Zandile Gumede case: State witness confirms former City Manager's role in waste tender decisions
Former eThekwini City Manager Sipho Nzuza.
Image: Doctor Ngcobo / Independent Newspapers
A State witness has told the Durban High Court that the former City Manager of eThekwini Municipality was well within his rights to sign letters of award for the waste collection tenders in 2017.
The R320 million Durban Solid Waste (DSW) tender fraud trial involves former Mayor Zandile Gumede and 21 other accused who facenumerous charges including money laundering, racketeering, fraud, corruption, and contravention of the Municipal Finance Management Act and the Municipal Systems Act.
In 2017 the Solid Waste Unit had to urgently appoint service providers to collect waste in the City as the contracts of existing service providers were due to expire on December 31, 2017.
Moreover, the State witness who in December 2017 worked at the tenders and contracts unit has admitted under cross examination that Sipho Nzuza, the former City Manager was within his rights to require or ask the former deputy head of Supply Chain Management, Sandile Ngcobo about the letters of awards on December 28 2017. Ngcobo is also an accused in this matter.
This is as the Bid Adjudication Committee (BAC) chaired by Ngcobo approved the Solid Waste unit to approach experienced service providers to collect waste in eThekwini.
The BAC gave it approval on December 19,2017 for the Solid Waste Unit to get new service providers to collect waste. It also approved their quotations. This witness told the court that she did not take the BAC decision to the Executive Acquisitions Committee (EAC). The EAC was an advisory committee established by Nzuza to assist him to make decisions.
In giving various reasons for this, the witness on Thursday told the court that these decisions did not go to the EAC because she was on leave and the agenda was prepared days before the EAC.
She had also told the court that she was responsible for drafting the agenda for all the committees and decision circulars.
Despite the urgency of the matter, the witness said the BAC decisions about the solid waste tender reached the EAC on January 29, 2018.
Nzuza's counsel, Advocate Credo Mlaba put it to the witness that Nzuza was faced with a situation where the waste was not going to be collected in the City and on December 28, 2017 he approached Ngcobo for an update on the waste collection and asked him to attend to the letters of award, as this was an emergency.
'Nzuza said it would have been impossible for him to wait for January 29, 2018 as the BAC decisions did not make it to the EAC meeting on December 21, 2017. Would you like to comment on that?'
The witness said it was understood this was Nzuza's role and the witness also agreed with advocate Jay Naidoo SC, counsel for Gumede that the SCM policy and regulations authorised Nzuza to sign the letters of awards based on decisions taken by the BAC. However, she said if he solely signed without consulting EAC, he would be disregarding his own internal policy.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
IOL News
2 hours ago
- IOL News
Persecuted gay man, shunned in his homeland, granted reconsideration of asylum in SA
The court ruled that home affairs had to reconsider granting asylum status to a Chad citizen after he was persecuted in his country for being gay. Image: File A Muslim man who was imprisoned in Chad on grounds of his sexual orientation and fled to South Africa after he was released as he fears persecution, has been given a lifeline, as the Western Cape High court ordered that his application for asylum status be heard afresh. The man, only identified as MA, turned to the Western Cape High Court on Friday, where he asked that the decision by the Refugee Status Determination Officer, in refusing his refugee status, be overturned. Judge Gayaat da Silva-Salie ordered that his application for asylum status had to be heard afresh, by another officer. The judge remarked that the reasons given by the officer for refusing his application were nonsensical. MA fled to South Africa to join his lover, a doctor working here. He explained that homosexuality is criminalised in his country of origin. He was arrested in Chad in September 2022, after which he was convicted on charges of homosexual activities and sentenced to 18 months imprisonment. On appeal, his sentence was reduced to 12 months with the option of paying a fine. He was released from prison in February 2023 and entered South Africa in May 2023, by way of a visitor's visa. He applied for asylum on a few occasions and his most recent interview was in September last year. While the reasons for refusing him asylum status formed part of the court proceedings, the judge remarked that they were unintelligible, irrational and failed to consider the applicable law. The officer also failed to consider the circumstances in Chad, in particular their position on homosexuality. MA submitted in support of his application for asylum that he fled Chad after being imprisoned solely for being a homosexual man. He further stated that his safety and freedom remain threatened in Chad, where homosexuality is a criminal offence. He also indicated that his family had disowned him and that he faces persecution both from the State and society at large in his home country. Home affairs, on the other hand, said he has not yet exhausted the internal remedies available to him and argued that he could return to that country. The department reasoned that the judiciary in Chad is independent, and that although homosexuality is criminalised, some courts had released offenders. Judge Da Silva-Salie found the arguments by the department 'rather problematic". 'It accepts the factual basis of criminalisation of homosexuality, with consequent criminal convictions and punishments in the applicant's home country of Chad, while simultaneously rejecting the credibility of the applicant's claim of fear of future persecution,' she said. She added that no attempt was made to test or evaluate the applicant's claim that his prior arrest, imprisonment, and societal ostracisation due to his homosexuality posed a continued threat. The judge said if the applicant returned to Chad, his position can only be worse if he continued his lifestyle as he would be already a convicted person of homosexual offences. She referred to the reason forwarded for refusing asylum as 'a characteristic of a sequence of illogical babble".
IOL News
20 hours ago
- IOL News
Court orders reconsideration of asylum for persecuted gay man
The court ruled that home affairs had to reconsider granting asylum status to a Chad citizen after he was persecuted in his country for being gay. Image: File A Muslim man who was imprisoned in Chad on grounds of his sexual orientation and fled to South Africa after he was released as he fears persecution, turned to court after home affairs officials here refused to grant him refugee status. The man, only identified as MA, on Friday headed to the urgent court at the Western Cape High Court, where he obtained a lifeline. He asked that the decision by the Refugee Status Determination Officer, in refusing his refugee status, be overturned. Judge Gayaat da Silva-Salie ordered that his application for asylum status had to be heard afresh, by another officer. The judge remarked that the reasons given by the officer for refusing his application were nonsensical. MA fled to South Africa to join his lover, a doctor working here. He explained that homosexuality is criminalised in his country of origin. He was arrested in Chad in September 2022, after which he was convicted on charges of homosexual activities and sentenced to 18 months imprisonment. On appeal, his sentence was reduced to 12 months with the option of paying a fine. He was released from prison in February 2023 and entered South Africa in May 2023, by way of a visitor's visa. He applied for asylum on a few occasions and his most recent interview was in September last year. While the reasons for refusing him asylum status formed part of the court proceedings, the judge remarked that they were unintelligible, irrational and failed to consider the applicable law. The officer also failed to consider the circumstances in Chad, in particular their position on homosexuality. MA submitted in support of his application for asylum that he fled Chad after being imprisoned solely for being a homosexual man. He further stated that his safety and freedom remain threatened in Chad, where homosexuality is a criminal offence. He also indicated that his family had disowned him and that he faces persecution both from the State and society at large in his home country. Home affairs, on the other hand, said he has not yet exhausted the internal remedies available to him and argued that he could return to that country. The department reasoned that the judiciary in Chad is independent, and that although homosexuality is criminalised, some courts had released offenders. Judge Da Silva-Salie found the arguments by the department 'rather problematic". 'It accepts the factual basis of criminalisation of homosexuality, with consequent criminal convictions and punishments in the applicant's home country of Chad, whilst simultaneously rejecting the credibility of the applicant's claim of fear of future persecution,' she said. She added that no attempt was made to test or evaluate the applicant's claim that his prior arrest, imprisonment, and societal ostracisation due to his homosexuality posed a continued threat. The judge said if the applicant returned to Chad, his position can only be worse if he continued his lifestyle as he would be already a convicted person of homosexual offences. She referred to the reason forwarded for refusing asylum as 'a characteristic of a sequence of illogical babble".
IOL News
2 days ago
- IOL News
Joshlin Smith's grandmother battling 'mental anguish' after daughter receives life sentence
Amanda Smith-Daniels, Kelly Smith's mother and the grandmother of missing child Joshlin Smith, arriving in court before the sentencing proceedings in the trial. Image: Ayanda Ndamane/IndependentNewspapers Amanda Smith-Daniels, the grandmother of missing six-year-old Joshlin Smith, says she is grappling with deep psychological trauma after her daughter, Racquel 'Kelly', Smith was sentenced to life in prison for trafficking her child. In an emotional interview, Smith-Daniels revealed that she has been admitted to a psychiatric facility for treatment for severe depression. The weight of her daughter's betrayal and the ongoing anguish of not knowing what happened to her granddaughter have taken a devastating toll. 'I must deal with psychologists and psychiatrists. I have to work on my mental health because it's too much,' she said. 'My pillow is riddled with tears. Every night I lie awake praying for Joshlin.' Joshlin went missing from her home in Middelpos, Saldanha Bay, on 19 February 2024. According to Kelly Smith, she left her daughter in the care of her boyfriend Jacquen 'Boeta' Appollis while she went to work. When she returned home, Joshlin was gone. A massive search effort was launched, but over a year later, the little girl has still not been found. Following months of court proceedings, Kelly Smith, her co-accused, Appollis, and their friend Steveno 'Steffie' van Rhyn were convicted and sentenced to life for human trafficking and 10 years for kidnapping. Meanwhile, a fourth accused, Lourentia 'Renz' Lombaard, turned State witness. Since the sentencing, Smith-Daniels says her daughter has cut all ties with her — even sending police officers to deliver the message that she wanted no further contact. 'I haven't seen her since she was sentenced,' she said. 'She blames me, I think, for what I said in court. But I only told the truth.' Her victim impact statement, delivered by Court Preparation Officer Deonett Boltney, laid bare the emotional destruction caused by Kelly's actions. 'Kelly, you've come to make our lives hell on earth,' the statement read. 'You came to break us and tear us apart. Do you know what it's like to lie awake every night? My heart is ripped out of my body because I pray for Joshlin.' In the same statement, Smith-Daniels recalled how Kelly's son wished Kelly a happy Mother's Day, while the boy's mother was behind bars. 'Didn't you wish you had your three children with you? I'm the one who prays with him at night, who helps him with his homework. You tried using our personal lives to air dirty laundry with your actions.' The heartbreak of Joshlin's disappearance continues to haunt her. 'She (Rachelle) was such a bright little girl. At night, when I got up to use the bathroom, she would fly up, arms stretched out, asking where I was going. I had to pick her up because she was afraid I'd leave her. It broke me every time,' she said in the statement. 'Sometimes when she was playing, she would stop and say: 'Mommy, you know my sister is gone and my mom too'." With Kelly in prison and Joshlin still missing, Smith-Daniels is now responsible for raising the two other children, Rachelle and Racquen. She has yet to tell Rachelle the full truth. 'She's too young to understand. I just told her we're going to find her sister and that her mommy will come back. Only Racquen knows the truth. I've taken him to psychologists to help him cope,' said on Smith-Daniels. Smith-Daniels said she now lives with constant fear and anxiety for the safety of her grandchildren. 'It weighs heavily on me every morning when I wake them for school. I feel like I need to be at the school all day to make sure nothing happens to them.' Her daily life is a battle with trauma, made worse by the uncertainty over Joshlin's fate. 'Even though there's no good news about Joshlin yet, I still believe the police haven't given up. I believe in Captain Lombard,' she said, referring to the lead investigator in the case. Joshlin's disappearance shocked the nation and led to widespread calls for action against child trafficking and abuse. Over the course of the trial, 35 State witnesses were called, and a trial-within-a-trial was held to examine the admissibility of confessions allegedly obtained under duress. Judge Nathan Erasmus ultimately found that Kelly Smith had willingly handed over her child to be trafficked. In handing down the life sentence, Erasmus said her actions were motivated by greed. Judge Erasmus has yet to rule on whether State witness Lourentia Lombard will receive indemnity from prosecution. A separate hearing is expected. As the case draws national attention, Smith-Daniels is trying to find a way forward. But she says the pain will never go away — not until Joshlin is found. 'I still remember the day we realised she was gone. I thought she would be found that same night. That was my prayer.' Though exhausted by grief, she remains grateful for those who continue to support the family and help search for Joshlin. 'Thank you to everyone who still remembers her name and fights for her. Please don't stop.'
