Wisconsin Supreme Court Suspends Milwaukee Judge Accused of Helping Man Evade Immigration Authorities
Milwaukee County Circuit Judge Hannah Dugan was officially suspended by Wisconsin's Supreme Court on April 29, after she was arrested by the FBI on April 25 and accused of helping a man evade immigration authorities.
'It is ordered ... that Milwaukee County Circuit Judge Hannah C. Dugan is temporarily prohibited from exercising the powers of a circuit court judge in the state of Wisconsin, effective the date of this order and until further order of the court,' the justices wrote in their statement.
Dugan faces one count of 'obstructing or impeding a proceeding before a department or agency,' and another of 'concealing an individual to prevent his discovery and arrest.'
Wisconsin's Supreme Court Justices said that it was in the public interest, to protect public confidence, to remove her from her post as she faces those two federal charges. They also noted that they were acting on their own initiative rather than at the request of anyone.
Dugan was assigned to preside over a hearing for a Mexican man named Eduardo Flores Ruiz, who was charged with
According to the affidavit, witnesses said she appeared 'visibly upset and had a confrontational, angry demeanor,' upon learning of the arrest party's arrival. Witnesses also alleged that Dugan 'escorted' Flores Ruiz and his lawyer 'out of the courtroom through the 'jury door,' which leads to a nonpublic area of the courthouse' (the door is only used by defendants if they are in the custody of deputies), after she 'ordered' the team of FBI and deportation officials to go to the chief judge's office.
Related Stories
4/28/2025
4/25/2025
Another officer noticed Flores Ruiz and his lawyer on an elevator and alerted the arrest team, who apprehended him after a foot race outside the courthouse.
FBI director Kash Patel said investigators believe
Her next court appearance as a defendant is May 15, and she could face more disciplinary actions against her license to practice law.
A state court spokesperson told The Associated Press that a reserve judge began serving in Dugan's place on April 28 and will continue to do so for an indefinite period of time.
The Associated Press contributed to this report.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
Opinion: Why SCOTUS' Monstrous Egos are Handing Trump Undeserved Wins
The U.S. Supreme Court has continued its expansion of President Trump's powers and the use of its emergency docket in its recent ruling allowing him to fire members of the National Labor Relations Board (NLRB) and Merit Systems Protection Board (MSPB)—an action that up until now was prohibited by precedent dating back 90 years. The Humphrey's Executor case is a foundational building block for the principle that the President isn't a ruler but rather heads one branch of a government—and in a system where any head of the executive branch is restricted from simply remaking the other branches to fit their own agenda, or chopping them off entirely. William Humphrey was a Federal Trade Commission member appointed by President Coolidge and then reappointed by President Hoover pursuant to the Federal Trade Commission Act which allowed his removal from that position only for 'inefficiency, neglect of duty, or malfeasance.' Despite this, F.D.R., three months into office and desiring commissioners more sympathetic to his New Deal, asked Humphrey to resign. Humphrey refused to do so and F.D.R. fired him. Five months later, Humphrey died, but his executor litigated the case all the way to the Supreme Court seeking Humphrey's backpay. The high court ruled unanimously in favor of Humphrey, finding that F.D.R. had exceeded his Constitutional authority. Like the 1935 Supreme Court, two different federal trial courts found it quite plain that President Trump lacked the power to remove Gwynne Wilcox from the NLRB and Cathy Harris from the MSPB. Both ordered Trump to keep the officials in their respective jobs. But in a 6-3 decision, the current Supreme Court sided with the Trump administration. Troublingly, the Court did so despite recognizing 'the relevant statutes prohibit the president from removing these officers without cause' and that 'no qualifying cause was given.' Even more troubling is the fact that the case was resolved through the emergency docket process, by which full arguments and briefings are skipped and 'orders' rather than opinions are issued under the idea that the expedited process is necessitated by emergency. This decision continues the alarming trend from the conservative majority—respecting precedent only when it suits their ideology. Enhancing the power of the President under a unitary executive theory has been a long-game effort by legal conservatives, but the combination of that transactional judicial analysis with overuse of the emergency docket may not only put stare decisis on a path towards its deathbed but also the effectiveness the high court. The unprecedented increase in the use of the emergency docket similarly undermines the lower courts and the processes in place to check excesses by the executive branch. It also makes one question who is really making the call as to what cases merit emergency attention. As The Hill put it: 'Forget 911. When the Trump administration has an emergency, it just calls nine—justices, that is.' This willingness to take on all cases immediately may reflect a conceit that the justices (at least the conservative ones) increasingly don't hide: That the high court's ability to act fast negates the need for lower courts to issue nation-wide injunctions. This approach, if fully implemented, would make the Supreme Court not the court of last resort but the only court. In theory, the court's taking on these cases could be seen as perhaps a willingness to take on the task of reining in Trump's excesses. But thus far they seem avoidant of direct confrontation. The instructions to the Department of Justice in the illegal deportation of Kilmar Abrego Garcia to a brutal Venezuelan prison were not a forceful 'bring him back' but rather a wishy-washy directive to 'facilitate' his return. Fear of an outright refusal by Trump to obey rulings might motivate the court's hesitancy; they may calculate that piecemeal capitulations will postpone confrontation thus protecting their authority. But robust rulings set by lower courts cases allow the high court to use judicial restraint in its decisions. Without it, restraint becomes avoidant behavior that undermines the court's effectiveness while emboldening the Trump administration's overreach. Perhaps blinded by their own egos and sense of self-importance, the Roberts-led conservative majority seems to relish the conceit that only they have the legal chops to manage legal cases in the Trump era. But such hubris actually undercuts the judiciary's effectiveness and, up against a figure like Trump who will seek to convert every inch given him into a mile, it may be undercut to the point of irrelevance.
New York Times
an hour ago
- New York Times
Antisemitism Is an Urgent Problem. Too Many People Are Making Excuses.
The list of horrific antisemitic attacks in the United States keeps growing. Two weeks ago in Boulder, Colo., a man set fire to peaceful marchers who were calling for the release of Israeli hostages. Less than two weeks earlier, a young couple was shot to death while leaving an event at the Jewish Museum in Washington. The previous month, an intruder scaled a fence outside the official residence of Gov. Josh Shapiro of Pennsylvania and threw Molotov cocktails while Mr. Shapiro, his wife and children were asleep inside. In October, a 39-year-old Chicago resident was shot from behind while walking to synagogue. The United States is experiencing its worst surge of anti-Jewish hate in many decades. Antisemitic hate crimes more than doubled between 2021 and 2023, according to the F.B.I., and appear to have risen further in 2024. On a per capita basis, Jews face far greater risks of being victims of hate crimes than members of any other demographic groups. Hate crime rates in the United States, 2023 Anti-Jewish 291 hate crimes per 1M Jewish people Anti-L.G.B.T.Q. 111 per 1M L.G.B.T.Q. people Anti-Muslim 79 per 1M Muslim people Anti-Arab 70 per 1M Arab people Anti-Black 64 per 1M Black people Anti-Asian 17 per 1M Asian people Anti-Native American 15 per 1M Native American people Anti-Hispanic 13 per 1M Hispanic people Anti-Hindu 9 per 1M Hindu people Anti-Pacific Islander 8 per 1M Pacific Islander people Anti-Buddhist 7 per 1M Buddhist people Anti-white 3 per 1M white people Anti-Mormon 2 per 1M Mormon people Anti-Catholic 1 per 1M Catholic people Anti-atheist 1 per 1M atheist people Anti-Jewish 291 hate crimes per 1 million Jewish people Anti-L.G.B.T.Q. 111 per 1 million L.G.B.T.Q. people Anti-Muslim 79 per 1 million Muslim people Anti-Arab 70 per 1 million Arab people Anti-Black 64 per 1 million Black people Anti-Asian 17 per 1 million Asian people Anti-Native American 15 per 1 million Native American people Anti-Hispanic 13 per 1 million Hispanic people Anti-Hindu 9 per 1 million Hindu people Anti-Pacific Islander 8 per 1 million Pacific Islander people Anti-Buddhist 7 per 1 million Buddhist people Anti-white 3 per 1 million white people Anti-Mormon 2 per 1 million Mormon people Anti-Catholic 1 per 1 million Catholic people Anti-atheist 1 per 1 million atheist people Sources: New York Times analysis of data from the F.B.I., Gallup, Pew Research Center and U.S. Census Bureau American Jews, who make up about 2 percent of the country's population, are well aware of the threat. Some feel compelled to hide signs of their faith. Synagogues have hired more armed guards who greet worshipers, and Jewish schools have hired guards to protect children and teachers. A small industry of digital specialists combs social media looking for signs of potential attacks, and these specialists have helped law enforcement prevent several. The response from much of the rest of American society has been insufficient. The upswing in antisemitism deserves outright condemnation. It has already killed people and maimed others, including an 88-year-old Holocaust survivor who was burned in Boulder. And history offers a grim lesson: An increase in antisemitism often accompanies a rise in other hateful violence and human rights violations. Societies that make excuses for attacks against one minority group rarely stop there. Antisemitism is sometimes described as 'the oldest hate.' It dates at least to ancient Greece and Egypt, where Jews were mocked for their differences and scapegoated for societal problems. A common trope is that Jews secretly control society and are to blame for its ills. The prejudice has continued through the Inquisition, Russian pogroms and the worst mass murder in history, the Holocaust, which led to the coining of a new term: genocide. Want all of The Times? Subscribe.
Yahoo
2 hours ago
- Yahoo
Chasing ICE: The mad scramble to track immigration raids across L.A. County
Giovanni Garcia pulled up to a dusty intersection in South Gate and scoped the scene. It was quiet, just folks walking home from work, but Garcia was among several people drawn there in hopes of bearing witness to one of the federal raids that have unfolded across Los Angeles County in recent days. Just minutes before, several Instagram accounts had posted alerts warning that white pickup trucks with green U.S. Customs and Border Protection markings had been seen near the intersection. With friends loaded into his white Grand Cherokee and a large Mexican flag flying out of the sunroof, this was the sixth day in a row that Garcia, 28, had spent up to 10 hours following such alerts through South L.A.'s immigrant-heavy neighborhoods. Fueled by sodas and snacks he picked up at a Northgate Market, Garcia's goal, he said, was to catch Immigration and Customs Enforcement or other immigration agents in the act of detaining people on the street. So far, it had been a fruitless chase. 'I've been doing this for six days. It sucks because I get these alerts and go, but I never make it in time,' said Garcia, a Mexican American U.S. citizen who lives in South Central. Read more: L.A. braces for multiple 'No Kings' demonstrations across the city Saturday Monitoring ICE activity has become a grim pastime for some Angelenos. Apps dedicated to the purpose have popped up, which combine with Citizen, Nextdoor, X and other platforms to create a firehose of unverified, user-generated information about federal movements and operations. Trying to keep up in real time can prove equally exhausting and frustrating. The reports sometimes turn out to be false, and immigration enforcers seem to strike and depart with swift precision, leaving the public little opportunity to respond. It's impossible to determine how many people are engaged in this Sisyphean chase. But they have become a frequent sight in recent days, as anger has grown in response to viral videos of swift and violent apprehensions. A Times reporter and photographer crisscrossed the southern half of L.A. County, encountering Garcia and other ICE chasers in hot pursuit of federal agents who constantly seemed one step ahead. A new notification popped up on Garcia's Instagram feed Thursday afternoon: ICE agents had been spotted in a nondescript residential area of South Gate, a city of about 90,000 people, of which more than 40% are foreign-born, according to the U.S. census. So Garcia put his SUV in gear and sped over. He and his crew were late again. They arrived on a corner about 15 minutes after witnesses say immigration agents with green bulletproof vests and gaiters over their faces had jumped out of vehicles, handcuffed and taken away a man who had sold flowers in front of a ranch-style house there for years. 'I keep doing this because they're messing with my people,' Garcia said. 'It's no longer about immigration. Trump's no longer targeting criminals; he's targeting Hispanics.' It was one of many such raids in South L.A. in recent days at homes, parks and businesses ranging from a car wash to grocery stores. Read more: Fears of ICE raids upend life in L.A. County, from schools to Home Depot parking lots The people whisked away in incidents captured in photos and videos that bystanders shared online ran the gamut: One man plucked out of a diverse crowd for no discernible reason while walking in South Gate Park. Another handcuffed on the curb outside a Ross clothing store in Bell Gardens. Two men in Rosemead snatched from the parking lot of a bakery. Workers at a Fashion Nova clothing warehouse in Vernon told The Times that ICE trucks had been spotted in the area and that they had heard agents planned to confront employees during a shift change. From senior citizens to children, nobody was safe from the federal enforcement effort. Jasmyn Vasillio, 35, said she first became concerned when she saw on social media that ICE agents had raided a car wash in South Gate, then an hour later saw a post about the flower seller's apprehension. 'I knew that flower guy is always there and I live nearby so I drove right over,' she said as she stood on the corner where he had been standing 20 minutes earlier. 'I think they're just picking people up and leaving.' A 20-year-old Latino man who declined to provide his name out of fear of reprisal said that he has been doing everything he can to spread awareness of what immigration enforcement agents are doing in his South Gate neighborhood and across South L.A. 'I'm a U.S. citizen, so I'm good. I'm worried about other people. It's been heartbreaking,' he said as he streamed live from a street in South Gate where CBP agents had been spotted minutes before, according to posts he had seen on Instagram. 'They're here to work and being torn apart from their families," he said. "It's sad. They came here for the American dream and this is what happens.' Teenagers Emmanuel Segura and Jessy Villa said they have spent hours over the past week scrolling through social media and despairing at the seemingly endless stream of videos of people being aggressively detained. They felt helpless in the face of the crackdown, so they planned a protest in the heart of their own community. On Thursday, they took to Atlantic Avenue and Firestone Boulevard in South Gate, where Villa waved a flag pole with both American and Mexican flags affixed to it. They were joined by more than 30 other protesters who chanted slogans and hoisted anti-ICE posters. Drivers honked in support as they passed by. "It's kind of scary. They're taking anyone at this point. I just saw that ICE went to a car wash and took two people. And those are hard-working people — they are not criminals," Segura, a 15-year-old South Gate resident, said. "So we planned the protest to go against ICE, Trump and his administration." Villa, 14, lives in nearby Lynwood, where he says everyone he knows is terrified they or someone they care about will be the next person swept up in an ICE raid. "The streets are empty. Nobody wants to come outside. And kids don't want to go to school, especially kids who migrated here," Villa said. "They're scared going to school in the morning, and worried they'll come home and find out their parents were deported." Read more: How L.A. law enforcement got pulled into the fight over Trump's immigration crackdown Five miles away in Vernon, Manolo stood Thursday morning on the loading dock of the candle-making business he owns as employees loaded boxes of candles into the back of a black SUV. He said he has been following news and rumors of the raids online, and that the fear generated by them and the protests in response have been devastating for his company and other small businesses. 'Everybody's worried about it,' Manolo said, recounting how he had heard that earlier that day ICE had raided a business two doors over from his. His company received zero calls for orders Thursday morning, down from the 50 to 60 it typically receives per day. If the immigration raids and protests haven't wound down by the end of the month, he said he might have to shut down his business. 'This whole snatching people on the street — they have you on the floor in handcuffs, traumatize you, why? It makes me nervous, of course,' said Manolo, a U.S. citizen who moved to the U.S. from Guatemala 33 years ago and declined to give his last name out of fear he and his company could be targeted by law enforcement. 'And it's not just that, it's affecting businesses, it's affecting people's lives. It affects the economy, law enforcement. It affects your daily routine. When's it going to end?' Sign up for Essential California for news, features and recommendations from the L.A. Times and beyond in your inbox six days a week. This story originally appeared in Los Angeles Times.
