Furious neighbour locked in row over next door's ‘nuisance' new fence which ‘scuppers her fancy back-yard picnics'
A COUPLE who sued their neighbour over a fence are locked in a court battle after a judge found their patio trespassed on next door's land.
Helen Faber and her partner Dominic Miles claimed the new fence interfered with back garden picnics.
6
6
6
But the couple have now been ordered to rip out the central heating system and patio from their £375,000 cottage after trying to sue the neighbour backfired.
Helen and Dominic returned to their country cottage in Oxfordshire in 2021 after living in France.
They were furious to discover that their neighbours Richard and Katherine Reid and installed a fence, "narrowing" a path leading to part of their back garden by 40cm.
The couple complained the fence was a "nuisance" because any narrowing of the four-foot wide path would make it difficult for them to carry a "large picnic tray laden with food and drinks...without spilling the drinks" to their patio and second garden area at the end.
After angry scenes, including an incident in November 2021, "during which Mr Miles was very aggressive towards Mrs Reid," they sued their neighbours.
They asked Judge Melissa Clarke at Oxford County Court to rule that the new fence created a "substantial interference" with their use of the shared right of way.
The judge ruled that there was no "nuisance" caused by the fence.
Not only this, but she ordered them to rip up their back patio and remove an oil pipe feeding their central heating system - rendering it useless - after finding that both constituted "trespasses" on the Reids' property.
The two couples are now facing off in London 's High Court.
Helen and Dominic are appealing, arguing that it was wrong for the judge to order them to remove the pipe - leaving them with no heating and hot water system - and the patio, as well as continuing to insist the fence is moved.
But Mr and Mrs Reid say the county court judge got it right when ordering their neighbours to scrap their patio and heating system and dismissing their gripes about the fence.
High Court judge Mr Justice Richard Smith last week heard that Mr and Mrs Reid's home, Forge Cottage, in Wardington, Oxfordshire, adjoins Ms Faber and Mr Miles' house, Pear Tree Cottage next door, which online sources estimate to be worth £375,000.
The fence which sparked the row lies alongside part of a path which runs up the side of Pear Tree Cottage, before turning and running along the back of both neighbours' main back gardens and ending at the second garden belonging to Pear Tree Cottage.
The path itself belongs to the owners of Forge Cottage, but both sets of neighbours have a right of way over it.
Ms Faber and Mr Miles complained that because of the "narrowing" of the shared right of way they were unable to "conveniently" use the path whilst carrying "a large picnic tray laden with food and drinks" to their second garden.
At the end of the Oxford County Court trial, Judge Melissa Clarke, while noting that "Mr Miles was very aggressive towards Mrs Reid" at one point during the row, ruled that the new fence "did not substantially interfere with the right of way".
Going on to order them to take out the oil pipe, disabling their heating system, she said: "An oil line running from an oil tank in the Pear Tree Cottage second garden is on, over and under parts of the right of way.
"The claimants now accept that the right of way is owned by Forge Cottage. The installation by the claimants of an oil line over the right of way is a trespass on the land of Forge Cottage and the defendants are entitled to an injunction requiring the claimants to remove it."
She said the pipeline is "susceptible to damage" and that, if damaged, any oil leaks would contaminate the Reids' land, which is a risk they "should not have to tolerate from trespass."
Dominic and Helen said that they had informed their previous neighbours at Forge Cottage before installing the heating system and they had not objected.
They insisted that means their current neighbours cannot now demand its removal.
The court heard that there is no gas supply in the village and that Mr Miles and Ms Faber claim "modern" heating systems like heatpumps are "not suitable for use in a stone-built property more than three centuries old."
Mr Justice Smith has now reserved his ruling on the case, to be given at a later date.
The Top Five Reasons Neighbours Squabble
One study by Compare the Market revealed the top reason British neighbour's argue
Broken fences - top of the board was broken fences and whose responsibility it was to fix it
Parking: one of the leading drivers of neighbour disputes, with 54.1 per cent of people having issues with people parking in front of their house, parking bay or driveway
Trees - complaints about a neighbour's tree cracking your garden path was also common with nearly half of participants finding it frustrating
Bin wars - outdoor bin etiquette continues to ignite the most furious debates between neighbours
Nosy Neighbours - some people have their eyes and ears at the ready to have a peek causing problems for others
6
6
6
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Telegraph
11 minutes ago
- Telegraph
Missiles thrown at police as violence breaks out in NI
Missiles were hurled at police officers and houses set on fire following a protest over an alleged sexual assault case in Northern Ireland. The streets of Ballymena town centre, located about 30 miles from Belfast, turned into chaos on Monday night as masked youths attacked police vehicles and threw projectiles at officers, some setting buildings alight and smashing in windows. Footage of the violent scenes captured houses up in flames. In one video, a masked man was seen throwing an object at police vans as a crowd looked on. PSNI riot officers swarmed the streets near Clonavon Terrace to bring the disorder under control, blocking off the area. Local media reported that paint and masonry had been thrown at PSNI Land Rovers. 'A number of missiles have been thrown towards police with damage reported to a number of properties,' a PSNI spokesman said. 'Officers are in attendance to ensure the safety of everyone involved. They will remain in the area tonight to continue to monitor the situation.' The disorder comes after hundreds of protesters gathered in the town centre, following a case involving two teenage boys who appeared before Coleraine Magistrates' Court earlier in the day, accused of sexually assaulting a teenage girl in the County Antrim town. Irish media outlet RTE News reported that the teenagers, who are Romanian and spoke through an interpreter, cannot be identified because of their ages. A separate police statement from Sunday said two teenage boys had been charged with attempted rape in connection with a serious sexual assault on a teenage girl in Ballymena on Saturday evening. People have been told to avoid the Clonavon Road area until further notice. In a statement, Chief Superintendent Sue Steen urged for locals to 'remain calm and to act responsibly'. 'Violence and disorder will only place people at greater risk,' she said. 'Our priority is to keep the community safe, and I would appeal to everyone to work with us to bring calm to the area as quickly as possible.'
Daily Mail
32 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
With five failed suicide bombers on the loose, the cop asked an explosives officer what would happen if one detonated a bomb when we raided the flat. 'We won't know much about it, Tony' came the reply... The 7/7 bombings, 20 years on
Park-keeper Jackie Whitcombe was picking up litter in Little Wormwood Scrubs Park, West London when he came across a plastic container in the bushes. Bending down, he grabbed it in his gloved hand and suddenly spotted dozens of screws, washers, nuts and bolts taped around the outside. He knew instantly what it was – a makeshift bomb designed to kill and maim.
Daily Mail
2 hours ago
- Daily Mail
Mail's shocking 'cash for visas' scam expose shows the UK is an 'immigration free for all', Shadow Justice Minister Robert Jenrick warns
Robert Jenrick demanded Labour end the immigration 'free-for-all' yesterday after the Mail revealed how crooked legal advisers run cash for visas scams. The Shadow Justice Secretary hailed our 'crucial' undercover investigation which exposed how companies are charging up to £22,000 per person to provide 'skilled' jobs in the UK for underqualified foreign workers. Our probe discovered range of brazen tricks being used to dupe the Home Office into providing sponsorship licences enabling convenience stores, barbers, warehouses and bars across the country to bring in overseas labour on false pretences. It is so lucrative that many firms have started up just to profit from hiring foreign staff and then exploit them for cheap labour. Immigration advisers working as fixers for the firms coach immigrants how to lie to officials, overstating their levels of education and experience to secure the visa. Mr Jenrick said: 'This crucial Daily Mail investigation shows our immigration system is a free-for-all. 'Scammers are lining their pockets while the public have yet more low-skilled migration forced upon them. 'It's gone on for decades and the public are sick to death of it.' He called for the adviser exposed by the Mail to face the 'toughest possible punishment.' 'The Government will only bring this farce to an end if they radically reduce numbers to historic levels officials can properly control.' Mr Estibeiro told our undercover reporter that he works with businesses in Bradford, Leicester, Northampton and Peterborough, but only takes payment for his services via third party bank accounts to avoid any paper trail linking the firm to his scam Border security minister Dame Angela Eagle launched an urgent investigation into our probe. She also immediately suspended the sponsorship licence of Leicester-based immigration advice firm Flyover International after the Mail revealed its managing partner tricks the Home Office into believing employers need a certificate of sponsorship to take on overseas workers. Joe Estibeiro told our undercover reporter that he works with businesses in Bradford, Leicester, Northampton and Peterborough, but only takes payment for his services via third party bank accounts to avoid any paper trail linking the firm to his scam. He makes it appear that employers can't find any British residents to fill 'skilled' jobs by first advertising the positions in the UK and only recording interviews with the worst candidates to use as evidence if they are investigated by the Home Office. The overseas workers he recruits officially earn around £3000 a month to meet the government's minimum salary requirements for skilled worker visas. But he described how after the money is paid into their account they have to withdraw all but £900 and secretly hand it back to their boss. Mr Estibeiro even claimed the Government didn't care if companies bring in unqualified staff on skilled worker visas, insisting: 'The Home Office is just interested in the money.' More than 131,000 businesses are now on the Home Office's list for licensed sponsors for the permits which includes market traders, dog groomers – listed as 'canine beauticians' - curtain fitters and even scores of kebab shops. Critics warned the open duplicity could sink Sir Keir Starmer's immigration crackdown which made new restrictions on the skilled worker visas a major part of his aim to end the economy's addiction to cheap overseas labour. Dame Angela said: 'Since taking office there have been 40 per cent fewer visa applications, we have removed nearly 30,000 people with no right to be here and arrests from illegal working raids are up 51%. 'We announced in the Immigration White Paper that backs British workers and ends the economy's addiction to cheap overseas labour. 'And under our new Borders legislation, the Immigration Advice Authority will get new powers to immediately suspend registered advisers and organisations suspected of carrying out the most flagrant abuse of the system, bringing them in line with legal regulators.' A Home Office source claimed when Mr Jenrick was immigration minister he had failed clamp down on the criminal gangs fueling illegal immigration. The source added: 'If he needs reminding what the Labour government has done to tackle this, we've introduced a new law to prevent suspected crooks like the one found by the brilliant journalism in the Daily Mail - so the Immigration Advice Authority will get new powers to immediately suspend registered advisers and organisations.' Flyover International is owned by another man who is understood to be taking the matter seriously and investigating and says that Mr Estibeiro was not officially hired to work in the UK end of the business. Mr Estibeiro denied involvement in any 'illegal or unethical' activity and said he was 'solely involved in student recruitment' and insisted he always told anyone who enquired about Certificates of Sponsorship for skilled worker visas that 'we do not deal with such matters.'
