Charges dropped against Spokane dermatologist accused of COVID fraud
May 30—Charges of fraud related to federal COVID relief were dropped Friday against Spokane dermatologist Dr. William "Phil" Werschler.
Between 2020 and 2022, Werschler's businesses received more than $2.9 million in federal CARES Act loans meant for struggling small businesses. The 23-count indictment filed last year alleged Werschler used $1.5 million of those dollars to purchase luxury vehicles and other items.
On Friday, the charges were dropped with prejudice — meaning they cannot be filed again. Werschler also agreed to pay a $1.4 million settlement with the federal government as part of the deal to avoid a civil penalty.
The Spokane dermatologist admitted to no wrongdoing as part of the settlement agreement. Lawyer Ronald Van Wert said the dismissal of such federal charges is "extraordinarily rare" and evidence of his innocence.
Van Wert said the problems were the fault of an employee in Werschler's office who pleaded guilty to embezzlement in 2023.
"The nature of this dismissal is highly unusual and uncommon. And between our defense team, I don't think any one of us has seen a dismissal with prejudice of criminal charges brought by a federal indictment," he said.
In a statement, U.S. Attorney's Office spokesperson Rob Curry said the case's resolution was "just and in the best interest of the public."
"Today's settlement restores public funds that were misused during the course of the Covid-19 pandemic, while also recognizing mistakes made by Dr. Werschler and his companies. This global resolution balances a just outcome and need to protect public funds with the unique facts of this matter," he said.
According to Van Wert, federal prosecutors were misled Carol Castilla, Werschler's former bookkeeper who pleaded guilty to embezzling more than $715,000 from Werschler's Spokane Dermatology Clinic. As part of that case, Castilla provided testimony and evidence Werschler embezzled COVID relief funds.
Weschler's lawyers argue they proved Castilla's testimony was fraudulent, which ultimately led to criminal charges being dropped.
"This bookkeeper had a number of texts and communications between her and the Werschlers. She took that information and manipulated and misrepresented those texts, and also the financial records and the timing of various types of transactions. From our perspective, we were able to demonstrate, through our own financial analysis and our own experts, where that was inconsistent," Van Wert said.
While Werschler was not aware or participated in the improper use of COVID funds, he could have been found civilly liable as the employer of Casilla, Van Wert added.
Spokane Dermatology Clinic has remained open since Werschler's indictment, and the dermatologist plans to continue his practice now.
"This ordeal has been emotionally and professionally devastating for me, my wife, and our employees. We are extremely pleased to put it behind us, and grateful for the support of our friends and colleagues," Werschler said in a statement. "Our greatest concern remains for our valued patients as we have tried to reassure them this case has nothing to do with the healthcare they receive at Spokane Dermatology Clinic, and that justice would prevail. We are moving forward, continuing to provide excellent care to those who trust us with their healthcare needs."
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CNBC
32 minutes ago
- CNBC
Social Security checks may be smaller starting in June for some, as student loan garnishments begin
Some Social Security beneficiaries may find their June check is smaller: Starting this month, a share of people's benefits can be garnished if they've defaulted on their student loans. The Trump administration announced on April 21 that the U.S. Department of Education would resume collection activity on the country's $1.6 trillion student loan portfolio. For nearly half a decade, the government did not go after those who'd fallen behind as part of Covid-era policies. More than 450,000 federal student loan borrowers age 62 and older are in default on their federal student loans and likely to be receiving Social Security benefits, the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau found. More from Personal Finance:What the House GOP budget bill means for your money'Maycember' is over — here's how to recover financiallyCourt order challenges Trump's plan to move student loans to SBA Depending on details like their birth date and when they began receiving benefits, their monthly Social Security check may arrive June 3, 11, 18 or 25, according to the Social Security Administration. Many Social Security recipients rely on those checks for most, if not all, of their income. So people who are facing a smaller federal benefit as a result of garnishment are likely in a panic, said Nancy Nierman, assistant director of the Education Debt Consumer Assistance Program in New York. But, Nierman said, "the good news is there are multiple options for borrowers to stop those payment offsets." Here's what you need to know if you're at risk of a smaller benefit. Federal student borrowers should have received at least a 30-day warning before their Social Security benefit is offset, said higher education expert Mark Kantrowitz. That notice should include information on whom to contact in order to challenge the collection activity, Kantrowitz said. (The alert was likely sent to your last known address, so borrowers should make sure their loan servicer has their correct contact information.) You may be able to prevent or stop the offset if you can prove a financial hardship or have a pending student loan discharge, Kantrowitz added. With that in mind, your next step may be pursuing a discharge with your student loan servicer. That's more likely in circumstances where you have significant health challenges. "If they are sick or disabled, they can file for a Total & Permanent Disability discharge," Nierman added. Borrowers may qualify for a TPD discharge if they suffer from a mental or physical disability that is severe and permanent and prevents them from working. Proof of the disability can come from a doctor, the Social Security Administration or the Department of Veterans Affairs. Another route to stop the offset of Social Security benefits is getting current on the loans, said Betsy Mayotte, president of The Institute of Student Loan Advisors, a nonprofit. You can contact the government's Default Resolution Group and pursue several different avenues to get out of default, including enrolling in an income-driven repayment plan. "If Social Security is their only income, their payment under those plans would likely be zero," Mayotte said. Social Security recipients can typically see up to 15% of their monthly benefit reduced to pay back their defaulted student debt, but beneficiaries need to be left with at least $750 a month, experts said. The offset cap is the same "regardless of the type of benefit," including retirement and disability payments, said Kantrowitz. The 15% offset is calculated from your total benefit amount before any deductions, such as your Medicare premium, Kantrowitz said. Many retirees worry about meeting their bills on a fixed income — with or without facing garnishment, experts said. Utilizing other relief options may help stretch your funds while you work on stopping the offset to your Social Security benefits. For example, there are a number of charitable organizations that assist seniors with their health-care costs. At you can apply for funds to put toward copays, premiums, deductibles and over-the-counter medications. The National Patient Advocate Foundation has a financial resource directory in which you can search for local aid for everything from dental care to end-of-life services. Many older people aren't taking advantage of all the food assistance available to them, experts say. A 2015 study, for instance, found that less than half of eligible seniors participated in the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program, or SNAP. The extra money can go a long way for retirees on a fixed income, though. The maximum benefit a month for a household of one is $292. Grocery stores, online retailers and farmers markets accept the funds.
Time Business News
an hour ago
- Time Business News
Why Short Term Rental Cleaning Can Make or Break Your Business
Cleaning isn't just about tidying up after guests leave; it's fundamental to the success of a short-term rental business. From racking up positive reviews to maintaining safety and hygiene standards, the way owners handle short term rental cleaning has a significant impact on their reputation and profitability. This blog explores why cleaning in the short-term rental industry is much more than a mundane chore. We'll uncover the hidden impacts of exceptional (and poor) cleaning practices on your bottom line, guest satisfaction, and competitive edge. Whether you're managing a single vacation rental or running a portfolio of properties, understanding the importance of cleaning could transform your business. When guests book a short-term rental, they're not just paying for a place to stay; they're paying for an experience. And one of the key components of that experience is cleanliness. Studies show that cleanliness is one of the most important factors influencing guest satisfaction. A survey by Airbnb revealed that over 80% of guests are more likely to leave a negative review if they find cleanliness lacking. Unlike hotels, where standardized cleaning routines are a given, short-term rental properties can vary significantly. Guests expect the best of both worlds: the personal touch of a home and the meticulous cleanliness of a hotel. Any deviation from this expectation? It could cost you not only a bad review but also future bookings. The COVID-19 pandemic elevated the global awareness of cleanliness standards. Today, guests aren't just looking for an aesthetically clean space; they want the reassurance that their rental property is hygienically safe. Regular sanitization of high-touch surfaces, fresh linens, and a checklist-driven cleaning routine are now staples for health-conscious travelers. Failing to prioritize cleaning doesn't just impact guest satisfaction; it comes with additional costs that many rental operators overlook. Online reviews are everything in the short-term rental business. If guests encounter cobwebs in the corner or an unclean bathroom, they're likely to vent their dissatisfaction online. Reviews labeling your property as 'unclean' can derail bookings, no matter how stylish or well-located it is. Positive reviews about great cleaning? That's word-of-mouth gold. Travelers trust reviews, and a reputation for cleanliness is one of the best ways to stand out in a competitive market. Returning guests represent consistent, predictable income. However, poor cleaning practices leave a lasting impression, driving away repeat customers. And when turnover rises, so does your marketing spend to attract new guests. If you're managing properties through platforms like Airbnb, cleanliness isn't optional. Many platforms enforce minimum cleaning protocols and penalize properties that fail to meet them. Violating these guidelines could lead to the deactivation of your listing. Neglecting cleanliness and routine upkeep adds to wear and tear, leading to higher long-term maintenance expenses. Think unclean HVAC filters causing breakdowns or kitchen grease accumulating into costly repairs. The good news? Thorough cleaning doesn't have to be a cost center for your business. Done right, it's one of the best investments you can make for your rental property. A well-kept property naturally attracts guests willing to pay premium rates. Travelers are often prepared to pay more for the promise of excellent hygiene and flawless presentation. Quick, high-quality cleaning ensures your property is guest-ready faster, minimizing the gap between bookings. This means improved occupancy rates and maximized income potential. When guests leave a sparkling clean property, it sets the tone for their overall experience. If everything feels fresh and welcoming, they're far more likely to book again the next time they're in town. Managing short term rental cleaning can feel overwhelming, especially if you're juggling multiple properties or don't live locally. At some point, many property hosts face a crucial question: Should you hire professional cleaners, or handle the cleaning yourself? Time Savings : Outsourcing cleaning means you can focus on high-value tasks like guest communication and marketing. : Outsourcing cleaning means you can focus on high-value tasks like guest communication and marketing. Consistency : Professional cleaners follow checklists and have quality assurance processes to ensure the job is done right every time. : Professional cleaners follow checklists and have quality assurance processes to ensure the job is done right every time. Comprehensive Service : Many companies specialize in short-term rental cleaning, offering extras like inventory checks, linen services, and restocking essentials. : Many companies specialize in short-term rental cleaning, offering extras like inventory checks, linen services, and restocking essentials. Expertise: Professionals are well-versed in sanitization practices and use industrial-grade equipment to deliver top-notch results. For hosts with only one or two properties, doing the cleaning yourself can save money. That said, it requires dedication, and you must be thorough, ensuring no detail is overlooked. With innovation reshaping every corner of the travel industry, cleaning hasn't been left behind. Here are some trends to watch out for in short term rental cleaning that could give hosts a competitive edge. Sustainability is top of mind for many travelers today. Offering guests an eco-conscious stay by using green cleaning products not only appeals to their values but also boosts your property's marketing appeal. From UV sanitization devices to robot vacuums, technology is making cleaning more efficient than ever. Hosts are also turning to apps that track cleaning schedules, flag needed repairs, and provide checklists to ensure consistency. Going beyond the photos of your property, include mentions of your cleanliness standards in your listing description. Use phrases like 'meticulously cleaned,' 'sanitized for your safety,' and 'hotel-grade hygiene standards.' It can give travelers the peace of mind they need to book with confidence. Consistent short term rental cleaning elevates your property's reputation and attracts more bookings. Immaculate spaces create memorable stays, encouraging repeat guests and positive word-of-mouth. Efficient turnover cleaning also maximizes occupancy rates, keeping your rental profitable. Partnering with skilled cleaners ensures every detail shines, from linens to surfaces. Invest in cleaning excellence to turn your rental into a top choice in a competitive market. TIME BUSINESS NEWS
Los Angeles Times
2 hours ago
- Los Angeles Times
There's one bright spot for San Francisco's office space market
SAN FRANCISCO — In recent years, San Francisco's image as a welcoming place for businesses has taken a hit. Major tech companies such as Dropbox and Salesforce reduced footprints in the city by subleasing office space, while retailers including Nordstrom and Anthropologie pulled out of downtown. Social media firm X, formerly Twitter, vacated its Mid-Market headquarters for Texas, after owner Elon Musk complained about 'dodging gangs of violent drug addicts just to get in and out of the building.' While the city remains on the defensive, one bright spot has been a boom in artificial intelligence startups. San Francisco's 35.4% vacancy rate in the first quarter — among the highest in the nation — is expected to drop one to three percentage points in the third quarter thanks to AI companies expanding or opening new offices in the city, according to real estate brokerage firm JLL. The last time San Francisco's vacancy rate dropped was in the fourth quarter, when it declined 0.2% — the first time since the COVID-19 pandemic, according to JLL. 'People wanted to count us out, and I think that was a bad bet,' said Mayor Daniel Lurie. 'We're seeing all of this because the ecosystem is better here in San Francisco than anywhere else in the world, and it's really an exciting time.' Five years ago, AI leases in San Francisco's commercial real estate market were relatively sparse, with just two leases in 2020, according to JLL. But that's since soared to 167 leases in the first quarter of 2025. The office footprint for AI companies has also surged, making up 4.8 million square feet in 2024, up from 2.6 million in 2022, JLL said. 'You need the talent base, you need the entrepreneur ecosystem, and you need the VC ecosystem,' said Alexander Quinn, senior director of economic research for JLL's Northwest region. 'So all those three things exist within the greater Bay Area, and that enables us to be the clear leader.' AI firms are attracted to San Francisco because of the concentration of talent in the city, analysts said. The city is home to AI companies including ChatGPT maker OpenAI and Anthropic, known for the chatbot Claude, which in turn attract businesses that want to collaborate. The Bay Area is also home to universities that attract entrepreneurs and researchers, including UC Berkeley, UC San Francisco and Stanford University. Venture capital companies are pouring money into AI, fueling office and staff growth. OpenAI landed last quarter the world's largest venture capital deal, raising $40 billion, according to research firm CB Insights. OpenAI leases about 1 million square feet of space across five different locations in the city and employs roughly 2,000 people in San Francisco. The company earlier this year opened its new headquarters in Mission Bay, leasing the space from Uber. OpenAI began as a nonprofit research lab in 2015 and the people involved found their way to San Francisco for the same reason why earlier generations of technologists and people pushing the frontier in the United States are drawn to the city, said Chris Lehane, OpenAI's vice president of global affairs in an interview. 'It is a place where, when you put out an idea, no matter how crazy it may seem at the time, or how unorthodox it may seem ... San Francisco is the city where people don't say, 'That's crazy,'' Lehane said. 'They say, 'That's a really interesting idea. Let's see if we can do it.'' Databricks, valued at $62 billion, is also expanding in San Francisco. Databricks in March announced it will move to a larger space in the Financial District next year, boosting its office footprint to 150,000 square feet and more than doubling its San Francisco staff in the next two years. It pledged to hold its annual Data + AI Summit in the city for five more years. The company holds 57,934 square feet at its current San Francisco office in the Embarcadero, according to CoStar, which tracks real estate trends. 'San Francisco is a real talent magnet for AI talent,' said Databricks' co-founder and vice president of engineering Patrick Wendell. 'It's a beautiful city for people to live and work in and so we really are just following where the employees are.' Several years ago, Wendell said his company was considering whether to expand in San Francisco. At the time, it was unclear whether people would return to offices after the pandemic, and some businesses raised concerns about safety and cleanliness of San Francisco's streets. Wendell said his company decided to invest more in the city after getting reassurances from city leaders. 'People are seeing an administration that is focused on public safety, clean streets and creating the conditions that also says that we're open for business,' said Lurie, who defeated incumbent mayor London Breed last November by campaigning on public safety. 'We've said from day one, we have to create the conditions for our arts and culture, for our small businesses and for our innovators and our entrepreneurs to thrive here.' Laurel Arvanitidis, director of business development for San Francisco's Office of Economic and Workforce Development, said that the city's policy and tax reforms have helped attract and retain businesses in recent years, including an office tax credit that gives up to a $1-million credit for businesses that are new or relocating to San Francisco. On Thursday, Lurie announced on social media that cryptocurrency exchange Coinbase is opening an office in San Francisco after leaving the city four years ago. 'We are excited to reopen an office in SF,' Coinbase Chief Executive Brian Armstrong wrote in response to the mayor's social media post. 'Still lots of work to do to improve the city (it was so badly run for many years) but your excellent work has not gone unnoticed, and we greatly appreciate it.' Santa Clara-based Nvidia is also looking for San Francisco office space, according to a person familiar with the matter who declined to be named. The news was first reported by the San Francisco Chronicle. Nvidia, which also has California offices in San Dimas and Sunnyvale, declined to comment. 'It's because of AI that San Francisco is back,' Nvidia Chief Executive Jensen Huang said last month on the Hill & Valley Forum podcast. 'Just about everybody evacuated San Francisco. Now it's thriving again.' But San Francisco still has challenges ahead, as companies continue to push workers to return to the office. While the street environment has improved, it will be critical for the city to keep up the progress. Lurie said his administration inherited the largest budget deficit in the city's history and they have to get that under control. His administration's task is to make sure streets and public spaces are clean, safe and inviting, he said. 'We have work to do, there's no question, but we are a city on the rise, that's for sure,' Lurie said. Times staff writer Roger Vincent contributed to this report.
