Beverly Hills seeks $400,000 in legal fees from abortion provider blocked from opening
The city of Beverly Hills is seeking more than $400,000 in legal fees from an abortion provider who accused officials of colluding with extremists to scuttle the opening of a clinic, drawing new outrage in a case that has already seen national outcry and official state censure.
Dozens of pro-choice protesters descended on the Beverly Hills City Council last week demanding city leaders abandon the pursuit of money spent fighting in court against the DuPont Clinic.
'What you guys are doing is so wrong,' said Marissa Levin, one of the activists. 'You should just settle with them.'
DuPont, which lost its lease months before it could open in 2023, would have been the only clinic in Southern California offering procedures after 24 weeks, making it a lightning rod of criticism for anti-abortion groups.
A California Department of Justice investigation found city officials illegally interfered with the clinic. Court documents show they waylaid permits and put its landlord 'on notice' after activists calling themselves Survivors of the Abortion Holocaust threatened them with relentless protest.
No members of the anti-abortion group lived in Beverly Hills. Many had never set foot in Los Angeles before. Their stated goal was to make Beverly Hills a test case for how they might continue to thwart abortion care even in places where it is politically popular.
'Through an intense pressure campaign in which the City exerted its governmental authority on both DuPont and the landlord of its building, the City succeeded in its mission of preventing DuPont from opening in Beverly Hills,' California Atty. Gen. Rob Bonta wrote, laying out the investigation's findings last October.
By that point, the city and the clinic had been fighting in court for a year, with DuPont alleging in a 2023 claim that the city should pay for blocking its operation.
Sacramento lawmakers moved to prevent similar disputes, streamlining the permit process for abortion providers and stripping cities of most power to restrict them.
But the changes came too late for DuPont, which has given up plans to occupy the space. Beverly Hills officials maintain they did nothing wrong, but have accepted new rules and state oversight.
'The City cooperated fully with the Attorney General's investigation,' said Beverly Hills Mayor Lester Friedman in a press release. 'We disagree with the allegations in the Attorney General's complaint.'
The outcome rankled some Beverly Hills leaders. Councilmember John Mirisch voted against accepting the state DOJ settlement, saying Bonta had singled out 'a well-known, often stereotyped city, which also happens to be the state's only Jewish-majority city' while failing to pursue a similar case in Fontana, where a Planned Parenthood came under fire.
In December, a Los Angeles County Superior Court judge tossed out most of DuPont's remaining claims, saying the city was protected by the first amendment in all but a few of its actions.
The clinic appealed. The city struck back, filing a motion for more than $400,000 in attorney's fees, with the next hearing scheduled in June.
The move could hobble DuPont, which lost more than $1 million renovating a clinic it will never occupy, said Andrea Grossman, one of four founding members of Beverly Hills for Choice, whose advocacy turned the local skirmish into a national scandal.
Last week, she and her fellow 'abortion yentas' mobbed the Spanish Colonial Revival building to pressure the city to just let it go.
'Do not be the tool of extremists, do not let this be your legacy,' Grossman implored the council, reading from a petition signed by 640 people during the March 18 meeting. 'Do the right thing, take the legal victory and leave DuPont alone.'
One by one, women filed up to the microphone to echo that plea. Many invoked their shared Jewish values.
'Any claim that the city desires to financially harm DuPont is groundless and simply not true,' said Friedman. 'We continue to seek a fair and reasonable resolution.'
The activists were unimpressed.
'You're not telling the truth,' said Jennifer Freeland. 'I'm so glad to look at each one of you in the eye and say, 'Shame on all of you.''
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
Eric Adams signs order adopting controversial definition of antisemitism
Eric Adams, the mayor of New York City, signed an executive order this week adopting a controversial definition of antisemitism, as Israel's invasion of Gaza and alleged antisemitism continued to dominate the city's mayoral election. The mayor signed the order, which requires city agencies to use the International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance's description of antisemitism, at a synagogue in Manhattan on Sunday. Adams described antisemitism as 'a vile disease that's been spreading across our nation and our city'. Critics of the definition say it is designed to protect Israel by punishing legitimate criticism. Examples of antisemitism that accompany the formal definition include 'claiming that the existence of a state of Israel is a racist endeavor' and 'applying double standards by requiring of [Israel] a behavior not expected or demanded of any other democratic nation'. The lead author of the definition has spoken out against its use to suppress free speech. The move comes two weeks ahead of the Democratic primary for New York City mayor, where a number of high-profile candidates are running against Adams. Support for Israel and the city's Jewish population has become a key issue, with the frontrunners holding starkly different views on Israel's war on Gaza. Related: The new definition of antisemitism is transforming America – and serving a Christian nationalist plan Adams, a deeply unpopular first-term mayor whose time in office has been blighted by accusations of accepting bribes, has positioned himself as a staunch defender of Israel as he seeks to win election. He referenced the recent murder of two Israeli embassy staff members in Washington and the attack on a crowd of people in Colorado who were raising awareness for Israeli hostages in Gaza before signing the order. 'Since Hamas' terror attacks on October 7 2023, we have seen this hateful rhetoric become normalized on our campuses, in our communities, and online as antisemitic propaganda far too often masquerades as 'activism'. When Jewish New Yorkers make up 11% of the population but more than half of all hate crimes, we know this moment demands bold, decisive action to crack down on anti-Jewish hatred,' Adams said. Antisemitic and Islamophobic violence have risen since the Hamas attack and Israel's response, and Adams has criticized pro-Palestinian demonstrations which have taken place on university campuses and around the city. Adams was elected as a Democrat, but is running as an independent candidate in this year's election. His main rivals are Andrew Cuomo, the former governor of New York who resigned in 2021 amid accusations of sexual harassment, and Zohran Mamdani, a New York state representative. In 2021, Orthodox Jewish support helped Adams win the Democratic primary, but with Cuomo, Adams is up against a fellow staunch supporter of Israel. Last year, Cuomo joined Benjamin Netanyahu's legal defense team after the international criminal court issued an arrest warrant for the Israeli prime minister for alleged war crimes in Gaza. Mamdani, a Democratic socialist who has long been outspoken on Palestinian rights, has described the situation in Gaza, where Israel has killed more than 50,000 people, as 'genocide' and said he would have Netanyahu arrested if he came to the city. Adams signed the executive order at a synagogue in Manhattan on Sunday. He then sat for a discussion with Phil McGraw, a television personality and Trump supporter, about the threat of antisemitism, in which he criticized anti-Israel demonstrations at universities.
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
College board reverses decision on hiring University of Florida president over DEI concerns
Conservatives on a state college board reversed a decision to hire the experienced academic Santa Ono to lead the University of Florida, despite his efforts to distance himself from previous support for diversity, equity and inclusion (DEI) initiatives and past criticism of Donald Trump. The 10-6 vote followed a contentious meeting of the Florida board of governors on Tuesday when members argued over Ono's record, including accusations he failed to protect Jewish students during pro-Palestinian protests last year while he was president of the University of Michigan. The rejection came a week after UF trustees voted unanimously to appoint him as the 14th president of the state's third-largest university at a salary of $1.5m. It also followed what some critics saw as an attempt by Ono to 'clean up' his record. Related: Pentagon orders military to pull books related to DEI and 'gender ideology' His name was quietly removed last month from a letter signed by more than 600 university presidents accusing the Trump administration of unprecedented interference in academic institutions. Ono wrote an opinion piece for Inside Higher Ed in May explaining why he no longer believed DEI on campus represented equal opportunities for students. 'Over time, I saw how DEI became something else – more about ideology, division and bureaucracy, not student success,' Ono wrote, taking credit for eliminating university DEI offices in Michigan. 'Combating antisemitism has [also] been a priority throughout my career. I've worked closely with Jewish students, faculty and community leaders to ensure that campuses are places of respect, safety and inclusion for all.' At least one governor in Tuesday's board meeting in Tallahassee was skeptical of Ono's shifting views. 'The public record completely contradicted what the nominee was telling us,' Paul Renner, a Republican former speaker of the Florida house, said, according to the New York Times. And a number of conservative figures in Florida, where the Republican governor, Ron DeSantis, has led an assault on what he sees as 'woke ideology' on campuses, were previously critical of Ono's nomination. They pointed to, among other issues, Ono's previous support for DEI efforts, and a claim he was slow to respond to pro-Palestinian protests at the University of Michigan's Ann Arbor campus in April and May last year. The university has since taken a particularly harsh approach to cracking down on the protests. Senator Rick Scott, a former Florida governor, said on X that Ono was the wrong choice to lead a university he called the 'gold standard' in fighting antisemitism. 'He is willing to appease and prioritize far-left activists over ensuring students are protected and receive a quality education,' Scott wrote. 'UF needs and deserves a president who will stand strong against hate, antisemitism and divisive policies and stand with our Jewish students.' The Republican Florida congressman Jimmy Patronis urged governors to reject Ono in a tweet before Tuesday's meeting. 'There's too much smoke with Santa Ono. We need a leader, not a DEI acolyte. Leave the Ann Arbor thinking in Ann Arbor,' he wrote. UF trustees, however, defended Ono against accusations he had changed his stance to secure the job in Gainesville. 'Dr Ono is not shifting his views to fit Florida. He has been evolving his perspective over time – before UF ever approached him about this role,' they said in a press release last month. 'Like any other good scientist, Dr Ono adopted new perspectives as he gained new information.' Mori Hosseini, chair of the UF trustees, said Ono would have ensured 'that merit and scholarship, not ideology, are the gold standards for success'. Florida's rejection of Ono, who would have become the highest-paid university president in the country, is symptomatic of the wider rightwing assault on higher education, with DEI and antisemitism allegations the primary pretexts. Trump is feuding with Harvard, one of the country's oldest and most respected academic institutions, over its resistance to the president's efforts to control enrollment and curriculum. The Trump administration revoked the visas of thousands of international students – though many have since been reinstated – and last week ordered embassies overseas to stop scheduling interviews for foreigners seeking to study in the US. The Associated Press contributed reporting
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
Talkshow host Dr Phil joined Ice agents for Los Angeles immigration raids
The television personality Dr Phil was embedded with Immigration and Customs Enforcement (Ice) officers as they carried out controversial raids in Los Angeles that led to days of protests in California, his TV network said. Phil, whose full name is Phil McGraw, was with Ice before and after its agents conducted a series of raids on multiple locations across LA on Friday. Immigration advocates said at least 45 people were arrested, and the action was condemned by California's governor and LA's mayor. It was the second time McGraw, a former practising psychologist who hosted a TV talkshow for two decades, has been embedded with Ice this year. In January, he joined the US border czar, Tom Homan, in a choreographed immigration raid in Chicago, in a stunt that was criticized at the time. CNN was the first to report on McGraw's presence at the Los Angeles raids. McGraw was there 'to get a first-hand look at the targeted operations', his conservative TV channel, MeritTV, told CNN. McGraw had 'exclusive' access to Homan before and after the raids, CNN reported. During the Chicago raids, McGraw was on the ground with Ice officers and even spoke to some of the people the agency had detained. His experience in LA was less immersive, MeritTV said. 'In order to not escalate any situation, Dr Phil McGraw did not join and was not embedded' during Friday's raids, a MeritTV spokesperson told CNN. On Sunday, he appeared with Eric Adams, the mayor of New York City, at a synagogue, as Adams signed an executive order which ordered city agencies to adopt a controversial definition of antisemitism. McGraw, who is not Jewish but has said it was his 'duty' to support Israel, has increasingly immersed himself in political issues in recent months, particularly regarding immigration. In April, he McGraw backed Donald Trump in the 2024 election, and in May he described Trump as 'a man of deep faith, a man of deep conviction'.
