Death of girl 'contributed to neglect' after hospital sent her home with meningitis
Lia Marsland was found unresponsive in bed by her mum on the morning of December 28, 2023. Around eight hours earlier, she was discharged from hospital.
A the tragic death of a five-year-old girl from meningitis was 'contributed to by neglect', a jury has concluded.
Lia Marsland was found unresponsive in bed by her mum on the morning of December 28, 2023. Around eight hours earlier, she was discharged from hospital.
She was sent home with antibiotics and a throat spray for tonsillitis, despite despite showing 'strong signs of meningitis' during her many hours in the hospital's A&E.
As the Manchester Evening News reports, an inquest has concluded Lila died from pneumococcal meningitis streptococcal pneumonia. A just determined today (Thursday, June 5) the little girl's death was 'contributed to by neglect'.
'Had Lila been admitted to hospital and given broad spectrum antibiotics within the first hour of being triaged, this would have prevented Lila's death,' the jury concluded.
The inquest how Lila's mum, who was a nurse at the time, asked hospital staff if Lila could have meningitis - which is an inflammation of the protective membranes surrounding the brain and spinal cord.
During the inquest, the court heard how Lila's mum, Rachael Mincherton, took her daughter to Tameside A&E and asked paediatric advanced nurse practitioner, Claire Casey, whether her child was suffering from meningitis.
Stockport Coroners Court heard that Lila suffered 'classic signs' of the brain-swelling condition over the eight-day hearing.
The family had gone to the hospital's A&E as Lila suffered headaches, a sore throat, a high heart rate, neck pain and limited neck movement, vomiting, lethargy, and was unable to pass urine.
Ms Casey, who worked at Tameside Hospital's paediatric A&E department, examined Lila and was ' clinically concerned' that the symptoms could be coming from tonsillitis, meningitis or another underlying illness, like a virus.
Ms Casey told the jury how she believed a child's neck pain was because of inflamed lymph nodes, and that her high heart rate was a result of the pain.
Meningitis remained a 'differential diagnosis', the court heard, but the nurse said her physical examination of Lila, and Lila's blood test results, suggested the symptoms came from tonsillitis.
Join the Daily Record WhatsApp community!
Get the latest news sent straight to your messages by joining our WhatsApp community today.
You'll receive daily updates on breaking news as well as the top headlines across Scotland.
No one will be able to see who is signed up and no one can send messages except the Daily Record team.
All you have to do is click here if you're on mobile, select 'Join Community' and you're in!
If you're on a desktop, simply scan the QR code above with your phone and click 'Join Community'.
We also treat our community members to special offers, promotions, and adverts from us and our partners. If you don't like our community, you can check out any time you like.
To leave our community click on the name at the top of your screen and choose 'exit group'.
If you're curious, you can read our Privacy Notice.
Ms Casey told Ms Mincherton that she was 'confident' the child did not have meningitis and Lila was given a dose of antibiotics.
After being discharged at around 2am, Ms Mincherton said they drove home, got in bed together and fell asleep.
Lila, from Hyde, woke up about 4am complaining of a headache and was given a half dose of Calpol.
At around 9am, Ms Mincherton woke up and found Lila unresponsive.
She called 999 and attempted CPR. Paramedics arrived at the home and Lila was pronounced dead at 9.19am.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Independent
8 hours ago
- The Independent
Labour pledges to lower A&E waiting times and end NHS ‘corridor care'
The government has pledged to drastically reduce the number of patients facing long waits in A&E, with plans also set out to end "corridor care". According to the Department of Health and NHS England, almost £450 million will be invested in creating better care and more facilities, with an emphasis on caring for people closer to their homes. The new Urgent and Emergency Care Plan for England states that more needs to be done to drive down long waits, cut delayed discharges, and improve care for patients. An earlier version of the document said NHS trusts would need to show how, by this winter, systems will "improve flow through hospitals, with a particular focus on patients waiting over 12 hours, and eliminate corridor care". The later version does not commit to a timescale for ending corridor care, instead stating that systems must "improve flow through hospitals, with a particular focus on reducing patients waiting over 12 hours and making progress on eliminating corridor care". Ministers have also set an ambition for a minimum of 78% of patients who attend A&E to be admitted, transferred, or discharged within four hours, up from the current 75%, meaning "over 800,000 people a month will receive more timely care". There will also be a focus on seeing more children. The Government wants to slash the number of patients waiting more than 12 hours for a hospital bed – or to be discharged from A&E – so this occurs 'less than 10% of the time', according to the new document. Around 1.7 million attendances at A&E every year currently exceed this time frame. Further measures in the plan are intended to drive down delayed discharges from hospital, which occur when people are medically fit to leave but care in their homes or community has not yet been put in place. Local performance targets will be set to improve patient discharge times, and 'eliminate internal discharge delays of more than 48 hours in all settings', the plan said. Experts said A&E 'league tables' will be published to drive up performance. Those patients who need an overnight emergency admission will also have their overall stay reduced where appropriate – the average is 'currently nearly a day longer than in 2019'. The plan further sets out how ambulance waiting times for category 2 patients – such as those suffering stroke, heart attack, sepsis or major trauma – will be cut by more than 14%, from 35 to 30 minutes. A previous target of 18 minutes has been repeatedly missed. In the document, there is an aim to 'eradicate' last winter's lengthy ambulance handover delays by meeting a maximum 45-minute target for patients to be handed over to A&E. This should help 'get 550,000 more ambulances back on the road for patients', it says. According to the document, around 40 new same day emergency care and urgent treatment centres will also be established to treat and discharge patients the same day, avoiding unnecessary admissions to hospital. Almost 500 new ambulances will also be rolled out across the country by March 2026. The plan details 15 mental health crisis assessment centres, which are designed to ensure mentally ill people do not have to wait in A&E for hours for care. It comes after the NHS experienced a crisis over winter, with patients waiting hours for beds and regularly being treated in corridors – so-called corridor care. A&E waiting time targets have not been met for more than a decade, while the 18-minute target for category 2 ambulance calls has never been hit outside the pandemic. Health Secretary Wes Streeting said: 'No patient should ever be left waiting for hours in hospital corridors or for an ambulance which ought to arrive in minutes. 'We can't fix more than a decade of underinvestment and neglect overnight. 'But through the measures we're setting out today, we will deliver faster and more convenient care for patients in emergencies. 'Far too many patients are ending up in A&E who don't need or want to be there, because there isn't anywhere else available. 'Because patients can't get a GP appointment, which costs the NHS £40, they end up in A&E, which costs around £400 – worse for patients and more expensive for the taxpayer. 'The package of investment and reforms we are announcing today will help the NHS treat more patients in the community, so they don't end up stuck on trolleys in A&E.' Under the plans, paramedics will play a bigger role in the community, with patients given 'more effective treatment at the scene of an accident or in their own homes from ambulance crews'. More patients will also be seen by urgent community response teams in their own homes to try to avoid hospital admission. The NHS is also pledging better use of virtual wards, where patients are monitored by hospital staff from their home, and there are plans to drive up vaccination rates among NHS staff to help protect patients. The Liberal Democrats claimed the Government had listened to their calls to end corridor care, but called on ministers to follow through on their promises. Lib Dem health spokesperson Helen Morgan MP said: 'Patients have heard these kinds of promises before only to be led up the garden path. 'We can't bear any more of the shameful neglect and failed delivery that we saw for a decade under the Conservatives. 'It's good to see ministers finally listen to Liberal Democrat demands to end corridor care but the misery in our A&Es will only be prolonged if they continue to move at a snail's pace on social care. 'Until they grasp this nettle, millions are at risk of dangerously long waits in A&E. 'They must see sense and conclude their review into social care by the end of this year.'
Daily Record
10 hours ago
- Daily Record
Medik8 unveils 'miracle' new serum that 'defends against premature ageing'
The results-driven brand has added a powerhouse new serum that boasts an "intelligent" combination of ingredients. Looking to target dull skin and wrinkles? Then many experts experts would agree that it is worth purchasing skincare products with vitamin C One that has become a staple for many beauty enthusiasts is Medik8's C-Tetra range, with the celebrity approved brand's range of serums said to "visibly reduce" wrinkles and hyperpigmentation within four weeks. Now there's a brand new addition, as the firm says the "wait is over" after adding the C-Tetra Advanced to the line-up, and, owing to Medik8's reputation, it has been hailed as a "miracle in a bottle." Retailing at £69 for a 30ml bottle, this serum has been designed to be used in a morning skincare routine, using a powerful formula that works to "defend against premature skin ageing and achieve accelerated visible skin brightening." Said to be infused with a next-generation combination of 20 percent vitamin C and cutting edge phyto exosomes, it helps to shield and improve the skin from any environmental aggressors that can cause early signs of ageing. The "intelligent" formula provides smarter, not harsher, results, with skin tone said to be "visibly brightened" in just seven days, leaving a soft, smooth, even complexion. It also offers a unique texture, acting as a gel-serum that is said to be "fast absorbing", leaving the skin "instantly refreshed", while also hydrating, priming and smoothing. Medik8 C-Tetra Advanced, 30ml £69 Medik8 Buy here Product Description While the new Medik8 serum is a unique addition to the market, there are a few other powerhouses on the high street. This includes The Ordinary's £14.28 Multi-Antioxidant Radiance Serum (30ml) that uses eight technologies to brighten and protect. Another that is fairly new to the UK is Olay's Super Serum that costs £18.14 for a 30ml on Amazon. The first of its kind to offer five ingredients, including vitamin C, it offers a multitude of benefits that range from brightening to anti-ageing. Skincare buffs keen to know more about the new C-Tetra Advanced might be eager to know that it has already earned a 4.8 rating from those who managed to sample it, with praise saying it "minimises" lines and leaves skin "brighter." Join the Daily Record WhatsApp community! Get the latest news sent straight to your messages by joining our WhatsApp community today. You'll receive daily updates on breaking news as well as the top headlines across Scotland. No one will be able to see who is signed up and no one can send messages except the Daily Record team. All you have to do is click here if you're on mobile, select 'Join Community' and you're in! If you're on a desktop, simply scan the QR code above with your phone and click 'Join Community'. We also treat our community members to special offers, promotions, and adverts from us and our partners. If you don't like our community, you can check out any time you like. To leave our community click on the name at the top of your screen and choose 'exit group'. If you're curious, you can read our Privacy Notice. A five-star review read: "This was an absolute treat to use. Applied smoothly, visibly made my complexion look radiant and bright. In the morning I looked nice and fresh, smooth looking skin reduced the look of wrinkles. Another miracle in a bottle by Medik8." A second read: "I absolutely love this product, within a few days my skin looked so much brighter & smoother plus my wrinkles seemed to have reduced, in my experience it's not often you see a noticeable improvement so quickly with skincare products, even my husband said I look fresh faced!!! Beauty deal of the week It's almost Father's Day, and are you in need of some gift inspiration? If you don't want to buy a last minute gift, then we have you covered, as a bottle of aftershave is always a good shout and Debenhams has just cut the Yves Saint Laurent L'Homme Eau De Toilette from £92 to just £55.20 for a large 100ml bottle. There is also a smaller 60ml bottle that is a bit cheaper, with the price being reduced by 37 per cent from £68 to £43. Since reviews say it "stands out from the crowd", it's a deal worth bagging for dad. Launched in 2006, this YSL fragrance has been described as "a fragrance for the urban and charismatic 21st century male". For the guy in your life who likes to smell a little different, then this is the bottle to reach for. It opens on sparkling notes of bergamot, zesty cedarwood and Chinese ginger that has been met with the middle notes of violet leaves and basil flowers, offering a floral and spicy contrast. It is said to end on base notes of sandalwood, Virginia cedar wood and Haitian vetiver to "highlight this charismatic and magnetic fragrance." Those who want to stand out from the crowd will appreciate the YSL L'Homme Eau De Toilette, as it has earned a 4.7 rating from Debenhams fragrance buffs who have said it is "unusual" and "always gets compliments." One positive review read: "An unusual and outstanding men's perfume! What an interesting fresh yet a hint of spice men's perfume! It's different. Stands out from the crowd. Purchase the Yves Saint Laurent L'Homme Eau De Toilette (100ml) in the Debenhams sale here. "It's light & quickly absorbed so very easy to apply. C Tetra Advanced really made a difference & I will be making a purchase when it's launched!" Someone else praising the results said: "My skin looked visibly improved after four weeks of use in terms of ageing and minimising lines and wrinkles. It also gave it a radiance that made it look healthy and younger. I can't recommend this product enough!" A few users haven't been keen on the texture or the scent, as one such three-star review read: "Although this serum absorbs quickly I was not keen on the smell and found the consistency too thin for my liking." Although, this wasn't the case for most reviewers, as a fan of the formula said: "The C-Tetra advanced is the perfect consistency goes onto the skin nice and smoothly and is not greasy. It has a lovely smell and gives a nice radiance to the face." Purchase the new Medik8 C-Tetra Advanced (30ml) for £69 here.
Wales Online
11 hours ago
- Wales Online
'I was told I had gallstones for five months - now I won't see daughter grow up'
'I was told I had gallstones for five months - now I won't see daughter grow up' Kanisha Collins is now 'preparing to say goodbye to her two-year-old daughter' Kanisha with her daughter Amaya (Image: Dean Collins/SWNS ) A bride-to-be was diagnosed with incurable stage four cancer after the mass on her pancreas was dismissed as gallstones for five months. Kanisha Collins, 24, started experiencing liver pain and recurring water infections last winter. She was treated for pancreatitis at Chesterfield Royal Hospital, during which doctors found a large mass on her pancreas and blood clots. A CT scan in February showed a slight shrinking in the mass and doctors told her the mass was likely gallstones. Given her young age, no further tests were carried out. Kanisha was scheduled for an MRI scan later in the year, but went to A&E in April due to pain, where her liver lesions were discovered. A biopsy revealed that she had stage four pancreatic cancer that had already spread to the liver. The 24-year-old started chemotherapy this week to hopefully slow down the cancer. Kanisha and her partner Mason Furnace, 29, are to get married on Saturday, with Kanisha's two-year-old daughter Amaya as the bride's flower girl. The bride, a care assistant from Chesterfield, Derbyshire, said: 'We've been engaged for two years, but when they found the mass my fiancé wanted to get married this year to speed things up. It's stressful, I'm having chemo so obviously I'm going to be tired on my wedding day – not how I wanted to feel on my wedding day. But I'm still going to be thoroughly looking forward to it because it's a day with friends and family and a day to celebrate me.' Kanisha went to see her doctor in December 2024 after experiencing pain, appetite problems and indigestion. Doctors found a mass on her pancreas in December, but didn't test it - assuming it was gallstones. Article continues below Kanisha said: 'They misdiagnosed me because of my age, saying they didn't think anyone my age would have that kind of cancer. They never attempted to test the mass they found back in December." Continually monitoring the mass, doctors found in February 2025 that it was shrinking. Kanisha said: "When they said the mass had shrunk slightly, obviously it was positive news, but I felt like they just kept testing the mass rather than actually doing something about it or properly testing it. And now I'm left with something incurable." In April the mum went to A&E for lower stomach pain and a CT scan finally revealed she had pancreatic cancer. Kanisha in hosptial (Image: Dean Collins/SWNS ) She said: 'When it came back that it all stemmed from my pancreas, it was heartbreaking for me, because I'm 24 and I just feel like the hospital could have done more and pushed for more tests in the beginning. Then I might not have been in the situation I am now. 'People should get tested sooner for anything they find mass-wise, in any age of person, because nobody should go through it. The problem with pancreatic cancer is that there are not that many symptoms. But your appetite lessens and you get a lot more indigestion and stuff because it's to do with your digestive system." Kanisha and her daughter Amaya are living in Chesterfield with Kanisha's father Dean Collins, who set up a GoFundMe to support photo sessions, keepsakes and memory-making days out between the mother and her daughter. The young mother said: 'My daughter is only the age of two so she's not understanding anything at the moment. Obviously it's putting a lot of strain on the family and financially of course. Everyone's trying to support me and my daughter.' Train driver Dean said on the fundraising site: 'Despite being so young, her life is being cruelly cut short. She now faces the unimaginable – preparing to say goodbye to her two-year-old daughter, Amaya. 'Amaya will grow up without her mummy by her side throughout her childhood, teenage years, and adult life. The pain of this loss is unimaginable for our family. Tragically, Kanisha's cancer was initially misdiagnosed by the hospital as a non-cancerous mass, causing a delay in proper treatment and reducing her chances of survival.' Kanisha with her daughter Amaya and partner Mason (Image: Dean Collins/SWNS ) Article continues below Dr Hal Spencer, chief executive of Chesterfield Royal Hospital said: 'We always strive to give the best care and we are sorry to hear of Kanisha's experience. Throughout, her care has always been considered seriously and we have consulted with regional specialist colleagues who were advising us on her care and management. 'We would encourage Kanisha and her family to contact us and we will support them in a full review of her care in order that we can understand the decisions taken and the management advice given. This will help inform our internal reviews already underway.'
