ago
- Global News
Canada invites Saudi Arabia's Mohammed bin Salman to G7 summit: sources
Canada has invited Saudi Arabia's Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman to the upcoming G7 Leaders' Summit in Alberta, Global News has learned. It is not yet known if bin Salman has accepted the invitation. He did not attend last year's G7 summit in Italy despite being invited there as well. Canada's invitation marks the third time in recent days that Prime Minister Mark Carney and his government has reached out to leaders of countries whose relationships with Canada have been strained. Leaders from the world's largest economies are set to gather in Kananaskis for three days of talks that begin Sunday. It is common practice for host countries to invite other world leaders to the annual summit to discuss pressing global issues. Saudi Arabia is seen as a key player in Middle East diplomacy. It has been supportive of efforts to secure a ceasefire in Gaza, where Israel continues to conduct a military offensive against Hamas that has created a humanitarian crisis in the Palestinian territory. Story continues below advertisement The kingdom has also hosted talks involving the United States on finding an end to Russia's war in Ukraine, a conflict that is expected to be among the major topics at the summit. Yet Saudi Arabia's human rights record has been criticized by Canada and independent advocacy groups, despite bin Salman's stated efforts to improve women's rights. 5:26 Controversy over Saudi Arabia hosting 2034 FIFA World Cup The country recalled its ambassador from Ottawa and expelled Canada's envoy in 2018 after Global Affairs Canada called on Saudi Arabia to 'immediately release' detained women's rights and democracy activists. Get daily National news Get the day's top news, political, economic, and current affairs headlines, delivered to your inbox once a day. Sign up for daily National newsletter Sign Up By providing your email address, you have read and agree to Global News' Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy That diplomatic spat began months before the murder of Washington Post journalist Jamal Khashoggi at a Saudi consulate in Turkey. Saudi Arabia has denied findings by U.S. intelligence agencies that bin Salman had approved his killing. Canada sanctioned over a dozen Saudi nationals linked to Khashoggi's murder. Story continues below advertisement Canada and Saudi Arabia began thawing relations in 2023 by welcoming new ambassadors to each other's capitals. Saudi Arabia's national airline also resumed flights to Canada after a five-year suspension. Before the diplomatic spat, the Liberal government had temporarily paused arm sales to Saudi Arabia over reports the country's Canadian-made light armoured vehicles were being used in a bloody conflict in Yemen. Bin Salman attended several events during U.S. President Donald Trump's tour of the Middle East last month. Trump gushed over the crown prince during that trip, calling him 'my friend' and praising his efforts to modernize the country. 1:58 Trump prioritizing foreign investment in Gulf states tour Carney personally invited Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi to the G7 summit last week, which Modi has accepted. The move has angered Sikh nationals in Canada — including within Carney's Liberal caucus — who point to allegations that Modi's government was involved in the murder of a Sikh activist leader in British Columbia in 2023. Story continues below advertisement The RCMP is continuing to investigate what it has said are reports of intimidation and violence against Sikhs by Indian agents on Canadian soil. Carney defended the invitation of Modi on Friday and avoided saying whether he believes Modi was involved in the murder of Hardeep Singh Nijjar, referring to the ongoing 'legal process.' Carney also spoke last week with Chinese Premier Li Qiang, with the Prime Minister's Office saying the two leaders agreed to regularize channels of communication between Ottawa and Beijing, despite ongoing disputes over trade and human rights. No officials from China are expected to attend next week's G7 summit. Mexican President Claudia Sheinbaum confirmed on Monday she had accepted an invitation to attend the summit. It will mark the first time the leaders of Canada, Mexico and the U.S. are together since Trump launched a multi-front trade war over the flow of fentanyl and the North American auto sector. Negotiations over the Canada-United States-Mexico Agreement on free trade (CUSMA) are expected to begin next year, but Trump's tariffs have led Canada to seek a bilateral economic and security agreement with the U.S. Multiple premiers have also called on Mexico to be written out of any future free trade agreement. Story continues below advertisement —With files from the Canadian Press


Toronto Star
6 hours ago
- Toronto Star
Gaza-bound aid boat with Greta Thunberg on board arrives in Israel after its seizure
JERUSALEM (AP) — A Gaza-bound aid boat carrying Greta Thunberg and other activists arrived at an Israeli port Monday after Israeli forces stopped and detained them — enforcing a longstanding blockade of the Palestinian territory that has been tightened during the Israel-Hamas war. The boat, accompanied by Israel's navy, arrived in Ashdod in the evening, according to Israel's Foreign Ministry. It published a photo on social media of Thunberg after disembarking.
Montreal Gazette
6 hours ago
- Montreal Gazette
Quebec won't appeal court ruling blocking 33% tuition hike for out-of-province students
By Quebec will not appeal a court ruling that ordered it to scrap controversial measures targeting Concordia and McGill universities: a 33-per-cent tuition hike for out-of-province students and French proficiency requirements for non-Quebec applicants. A spokesperson for Higher Education Minister Pascale Déry confirmed the decision in an email to The Gazette on Monday, the last day an appeal could be filed. Déry is expected to comment on the matter at a later time. In an April 24 ruling, Quebec Superior Court Justice Éric Dufour largely sided with Concordia and McGill, which had filed lawsuits arguing the Coalition Avenir Québec government's education reforms, announced in the fall of 2023, were illegal. The tuition hike, which made headlines across Canada and the world, led to a drop in applications from the rest of Canada, with the universities offering scholarships to lure out-of-province students. Concordia and McGill have partially blamed the measures for deep budget cuts. The Legault government said the changes would protect the French language and reduce the number of non-French-speaking students in Quebec. In his ruling, Dufour called some of the CAQ's measures 'unreasonable.' The tuition hike, introduced in fall 2024, raised fees for out-of-province undergraduates and non-thesis master's students from about $9,000 to $12,000. Quebec students continued to pay around $3,000. Dufour gave the government nine months to revise the fee structure. He criticized the government's rationale, finding the decision was not supported by solid data and was enacted before receiving advice from an advisory committee, which later urged Déry to scrap the hike. The judge also struck down, effective immediately, a planned French-language rule, which would have required 80 per cent of newly enrolled non-Quebec undergraduates at Concordia and McGill to attain intermediate oral French proficiency by graduation. Dufour found the target virtually impossible to achieve and the penalties for non-compliance — including the possible retroactive withdrawal of subsidies — were unclear. However, Dufour upheld the CAQ government's new rules for international students, including a $20,000 minimum tuition rate and changes to the funding formula. When his government announced the changes in 2023, Premier François Legault said it was part of a plan to 'reduce the number of anglophone students' in Quebec. He said English-speaking students from other provinces 'threaten the survival of French.' McGill laid off 60 workers in March as it grappled with a large deficit that it partly blamed on CAQ government policies. Last month, Concordia announced it may also have to lay off employees as it works to slash tens of millions of dollars from its budget. At the time, Concordia president Graham Carr said the legal victory 'is ultimately a moral, not a material win for Concordia. The damage from those policies has already been done. ' He added: 'Furthermore, the negative impact has been compounded by stringent immigration policies that have caused international applications to plummet, weakening the reputation and financial position of universities across Quebec for years to come.' Carr has previously said he hoped the CAQ government would 'look at this judgment and the larger context and (decide) we can hit reset and take a genuinely collaborative approach to supporting a higher education system that is world-class.' In their lawsuits, Concordia and McGill argued that the reform violated equality and language rights under the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms. McGill also claimed the measures contravened anti-discrimination provisions of Quebec's Charter of Human Rights and Freedoms, particularly regarding harm to its reputation and academic freedom. However, the judge did not rule on charter issues, saying the matter could be resolved on administrative law grounds. Jeffery Vacante, an assistant history professor at the University of Western Ontario, has argued the court ruling offers a short-term reprieve but is 'a less resounding victory for McGill and Concordia than one might assume.' 'The judge is not pushing back against the idea that McGill and Concordia are contributing to the decline of the French language, nor is he suggesting that tuition increases or language requirements for students cannot be imposed,' Vacante argued in an op-ed submitted to The Gazette in April. The judge is 'suggesting, rather, that the government can impose such policies only after it has offered compelling data to justify their necessity,' wrote Vacante, author of a National Manhood and the Creation of Modern Quebec.