Can this built heritage war room save a crumbling Glasgow?
Representatives attended from New Glasgow Society, Architectural Heritage Society of Scotland, National Trust of Scotland, Glasgow Building Preservation Trust, Glasgow City Heritage Trust, Glasgow Building Preservation Trust, Glasgow School of Art, Historic Environment Scotland, Alexander Thomson Society, Glasgow Institute of Architects, and the Architectural Heritage Fund. Esteemed architects Alan Dunlop and Scott Abercrombie were also there. Notably absent was anyone from Glasgow City Council. I was assured an invite had been sent.
There was a lot of hurt and a lot of hope in the room. And a lot of questions for the council that could not be answered because no one from the local authority was present. Why, for example, are they considering selling the McLellan Galleries on Sauchiehall Street? 'If Glasgow wants to have an international exhibition, it needs to have something resonating,' Stuart Robertson says. 'Kelvingrove doesn't cope with that.'
The McLellan Galleries are a great exhibition space. Why are we not using the building as such? Alas, the council says they do not have a 'core operational need' for the B-listed gem. Sauchiehall Street is currently the site of a major PR makeover that will see money pumped into it to create a new Culture and Heritage District. It would be nice to revive the 2007 plans to turn the McLellan Galleries into a Gallery of Scottish Art in the city. We could charge a small fee for exhibitions and create a self-funded culture and heritage asset worthy of the new district.
Mackintosh Church (Image: Newsquest)
Another thorn was the announcement last week that £2 million in funding from the UK Government would be going straight to The Lighthouse in the city centre. Everyone agrees that the A-listed former Herald offices are worthy of a makeover, but confusion abounds as to how the decision was made. I asked the council, and a spokesperson said the investment was to make it more attractive and fit for purpose to lease out. Permission to negotiate a lease with Sustainable Ventures to turn the Mackintosh building into a Net Zero Innovation Hub was agreed in February. 'None of this funding will go to Sustainable Ventures, no lease has been signed, and negotiations are ongoing,' the spokesperson added. The money will be used to fix defects in the building.
'I think the recurring theme is a lack of systems thinking,' Paul Sweeney says. The Lighthouse and Kelvin Hall (which is getting £600,000 in funding) might be 'worthy' projects, "but the decisions were made by officers behind closed doors,' he adds. 'They weren't decided democratically, openly or transparently. And I don't think that's a sustainable way to allocate two and a half million pounds in capital funding.'
I look around the room and nervously pop blueberries in my mouth from my paper plate. I am no expert on built heritage, but these folks are. Surely, I think, these should be the people our city takes advice from with every decision regarding heritage and redevelopment? But after an hour, I get the feeling these key figures do not feel in the loop. The look of surprise that danced across the face of a representative from the Glasgow Building Preservation Trust when the sale of the McLellan Galleries was mentioned was fairly telling.
The sentiment at the round table was that there must be more transparency between the council and the organisations represented when it comes to decisions that affect built heritage. There was a lot of love for a Compulsory Purchase Order being used to take back the Egyptian Halls, but why don't we use them more often? Why did they make the 'stupid' decision to scrap business rates relief for empty and partially empty buildings in the city? Why are we installing PVC windows in conservation areas?
READ MORE
Glasgow has an incredible, passionate population of experts and enthusiasts who are deeply committed to protecting the fabric of the city. By the end of the meeting, we had heard some pretty good ideas about how to tackle the derelict building crisis. Take, for example, bringing experts back into the council. We need joined-up thinking to bring the city to its full potential. A team that decides what should go up and what should get torn down. What should be sold, and what should be kept and repurposed. 'We're a city of architecture without a city architect,' Alan Dunlop tells me later over the phone. 'I think that's ridiculous.'
Glasgow City Council has spent more than £280 million on heritage buildings and projects over the last dozen years. But the built heritage situation is still a calamity. And the council is the largest owner of derelict buildings in the city. I empathise that they don't have the budget to fix everything, but the consensus in this room is pretty clear: more needs to be done. Decisions need to be made better and more openly. And evidently from this discussion, we have the expertise to do it. It's just not getting tapped into.
I leave feeling more optimistic than I thought I would. It's not every day that senior-level architects, politicians and conservationists come together for a meeting over coffee, cakes and fruit. Let's hope the next time this impressive situation room gets together, the council sends a liaison.
Marissa MacWhirter is a columnist and feature writer at The Herald, and the editor of The Glasgow Wrap. The newsletter is curated between 5-7am each morning, bringing the best of local news to your inbox each morning without ads, clickbait, or hyperbole. Oh, and it's free. She can be found on X @marissaamayy1
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Glasgow Times
31 minutes ago
- Glasgow Times
We ask the Apprentice Boys of Derry what they stand for
For some, it is a celebration of culture history and identity for others, it is a display of bigotry and sectarianism better left in the past. The Apprentice Boys of Derry held their biggest Scottish parade of the year in Larkhall with more than 50 associated clubs, each with a band, taking to the streets, with many more following or watching from the side. READ NEXT:Rachel Reeves says Labour will end use of hotels for asylum seekers The Glasgow Times was invited by the organisation to come along and speak to its leaders to find out what it is all about. Larkhall's streets were decked out in red, white and blue for the day with Union flags hanging from lampposts, windows and in gardens along the route. Late morning in Birkenshaw Park, the parade was assembling, with groups from Glasgow, Lanarkshire and beyond. Men are meeting and greeting, shaking hands, dressed in suits and crimson collarettes, carrying white gloves and bowler hats. (Image: Colin Mearns) The flutes and drums were starting to be heard from the bands, the same bands that accompany Orange Order parades. (Image: Colin Mearns) READ NEXT:Rise in suspected drug deaths in Glasgow so far this year David Hoey, general secretary of the Associated Clubs of the Apprentice Boys of Derry, was in demand, being introduced to members from around Scotland. (Image: Colin Mearns) We asked him what the purpose of the organisation is, which has 52 branch clubs in Scotland and many in Glasgow, and what the parade is all about. He answered that it is 'principally, a historical, commemorative organisation.' He said: 'The organisation has as its main purpose to celebrate the siege of Derry and the brave 13, but particularly the two big events are: the shutting of the gates, which is usually December when the Gates of Londonderry were closed against the forces of King James and then the relief of Derry when the city was finally relieved after 105 day siege in August.' 'That,' he said, 'is the primary purpose'. Not everyone, however, can join and commemorate this historic event. Mr Hoey explains: 'The criteria for membership is male and Protestant.' 'In terms of local areas, people would have to know each other and be invited, or apply and they would have to be known. 'But other than that, there's no particular criteria.' The male-only element, he said, is a support network, a place for men to come together and help one another. Mr Hoey said: 'It's a good place to meet. I keep telling people when they ask about it being male, it's the biggest men's shed organisation available because men get together, they meet. 'We're getting a remarkable number of young members into the organisation now and I think they're in where they can get people they can learn from. He added: 'They can learn skills. You have to run an organisation, you get positions on committee. You organise some of the events, and you get some of the young people involved. 'So, it's very much people coming together to try and organise and to help each other.' (Image: Colin Mearns) As well as organising parades, he said branch clubs rea active in the community and fundraise for their benevolent fund. Asked what they do when not on parade, Mr Hoey joked they are "organising the next one". He added: "There's a lot of activity, but everything is really geared to the big days. "There's occasionally a church service, but it's predominantly for those two big days." The events from 1689 being celebrated, he said, are still relevant today. (Image: Colin Mearns) (Image: Colin Mearns) Mr Hoey said: 'I think it's largely identity and place, so it gives people a sense of belonging. 'There are a lot of the characteristics of those who were besieged, I think form the identity of the Protestant loyalist culture, if you like. 'And that's what people identify, the determination, the resilience, the preparedness to basically stick it out, but also to create dialogue, to try and change things as well. 'And we're very, very keen that we work outside.' The other exclusive criteria, the Protestant only rule, has led to claims of sectarianism and accusations of being anti-catholic. Mr Hoey said such claims are rooted in ignorance and said he and his organisation is willing to have dialogue to prevent any flashpoints at parades. (Image: Colin Mearns) The Larkhall parade passed with no incident but in Glasgow, there have been protests, particularly around passing a specific Roman Catholic church, and previously in Northern Ireland, there was well well-documented, high-profile, sustained and violent confrontation. Mr Hoey said: 'I think the biggest opposition comes from the people who are most ignorant of what it's all about and imagine some offence or imagine that it's against them. 'It's really not. It's for us.' On the anti-catholic accusation, he added: 'People who want to say that don't want the parades to happen and they're basically throwing or projecting sectarianism onto the parades, but they have no basis for saying that. 'This is a culture. It is on parade. It's not trying to offend anybody. It's simply walking down a very long street and being out and saying we are the association. 'We are remembering a very important part of British history and that is what the day is about. 'It's not about others or offending or anything else. It's about the identity of those people and saying this is us, we're out here having a good day with our brothers, with our friends, with our families watching.' He used the example of Northern Ireland to illustrate how communities can work together. Mr Hoey said: 'The association, 25 years ago, was the first to engage outside of itself, you know, to go to go into the Parades Commission, to work with the local community, to work with the business community because we had a really bad time with violent opposition in Londonderry and there was no violence back. 'Our approach was to engage, and I know here in Scotland the SAC (Scottish Amalgamated Committee) has been working closely with the Centre for Good Relations, again to try and open up avenues of dialogue. 'People say 'the other' but there are lots of communities in Scotland now.' They are, he said, willing to 'work in formal channels' and 'open up' as far as possible. He added, however, there are always people who just don't want you there, and it's very hard to talk to people who simply are impractically opposed and don't want to talk.' The approach in Northern Ireland, he said, took a long time but has worked but he said it is an ongoing process. He added: "We have kept working ever since because you can never stop on that process. Stopping is the worst thing you could do.' He said the willingness to engage must be a two-way process, adding: "You can do your best to reach out. But you know you hold out your hand, but if. Someone doesn't. Want to shake it's not our job to make them.'
Glasgow Times
31 minutes ago
- Glasgow Times
Silverburn: H Beauty opens first ever Glasgow store today
The Glasgow Times reported that H Beauty will officially launch its Glasgow location on Thursday, June 12. The 22,500-square-foot store occupies part of the former Debenhams space, marking a significant addition to Silverburn's retail offering. READ MORE: Silverburn: H Beauty shares first look inside new Glasgow store To build excitement, H Beauty shared a behind-the-scenes transformation video on social media, inviting followers to 'trust the process' as the unit evolved from an empty shell into a glamorous beauty destination, complete with luxurious counters and curated displays. In celebration of the grand opening, MyBeauty members will be treated to exclusive perks throughout the launch weekend. Running until June 15, the festivities will include a 10% off selected purchases, a 'spin the wheel' prize game, live entertainment, surprise treats and giveaways. The brand teased: "H Beauty Glasgow, are you ready? "H beauty Silverburn lands June 12 and trust us, this is no ordinary opening. "MyBeauty members will unlock a whole host of perks all weekend: 10% off selected purchases, a chance to spin the wheel to win prizes, live entertainment and major surprises all weekend long until June 15." READ MORE: Fashion giant announces first Glasgow store to open in Silverburn The new store is H Beauty's second Scottish location, following its Edinburgh debut at St James Quarter, and becomes the sixth branch across the UK. Its arrival is part of a broader retail strategy led by joint venture partners Henderson Park and Eurofund Group, who are working to revitalise key retail spaces at Silverburn and enhance the centre's experiential shopping offering. Once open, customers can expect a wide-ranging selection of make-up, skincare, and fragrance from both established luxury labels and emerging beauty brands, continuing H Beauty's mission to elevate the in-store beauty experience.
Daily Record
37 minutes ago
- Daily Record
Lanarkshire has third highest number of suspected drug-related deaths in Scotland in first three months of 2025
From January to March of this year, there were 33 suspected drug-related deaths in the Lanarkshire police division, compared to 25 in the final quarter of 2024 and 29 in the equivalent quarter of 2024. Lanarkshire had the third highest number of suspect drug-related deaths in Scotland in the first three months of 2025. From January to March of this year, there were 33 suspected drug-related deaths in the Lanarkshire police division, compared to 25 in the final quarter of 2024 and 29 in the equivalent quarter of 2024. Only Glasgow (61) and Ayrshire (36) recorded more deaths in 2025. East Kilbride and Strathaven MP Joani Reid has pinned the blame on the Scottish Government. She said: 'The SNP have treated drug deaths as an opportunity for photocalls and ideologically driven politics. 'Instead of tackling the root causes of drug deaths they have promoted their drug consumption room, something that has made the life of too many people in Glasgow's East End a misery and has plainly utterly failed but had the political advantage of being something not being tried in England. 'The SNP could have tried fixing the local authority budgets they have ruthlessly slashed over their 20 wasted years in government, putting money back into support services, tackling poverty and fixing public health. But they have never been interested in any of that. Instead, there is renewed speculation that John Swinney plans another round of council tax freezes and council spending cuts ahead of next year's polls.' Ms Reid's Labour colleague, the Central Scotland list MSP Monica Lennon added: 'This tragic rise in drug deaths shows just how badly the SNP is failing vulnerable people and their families. 'SNP ministers must provide proper access to recovery, treatment and rehab services, because substance use deaths are preventable. 'Each of these deaths is a tragedy – the SNP must act urgently to prevent the crisis spiralling further out of control.' Across Scotland, there were 308 such deaths over the period January to March, with this total up by 33 per cent on the last three months of 2024. The figures come after the UK's first safer drugs consumption room, the Thistle centre in Glasgow, opened for a three-year pilot in January this year as part of Scottish Government efforts to reduce Scotland's drugs deaths. They said that 'suspected drug deaths in Scotland remain at a high level' - with such cases up by 76 when compared to the final three months of 2024. Speaking as this week's figures were published, Health Secretary Neil Gray, who is also the MSP for Airdrie and Shotts, said: 'Every death is a tragedy and through our £250 million national mission we are determined to continue our efforts to reduce harm and deaths. My condolences go to anyone who has lost a loved one. ' Mr Gray added: 'While these figures show a quarter-on-quarter rise in suspected drug deaths, they also note a year-on-year fall. 'We want every person experiencing harm to be able to access the support they need. 'We are taking a wide range of evidence-based measures including opening the UK's first safer drug consumption facility pilot, working towards drug-checking facilities and widening access to treatment, residential rehabilitation and life-saving naloxone.' Article continues below *Don't miss the latest headlines from around Lanarkshire. Sign up to our newsletters here. And did you know Lanarkshire Live had its own app? Download yours for free here.
