Officials drop traffic charges that led ICE to arrest 19-year-old Georgia teen
Dalton, Georgia — Local authorities in Dalton, Georgia, on Monday dismissed the traffic charges that led Immigration and Customs Enforcement to detain a 19-year-old Mexican-born college student who has lived in the United States since she was 4.
Ximena Arias Cristobal, who is in the country without authorization, was taken into ICE custody earlier this month after a May 5 traffic stop in Dalton, where she lives with her family. Local police cited her for making an improper turn and driving without a license before booking her into the Whitfield County Jail in Dalton, where she was picked up by ICE officers.
But the Dalton Police Department and the city's prosecutor announced on Monday they had reviewed dashboard camera footage of the traffic stop and determined that the officer had stopped the wrong vehicle. Officials said the vehicle that made the improper turn was similar to the truck Arias Cristobal was driving.
Arias Cristobal is now facing deportation and remains detained at the Stewart ICE detention facility in Lumpkin, Georgia, according to the agency's online system for tracking detainees. Her father, Jose Francisco Arias Tovar, is also being held there. ICE arrested him last month, also following a traffic stop, his family said.
ICE did not immediately respond to requests for comment on what actions, if any, it would take in response to the decision by authorities in Dalton to drop the traffic violations against Arias Cristobal.
In a statement before Monday's announcement, Tricia McLaughlin, a spokesperson for the Department of Homeland Security, called Arias Cristobal an "illegal alien" who had "admitted to illegally entering the United States." McLaughlin said Arias Cristobal's father, Arias Tovar, "self-admitted that he is in the country illegally."
Federal officials have not disputed that Arias Cristobal and her father lack criminal records.
"[The] family will be able to return to Mexico together," McLaughlin said in her statement. "Mr. Tovar had ample opportunity to seek a legal pathway to citizenship. He chose not to. We are not ignoring the rule of law."
According to her family, Arias Cristobal came to the U.S. in 2010 and graduated from Dalton's high school last year. She did not qualify for the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals, or DACA, program for other undocumented immigrant "Dreamers" who came to the U.S. as minors because she arrived after the policy's June 2007 cutoff date.
During a press conference on Monday, Chris Crosser, the assistant Dalton police chief, expressed regret about his agency's mistake. But he said he could not opine on how ICE should treat Arias Cristobal's case going forward, given the new information. He said local officials notified her lawyers of the dismissed charges but did not alert ICE.
"It's a very regrettable place that we are right here, that we've ended up in this place with the way this unfolded and the way it turned out," Crosser said, adding that an internal review of the incident is ongoing.
Arias Cristobal's lawyers said their client is likely to remain in ICE custody for now, even after the dismissal of the charges, since federal officials are holding her because she's in the U.S. without legal permission. They said she has a bond hearing scheduled for next week.
Arias Cristobal's arrest is one of several high-profile cases of undocumented immigrants being arrested by ICE during the Trump administration, despite living in the country for many years and lacking criminal histories.
Soon after President Trump took office, his administration dramatically expanded who could face arrest and deportation, reversing Biden-era rules that largely limited ICE operations to arrests of serious criminals, national security threats and recent arrivals in the U.S. illegally.
While Trump administration officials have said they will prioritize the arrest of dangerous individuals who are in the U.S. unlawfully, they have stressed that no one will be protected from deportation if they lack valid immigration documents.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CBS News
22 minutes ago
- CBS News
Protesters rally, march against ICE in downtown Chicago
Protesters gathered in Federal Plaza and marched along downtown Chicago streets Tuesday evening in a demonstration against the Trump administration and raids by U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement. Streets were closed on a rolling basis as the protest march advanced. At Federal Plaza, protesters beat drums and chanted, "Revolution!" and other chants. Some waved the flag of Mexico, and some also waved Palestinian flags and wore keffiyehs in solidarity with the pro-Palestinian cause. Signs in English and Spanish were seen, "The People say ICE out," and, "The People say ICE out of Chicago." Many signs also referenced keeping families together. A series of speakers took to a podium during the protest. The group then began marching north on Dearborn Street, yelling, "F**k ICE," and "No justice, no peace!" Police kept their distance on the sides of the march. The group that began at Federal Plaza apparently merged with a group that had been circling the downtown area for a few hours. CBS News Chicago talked with protesters before the march began. "We don't think what's happening is just, and personally, I'm against my government using my tax dollars to fund genocide, as well as ICE going into people's homes without warrants," said protester Timothy Edward. "Something's happening right now like in our country where people have to ultimately decide, like, what side of history that they want to be on," said protester Johnathan Ellison. CBS News Chicago also asked the Chicago Police Department about its protocols for handling such protests as the one on Tuesday, and the "No Kings" protest against the Trump administration planned for Saturday. Police cited their experience with the Democratic National Convention last year as an example of successfully handling protest. Police also said they would ensure people's First Amendment rights were protected, but said violence would not be tolerated.
Fox News
28 minutes ago
- Fox News
Fetterman emerges as Dems' ‘voice of reason' as LA burns, conservatives say
Pennsylvania Democratic Sen. John Fetterman has once again emerged as the his party's "voice of reason" after he denounced the Los Angeles riots for their "anarchy and true chaos" and Democratic colleagues attempt to characterize the anti-ICE riots as "peaceful protests." "John Fetterman is once again a voice of reason within the Democrat party," University of Pennsylvania grad Eyal Yakoby, who has frequently spoken to the media about antisemitism on college campuses since 2023, posted to X Monday. Fetterman issued a strong message on X Monday evening denouncing the riots in Los Angeles and included a now-infamous photo showing a rioter standing on a car while waving the Mexican flag surrounded by raging flames. "I unapologetically stand for free speech, peaceful demonstrations, and immigration—but this is not that," Fetterman posted. "This is anarchy and true chaos. My party loses the moral high ground when we refuse to condemn setting cars on fire, destroying buildings, and assaulting law enforcement." The message received strong support among conservatives who have balked at Democrats attempting to portray the riots as peaceful and only turning violent and chaotic when President Donald Trump activated the National Guard over the weekend. "We conservatives were wrong about John Fetterman," one social media commenter posted, referring to how conservatives were quick to denounce Fetterman's 2022 Senate run. "He seems to be the only voice of reason on the left at this point." "You are welcome to come to the winning side like the rest of us…" comedian Rosenne Barr responded. "He is 💯 correct. As I have always said, anyone who engages in this type of conduct, whether in LA, in Minneapolis, in Portland, or on January 6th should be arrested and prosecuted," New York Republican Rep. Mike Lawler responded. "Causing violence, physical damage or harm is unacceptable and cannot be tolerated." "Why aren't more democrats saying this?" Republican Minnesota politician Joe Teirab posted. "To me, this is obvious and common sense." "Senator John Fetterman should lead the Democrat party," another account posted. "Sen. Fetterman appears to be the only prominent Democrat to denounce the rioting. Everybody else is as quiet as a mouse (or as a clenched fist). Didn't they tell us that 'Silence is Violence'?" another wrote. "True," former Republican Wisconsin Gov. Scott Walker posted in response to Fetterman's message. "Once again, my friend @JohnFetterman is simply telling the truth," Republican Alabama Sen. Katie Britt posted in response. This is far from the first time Fetterman has found himself being praised by conservatives and typical critics of the Democratic Party. Fetterman was among a handful of Democrats to denounce anti-Israel protests that took over college campuses after war broke out in Israel in 2023. He praised Trump for ending the Joint Comprehensive Plan of Action (JCPOA) with Iran and re-imposing sanctions against the nation in 2018. Fetterman was vocal about Democratic missteps during the 2024 presidential election, remarking in the lead-up to Election Day that Trump support in the Keystone State was "astonishing" and condemning Democrats who slammed Trump as a "fascist" after the election. Conservatives are praising Fetterman as the Democrats navigate their future after a disastrous 2024 election cycle that saw Joe Biden exiting the race with just over 100 days left in the cycle and Kamala Harris launching a truncated presidential campaign that failed to rally support against Trump's bid. Fox News Digital reached out to Fetterman's office for additional comment on the matter but did not immediately receive a reply.
CBS News
29 minutes ago
- CBS News
Los Angeles ICE protests head into fifth night after Newsom sues to halt Marines, National Guard deployment
It's been five days since anti-ICE demonstrations erupted in Los Angeles, some turning violent between protesters and law enforcement officers, prompting President Trump to deploy National Guard troops and hundreds of Marines. The violent clashes have left an aftermath of destruction, including graffiti, looting, vandalism and debris. The Los Angeles Police Department has arrested over 100 people over the past few days, including 96 on Monday night. Mayor Karen Bass provided an update on the protests during a news conference on Tuesday. She told reporters that thorough investigations will be conducted to identify people who are involved in committing damage or vandalism. She warned people that they would be prosecuted to the full extent of the law. She said that the protests should be focused on advocating for immigrants' rights and not on committing crimes. "I don't not believe that individuals that commit vandalism and violence in our city really are in support of immigrants; they have another agenda," Bass said. The protests began Friday night after several immigration raids took place in the Westlake District, downtown and South LA. SkyCal flew over the locations where crowds quickly formed, and protesters attempted to prevent federal agents from placing individuals into vans. The protests that took place over the weekend were declared unlawful assemblies and people were ordered to disperse and clear the area. Over several days, law enforcement and troops have been dressed in riot gear and have been seen firing less-than-lethal, tear gas and flash bangs into crowds to try and disperse people. Department of Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem posted on X that people who "lay a hand" on law enforcement officers will be prosecuted to the full extent of the law. National Guard and military in Los Angeles As of Tuesday morning, about 700 active-duty Marines began arriving in the LA area, a defense official said, to join the thousands of National Guard troops already deployed to respond to the protests. Acting Defense Department comptroller Bryn MacDonnell testified before the House Appropriations Subcommittee on Defense and said the deployment of the National Guard will cost about $134 million. On Tuesday, California Attorney General Rob Bonta asked a federal judge to provide a temporary restraining order to stop Mr. Trump, Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth and the U.S. Department of Defense from using the military and the National Guard to patrol the region and protect federal officers and facilities. The day before Bonta filed a lawsuit against the Trump administration, arguing the orders are unlawful and exceed the federal government's authority under the Tenth Amendment. "President Trump's order calling federalized National Guard troops into Los Angeles — over the objections of the Governor and local law enforcement — is unnecessary and counterproductive. It's also deeply unfair to the members of the National Guard who are hard at work every day protecting our state, preparing for and responding to emergencies, and training so that, if called, they can fight our nation's wars," Bonta said. Bass blamed the unrest in LA on the federal government's involvement, saying that before immigration enforcement actions last week, the city was "peaceful." Protests take place across California Demonstrations have also taken place in cities across California in response to the events in Los Angeles. On Monday, over 100 people gathered in Santa Ana outside the complex of federal buildings in the downtown area. Law enforcement officials used crowd dispersal methods like smoke-filled canisters and pepper balls. SkyCal flew over the scene where cans of tear gas were seen being launched by federal agents at protesters who moved closer to the building. "When a peaceful demonstration escalates into rocks, bottles, mortars, and fireworks being used against public service personnel, and property is destroyed, it is no longer a lawful assembly. It is a violation of the law," said a statement from Santa Ana Police Chief Robert Rodriguez. "We will not stand by while our City is put at risk. Santa Ana Police officers, along with our mutual aid partners, are actively working to restore order. We urge everyone to go home." Tensions grew in San Francisco Monday night when police said two small groups of individuals committed vandalism and other criminal acts. Police said multiple people were arrested and detained after refusing to comply.
