
Judge offers to recuse himself from Senzo Meyiwa murder trial after racial remarks
Judge Ratha Mokgoatlheng publicly apologised for his conduct in court.
Judge Ratha Mokgoatlheng during the Senzo Meyiwa murder trial at Pretoria High Court on 17 July 2024. Picture: Gallo Images/Phill Magako
Judge Ratha Mokgoatlheng has apologised for his controversial racial remarks and says he is prepared to recuse himself from the Senzo Meyiwa murder trial.
His apology follows widespread public backlash, including criticism from parliament.
The controversy erupted after Mokgoatlheng harshly criticised Advocate Charles Mnisi, who had excused himself from Monday's session to participate in the Comrades Marathon in KwaZulu-Natal (KZN).
The judge's comments included a strong condemnation of black lawyers, during which he said: 'This is what happens in a South Africa run by blacks. I can tell you now, even if you call Uncle Tom, I don't think a white advocate will ever have the gall to ask me that.'
His remarks prompted calls for the Judicial Services Commission (JSC) to investigate his conduct.
Senzo Meyiwa murder trial judge apologises
During proceedings at the Gauteng High Court in Pretoria on Monday, Mokgoatlheng publicly apologised for his remarks.
'I have been 26 years on the bench, I have never ever behaved the way I did,' the judge said.
He explained that Gauteng High Court Judge President Dunstan Mlambo had reprimanded him, stating that his behaviour was 'not befitting' for someone of his experience and stature.
'I agreed. My conduct was questionable and incorrect. My wife also told me to apologise to the whole of South Africa,' Mokgoatlheng said.
'I wish to tender my sincere apologies. It's contrary to my nature to do that.'
ALSO READ: Justice committee chair slams Mokgoatlheng's 'unfortunate' comments in Meyiwa trial
He shared that his son, an advocate who recently passed away from cancer, would have been disappointed by his behaviour.
'I heartily and unreservedly apologise to my colleagues and to the accused.'
Responding to accusations of racism, Mokgoatlheng briefly reflected on his past as an anti-apartheid activist.
'If people say I am a racist, maybe I'm not aware of that, but if I trampled on anybody's toes because of my racism… I wish to apologise for being a racist.
'I'll try and mend my ways, but I can tell you it's not a conscious thing about me to be a racist.'
Judge to recuse himself from Senzo Meyiwa murder trial?
He went on to address the accused directly, saying he would step down from the case if they doubted his fairness.
'The gentlemen in front of me, if you believe that, as a judge, I'm useless, dumb [or a] moegoe, and you think you can't get a fair trial from me, please tell me I will recuse myself.
'I don't want to impose myself on people who doubt my integrity, honour and dignity. And I mean it.'
READ MORE: 'No proper investigation was done': Defence frustrated over missing evidence in Senzo Meyiwa murder trial
The judge also extended his apology to political leaders.
'I'm told that the politicians are worried about me and want to summon me to Parliament. Don't know for what.'
This is not the first time Mokgoatlheng has faced criticism over his remarks.
He previously issued an apology following comments about black lawyers, made while criticising the late defence lawyer Thulani Mngomezulu for his absence.
Charges
Five accused – Muzikawukhulelwa Sibiya, Bongani Ntanzi, Mthokoziseni Maphisa, Mthobisi Mncube, and Fisokuhle Ntuli – are on trial for Meyiwa's murder.
The former Bafana Bafana captain and Orlando Pirates goalkeeper was fatally shot on 26 October 2014 while visiting his then-girlfriend, singer Kelly Khumalo, at her family's home in Vosloorus, Ekurhuleni.
The accused have been charged with murder, attempted murder, robbery with aggravating circumstances, possession of an unlicensed firearm, and possession of ammunition.
The suspects have pleaded not guilty.
NOW READ: 'That is the law': Judge intervenes as lawyers squabble in Senzo Meyiwa murder trial

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles

IOL News
4 hours ago
- IOL News
Critical condition for Fish Hoek athlete Moira Harding after Comrades Marathon incident
Moira Harding, was found on Mahatma Gandhi (formerly Point) Road in Durban on Monday morning after going missing on Sunday June 8. Fish Hoek Athletics Club (FHAC) member Moira Harding, 54, is in a critical condition in an Umhlanga hospital after she wandered off and went missing after completing the Comrades Marathon on Sunday. Athletics club clubhouse manager, Andre Blom, said Harding had been wearing an "in case of emergency" rubber bracelet with her emergency contact details when she was found. He said thanks to the information on the bracelet, her husband had been contacted. IOL reported that a missing persons report was filed after friends and family were unable to locate her following her 5pm race finish, prompting a full-scale search. Police in KwaZulu-Natal are piecing together the circumstances around her initial disappearance.


The Citizen
5 hours ago
- The Citizen
Government intervention worsened Mangaung Municipality crisis, but recovery underway — mayor
The appointment of a city manager has brought a measure of stability to the municipality. Mangaung Municipality Mayor Gregory Nthatisi speaks during a media briefing in Bloemfontein on 9 May 2025. Picture: Gallo Images/Mlungisi Louw The Mangaung Municipality says it continues to face ongoing challenges related to governance and the delivery of basic services, but emphasised that efforts are actively underway to tackle these issues. On Wednesday, municipal officials appeared before parliament's Standing Committee on Appropriations to brief MPs on the city's progress. Mangaung was placed under administration in 2020 after section 139 of the constitution was invoked by the Free State and National Government. This intervention followed the metropolitan municipality's ongoing dysfunction and repeated failures to implement a financial recovery plan (FRP). Mangaung Municipality mayor details challenges Mangaung Mayor Gregory Nthatisi told the committee that political instability and internal conflict within the municipality prompted the Department of Cooperative Governance and Traditional Affairs (Cogta) and Cabinet to intervene. However, Nthatisi said that the two task teams deployed to Mangaung were hindered by the same political turbulence they were meant to resolve. 'The political infighting also engulfed them as a result. They could just not impact on what they were sent to do,' he said. ALSO READ: Mangaung Municipality in spending crisis after exceeding budget He pointed out that some officials on the teams lacked the necessary experience to handle the responsibilities assigned to them. 'Others were quite junior than the responsibility that they were given as HoDs [Heads of Department] and that led to even exacerbating the crisis of Mangaung in a number of spaces, but the best thing that they left us with was a financial recovery plan document, which is guiding us today,' Nthatisi said. According to Nthatisi, the appointment of a municipal manager has brought a measure of stability to the municipality. 'There's also relative stability when it comes to political structures because people are now performing their tasks, work is being done [and] council is sitting properly. We are now addressing challenges that have to do with administration.' Financial recovery plan Mangaung City Manager Sello More told the committee that the FRP is still in its rescue phase, with the implementation progress currently at 53.82%. More said, the next phase – stabilisation – involves 100 activities. He noted that the municipality has been receiving qualified audit opinions from the Auditor-General over the past year. Mangaung has since created an action plan aimed at strengthening internal systems and addressing financial management weaknesses in response. READ MORE: Eskom to disconnect 15 Free State towns over billions worth of debt This plan also seeks to address overspending after the Auditor-General reported that the municipality spent 111% of its budget in the 2023/2024 financial year. 'Areas of overspending have been identified as employees' costs and contracted services. So the city must contain employee costs expenditure, especially overtime and acting allowances,' More said. He revealed that the municipality has introduced a shift system to curb excessive overtime. Critical positions are now being filled to manage acting allowances, according to the city manager. 'There has been a seriously high number of people in acting posts.' Watch the meeting below: The action plan further outlined reviewing staffing levels and costs associated with supporting political offices, as a means of reducing overspending. More conceded that the municipality relies heavily on contractors for both routine and emergency maintenance due to limited internal capacity. 'We are now moving towards building our own teams and infrastructure required for routine maintenance, especially unblocking of sewer systems.' Mangaung Municipality's liquidity and revenue challenges Regarding Mangaung's financial health, More said liquidity challenges are driven by a low revenue collection rate and persistent overspending. 'The collection rate is not picking up from the average of 75%, which was one of the reasons the city was placed under provincial and later Cabinet intervention. 'The previous amalgamations into the city exacerbated the situation, bringing more indigents, billing issues and incomplete records.' He highlighted an ongoing trend where even reliable ratepayers, both businesses and households, have begun to default, largely due to slow economic growth and underperforming industries. READ MORE: Water wasted in Free State totals R3.7 billion in last seven years Additional liquidity pressures stem from costly contracts, such as security and waste management tenders. More explained that these contracts are often outsourced because in-house services are viewed as more expensive due to salary levels and benefits. 'Our recovery is not matching what we are supposed to be paying.' He said the reliance on contractors for essential operations, such as service connections, has further strained the municipality's budget due to high costs. More added that Mangaung is implementing several strategies such as realistic cash projections, tighter cash flow monitoring, and improved revenue management. This includes restructuring, reviewing credit control procedures, enhancing debt collection, and resolving metering problems. Supply chain corruption More stated that no corruption cases within Mangaung's supply chain management had been identified internally by the municipality. However, some arrests have been made by police based on tips from whistleblowers. 'Our [contract] awards have not been subjected to any court orders. It is safe to say that there is one bid where Saps arrested a successful bidder, two months after the award and start of the contract.' The arrested bidder was released on bail. More also indicated an ongoing police investigation into a 2019 security tender. The municipality has begun rotating staff involved in bid committees to combat corruption. It has also approved a whistleblower protection policy and established a dedicated hotline for fraud and corruption reporting. NOW READ: Matjhabeng municipality's appeal rejected amid financial challenges, service delivery collapse

IOL News
5 hours ago
- IOL News
Meyiwa trial in turmoil again as judge sparks outrage — 'He must go'
Last week, after Judge Mokgoatlheng made a series of inappropriate remarks — first berating a defence lawyer for requesting time off to run the Comrades Marathon, then launching into a monologue about black lawyers, race relations, and his political history. The Senzo Meyiwa murder trial — already marred by controversy — has entered another crisis, with growing calls for presiding Judge Ratha Mokgoatlheng to recuse himself following racially charged courtroom comments and political outbursts. Over the past decade, the case has come to symbolise dysfunction in South Africa's justice system. It has featured the arrest and public humiliation of Advocate Malesela Teffo, courtroom chaos, and persistent speculation around singer Kelly Khumalo's alleged involvement in Meyiwa's killing. Now, it faces what could be its most serious credibility blow yet: a presiding judge accused of losing impartiality. Last week, after Judge Mokgoatlheng made a series of inappropriate remarks — first berating a defence lawyer for requesting time off to run the Comrades Marathon, then launching into a monologue about black lawyers, race relations, and his political history. He also made unsolicited comments about President Cyril Ramaphosa, calling him his 'junior' and referencing shared links to the ANC and Azapo. The remarks triggered outrage both inside and outside the courtroom, with many calling them inappropriate, irrelevant, and undignified. In response, the judge issued a lengthy apology on Monday. 'If you believe that I, as a judge, am so useless, dumb, and you think you can't get a fair trial from me, please tell me, I will recuse myself,' he told lawyers in court. 'I don't want to impose myself on people who doubt my integrity, honour and dignity.' He went on to insist that he is not racist, citing his presence at the historic 1955 Congress of the People in Kliptown alongside his father. 'If I trampled on anybody's toes because of my racism... I wish to apologise for being a racist,' he said. 'But I can tell you, it's not a conscious thing about me to be a racist.' Despite his apology, public confidence is waning fast.'This judge has clearly lost the plot,' said criminal law expert Advocate Thembeka Radebe. 'It's no longer about Senzo Meyiwa. It's about Judge Mokgoatlheng, and that's a complete derailment of justice. He must go.' If Mokgoatlheng does recuse himself — or is removed — the trial would need to start from scratch for a third time. That means a new judge, re-hearing all witness testimonies, and likely several more years before a verdict is reached. For the Meyiwa family, already exhausted by nearly 10 years of legal delays, this would be yet another devastating blow. The murder of Bafana Bafana captain Senzo Meyiwa in 2014 shook the nation. What was expected to be a clear-cut trial has instead turned into a saga of dysfunction, scandal, and spectacle. Many legal analysts now warn that unless urgent corrective steps are taken — starting with the judge stepping down — the public may permanently lose faith in the justice system.'The trial has become a circus,' said Radebe. 'And justice is nowhere in sight.'