US judge rejects call to withdraw from real estate antitrust lawsuit
April 11 (Reuters) - A federal judge in Missouri declined a request that he withdraw from hearing a major antitrust lawsuit after disclosures showed lawyers in the case previously donated to political campaigns involving the judge's wife.
In an order, opens new tab on Thursday, U.S. District Judge Stephen Bough said Howard Hanna Real Estate Services had not met the 'heavy burden of proof' to justify his recusal in the litigation in Kansas City.
Howard Hanna is among several defendants in the antitrust lawsuit, which was filed by home sellers in 2023 accusing brokerages of conspiring to inflate the commission that sellers pay in residential real estate sales.
A spokesperson for Howard Hanna said the company was evaluating the judge's order.
Michael Ketchmark, a lead attorney for the plaintiffs, on Friday welcomed the order and said they looked forward to presenting the case to a jury.
Bough did not immediately respond to a request for comment.
Pittsburgh-founded Howard Hanna markets itself as the country's largest family-owned real estate brokerage.
The lawsuit was filed by plaintiffs' lawyers who had won a landmark class action jury verdict in Bough's courtroom in a related antitrust lawsuit.
Home sellers since that October 2023 verdict have secured more than a billion dollars in settlements with major brokerages and the real estate industry's chief trade group. The verdict spurred a wave of similar lawsuits against brokerages around the country.
Bough's wife is an attorney and at-large councilmember for Kansas City, Missouri. Bough had disclosed the donations from members of the plaintiffs' team in an earlier, related class action.
Donations from plaintiffs' lawyers to the judge's wife 'create an appearance of impropriety' for the court, Howard Hanna had argued to the court.
A lawyer for the plaintiffs countered that the donations were not improper and that Howard Hanna delayed raising its disqualification bid "until after it lost all its motions trying to escape accountability in Missouri."
In his ruling, Bough said his wife's campaign committee had received 'contributions from a huge cross section of the community, including lawyers representing both plaintiffs and defendants in this case.'
The judge questioned the timing of the recusal bid by Howard Hanna, saying it had come after the court declined the company's effort to dismiss the lawsuit.
Bough, in his decision, said he 'has taken significant time and effort to comply with the ethical rules.'
The case is Don Gibson et al v. National Association of Realtors et al, U.S. District Court for the Western District of Missouri, No. 4:23-cv-00788-SRB.
Lawyers cry foul over $34 million eXp settlement with US home sellers
Home listing service ends antitrust lawsuit against US realtors' group
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Reuters
6 minutes ago
- Reuters
Russia fines Apple for violating 'LGBT propaganda' law, TASS reports
MOSCOW, June 10 (Reuters) - A Russian court on Tuesday fined U.S. tech giant Apple (AAPL.O), opens new tab six million roubles ($76,510) for violating Russian rules on what Moscow calls "LGBT propaganda," the state TASS news agency reported. Russia in 2023 widened existing restrictions on the promotion of "non-traditional sexual relations" amid a broader crackdown on LGBT rights, part of President Vladimir Putin's push to uphold what he calls traditional values. Apple was fined three million roubles in two civil cases on Tuesday, TASS reported. Apple was last month fined a total of 7.5 million roubles for the same offence. Apple (AAPL.O), opens new tab did not immediately respond to an emailed request for comment. ($1 = 78.4205 roubles)
Reuters
10 minutes ago
- Reuters
AI company Glean hits $7.2 billion in valuation in latest funding round
June 10 (Reuters) - U.S. enterprise AI search startup Glean said on Tuesday it had notched a $7.2 billion valuation in its latest funding round, led by asset manager Wellington Management. The company raised $150 million in a Series F funding round, which also included participation from new investors including Khosla Ventures. The latest investment will help Glean to enhance its product offerings and bolster international presence, the company said.
Reuters
15 minutes ago
- Reuters
Russian budget deficit for January-May was 1.5% of GDP
June 10 (Reuters) - Russia ran a budget deficit of 3.4 trillion roubles ($43.3 billion), or 1.5% of gross domestic product, for the first five months of the year, the finance ministry said on Tuesday, citing preliminary data. The budget shortfall was almost five times as wide as in the same period of 2024, when Russia ran a deficit of 730.4 billion roubles, or 0.4% of GDP. The ministry said the deficit was mainly caused by advance payments to finance budget spending in January and a decrease in oil and gas revenue amid lower prices for oil, Russia's main export commodity. Russia raised the 2025 budget deficit estimate to 1.7% of gross domestic product in April from 0.5% after reducing the energy revenue forecast by 24%, expecting a prolonged period of low oil prices. State spending on national defence was hiked by a quarter in 2025 to 6.3% of GDP, the highest since the Cold War, as the country continued its war in Ukraine, now in its fourth year. The government is planning to tap its fiscal reserves for 447 billion roubles ($5.51 billion), or about one-tenth of its liquid assets, to balance the budget in 2025 Spending in the first five months was 20.7% higher than in the same period of 2024, the ministry's data showed. Revenues for the period were 3.1% higher than a year ago. The Finance Ministry is planning another revision of the budget in autumn. ($1 = 78.5000 roubles)
