Drew Harris: TDs made 'unfounded' claims in the Dáil about garda conduct after arresting protesters
THE GARDA COMMISSIONER has written to the Ceann Comhairle expressing concern over what he says are unfounded allegations about the treatment of people arrested during a protest outside Leinster House.
On 1 April, the Dáil had heard allegations that
female protesters were strip-searched
following the Mothers Against Genocide demonstration, during which 11 people were arrested.
In a letter to Verona Murphy on 16 May, which was shared with the Dáil business committee last night, Commissioner Drew Harris said, after a 'comprehensive review' of the allegations, he can confirm that all gardaí involved in the searches 'acted at all times professionally, lawfully, and in accordance with established procedures and legislative provision'.
He said the protest and the arrests were recorded by garda bodycams. There were also recordings reviewed from the garda stations involved, which Harris said 'show nothing that would substantiate any allegations of wrongdoing'.
He added: 'There are no recording devices in cells when prisoners are being searched for obvious requirements for dignity and privacy.'
Last month, Justice Minister Jim O'Callaghan
told the Association of Garda Sergeants and Inspectors (AGSI) conference
that the allegations were false and called on politicians to be careful when using Dáil privilege.
Two TDs who repeated the allegations in the Dáil were Solidarity-People Before Profit TD Ruth Coppinger and her colleague Richard Boyd Barrett.
The party said they have been vindicated by Harris's admission that there are no recording devices in cells when prisoners are being searched.
Paul Murphy TD said the Justice Minister did not disclose the 'crucial information' that there was no footage of what happened within the cells.
Advertisement
'The Minister gave the clear impression that footage had 'revealed' that our claims on strip and cavity searches were false.
'But on the contrary, this letter from the Garda Commissioner vindicates our claims and proves that the Minister misled the public.
'The Minister should now make a statement acknowledging that no recording devices were in cells when prisoners were being searched and he should apologise for misleading the public in this regard.'
Allegations
In the Dáil, Ruth Coppinger said she personally knew some of the protestors.
'Some of those women were strip-searched and one was subjected to a cavity search,' she said.
She also alleged that protesters were told by gardaí: 'What do you think would happen if you were outside the White House right now?'
Richard Boyd Barrett quoted from an account he said he received from one of the women involved.
'I was stripped completely naked and was asked to remove my underwear. When I questioned the necessity of this, I was told I would be forced violently, if I didn't comply,' the account read.
'After removing my underwear, they looked inside my private areas and touched all my sensitive parts.'
In his letter to the Ceann Comhairle, Harris said the TDs were using Dáil privilege to spread 'misinformtion and disinformation,' which negatively impacts members of An Garda Síochána.
He added: 'It undermines public trust and confidence in a fundamental institution of the state.'
Readers like you are keeping these stories free for everyone...
A mix of advertising and supporting contributions helps keep paywalls away from valuable information like this article.
Over 5,000 readers like you have already stepped up and support us with a monthly payment or a once-off donation.
Learn More
Support The Journal
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
4 hours ago
- Irish Times
Co Limerick garda acquitted of charges he fixed motoring offences for drivers
A Limerick-based garda has been found not guilty of attempting to pervert the course of justice after allegations he fixed motoring offences for drivers. Garda Thomas Flavin was acquitted of a total of 22 counts of allegedly attempting to pervert the course of justice by a jury at Limerick Circuit Criminal Court following an eight day trial. The jury returned unanimous not guilty verdicts on 17 of the charges. Earlier, the jury was directed by the trial judge, Colin Daly, to return not guilty verdicts in respect of five counts against Garda Flavin. The garda, who had denied all of the charges, was supported in court throughout the trial by family friends and colleagues. READ MORE Garda Flavin was arrested following an investigation by the Garda National Bureau of Criminal Investigation (GNBCI). He was accused of knowingly entering false motor insurance details on the Garda Pulse computer records system, in an attempt to frustrate potential prosecutions against people for driving without insurance. His trial heard the drivers involved were stopped at routine Garda checkpoints around the country and asked by the garda present to produce their insurance and licence details at a nominated Garda station within 10 days of the traffic stop. All of the drivers involved nominated Rathkeale Garda station, and, later, when the investigating garda in each of the traffic stops carried out follow up checks of Pulse they were satisfied the details entered indicated that the driver in each case was insured. However, the court heard some of the drivers were actually not insured and had been prosecuted in court after pleading guilty to driving without insurance. On Thursday, Garda Flavin's barrister, senior counsel Mark Nicholas, instructed by solicitor Dan O'Gorman, urged the jury to acquit his client of all of the charges and said there was no evidence of wrongdoing. Mr Nicholas told the jury Garda Flavin was an exemplary garda who had served with dedication in Croom and Rathkeale, Co Limerick, for many years. Mr Nicholas spoke of the 'unique challenges' gardaí face in Rathkeale as opposed to other jurisdictions. 'People who live down here know it has an enormous population, transient, in and out at various times of the year. 'One policeman said (the population) quadruples and with that comes its own set of problems and own sets of vehicles – UK car registrations, UK insurance, some not insured, some not being entirely truthful," he said. 'We know that a certain number of times that people who were pulled up and stopped and asked for their documentation, produced bogus insurance certificates.' The court heard evidence that people had provided certain documents at Rathkeale Garda station, where Garda Flavin was based at the time. However it was unclear who produced the documents nor was it clear what documents they produced. Fiona Murphy SC, prosecuting, had alleged that the evidence would show that Garda Flavin had 'sorted out' the uninsured drivers by inputting data into Pulse to try to frustrate prosecutions against them. Ms Murphy had told the jury that the prosecution case was 'a circumstantial case' with 'no direct evidence'. 'Instead, the prosecution relies on indirect evidence,' she said. She had argued that all of the relevant data entries into Pulse 'were entered under the ID of Thomas Flavin'. She alleged Garda Flavin knew the drivers were not insured and that he entered their details on to Pulse to ensure they appeared covered. 'Mr Flavin knew what he was doing, and he did so to ensure those people were insured (on Pulse) when they were not, in order to ensure there was no prosecution,' Ms Murphy said. However, after deliberating for three hours and 21 minutes, the jury unanimously dismissed all of the allegations.
Irish Times
6 hours ago
- Irish Times
Man who beat vulnerable partner to death in Co Antrim home jailed for 19 years
A man who beat his vulnerable partner 'again and again and again until he killed her' in her Co Antrim home has been jailed for a minimum of 19 years for her murder. As he sentenced John David Scott (36) for murdering his 32-year old partner Natasha Melendez, Mr Justice Weir said he had inflicted multiple injuries upon the mother-of-four in prior assaults before the fatal attack on March 22nd, 2020. This occurred in her Finch Gardens home in Lisburn, which the judge said was a place where she should have felt safe. Ms Melendez, who was orginally from Venezuela, died in hospital on April 1st, 2020. READ MORE As he sentenced Scott, Mr Justice O'Hara said: 'I accept that the murder was not pre-meditated but it was an easily foreseeable end result of how the defendant treated Ms Melendez.'
Irish Daily Mirror
7 hours ago
- Irish Daily Mirror
Top garda Drew Harris reveals review into Michael Gaine and Satchwell probes
The Garda Commissioner has said that it may seem 'very obvious in hindsight' that Tina Satchwell was buried under the stairs of her Garda boss Drew Harris has confirmed that gardai are now set to launch a review of how the investigation into the murder of Ms Satchwell in Youghal, Co Cork was handled. He also spoke of a 'peer review' of how the current investigation into the murder of Kerry farmer Michael Gaine has been handled to date. It comes after wife killer Richard Satchwell was sentenced to life in prison this week - following a five week trial which heard how her remains were ultimately discovered in a two foot grave under the stairs - following a second search of the home in October 2023. Speaking to reporters as 120 Gardaí were attested as sworn members of An Garda Síochána on Friday, Commissioner Harris said:'I've received reports obviously in respect of that investigation (Satchwell) and then a subsequent review which then led obviously now to the conviction. That's a positive outcome but we want to learn as well from the course of the investigation and the decisions that were made and the conduct of the inquiries but also then the conduct of the physical search as well.'Mr Harris said the original 2017 missing persons investigation - which included a search of the Satchwell home in June of that year that missed the remains under the stairs, did 'harvest a huge amount of information.' 'That information then was very useful in the subsequent re-examination in the incident room. The ability then to forensically analyse things around finances but also then communications and all of those were crucial,' he about whether initial 2017 investigation - which Satchwell's trial heard saw over 10 gardai search the home from top to bottom - and included a forensic expert searching for blood spatter failed, Commissioner Harris said:'So I would say the initial investigation was hamstrung because of the lack of information in comparison to the later re-examination of this matter. There was far more information to hand which gave us real grounds then for actual suspicion and enquiries.'The Garda boss went on to say that it may seem obvious now that Tina was buried under the stairs - but cited the lack of information investigators had at the time. "I know when you look at hindsight some of these things can seem very obvious. But in the moment, what was known, what was being said in terms of sightings, what was being said in terms of the victim by her husband, and one has to recognise the victimology that was being applied here. 'His suppression of her, the coercive control that obviously she was subject to for many years, her isolation in that particular community - that meant that there was very few other people that we were able to speak to that were able to give a victimology and an idea of what Tina Satchwell's life was like. So it was a complex investigation,' he said. "Yes, the house was searched in 2017. Forensic scientists also accompanied that search, it was subject to thorough examination in effect looking for blood spatter - none was found,' he whether he was satisfied with the manner in which the June 2017 search was handled or whether more could have been done - with gardai at the time not utilising a cadaver dog and with the fact that journalists who had been in the home prior had noticed a terrible smell, Commissioner Harris said:'I think it's very early for me to make a judgement on that. I want to see the papers and I think we want to review that ourselves. We have the expertise within the organisation and obviously then we will be reporting that to the Minister and community policing authority. ' I do think there are definitely lessons that we wish to learn from all of these homicides with missing persons which convert in time to homicide investigations. "We want to be sure going forward when we see a missing person report that we actually have an investigative mindset around a crime also being committed,' he Commissioner also mentioned the ongoing investigation into the murder of Kenmare farmer Michael Gaine - and said even that case is being peer reviewed to allow officers to better understand investigations of this nature. His comments come amid concerns that gardai discovered Mr Gaine's remains inside a slurry tank on his land - seven weeks after they had already searched it and seemingly missed them. 'What I can say we have done already is we reviewed all our missing person reports nationally that was done last year, we found no other suspected homicide cases. So that's the position we're in at the moment. Following the Michael Gaine, or in the middle of the Michael Gaine investigation we're subjecting that to a peer review because I do think there's learning for us around those who would commit crime and then attempt to dispose of the body and often are successful in disposing of the body.'The Commissioner was speaking as 120 new members were added to the Garda force - and spoke of a new memorial in Templemore for Garda Kevin Flatley - who was killed in a horror road collision in North Co Dublin last month.'It is obviously a very positive day for all of us, we're very pleased to see it. It's also a poignant day as has already been said you would have seen that Garda Kevin Flatley's name is remembered here, his name is now added to the memorial. So I have to say when I saw that this morning it was a very poignant moment for his colleagues here as well. We all remember Kevin and his service,' he 89 of the new garda members are male and 31 are female - 22 of which were born outside of the State and originate from the likes of Belarus, Belgium, Brazil, Croatia, England, India, Italy, Moldova, Pakistan, Poland, Russia, Scotland, South Africa, Spain and Northern Ireland. Gardai in a press release stated that 74 of the new recruits are headed to the Dublin region, 17 to the Eastern Region, 11 to the Southern Region and 18 to the North Western Region. There are now 14,318 members in the Garda force - and a further 359 recruits are scheduled to enter the Garda College next at the attestation, Commissioner Drew Harris told those gathered:"I'm delighted to be here on what is a proud and important day for you all. I'd like to welcome your families and loved ones to the Garda College for what is a special occasion for you all. "It is a day to celebrate your achievements and it marks the start of an exciting career.' The Commissioner reminded the new probationers:"Earlier you swore an updated oath to the people of Ireland. To serve them with fairness, integrity, diligence and impartiality in a manner that protects and vindicates human rights, upholds the Constitution and the laws, and accords equal respect to all people."The additions to the Oath of protecting and vindicating human rights, and adhering to the Code of Ethics, reflect the significant responsibility you now have to live up to, the ethos of the first Garda Commissioner, Michael Staines. An ethos that has guided An Garda Síochána for over 100 years as a community-focused, unarmed police service.'"You will support victims of crime. You will be a shoulder to lean on for those experiencing loss. You will also be a light of hope to others, providing safety and protection. I wish you the very best in your career and I hope you enjoy the celebrations today.'
