Scottish prison deaths are far too high
Good evening! This week's edition of the In Common newsletter comes from Kaitlin Dryburgh, policy and communication director at Common Weal. To receive the newsletter direct to your inbox every week click here.
THE Scottish Centre for Crime and Justice Research (SCCJR) has found that deaths in Scottish prisons have risen to among the highest in Europe. From 40 in 2023 to 64 in 2024, with some of the most common reasons stated as health conditions, suicide and drug-related causes.
Furthermore, the SCCJR found that the overall number of people who died while in custody or in the care of the state in 2024 was a staggering 244 people. While a Fatal Accident Inquiry is automatically provided for those who died while in prison or police custody, those who died under different custody circumstances or care of the state are not provided the same right. Which unfortunately means that we won't know how the majority of those passed away or if the state was to some extent responsible.
This embarrassing finding is another example of how Scotland's prison estate is one of the worst in Europe, in so many different ways.
Although we are set to build and replace the current Barlinnie prison in Glasgow, this just goes to show our under-funded prison estate is not capable of either rehabilitation or offering a safe place. The structures already in place are not working, and what that means is more people will die.
The centre also found that sadly 16 children and young persons died while in the care of the state, including a person with disabilities residing in a hospital. Scotland has previously been scrutinised for its high number of young people dying while in the youth estate and a few high-profile cases in the media have highlighted the need for change.
READ MORE: Aberdeen locals react to Michael Gove choosing 'Lord of Torry' title
A report published at the start of the year found that the suicides of two youths at Polmont Young Offenders Institution (below) could have been avoided. Due to the nature of Fatal Accident Inquiries, no-one at a prison can be found criminally responsible for death of a person in their custody. So it is no surprise that recommendations made to the Scottish Government are slow to be implemented when there is little pressure from anywhere to see it through.
Radical reform is needed in the prison estate if we are to improve and increase rehabilitation, provide people with a better standard of living on the outside, deliver true justice and actually help people. However, at the very least we should be keeping people alive.
Prison should not be a death sentence. The data shows that those with mental health issues are more likely to die in custody. The suicide rate for those on remand in prison is untenably high, and yet our remand population is one of the highest in Europe, once again.
There are two options that the Scottish Government can start putting in motion right now. No need to wait on another consultation or research, there is enough evidence out there to show the current model is a waste of time and ineffective.
Either they enact a prison model that bears more resemblance to Norway, which emphasises rehabilitation and alternatives to the usual prison establishments. Looking at placements that remove troubled people from their usual tumultuous environments and give them stability, teaching them life skills that they've not had access to. With accountability and responsibility at the core of these environments, while treating crime as a public health issue. Something that isn't present currently.
Or, they build bigger and better prisons that allow prison officers to offer better care so that we don't have another large increase of people dying while in the care of the state, and have a more streamlined healthcare and mental health service available in prisons.
However, considering the high rate at which we throw people in prison, building bigger prisons should not be seen as an incentive to fill them, and more out-of-prison alternatives must be invested in. Either way, this is not the option that will enact the most positive change, but if that's what's needed to keep more people alive, so be it.
READ MORE: St Andrews rector wins appeal after dismissal over Gaza comments
Lastly, the prison officers and personnel that keep these prisons ticking over should stop being overlooked. Not unlike other public services, the bureaucracy and top-heavy management structure is producing an at-times demotivated workforce that should be more valued, listened to and trusted to make decisions concerning the people they interact with.
What the findings from the SCCJR prove is once again we have one of the worst prison estates in Europe, one that is in desperate need of reform. We do not have the death penalty in this country for a reason; going to prison should not increase the likelihood of dying.
Furthermore, if we want to explore a different way and do better, we must know how people are dying. Therefore, a Fatal Accident Inquiry is essential when anyone in custody or in the care of state passes away, no exceptions.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The National
6 hours ago
- The National
Farage's proposal is just the latest undermining of the Barnett system
This, according to senior criminologists and ex-police officers, is not just a failure of admin, it's the result of austerity-era cuts that stripped police forces of capacity, dismantled the state-run Forensic Science Service in 2012, and left fragmented, underfunded systems to cope with ballooning evidence demands. Austerity didn't just weaken institutions; it disassembled infrastructure. READ MORE: Nigel Farage could cut the Barnett Formula. Here's what devolution experts think of that While these failings may seem like an English and Welsh concern, they tell a broader UK-wide story. Because when public services are cut in England, the Barnett formula translates those cuts into reduced budget allocations for Holyrood, too. Scotland has long borne the dual burden of being denied full fiscal autonomy while also seeing its devolved budget squeezed by decisions made for entirely different priorities south of the Border. Cuts to police, criminal courts, housing, public health, and local government in England have systematically eroded the spending floor on which Scottish services rest. So when justice collapses in England, it affects Scotland financially – even if the governance is separate. And now, against this backdrop of UK-wide budgetary degradation, Nigel Farage has called for the scrapping of the Barnett formula entirely. It's a move that's politically convenient, historically illiterate, and economically reckless. But more than anything, it's a distillation of what's already happening by stealth. Successive UK governments have undermined the foundations of the Barnett system – and devolution itself – for more than a decade. READ MORE: Furious Anas Sarwar clashes with BBC journalist over Labour policies It's obvious to every Scot that Farage's view relies on a mischaracterisation of Barnett as a subsidy, when in fact it simply ensures Scotland receives a proportional share of changes to spending in England for devolved services. It doesn't calculate entitlement or need, it mirrors policy shifts at Westminster. If England increases education or health spending, Scotland sees a relative uplift. If England cuts deeply, Scotland's budget falls, even if demand remains or rises. This has led to an absurd and punitive dynamic where Scotland loses funding not by its own decisions, but because England spends less. And when Scotland chooses to maintain higher standards in public services, it must do so from a proportionately smaller pot. Perversely, it doesn't stop there, though. Since the 2016 Brexit vote, Westminster has begun bypassing devolved governments directly. Funds like the Levelling Up Fund and Shared Prosperity Fund are allocated by UK ministers to local authorities, often bypassing Holyrood entirely. Promises made in The Vow on the eve of the 2014 independence referendum to deliver near-federal powers and respect Scottish decision-making have unravelled. READ MORE: SNP must turn support for independence into 'real political action' The Internal Market Act has overridden devolved laws under the banner of market 'consistency'. Powers that returned from Brussels in areas like food standards, procurement, and agriculture were supposed to go to Holyrood, but in many cases they were retained by Westminster. The Sewel Convention, once a safeguard of devolved consent, has been treated as optional. Farage's proposal to scrap Barnett isn't an outlier, it's the natural conclusion of a decade-long pattern: cut services in England, shrink the Barnett allocation, bypass devolved institutions, and then blame the devolved nations for 'taking more than their share'. There's no consideration of fairness, or implementation of a needs-based analysis, it's a strategy of erosion; one that gouges out the Union from the centre while draping itself in the flag. The failures of justice in England, catastrophic as they are, expose a deeper injustice: the systematic unravelling of the constitutional promises made to Scotland. Ron Lumiere via email
Edinburgh Live
9 hours ago
- Edinburgh Live
Where Michael Ross is now as Prime Video's The Orkney Assassin airs
Our community members are treated to special offers, promotions and adverts from us and our partners. You can check out at any time. More info Prime Video's The Orkney Assassin is now available for viewing, but where is Michael Ross? In 1994, the Orkney Islands were thrust into the international limelight when 26 year old Shamsuddin Mahmood was brutally murdered in Mumtaz restaurant, a bustling curry house in Kirkwall. At approximately 7.10pm on June 2, a masked man donning a balaclava entered the restaurant and fatally shot the Bangladeshi waiter before calmly exiting the premises. For 14 years, his murderer managed to evade capture until a breakthrough occurred in 2006 when a witness informed the Kirkwall police that they had seen 15 year old Michael Ross with a firearm on the night of the murder. (Image: ORKNEY PHOTOGRAPHIC/PRIME VIDEO) Before his arrest, Ross joined the renowned Scottish regiment Black Watch at the tender age of 17 where he ascended to the rank of sergeant of a sniper platoon and served in the first Gulf War. It was then in 2008 that, after a trial at the High Court in Glasgow where he refrained from giving evidence, he was convicted for the murder of Shamsuddin Mahmood. Where is Michael Ross now? Ross is currently serving a life sentence for Mahmood's murder at one of Scotland's maximum-security prisons, HMP Shotts in Lanarkshire, as reported by the BBC. To date, he has served nearly 17 years of his sentence and during this period, Ross has attempted to escape on multiple occasions, including in 2018 when he tried to scale a fence. Ross had crafted a makeshift ladder and attempted to climb over the fence while other inmates were exercising in the yard. Consequently, Ross was allegedly held in solitary confinement for weeks and barred from contacting his loved ones. (Image: PA) His lawyer Aamer Anwar asserted that Ross was aware the escape attempt would fail but aimed to draw attention to his appeal against conviction. Despite being found guilty in 2008, Ross maintains his innocence, telling The Orcadian newspaper recently: "I'm doing a 25-year life sentence for something I didn't do." Ross' earliest possible release date is reportedly set for 2035. The upcoming Prime Video documentary, The Orkney Assassin: Murder In The Isles, will thoroughly examine the brutal murder, the prolonged investigation, and feature interviews with investigators from the time, Ross' lawyer, and his parents, who also claim he is innocent. The Orkney Assassin: Murder In The Isles is available to watch on Prime Video.
Daily Record
9 hours ago
- Daily Record
Inside where Michael Ross is now as Prime Video's The Orkney Assassin documentary airs
Prime Video's The Orkney Assassin: Murder In The Isles has arrived, delving into the murder of Shamsuddin Mahmood. Prime Video's The Orkney Assassin is now available for streaming but where is Michael Ross? In 1994, the Orkney Islands were thrust into international headlines following the murder of 26 year old Shamsuddin Mahmood at Mumtaz restaurant, a bustling curry house in Kirkwall. On June 2, around 7.10pm, a man donning a balaclava strolled into the restaurant and fatally shot the Bangladeshi waiter before calmly exiting the premises. For 14 years, the perpetrator managed to evade capture until a breakthrough occurred in 2006. A witness came forward to the Kirkwall police, claiming they had seen 15 year old Michael Ross with a firearm on the night of the murder. Prior to his arrest, Ross enlisted in the renowned Scottish regiment, the Black Watch, at just 17-years-old. He rose through the ranks to become a sergeant of a sniper platoon and served in the first Gulf War. In 2008, after a trial at the High Court in Glasgow where he did not testify, Ross was found guilty of murdering Shamsuddin Mahmood. Where is Michael Ross now? Ross is currently serving a life sentence for Mahmood's murder at HMP Shotts in Lanarkshire, one of Scotland's maximum-security prisons, as reported by the BBC. To date, he has served nearly 17 years of his sentence. During this period, Ross has made multiple escape attempts, including an incident in 2018 when he attempted to scale a fence. Ross had crafted a makeshift ladder and tried to climb over the fence while other inmates were exercising in the yard. Consequently, Ross was allegedly put in solitary confinement for several weeks and prohibited from contacting his family. His solicitor Aamer Anwar stated that Ross was aware his escape attempt would fail but aimed to draw attention to his appeal against the conviction. Despite being found guilty in 2008, Ross continues to assert his innocence, as he conveyed to The Orcadian newspaper earlier this month: "I'm doing a 25-year life sentence for something I didn't do." It is understood that the earliest Ross could be released is in 2035. Prime Video's upcoming documentary, The Orkney Assassin: Murder In The Isles, promises an in-depth exploration of the gruesome murder, the extensive investigation that followed, and includes interviews with the officers involved at the time, Ross' legal representative, and his parents who also stand by his claim of innocence.
