Alleged killer's verdict could remain sealed forever
The only person who can say definitively whether Leisl Smith was murdered has been sworn to secrecy by Australian law.
Ms Smith, 23, was last seen alive on CCTV getting into a white ute at Tuggerah railway station on the NSW Central Coast in August 2012.
The vehicle belonged to her accused killer, James Church, who died by suicide on the eve of a verdict being delivered in the Supreme Court in July 2022.
Legal proceedings must be terminated if the accused person dies, according to laws of abatement.
The legislation means Ms Smith's family still do not know if she was murdered, almost 13 years after she went missing.
The lead detective in her case on Wednesday used the woman's inquest to call for law reform.
Her family deserved to know Justice Elizabeth Fullerton's sealed verdict, Detective Sergeant Michael Jones told the court.
"I believe in our investigation, I know in my heart what the result was going to be in trial," he told the NSW Coroner's Court.
"That decision would have helped (Ms Smith's family) to reconcile and move forward."
Det Sgt Jones said an exception should be made to the laws of abatement once a verdict has been reached and needs only to be delivered.
Church died during the judge-alone trial but after Justice Fullerton had settled on her verdict and finalised her written reasons.
Questioned by the coroner, Det Sgt Jones said he had considered the inability of a dead person to exercise their right to appeal.
He suggested the verdict and its reasons could be revealed in the Coroners Court as part of the inquest, rather than as a criminal court finding.
The detective has worked on Ms Smith's case since she disappeared
Her body has never been found and he believes it lies close to his area of work.
"It's something that I think about all the time," he said, before addressing Ms Smith's mother Sandi Harvey in the courtroom.
"I'm sorry I couldn't give you the ultimate answers that you really wanted ... you deserve them.
"I've done my best and I'm sorry."
Deputy State Coroner Harriet Grahame praised the quality of his investigation and said hope remained something could be found.
"It is very clear to me that you went above and beyond," she said.
The inquest continues.
Lifeline 13 11 14
beyondblue 1300 22 4636
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
7NEWS
an hour ago
- 7NEWS
Queensland nurse who hid $1.7m drug money under bed spared jail
An assistant nurse caught with almost $2 million in drug money under her bed has been spared jail. Jannine Williams, 35, pleaded guilty in Queensland Supreme Court on Thursday to one count of dealing in the proceeds of crime worth $1 million or more. Crown prosecutor Patrick Wilson told Justice Peter Callaghan that Williams — a pediatric intensive care assistant nurse — was not accused of taking part in drug crimes herself. 'Williams possessed just over $1.7 million in a duffle bag under her bed on behalf of her (now former) partner,' Mr Wilson said. Wilson said there was evidence of discussions that showed Williams had some knowledge of her former partner's involvement with shipments of cocaine up to 150kg. 'There was discussion of $2.2 million, and reference to vacuum sealing the money and storing it somewhere else,' Wilson said. 'They had a conversation about a very large quantity of drugs: 150kg. 'There was talk of the risk of prison, making it abundantly clear this was a serious criminal enterprise.' Police found the money on July 22, 2022 in Williams' apartment in the inner-Brisbane suburb of West End. Justice Callaghan heard Williams initially denied knowledge of the money to police. Williams had spoken about having to ignore the $1 million under her bed and needing to lock her apartment every time she left, Wilson said. Defence barrister Mark McCarthy said Williams was an Australian citizen who was born in the UK and had no prior criminal record. 'She has had a long career in a pediatric intensive care unit in the local hospital. She is a valued team member,' he said. 'This was clearly out of character. But for her relationship she would never be involved in anything like this. 'She is extremely unlikely to be involved in anything criminal again.' McCarthy said Williams had been in a 'destructive relationship' and had little choice at the time but to tolerate having the money under her bed. 'She received no benefit from the cash,' he said. Justice Callaghan said it was incongruous to see someone with Williams' history of working to better the community end up in criminal court and facing the prospect of jail. 'The sentence I am about to pass will have an impact on your prospects of employment,' Justice Callaghan said. 'It is to be hoped there is a discretion to be exercised by those who decide these things, and it will be exercised fairly and responsibly.' Williams was sentenced to three years' imprisonment but ordered to be immediately released on a $1000 good behaviour bond. She broke down crying and was comforted by her parents after the sentence was handed down.
The Advertiser
5 hours ago
- The Advertiser
'He's dead bro', GP murder accused says after stabbing
A panicked teenager allegedly told friends he only realised the knife he used to stab a doctor to death "was actually going in" after two strikes. The boy, who cannot be named for legal reasons, has pleaded not guilty to one count of murdering GP Ash Gordon and guilty to two counts of aggravated burglary after breaking into his home. The accused had attended a house house party in Doncaster, in Melbourne's northeast on January 12, 2024, when just after 4am the next day, he and another boy decided to "take" a black Mercedes they had seen at a home down the road, prosecutor Kristie Churchill told a Supreme Court jury on Thursday. The pair walked over to the residence, where inside the three-story townhouse and asleep in their rooms were Dr Gordon and his housemate on the first and third floors, respectively. The pair broke in by sliding under the garage door before stealing shoes, headphones, laptops and silver necklaces belonging to Dr Gordon. Upon returning to their friend's house, the boys "boasted about things they stole" and planned to return again, the prosecutor said. Two more teens joined the pair, with the four captured on CCTV wearing gloves, balaclavas, face masks and hats. The prosector alleged they again slipped under the garage door but this time, they don't go undetected. "Hello boys," Dr Gordon said, after being awoken by the intruders, prompting the teens to run outside. The GP's housemate had told him they should call police but Dr Gordon said, "We'll call them later. We need to get our stuff back". After catching up with three of the teens outside his driveway, two of them jumped the fence, leaving the accused who the GP attempted to restrain, the prosecutor said. During the scuffle, the teen allegedly pulled out a knife and inflicted 11 sharp injuries, leaving the victim laying on the ground. "One of those penetrated Dr Gordon's chest cavity which killed him," Ms Churchill said. Two teens jumped back over the fence after the accused yelled for help before one allegedly kicked the victim in the face so forcefully that his "eyes rolled into the back of his head". After fleeing, the panicked accused allegedly told the others he had "stabbed a guy" four to five times. "Shit, just killed a guy. Like he's dead bro," the accused allegedly said. "The first two times I stabbed him I didn't realise (the knife) was going in. After the next few times I realised it was actually going in." On January 14, the accused and two others met up at an apartment in Melbourne's inner-south, where they discussed fleeing the country and no snitching. Three days later, police attended the apartment and arrested the accused, where they also found a silver chain allegedly belonging to Dr Gordon. Defence barrister Amelia Beech urged the jury to look at the evidence and approach the trial as if it was a "task of the mind, not a task of the heart". Ms Beech accepted jury members may have heard about the issue of youth crime in Victoria and how it has become "political fodder". She said the case was just about what happened between Dr Gordon and the accused at 5.27am on 13 January, 2024. "You can't send a message to the attorney-general or the premier here in this court," she said. The trial continues. A panicked teenager allegedly told friends he only realised the knife he used to stab a doctor to death "was actually going in" after two strikes. The boy, who cannot be named for legal reasons, has pleaded not guilty to one count of murdering GP Ash Gordon and guilty to two counts of aggravated burglary after breaking into his home. The accused had attended a house house party in Doncaster, in Melbourne's northeast on January 12, 2024, when just after 4am the next day, he and another boy decided to "take" a black Mercedes they had seen at a home down the road, prosecutor Kristie Churchill told a Supreme Court jury on Thursday. The pair walked over to the residence, where inside the three-story townhouse and asleep in their rooms were Dr Gordon and his housemate on the first and third floors, respectively. The pair broke in by sliding under the garage door before stealing shoes, headphones, laptops and silver necklaces belonging to Dr Gordon. Upon returning to their friend's house, the boys "boasted about things they stole" and planned to return again, the prosecutor said. Two more teens joined the pair, with the four captured on CCTV wearing gloves, balaclavas, face masks and hats. The prosector alleged they again slipped under the garage door but this time, they don't go undetected. "Hello boys," Dr Gordon said, after being awoken by the intruders, prompting the teens to run outside. The GP's housemate had told him they should call police but Dr Gordon said, "We'll call them later. We need to get our stuff back". After catching up with three of the teens outside his driveway, two of them jumped the fence, leaving the accused who the GP attempted to restrain, the prosecutor said. During the scuffle, the teen allegedly pulled out a knife and inflicted 11 sharp injuries, leaving the victim laying on the ground. "One of those penetrated Dr Gordon's chest cavity which killed him," Ms Churchill said. Two teens jumped back over the fence after the accused yelled for help before one allegedly kicked the victim in the face so forcefully that his "eyes rolled into the back of his head". After fleeing, the panicked accused allegedly told the others he had "stabbed a guy" four to five times. "Shit, just killed a guy. Like he's dead bro," the accused allegedly said. "The first two times I stabbed him I didn't realise (the knife) was going in. After the next few times I realised it was actually going in." On January 14, the accused and two others met up at an apartment in Melbourne's inner-south, where they discussed fleeing the country and no snitching. Three days later, police attended the apartment and arrested the accused, where they also found a silver chain allegedly belonging to Dr Gordon. Defence barrister Amelia Beech urged the jury to look at the evidence and approach the trial as if it was a "task of the mind, not a task of the heart". Ms Beech accepted jury members may have heard about the issue of youth crime in Victoria and how it has become "political fodder". She said the case was just about what happened between Dr Gordon and the accused at 5.27am on 13 January, 2024. "You can't send a message to the attorney-general or the premier here in this court," she said. The trial continues. A panicked teenager allegedly told friends he only realised the knife he used to stab a doctor to death "was actually going in" after two strikes. The boy, who cannot be named for legal reasons, has pleaded not guilty to one count of murdering GP Ash Gordon and guilty to two counts of aggravated burglary after breaking into his home. The accused had attended a house house party in Doncaster, in Melbourne's northeast on January 12, 2024, when just after 4am the next day, he and another boy decided to "take" a black Mercedes they had seen at a home down the road, prosecutor Kristie Churchill told a Supreme Court jury on Thursday. The pair walked over to the residence, where inside the three-story townhouse and asleep in their rooms were Dr Gordon and his housemate on the first and third floors, respectively. The pair broke in by sliding under the garage door before stealing shoes, headphones, laptops and silver necklaces belonging to Dr Gordon. Upon returning to their friend's house, the boys "boasted about things they stole" and planned to return again, the prosecutor said. Two more teens joined the pair, with the four captured on CCTV wearing gloves, balaclavas, face masks and hats. The prosector alleged they again slipped under the garage door but this time, they don't go undetected. "Hello boys," Dr Gordon said, after being awoken by the intruders, prompting the teens to run outside. The GP's housemate had told him they should call police but Dr Gordon said, "We'll call them later. We need to get our stuff back". After catching up with three of the teens outside his driveway, two of them jumped the fence, leaving the accused who the GP attempted to restrain, the prosecutor said. During the scuffle, the teen allegedly pulled out a knife and inflicted 11 sharp injuries, leaving the victim laying on the ground. "One of those penetrated Dr Gordon's chest cavity which killed him," Ms Churchill said. Two teens jumped back over the fence after the accused yelled for help before one allegedly kicked the victim in the face so forcefully that his "eyes rolled into the back of his head". After fleeing, the panicked accused allegedly told the others he had "stabbed a guy" four to five times. "Shit, just killed a guy. Like he's dead bro," the accused allegedly said. "The first two times I stabbed him I didn't realise (the knife) was going in. After the next few times I realised it was actually going in." On January 14, the accused and two others met up at an apartment in Melbourne's inner-south, where they discussed fleeing the country and no snitching. Three days later, police attended the apartment and arrested the accused, where they also found a silver chain allegedly belonging to Dr Gordon. Defence barrister Amelia Beech urged the jury to look at the evidence and approach the trial as if it was a "task of the mind, not a task of the heart". Ms Beech accepted jury members may have heard about the issue of youth crime in Victoria and how it has become "political fodder". She said the case was just about what happened between Dr Gordon and the accused at 5.27am on 13 January, 2024. "You can't send a message to the attorney-general or the premier here in this court," she said. The trial continues. A panicked teenager allegedly told friends he only realised the knife he used to stab a doctor to death "was actually going in" after two strikes. The boy, who cannot be named for legal reasons, has pleaded not guilty to one count of murdering GP Ash Gordon and guilty to two counts of aggravated burglary after breaking into his home. The accused had attended a house house party in Doncaster, in Melbourne's northeast on January 12, 2024, when just after 4am the next day, he and another boy decided to "take" a black Mercedes they had seen at a home down the road, prosecutor Kristie Churchill told a Supreme Court jury on Thursday. The pair walked over to the residence, where inside the three-story townhouse and asleep in their rooms were Dr Gordon and his housemate on the first and third floors, respectively. The pair broke in by sliding under the garage door before stealing shoes, headphones, laptops and silver necklaces belonging to Dr Gordon. Upon returning to their friend's house, the boys "boasted about things they stole" and planned to return again, the prosecutor said. Two more teens joined the pair, with the four captured on CCTV wearing gloves, balaclavas, face masks and hats. The prosector alleged they again slipped under the garage door but this time, they don't go undetected. "Hello boys," Dr Gordon said, after being awoken by the intruders, prompting the teens to run outside. The GP's housemate had told him they should call police but Dr Gordon said, "We'll call them later. We need to get our stuff back". After catching up with three of the teens outside his driveway, two of them jumped the fence, leaving the accused who the GP attempted to restrain, the prosecutor said. During the scuffle, the teen allegedly pulled out a knife and inflicted 11 sharp injuries, leaving the victim laying on the ground. "One of those penetrated Dr Gordon's chest cavity which killed him," Ms Churchill said. Two teens jumped back over the fence after the accused yelled for help before one allegedly kicked the victim in the face so forcefully that his "eyes rolled into the back of his head". After fleeing, the panicked accused allegedly told the others he had "stabbed a guy" four to five times. "Shit, just killed a guy. Like he's dead bro," the accused allegedly said. "The first two times I stabbed him I didn't realise (the knife) was going in. After the next few times I realised it was actually going in." On January 14, the accused and two others met up at an apartment in Melbourne's inner-south, where they discussed fleeing the country and no snitching. Three days later, police attended the apartment and arrested the accused, where they also found a silver chain allegedly belonging to Dr Gordon. Defence barrister Amelia Beech urged the jury to look at the evidence and approach the trial as if it was a "task of the mind, not a task of the heart". Ms Beech accepted jury members may have heard about the issue of youth crime in Victoria and how it has become "political fodder". She said the case was just about what happened between Dr Gordon and the accused at 5.27am on 13 January, 2024. "You can't send a message to the attorney-general or the premier here in this court," she said. The trial continues.
The Age
5 hours ago
- The Age
‘He's full dead, bro': Distressing final moments of stabbing death of doctor aired in court
A teenager told his friends 'just killed a guy. Like, he's dead bro', after stabbing a Melbourne doctor in the driveway of a Doncaster street. The then-16-year-old had broken into the Doncaster home of doctor Ashley Gordon twice in one night to steal shoes, jewellery and electronics. The teenager also allegedly showed the bloodied knife to friends before saying he needed to burn his clothes, a court has heard. The now 17-year-old, who cannot be named due to his age, has pleaded guilty to two counts of aggravated burglary and not guilty to a charge of murder. On the first day of the trial into the 33-year-old's alleged murder, distressing details of the doctor's final moments, and the two home invasions that preceded his death, were aired in the Supreme Court. The court heard the boy and his co-accused, who was also 16 at the time, had been drinking at a friend's party at a house in the same street as Gordon's home on the evening of January 12 last year. The other, now 17-year-old boy, has also been charged over Gordon's death and will face a separate trial. The hearing was told in the early hours of January 13 the two teenage boys began talking about stealing a black Mercedes they had seen parked in Gordon's garage. The court was told that some time after 3am the teenage boy, and his co-accused left the party and walked to Gordon's home, which he shared with his lifelong friend, Tristen Standing.
