Trump administration says New York mascot ban violates civil rights law

Boston Globe

2 days ago

The Education Department had opened a civil rights investigation into the ban shortly after Trump weighed in. The ban had set off a backlash in Massapequa, a middle-class hamlet on Long Island's South Shore about 40 miles from Manhattan. Most residents voted for Trump last November.
Get Starting Point
A guide through the most important stories of the morning, delivered Monday through Friday.
Enter Email
Sign Up
The school district has used the 'Chief' nickname and logo for decades. The mascot's image, an illustrated side profile of a Native American man wearing a feathered headdress, is plastered across Massapequa campuses, welcome signs, and football fields.
Advertisement
The Trump administration's finding came after a particularly speedy version of what are typically lengthy inquiries. The Education Department's Office for Civil Rights often takes months to identify violations of Title VI of the Civil Rights Act of 1964, which prohibits the recipients of federal funds from discriminating based on race, color, or national origin.
Such investigations seldom result in the loss of federal funds, and the Trump administration did not immediately threaten New York's bottom line. But the federal government has increasingly targeted public school and university ledgers.
Advertisement
The administration recently reached a deal with Maine to restore federal money for its public schools, after education officials initially moved to slash school aid because the state allows transgender athletes on girls' sports teams.
New York was the state least reliant on federal funding for its public schools in 2022, according to the most recent nationwide data. Federal money accounts for less than 8 percent of the state's overall spending on public education.
New York education officials described the mascot ban as part of an effort to promote diversity, equity, and inclusion in schools. It came amid a broader national movement to eliminate logos and nicknames that Native American people may find disrespectful. Many local tribes support New York's policy, and had pushed for a statewide ban for more than two decades.
But the federal Education Department decided that the policy amounted to discrimination.
On Friday, Linda McMahon, the education secretary, traveled to Massapequa High School to speak with students, administrators, and Nassau County leaders, who said the mascot was meant to convey respect.
McMahon said the department would demand that New York offer a formal apology to Massapequa, allow the district to maintain the Chief nickname, and permit other schools to choose their preferred mascots.
She added that she was alarmed that New York would deny Massapequa the chance to celebrate its heritage, and accused the state of unfairly targeting Native American representation in education.
'This is a racist environment,' she said at a news conference at the high school, adding that if New York did not comply, her department would refer the case to the Justice Department 'because that's how serious we are.'
Advertisement
Trump has often promised to give control of education 'back to the states,' but McMahon said Friday that the government's intervention in Massapequa was warranted 'because this is incredibly important.'
JP O'Hare, a spokesperson for the state Education Department, said that it was 'shocking, but not at all surprising, to see the secretary completely reverse course by inserting herself and the federal government into this local matter.'
He called it 'troubling' that the nation's top education official would 'take time out of her schedule to disrupt student learning in the name of political theater.'
'The district claims that it seeks to honor the area's Native American past and its people, but has failed to get even the most basic facts right,' he added, noting that the mascot was a historically inaccurate representation of local tribes.
The president had taken a special interest in the fight on Long Island, posting a photo on Instagram last month that showed him in the Oval Office holding a navy sweatshirt emblazoned with the phrase 'Massapequa Chiefs.' McMahon said Trump had told her: 'I need you to look into this because I think this is wrong.'
Some former members of the Education Department's investigative office have questioned the basis for the mascot inquiry.
Michael Pillera, a former longtime senior attorney in the civil rights office who recently left the department, said the Trump administration has argued that it is acceptable to restrict the teaching of Black studies, while saying that a Native American mascot ban is impermissible because it removes representation of a minority group.
'It's really hard to see how the department believes those two separate ideas coexist,' he said.
Advertisement
This article originally appeared in